Luthra, Amarchand, SJ Law lead Q3 Indian project finance rankings, mix up globally

transportation engineering
transportation engineering
Luthra & Luthra has built on its lead in the Dealogic Indian project finance league table of the first three quarters of 2010, as Amarchand Mangaldas completed four project financings in the last quarter and caught up into second place ahead of newcomers such as Axon Partners LLP and R&A Legal Advocates. Globally the top two firms are also in the top 10 of project finance legal advisers by value.

Q3 2010 project deals snapshot Luthra’s top deals: - Videocon Telecommunications: $3.1bn telecoms project - Krishnapatnam Ultra Mega Power Project for $2.8bn - Prayagraj Thermal Power Plant: $2.4bn renewable fuel project - GMR Rajahmundry Thermal Power Plant for $702m - National Highway No 5 PPP Project for Simhapuri Expressway worth $549m Axon Partners LLP and Amarchand jointly advised on JSL borrowing $1.6bn for the Orissa Phase-II Project Expansion. Amarchand also advised on: - Utkal Alumina Refinery Project for $1.5bn, and - Dhenkanal Power Plant Project for $1.5bn - Surana Power Coal Based Thermal Power Plant for $526m Source: Dealogic

Luthra & Luthra topped the table advising on almost $5bn worth of project financing in the last quarter alone, consolidating its position at the the top of the table in the first half of 2010. Its total deals tally for the year now stands at 10 deals, commanding a market share of more than 50 per cent.

Amarchand Mangaldas, which was in fourth position in the first half of 2010, has advised on a further two projects of $1.2bn, giving it a market share of 27 per cent according to Dealogic.

SJ Law Advocates & Solicitors also added another two deals in the last quarter to keep it steady in third place.

A new entrant to the rankings is a little over one-year old Delhi firm Axon Partners LLP, which bagged a role with Amarchand on the $1.6bn Orissa Phase II Project Expansion with JSL as the borrower.

Global projects

In global project finance rankings of the first nine months of 2010 Luthra & Luthra advised on a total of $15.6bn over 17 deals, putting the firm less than $2bn behind Linklaters, which is in first place with 25 deals. Allen & Overy is just behind Luthra with project deal values of $15.5bn over 32 deals, with Clifford Chance and White & Case also featuring in the top six.

Amarchand was ranked seventh by global deal values with 13 deals worth $8.3bn, followed by Latham & Watkins, Milbank Tweed Hadley & McCloy.

SJ Law Advocates & Solicitors also featured in the global rankings in 10th place with 11 deals totalling $5.1bn.

PFI/PPP project finance

As global private finance initiative (PFI) and public private partnerships (PPP) continued their depression, Luthra & Luthra also topped that table globally with two deals worth £3.3bn and India Law Services won third place with three PFI/PPP deals worth $3.4bn.

Pos Q1-Q3 2010Pos H1 2010Legal AdviserAmount ($m)No of deals% share
11Luthra & Luthra10,2681057.9
24Amarchand & Mangaldas & Suresh A Shroff & Co4,748826.8
33SJ Law Advocates & Solicitors (India)99865.6
4-Axon Partners LLP78114.4
57Khaitan Jayakar Sud & Vohra49512.8
65AZB & Partners18521.0
72India Law Services10410.6
7-R & A Legal Advocates10410.6
9-Juris Corp4610.3

Source Dealogic

Dealogic compiled only infrastructure project financings that signed within the previous half-year and specifically excluded real estate projects (except PFI and PPP deals), shipping or aircraft financing, equipment financing, agriculture and manufacturing. Legal advisers are counted if they advised a borrower, concession awarder, commercial lender, multilateral lender, ECA, guarantor or divestor). If two or more firms advised on the same project, the attributed project value was evenly divided between the advisors.

Comments

Anonymous guest 11 Oct 2010, 23:43
+0 -0
[...]
Anonymous guest 11 Oct 2010, 23:50
+0 -0
wat abt Trilegal and Singhania n Partners?????
Anonymous guest 12 Oct 2010, 03:13
+0 -0
Never heard of some of the firms in this table. Are the new entrants (Axon Partners, Khaitan Jayakar Sud and Vohra, R&A etc.) project finance specialists? Also, is this a compilation purely from Dealogic or is there some independent verification/research (as regards the ongoing/completed transactions) undertaken by Legallyindia
Anonymous guest 12 Oct 2010, 14:41
+0 -0
Thanks for the great update once again Kian.

Was wondering if you could also provide the link to the .pdf file of the dealogic report or make it available as a downloadable file.


Thanks.
Anonymous guest 13 Oct 2010, 21:39
+0 -0
What about other big law firms like JSA, Trilegal....what sort of firm is R & A and Khaitan Jayakar Sud.....&...please state the basis for this study..its absolutely misleading
kianganz 13 Oct 2010, 21:42
+0 -0
Hi, apologies for the delayed response.

Here is a link to the original press release. However, we also got customised India-only data from Dealogic which we published in the story.

http://www.legallyindia.com/images/stories/docs/DealogicProjects-Q3-2010.pdf

In response to #3 - no Legally India does not undertake independent research and we simply re-report the Dealogic projects tables.
Anonymous guest 14 Oct 2010, 03:18
+0 -0
So these ratings are based purely on the volume/size of deals done, or are a true reflection of the Firms' project finance/general credentials. Can a potential client be guided by these?
Anonymous guest 14 Oct 2010, 18:32
+0 -0
how come no report on the phone booth vs knockout case? u seem to report every two-bit shitty M&A deal.
Anonymous guest 16 Oct 2010, 19:46
+0 -0
As per my knowledge, Dealogic report is basically based on the debt component of the Projects handled by firms. Hence, even if a firm has done less no. of projects as compared to others, as per dealogic, they will only take the quantum of debt component of the Project and do the rankings accordingly.
Anonymous guest 22 Oct 2010, 19:45
+0 -0
All these reports are paid for...........very little truth in them..............what is bar council doing?
Anonymous guest 16 Nov 2010, 06:19
+0 -0
#3 Khaitan Jayakar Sud and Vohra is a new entrant in the Project Finance arena. The partner leading the firm's project finance practice is Tanuj Sood who left Dua Associates Delhi in 2009. The firm is doing some really big projects compared to the size and experience of the team.
Anonymous guest 9 Dec 2010, 05:29
+0 -0
These ratings are meaningless unless backed by client feedback/quotes as that is the true hallmark of/benchmark for advocates. Next time, Legallyindia should include snippets of each Firm's practice description (and overall credentials) such that one or two deals don't result in lopsided ratings being accorded - Kian should take note