SCOI Reports

BCI prima facie defames young female Nalsar-Harvard-Cambridge-advocate in press release for not being a top lawyer ‘man of repute’ but ‘sinister’

The Bar Council of India (BCI) has form and a good track record in long press releases containing many strong words, but the regulator of the legal profession may have outdone itself this time with a statement to the press fired off late yesterday (see below for full release, with relevant portions from page 3).

Straight from the Bar: The recent lethal lottery played by the SC with the death penalty

This week, we intend to address a fairly sombre issue: the death penalty (and we don’t mean the punishments by pollution all those in Delhi have been undergoing). As a result, there will be no crass jokes about how chokers are in fashion these days. We will also avoid jokes about how hanging unto death could make our eyes pop better than Loreal eyeliner.

Happy-ish ending: Arun Mishra J ‘apologises 100 times’ to ‘any living creature’ and ‘younger lawyers’ hurt by him

A fter Justice Arun Mishra apparently made contempt and swift conviction threats against recently-designated senior counsel Gopal Sankaranarayanan yesterday, much of the bar came to the latter’s defence. (Much of the bar, except predictably the Bar Council of India (BCI) , whose chairman Manan Kumar...

Fresh senior Gopal Sankaranarayanan ‘retorts’, walks out of SC consti bench after Justice threatens certain contempt conviction

Y oung and recently minted senior counsel Gopal Sankaranarayanan walked out of a constitution bench hearing on land acquisition after the Supreme Court’s Justice Arun Mishra chastised him for making “repetitive” arguments that had already been made by senior counsel Shyam Divan earlier, as reported ...

Supreme Court gets possibly first ever judge from an IP law firm (who’s also super progressive about video)

The Supreme Court has today confirmed the elevation of ex-Calcutta high court judge and, since August 2018, Jharkhand high-court chief justice Aniruddha Bose, alongside justices AS Bopanna, BR Gavai and Surya Kant, according to NDTV and others.

Advocate on record exam pass rate hits record low of 19% • VIPS Delhi, Nalsar alums top 125 new AORs, one reveals secret of success

The Supreme Court Advocates on Record (AOR) exam has produced the lowest pass rate in 4 years after it dropped down to 19%.

SC cancels all Goa iron ore mining licences for lacking enviro clearance

The Indian Express reported:

Supreme Court quashes all Goa iron ore mining leases, says can’t operate after March 15 | The Indian Express

The Supreme Court on Wednesday cancelled all iron ore mining leases in the

Judge Loya case: Read the Bombay Lawyers Association written submission to the SC

The Bombay Lawyers Association, represented by Dushyant Dave before the Supreme Court in the hearing into the death of Judge BH Loya, has filed the following written statement today.

SC judges roster published on website, in bid to bring a little more transparency into case assigments

The rather badly-scanned PDF contains a list of all matters that each judge handles, though that by itself is unlikely to remove the CJI’s discretion from the process completely.

The Indian Express reported:

Supreme Cou

Oh my: Chandrachud J lays into Shyam Divan over imputations that bench biased towards Aadhaar

Great write-up on what sounds like utterly harrowing scenes…

The Indian Express reported:

At hearing on savings ‘due to’ UID, Supreme Court judge fumes: Don’t call me Aadhaar judge | The Indian Express

3 judges pick up probe against 2 Odisha HC judges over loans, renovations in breach of rules

Live Law reported:

Exclusive: In-House Committee To Resume Inquiry Against Two Sitting Orissa HC Judges Tomorrow | Live Law

The three-member in-house committee headed by Justice S.J. Vazifdar, Chief Justice of Punja

Resolution of SC impasse still elusive, as quartet of judges propose making roster public

The Indian Express reported:

Supreme Court crisis: No meeting held with CJI, judges propose roster reform panel | The Indian Express

A scheduled meeting between four senior judges of the Supreme Court, who went publ

'Like flogging dead horse to life': SC rejects inquiry into when 'lawyers' attacked Kanhaiya Kumar in 2016

A sealed cover report by Patiala House had been submitted to the court blaming police lapses. Suffice it to say, no bar council disciplinary or other actions had been taken against the alleged assaulting lawyers.

The Hindu reported:

SC to hear contempt petitions that could make martyrs of Karni Sena leaders...

The Economic Times reported:

Supreme Court: Supreme Court to hear contempt pleas against Karni Sena on Jan 29

A bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justice A.M. Khanwilkar and Justice D.Y. Chandrachud said that the

Judiciary remains a major Brahmin bastion • No SC/ST judge has been elevated to apex court in 7 years

With Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra, the nephew of former CJI Ranganath Misra, the Loya case having initially been transferred to Justice Arun Mishra, as well as Bar Council of India (BCI) chairman being Manan Kumar Mishra (and that Narendra Modi’s principal secretary Nripendra Misra had tried to meet the CJI after the rebellion), Ravikiran Shinde argues that the flood of Mishras in the news is a symptom of far too many Brahmins in the legal system and judiciary…

Loya in SC: Indira Jaising reminds CJI that she will be intervening on behalf of Admiral Ramdas, not the existing petitioners

Senior advocate Indira Jaising has requested the Supreme Court to amend its order to reflect that she did not agree to the transfer of Bombay high court petitions to the apex court, since she was not appearing on behalf of the Bombay high court petitioners but “reminded the court” that she would be intervening on behalf of Admiral Ramdas.

SC tells investigating agency not to dig into marital status in Kerala Hadiya case

Live Law reported:

Hadiya Case: We Can’t Question The Legitimacy Of An Adult Woman’s Choice Of Marriage, Observes SC | Live Law

The Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justice D. Y. Chandrachud and Jus

SC holds firm on Padmaavat ban against MP, Rajasthan, Karni Sena appeals • Rohatgi, Naik rep Viacom

The Supreme Court has dismissed all intervention applications filed by various organisations, including the Karni Sena, for intervention in the writ petition in which it had cleared the screening of the movie Padmaavat on 18 January.

Whether or not GST chargeable for legal services now before SC

Whether or not Goods and Services Tax (GST) is chargeable by individual advocates or law firms will now be looked at by the Supreme Court, staying current Delhi and Chhattisgarh high court proceedings. Live Law reported: GST On Lawyers: SC Stays Further Proceedings In Petitions Pending Before Delhi ...

Blow-by-blow fireworks in the SC Loya case today: Dave vs Salve & Rohatgi • CJI vs Jaising

Judge BH Loya’s mysterious death was finally heard today for nearly an hour by the Supreme Court, under the shadow of the 12 January press conference of the Famous Four Judges, as well as Justice Arun Mishra’s equally mysterious recusal from hearing the case, after passing an order on 16 January.