NLIU Bhopal investigates ‘challenging’ anonymous online ragging complaint

Can the ragging underbelly, be uprooted through anonymous complaints?
Can the ragging underbelly, be uprooted through anonymous complaints?

NLIU Bhopal is currently investigating complaints of ragging that were registered with the University Grants Commission (UGC), purportedly by first year LLB students of the law school against their seniors, as first reported by the Express.

However, the law school in its investigation has no assistance from the complainant who has entered the phone number of the accused senior in the space meant for the complainant’s phone number in the UGC complaint form, according to sources who have seen a copy of the UGC complaint.

The Times of India reported: “[NLIU] Proctor, Rajeev Khare told TOI that an investigation is on to identify the culprits. However, the biggest challenge in front of the authorities is how to identify the complainants. ‘We are trying to identify the complainants, so that the real culprits could be caught. We have tried to convince the juniors that their identity will not be disclosed as it is the responsibility of the college to stop ragging,” said Khare. “Unfortunately, none of them has come forward.’ Director, NLIU, Prof S S Singh, told media that a probe has been ordered but claimed that the complaints were not entirely true as some people named in the complaint do not exist on campus.”

According to the complaint, one male student was molested and sexually abused in an inebriated state by a senior female student, while other junior students were made to watch porn against their wishes.

Complaint Mechanism

The UGC’s anti-ragging cell, created after ragging on college campuses became an offence in 2009, allows complainants to register their ragging complaints online by filling in basic information and attaching a word document with full details of the alleged instance of ragging.

There is no mechanism for verification of the identity of the complainant. The complaint in this case at NLIU was made completely anonymously, to the extent that the complainant provided the wrong phone number in the form.

A source on campus who saw the detailed copy of the complaint called it a “hoax” and a “prank” and commented: “If you see the complaint it looks like a parody. Last year also something like this had happened and the students who were named in [the UGC complaint] are the most disciplined ones They don’t even talk to juniors.”

“As a student body we do feel that there is a 1% chance that the complaint might be right so we have a duty to check that. On the face of it it may look like a parody but we have a duty to follow [UGC mandated] procedure,” the source added.

The source also told us that the alleged incidents would have been hard to accomplish at NLIU due to the separate hostels and mess for the fresher students from the rest of the student body, as also due to the stricter curfew for the freshers. Due to the 9pm curfew, said the source, senior students cannot interact with the fresher students as the freshers are supposed to go back into their hostels so being forced to watch porn till 5am is a hard task to execute.

NLIU director Prof Singh was not reachable for comment by phone at the time of going to press and has been emailed.

NLU Jodhpur suspended three students found guilty of ragging by the law school’s anti-ragging cell at the beginning of this month, and in 2012 NUJS Kolkata banned a third year student from representing the college in inter-university events after the student was found guilty of ragging.

Comments

Guest 24 Jul 2017, 09:48
+4 -0
I hope students from more universities will do the same and the administration will wake up to the problem of ragging. All people involved should be publicly named and shamed and banned from placements. At NLSIU Bangalore, sadistic people from earlier batches ragged people badly but nothing happened to them --- they are today partners in law firms. This is why people feel they can get away with it.
Guest 24 Jul 2017, 18:32
+3 -0
First the student body needs to wake up to the problem. If they start providing an internal atmosphere where juniors can complain without fear of repressions in the hostel, only then can things move forward.
NLIU Fresher 24 Jul 2017, 11:00
+12 -5
Anonymous complaints serve no purpose except sensationalizing an issue, and hold the dangerous potential of sabotaging the reputation of an innocent individual. There is no way to know who is the real victim -- the anonymous complainant or the one who has been targeted?

The very fact that the UGC entertains anonymous complaints from unverifiable sources facilitates fake senders to manipulate and mislead the system.

The irresponsible press and electronic media exploit the anonymous sensationalizing, particularly when allegations are salacious in nature, such as in the present case.

Kudos to Legally India, which is probably the only publication that resisted the temptation of exploiting an anonymous story, and presented a balanced and just picture, while the entire mainstream Indian press copy-pasted the Press Trust of India newsfeed without applying any sense.

