‘Largest employer of NLU graduates’: Jindal law school hires 25 new teachers, 32% NLU alums

JGLS ramps up faculty
JGLS ramps up faculty

JGLS Sonepat has recruited 25 new faculty, including eight national law university (NLU) graduates, to take its total faculty tally to 140 and that of teachers who are NLU graduates to 44.

JGLS dean Prof C Raj Kumar commented: “[The salary we offer is] significantly more than a typical public law school, the NLUs, central universities and state universities. 20% of our full-time faculty are non-Indian nationals.

“We are the largest non-corporate employer of NLU graduates. As a university we have over 44 NLU graduates [employed with us].”

Clarification 04:32: The initially published story stated that there were over 150 professors at Jindal. The number of “full-time exclusive JGLS” professors is in fact 140. Another 60 faculty members at other schools of Jindal Global University offer electives at JGLS, said Kumar (from the Jindal Global Business School, the Jindal School of International Affairs, the Jindal School of Government and Public Policy, the Jindal School of Liberal Arts and Humanities, the Jindal School of Journalism and Communication).

The hires follow the young law school, which was set up in 2009, having last year increased the size of its intakes to 480 in its five-year LLB programme, 120 students in the three-year LLB and to 50 for its LLM. The tuition fees for the 5-year LLB are listed as Rs 5.5 lakh per year, excluding scholarships.

The law school’s teacher to student ratio continued to stand at 1:15 Kumar said.

The 25 new teachers include 2 new professors, 4 associate professors 2 of whom are also associate deans, 9 assistant professors, 7 senior research associates and 3 research associates.

The 3 assistant professors are all Nalsar Hyderabad graduates, 3 senior research associates each are graduates of NLSIU Bangalore, RGNUL Patiala and NLU Delhi, while 2 research associates are from GNLU Gandhinagar and NLU Jodhpur.

A total of 15 new hires have LLMs from foreign universities, including professor Prof Michael C Davis with a Yale LLM, as well as associate professors with LLMs from Cambridge University, University of London, Yale, University of Sussex, New York University and Michigan University.

Kumar said: “We have a very strong research ecosystem. Every faculty member has access to a research grant of up to Rs 20 lakh. We also have a research rewards scheme where for every faculty publication, if [the faculty is] publishing in one of the top journals they get Rs 50,000 to Rs 1 lakh as research reward. We have a very generous sabbatical policy, we have summer and winter break.”

While he declined to confirm precise remuneration paid to faculty members, he added: “Most of the time faculty members are not so interested in a lot of money but in academic independence, autonomy, an ecosystem that favors research. We of course like to make it attractive financially but I think for most people who join academia it never is the money [as the primary motivation].”

Editor’s note: Kumar has now told us that the total number of NLU graduates in JGLS teaching staff is 44, instead of the previously stated 35, and that NLU graduates make one-third of the law school’s teaching staff. The break-down is: NLSIU Bangalore 7; NALSAR, Hyderabad 9; NUJS, Kolkata 15; NLU, Delhi 2; NLU, Jodhpur 3; GNLU, Gujarat 5; NLIU, Bhopal 1; RGNUL, Punjab 2.

