NLU Delhi legal aiders free Tihar undertrial accused of Rs 1,000 theft

Exclusive: Members of NLU Delhi’s legal aid committee have won their first release of an undertrial prisoner languishing in Tihar jail for two years for the theft of a Rs 1,000 wallet.

The prisoner, whose name the legal aid committee did not disclose to prevent prejudicing his case that was still sub judice, was accused of stealing a wallet and being a wrongful receiver of stolen goods, with a total alleged value of Rs 1,000.

The accused is a 22-year old man living in Delhi, originally from a village near Aligarh in Uttar Pradesh where his family lives.

However, the accused was kept as an undertrial in Tihar jail because he was unable to furnish the bail amount of Rs 10,000.

NLU Delhi’s legal aid committee convenor Siddharth Garg said that he was ecstatic about the committee’s first success in their Tihar jail prison advocacy project.

Garg, together with Subhro Mukherjee, Apoorv Sharma and Anshuman Singh, had argued the matter with special permission from the magistrate. They convinced the magistrate to compound the undertrial’s case after a students arranged for a settlement with the alleged victim, allowing the accused to be released on a surety bond.

“We decided to argue the matter ourselves after it came to our notice that the legal aid lawyers were not taking an interest in the case.” said Garg.

“It is great to actually bring happiness to people who are unnecessarily detained for a long period of time because they are unable to furnish the bail amount.”

The legal aid committee has created a policy to try and secure the release of undertrial prisoners who have been in jail for more than half of the maximum sentence that can be awarded for the offences that they are booked under.

Undertrials can be released under Section 436-A of the CrPc if they have served half of the maximum possible sentence, said Garg, and the committee was attempting to encourage legal aid lawyers and amicus curiae to take an active interest in pending cases.

The committee visits Tihar jail at least four times a month to guide the prisoners in Asia’s biggest prison.

At the moment the committee was actively pursuing the cases to release six other undertrial prisoners. Garg added that the project would not have been a success without the support of the college’s vice-chancellor Ranbir Singh, faculty advisors, members of the legal aid committee and 18 student volunteers.

“I would also like to thank the law-officer and DGP of Tihar jail, and DIG Prisons for giving us permission to start this initiative” he added.

Garg said that the successful release of the undertrial had “boosted their confidence” to take up more such projects in the future.

Last week law minister Veerappa Moily announced that 700,000 undertrials had been freed in the past 18 months.

Photo by Tim Pearce, Los Gatos

Comments

Saurabh 9 Jun 2011, 09:14
+1 -1
Absolutely Brilliant. Kudos to the Magistrate too, who allowed the youngsters to argue.

Just one thing. Sub-judice is a principle of law in trial systems where the trial is conducted via Jury. This is not so in India.

Maybe not disclosing the name for privacy reason would have been better!
good. 9 Jun 2011, 09:32
+6 -0
good job! but i suspect the hidden hand of ranbir singh here .. haha.
ak1003 9 Jun 2011, 10:50
+2 -1
Wonderful and great news! well done NLU-D; hope we from other law schools will follow.

@ No.1 - I am not sure whether the position you explained on sub-judice is correct. The principle is not so restrictive. Broadly it means - awaiting decision in the courts. See Griffith and Ryle, Parliament, Functions and Procedure (2003); also Sup Ct in Amarinder Singh
v. Special Committee, Punjab Vidhan Sabha (2010)6SCC113. I feel, in the context, the report carries the word correctly.
@Wally 9 Jun 2011, 16:01
+2 -0
Great work. As a rule undertrial prisoners should be released if they are in jail for the maximum period of punishment for the offence they are charged with. After they have served the entire period, conviction or acquittal becomes a mere formality. At least they shouldn't be punished for a period longer than they deserve. In the alternative, the state should compensate them for illegally detaining them for a longer period of time.
Kudos to NLUD. But curious 10 Jun 2011, 10:22
+3 -0
Are the cells of Tihar as good as the picture suggests?

Great work by NLU-Delhi, BTW.
just human 10 Jun 2011, 21:56
+0 -0
@2--- Does it matter till the time it is for some good cause... change your mentality brother...
just human 11 Jun 2011, 07:54
+0 -0
Also, i would say NLUD Great work... keep going...
Snape 11 Jun 2011, 12:00
+0 -0
Good work by NLUD. Keep it up guys!
avril laween 11 Jun 2011, 14:41
+5 -0
i am stunned by the similarity of my own room in an N-school, to the one pictured. same layout, size....well well well.

i wonder if an enterprising person would like to free me.
pro bono 14 Jun 2011, 05:43
+1 -0
good job!!! keep up ur legal aid initiatives (glad to know atleast some law school takes it seriously)