Bad drafting kneecaps legal ban on manual human waste removal; most media ignores

Fascinating read by Max Bearak in the New York Times’ India Ink blog, which describes a new law passed a month ago banning unhygienic “dry toilets”, which require manual cleaning mostly by poor Dalit women who are often forced to do the demeaning work by societal pressure and face significant discrimination.

While sponsoring politicians are quick to claim the success of the new law, which requires destruction of dry toilets and entitles workers to compensation, activists claim that the rules lack teeth by not specifying how those women can be rehabilitated and how much they are entitled to [India Ink]

Perhaps unsurprisingly The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and Their Rehabilitation Act, 2013, dealing as it does with the unglamorous issue of human waste, seems to have received no other English language media coverage whatsoever since having been passed, as far as Legally India could tell [Read the Act (PDF 135KB)]

Comments

Dazed and Confused 25 Jan 2014, 10:32
+2 -0
Who is the New York Times to tell us what to do anyway. We need to show the You Ess of A who is boss, no?

We are much too busy defending Khobragade's honour and making Ugandan women pee on the road to be bothered with what happens to poor women in this country.

The foreign press just doesn't get us.
Bharati 26 Jan 2014, 12:10
+1 -0
There is NO law that compels anyone to clean any toilet in India! Pl research. However there can be a lack of options. The Mughals enforced this excrement cleaning on widows and kids after they had killed their menfolk. Hindus did not have indoor toilets but outhouses in attached farms/ gardens. Muslim zenanas had indoor toilets and the conquered women had so their kids could survive. Now,of course, the US sends its hazmat garbage to Indians and other poor folk to clean up. India has too many residents and the poor do whatever work they find to survive.
Dazed and Confused 26 Jan 2014, 15:09
+0 -0
Yes, yes., Bharati! All these problems coming from outsiders.