The new hires

NAMEDESIGNATIONLLBLLMOTHER QUALIFICATIONS
1Dr Oleksander MerezhkoProfessor--Ph.D. (Taras Shevchenko Kiev National University)
2Prof Michael C DavisProfessor-YaleBA (Ohio State), JD (University of California)
3Dr Jasmeet GulatiAssociate professor & Associate deanPanjab UniversityCambridgeMA and PhD (Panjab University)
4Dr. Shankar RamaswamiAssociate professor & Associate dean--A.B. (Harvard); M.A.; Ph.D. (Chicago)
5Prof Shuchi SinhaAssociate professorDelhi University (DU)University of LondonMA (DU)
6Dr. Samiparna SamantaAssociate professorB.A. (History), Presidency College, Kolkata; M.A. (History), University of Calcutta; M.A. History of Science & Medicine; Ph.D. (History), Florida State University
7Dr. Mohsin Alam BhatAssistant professorNalsarYaleJSD (Yale)
8Prof. Anshuman ShuklaAssistant professorDUNalsar and CambridgeB.Sc (Hons) (DU)
9Prof. Ronald P. Blue IIAssistant professor-University of SussexB.A.; JD (Indiana University)
10Prof. Ajey SangaiAssistant professorNalsarNew York University
11Dr. Madhumita DasAssistant professor--B.A. (Jadavpur University); M.A.; M.Phil; Ph.D. (JNU)
12Dr. Aishwarya PanditAssistant professor--B.A. (Hons.) (Delhi University); M.A. (LSE); Ph.D. (Cambridge)
13Prof. Danish SheikhAssistant professorNalsarMichigan
14Dr. Sabyasachi DasguptaAssistant professor--B.A., M.B.A. (University of Calcutta); FPM (MICA)
15Dr. Deepak VarshneyAssistant professor--B.A.; M.A. (JNU); Ph.D. (Delhi School of Economics)
16Prakhar Narain Singh Chauhan Senior research associateUniversity of LucknowQueen Mary
17Akshay SreevatsaSenior research associateNLSIUCalifornia
18Karan LatayanSenior research associateRGNULNYU
19 Gaganpreet Singh Senior research associate--B.Tech (Ropar); M.B.A. (Thapar University) Ph.D. Candidate (NITIE)
20Apoorva SharmaSenior research associateNLU DelhiLSE
21Eesha MohapatraSenior research associatePuneKing’s College
22Saika SabirSenior research associateCalcutta UniversityNUJS KolkataM.Res. (University of Reading)
23ShubhangiResearch associateGNLUUniversity of Chicago
24Peerzada Raouf AhmadResearch associateB.A. (Hons.) (AMU); M.A. (JNU); Ph.D. Candidate (Delhi School of Economics)
25Sandeep SureshResearch associateNLU JodhpurCentral European University

Comments

NLU Stud 9 Aug 2017, 14:40
+21 -1
Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas has stiff competition in terms of numbers.
Guest 9 Aug 2017, 17:35
+12 -3
Wait for foreign law firms to come in, CAM will be lucky to be the largest recruiter of Amity and Symbi grads.
a moroseJINDAL alumni 9 Aug 2017, 16:38
+3 -8
480+120=? THAT TOO AT 5.5 LAKHS A YEAR, when infrastructure costs are nowhere near what is required for medical or engineering education. Jindal has shown legal education is big business. Hope this solves the financial problems of Naveen Jindal.
Guest 9 Aug 2017, 17:15
+18 -11
This news makes me depressed. NLU students are a thousand times better than JGLS but are stuck with bad faculty, barring some exceptions. What the JGLS VC says about freedom being more of a factor than money is actually true. Many of the JGLS faculty would happily teach in cities rather than a remote place in Haryana, but they do not so because of the VCs at NLUs. Maybe NLUD and NALSAR have decent VCs, certainly not NLS, NUJS, NLUJ, GNLU etc.
wut 11 Aug 2017, 06:38
+17 -4
I am sorry but your remark about student quality is nothing but misinformed. I am a NALSAR graduate and get to frequently meet students from various law school. I must say student quality at Jindal is at par with top-NLUs, and overall definitely better than lower-rung NLUs including RGNUL and RMLNLU. Saying that students at a certain college 'are a thousand times better' (or any such blanket statement) would always be wrong, regardless of the institutes you compare. Simply put, it's a logical fallacy of generalisation.

I have seen students from RMLNLU who couldn't use SCCOnline or Manupatra, while I have also seen some exceptionally intelligent students from the same college. Same goes for the law school in question here. In my experience, many students at Jindal did have the option to go to NLUs (including GNLU, NLUJ, etc) but [i]chose[/i] to study at JGLS instead. Then you must consider outstanding performance at activities like moot court competitions; students going for post-grads at universities like Oxford and Cambridge. Clearly, the students are not as bad as you put it.

I must clarify here that my interaction is not with the current first and second years. I've interacted with third, fourth and fifth years at Jindal and my opinion is based on that - yet, the situation isn't the way you are painting it.
Dat 11 Aug 2017, 17:53
+7 -10
Using SCC Online / manupatra as a tool to judge students is plain dumb.

NLUs attract many small town students who often lag behind in these things. Jindal has the kids of wealthy daddies and mommies and it shows in their IT skills.

The real difference is felt in the offices where I find the Jindal kids content to just hang around till their chauffer comes to pick them up whereas the NLU kids are busy trying to impress their boss in order to get a PPO.
Wise guy 9 Aug 2017, 17:29
+65 -2
NLU stud: Jindal is crap

NLU stud after graduation: Jindal is crap

NLU stud during LLM in US: Jindal is crap

NLU stud after LLM in US: Jindal is the best. Will you hire me?
Wiser Guy 10 Aug 2017, 07:26
+11 -9
...