PS: There are multiple anonymous complaints in this case (four by now, and counting). Quite a coincidence that 100% of the complainants have chosen not to disclose their names.
Guest 24 Jul 2017, 18:19
+2 -3
Ragging is heinous. Just kick out the students who did this.
Guest 24 Jul 2017, 22:15
+2 -2
TOI is reporting yet another ragging complaint at NLIU. yet, Legally India is still giving the impression that there is no ragging that happens. What do you have to say now??

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bhopal/another-ragging-cry-at-nliu/articleshow/59746356.cms
Old boy 25 Jul 2017, 09:03
+3 -5
As a law student, I was told by a NLIU student that his seniors ask the juniors to hump trees and mirrors and are also beaten up often.

I was told by another NLIU student who was sharing a PG with me at Delhi during internship season that "he must go to his senior's PG" in the middle of the night since the senior had commanded his presence and his laptop. The poor kid was a 1st year and he was really stressed.

I have reasons to believe that NLIU has a sad and violent ragging culture which needs to be curbed with an iron fist.
Guest 25 Jul 2017, 09:39
+2 -2
Prachi, I am pained that you are projecting the complaints to be fictitious and allowing comments saying the same. It is very irresponsible journalism by you. Please understand that there are reasons why people cannot disclose names. Serious criminal offences have happened which should be investigated further by you instead of defending NLIU. There is already a comment saying that students are beaten up and sexually humiliated by being made to hump trees. Why are you ignoring this?
Bhopali 25 Jul 2017, 14:50
+2 -2
Hi Guest. I hope you understand there is a reason why we believe that this Complaints are fictitious in Nature. One anonymous complaint has infact stated that a senior made him watch Porn till 5 am in his room. Please tell me how is that even logically possible when the juniors have a separate Hostel and the senior against whom the complaint was made was infact in another hostel that day. Please don't come here and make irresponsible comments without having any idea about what's happening. Prachi in fact should be lauded for trying to investigate and portray both the sides of the story. Its high time Journalists try to imbibe that rather than just doing Masala items in their papers.
Old boy 26 Jul 2017, 07:29
+2 -1
Your comment is most ridiculous and illogical! Are you suggesting it is a perfect alibi that the senior and junior have rooms in different hostels? We all know that students freely move across hostels. Even if one complaint is fictitious, are you denying that your juniors are made to hump trees and mirrors, imitate dogs in heat, and given beatings????

Your refusal to acknowledge the reality is only natural, given that it is very shameful. Instead of feeling embarrassed by the reality, you NLIU chaps will do well if you reflect on this serious issue, acknowledge the ragging culture, and tackle the problem. Trust me, if you can do it, you will look great and everyone will applaud NLIU. On the other hand, refusing to acknowledge the reality reflects very poorly on the institution and its students.
NLIU Fresher 26 Jul 2017, 04:57
+1 -2
It seems only the Parliament or a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court may be able to relieve you of your pain.

Please petition them to consider amending the Constitution on the model lines of North Korea or Iraq.

A rapist should be put behind bars even when the victim wants to remain anonymous for the fear of retribution and social ostracizing.

No victim, no evidence, no trial. Simply shoot the accused. Guilty until proven innocent.

PS: One incidental benefit of this outstanding system of natural justice will be that the society can get rid of lawyers once and for all.
Old boy 26 Jul 2017, 07:39
+3 -1
Wait till you are asked to hump a tree or get a thrashing in the woods! Just kidding. Actually, I really hope you don't suffer and have a great time at lawschool.

Please understand that you do not have to defend your college at all costs. You will make NLIU proud if you acknowledge the ragging culture and condemn what is wrong. That is what great lawyers do - fight for justice.
joker 25 Jul 2017, 12:32
+0 -0
what happened to LI's faculty ranking of NLUs??? When is it coming out??
Guest 26 Jul 2017, 12:58
+2 -1
I can see desperate messages by some senior students trying to cover up the incident and feed false information to Legally India. I hope the guilty are sent to jail.
bhopal student 3 Aug 2017, 08:05
+0 -0
Seniors bully bad in NLIU, still witnessing it.
V 16 Sept 2017, 19:25
+0 -0
Is it all fake?
If fake then what did college admin do against complainant for filing fake complaints?
If complaints are fake and no one showed up what about the rights of students who were debarred? Do this system only protects the right of one student?