NLU stud after joining: Jindal is crap
Wiser Guy 2 Aug 2018, 09:59
+2 -1
NLU Stud: NLU's (except NALSAR and NLUD) are crap.
Guest 2 Aug 2018, 10:19
+0 -0
@Wiser Guy: Nope, those two are crap too in terms of global standard of education offered. Just more glitter on the top at present. Anybody who says otherwise is delusional.
p.s. I've actually studied at NALSAR and I love the place. But I've no illusion about its position when compared to globally renowned universities.
Best comment 10 Aug 2017, 07:54
+4 -0
So very true! The [...] folks in the list of hires fall squarely in that category.
Inexplicable 9 Aug 2017, 19:26
+5 -0
NLSIU Bangalore had conducted interviews for regular teaching positions in July 2017 which was more than a decade after the previous round had been held in September 2006. Almost all the appointments since then have been on an ad-hoc, adjunct or visiting basis. Legally India had previously carried a story where current NLSIU students had published their ratings of several ad-hoc teachers who were being considered for regularization. Has NLSIU absorbed some competent teachers this time? It might be worthwhile for LI to report on the same.
Guest 9 Aug 2017, 23:22
+8 -0
Yes, LI should do some proper investigative journalism and ask why the state of faculty at NLSIU is so poor and such few alumni teach. It's lazy to say that people join Jindal just for the money. There are other reasons.
Guest 9 Aug 2017, 19:40
+0 -3
A few clarifications by Ms Prachi will be helpful:

1. "NLU" is a broad term, ranging from Bangalore to Patna. Can we have a breakup of the exact NLUs the 35 faculty members are from? How many from tier 1 NLUs?

2. Does "NLU" mean LLM from an NLU (no value) or BALLB from an NLU (lot of value)? Are all the 35 BALLB graduates? It would appear so from the chart but please confirm.

3. What is the corresponding percentage for other NLUs? 35/150 is around 23%. Is this really very high, in comparison to other NLUs?
Reply 9 Aug 2017, 23:24
+7 -0
1. Mostly from NLSIU, NALSAR, NUJS, a few from NLUJ, GNLU, NLIU, NLUD, RGNUL, none from Patna, Raipur etc.

2. BALLB NLUs

3. Higher than NLUs.
Darkseid 10 Aug 2017, 08:20
+0 -4
Answer number 3 isn't entirely correct. NUJS, for example, has about 32 teachers, and 8 NLU grads currently teaching at least one subject full time regularly every semester. That's about 40%. Not all of them have permanent positions, but even at JGLS, that's the same, with RAs, etc. as evident from the list. It's another thing that NUJS needs more teachers given the student strength.
Darkseid 10 Aug 2017, 10:46
+1 -4
I meant 25%
ElCid 10 Aug 2017, 02:54
+1 -0
Read the articlr carefully. You will get a fair idea.
Guest 10 Aug 2017, 07:52
+0 -2
I know some profs at Jindal who are unhappy living in Sonipat and unhappy with teaching rich brats and unhappy with many things about the place. Yet, they would rather be here than some of the NLUs, even in metro cities, as there is no freedom in those places. Sad.
Sunny76554321 10 Aug 2017, 11:37
+0 -8
" Largest employer of NLU grads " (@ 44 no.) Title seems a wet dream to a kid who wanna be a cowboy when he grows up..
Just Kidding
Seriously, Was this news title paid for?
kianganz 10 Aug 2017, 11:39
+3 -0
No :)

Headline was shortened though - full quote is a few paragraphs down, that they claim they're the largest non-corporate employer of NLU grads, but that was a bit long to squeeze in.
Darkseid 10 Aug 2017, 15:47
+1 -6
What makes them non-corporate? :D They seem to be running the institution in the lines of a law firm only, charging lakhs from clients (students).
Guest 10 Aug 2017, 16:33
+0 -0
Kian it is very wrong of you to print such claims by JGLS without verifying. One of the comments has pointed out that NUJS has 25% NLU faculty (BALLB alumni), which is higher than JGLS. Another comment has raised the possibility of NLSIU hiring more alumni. Also, one grey area is whether adjunct/visiting faculty counts. If yes, then the gap between JGLS and NLUs becomes closer.

Thus, it will be good to verify just how many NLU alumni are teaching and their names, before publicising the claims by JGLS. Remember that percentage is more important than numbers, as JGU has 150 faculty total while others have fewer. If the administration at JGLS and other NLUs does not give you the info, just contact the student body presidents.

The impression one gets from the article is that it is worth paying 7 lakhs a year at JGLS over NLUs because NLUs don't hire alumni as faculty. This is potentially very misleading for law aspirants, who don't know the real picture.
kianganz 10 Aug 2017, 16:37
+2 -0
It looks like JGLS has 29% (44 out of 150). In any case, the claim that they are the largest single recruiter in absolute numbers seems correct...

Agree visiting faculty etc is interesting.

Unfortunately, most of the NLUs are not very transparent on this front and don't update their websites.

Similarly, we'd love to cover faculty recruitments at other colleges for a few years but have not had much luck there.
69 10 Aug 2017, 17:09
+1 -0
Agree that in terms of numbers JGLS probably has more NLU alumni than other NLUs combined. Also, 29% is pretty high, as it includes only full-time faculty. As for adjuncts, even JGLS has many adjuncts who are NLU alumni so that doesn't help. The bottom line is that NLU alumni are flocking there because of administrative deficiencies at NLUs, which need to be addressed. Yes JGLS pays more, but if you are from Bangalore and have your own house there, than teaching at NLSIU is better than teaching at JGLS.
Tweety 10 Aug 2017, 16:59
+1 -0
Kian, if you want to verify that claim about NUJS, ask any of the teachers there. Or else if there is any way to send you a post w/o using an email ID, let me know and I'll be glad to do it myself. I can also provide that stats for NLUD probably.
kianganz 10 Aug 2017, 17:02
+0 -0
Thanks! Sure, you can send an anonymous message via a comment here, marked not for publication, if you like. If it's a PDF or other file, maybe upload it here securely and share the link in a comment? https://send.firefox.com/
Guest 10 Aug 2017, 19:25
+0 -0
Kian, please be careful. The student website sja.nujs.edu has a "Visiting Faculty" section with names of people who just gave one lecture over there! The official website nujs.edu does not list them (rightfully) and you should only go by the official website. Only people who teach regularly should be counted.
Academic 10 Aug 2017, 21:56
+1 -3
Too much fuss is made about NLU teachers. Many non-NLU teachers are good. I would say NLU Jodhpur has the best faculty in India. I invite you to take a look at the experience qualifications of the faculty, which are unmatched by any NLU.

http://www.nlujodhpur.ac.in/faculty.php
Guest 11 Aug 2017, 17:22
+1 -1
Kian in light of your clarification (JGLS has 140 faculty, not 150) the percentage of NLU-qualified faculty increases, as 44/140 is 31%. That's a pretty big percentage, almost 1 in 3. Please highlight this. Some haters are posting messages trying to dilute the story. Note that if you include adjunct faculty the percentage at JGLS will be even higher.

Kindly do not give in to pressure without verifying everything.
Tweety 12 Aug 2017, 07:10
+0 -0
The stats provided here (at least the new recruits) includes people like RAs. How- exactly are they permanent positions, as you seem to be claiming?--
Third party 13 Aug 2017, 14:06
+0 -0
Kian please clarify all this and do a proper comparison between the different NLUs. Many questions are being raised.
Virat 12 Aug 2017, 13:47
+4 -0
This moral of this article is not what Jindal is doing right but what NLUs are doing wrong. Please do a story on why alumni are not teaching at NLUs because of corruption, nepotism and incompetence in the administration of various NLUs.
Dat 13 Aug 2017, 07:43
+1 -0
Simple Answer

Low salary (7 lacs yearly) versus double tht at even ordinary law firms (with bonus)

Burowcratic process (takes long time to recruit) and it is EXTREMELY rare for NLUs to hire permanent positions so ppl prefer to just stay away.

As students we want alums with years of experience. Those guys could be easily earning 30/50 lacs annually. Why will they give up that and join under these pitiful conditions???
Darkseid 13 Aug 2017, 14:27
+3 -0
What about treating as students the alum who are already there? The admin will probably remain a sore point always, barring a few exceptions likes Ranvir singh. But from my interactions with existing alum teaching at NLUs, I've gathered that they are quite concerned with declining student standard in terms of effort too, although all of them still believe there are more number of good students to be found at leading NLUs than at anywhere else.