Wired: Nalsar tops India Today | Sweeping marriages | Suicidal state of affairs | Anti-PRISM PIL

Nalsar tops India Today: Nalsar Hyderabad displaced NLSIU Bangalore at first place in India’s top 25 law colleges this year according to India Today. NLSIU, Delhi University, NUJS Kolkata, NLIU Bhopal, GNLU Gandhinanar, Symbiosis Pune, NLU Jodhpur, ILS Pune, AMU Aligarh, BHU Varanai and Amity Law School Delhi follow Nalsar, in that order. [Rankings via India Today] Legally India has reduced coverage of third party law school rankings since last year.

Sweeping marriages: As social media buzz continued about the Madras HC maintenance order on sex and marriages, former Madras HC judge K Chandru “warns against the tendency to make sweeping statements in family matters”, saying that the Justice CS Karnan’s judgment reported yesterday is likely to be “misunderstood” by subordinate courts, which might force people into relationships merely because they have had sexual intercourse. [Times of India] Karnan, in turn, today defended the judgment, saying it was misunderstood, and “not only for the purpose of giving relief to the victim woman, but also to maintain the cultural integrity of India” [Hindu]

Suicidal state of affairs: “Treating a person who is driven to take such a drastic step as a hard-core criminal violates basic human dignity in a way few other actions do,” argues psychiatrist Dr Ashoka Jahnavi Prasad about the law criminalising suicide attempts. He says that India should follow the example of 59 countries who have decriminalised attempted suicide. [Newslaundry]

Anti-PRISM PIL: Ex-Delhi University law prof, Professor SN Singh, files PIL to stop government using US internet companies’ services, and prays for government to take action against for breach of privacy, after US internet companies were revealed to have shared data of non-US citizens with US spies in leaked top secret documents [PTI]

Comments

Bemused 19 Jun 2013, 13:09
+4 -3
[Nalsar VC] has mastered the art of opening the purse strings a bit too early.
Ha ha 19 Jun 2013, 19:50
+2 -1
So have other colleges like Symbi and GNLU!
FYI 19 Jun 2013, 14:50
+3 -1
The full page "Impact Feature" advertisement of Nalsar in the India Today edition speaks a lot. Hope current and future students and the legal fraternity dont pay attention to such blatant paid news and self-gloating.

Media should learn to be objective rather than get lured by such advertisement proposals and publish paid news. Katju and PCI should take this up.
NALSARite 19 Jun 2013, 21:43
+1 -1
Haters gonna hate!
Guest 20 Jun 2013, 11:33
+2 -0
If I shake you will you jiggle with the sounds of advertorial money? I wonder.
Guest 20 Jun 2013, 02:13
+2 -1
And what has CLC, DU (with no sound credentials to speak of) done to secure a 3rd rank, over and above NUJS, NLIU, NLU J (and NLU D???)
Confused Lawyer 19 Jun 2013, 16:53
+0 -5
It is disheartening that ILS is given such a low ranking. With an autonomy exceeding the NLUs and student facilities due to which UGC give it an 'A' reccomendation its hard to see how tried and trusted ILS is ranked below colleges which are not even 20 yrs old. It is a well known fact that legal acumen and integrity of ils lawyers is very high and there are so many talented ILS alumni today recruited by top tier law firms, like arjun sawade, deb dutta, anu gopalan, etc. etc. In addition each year so many make it to Warwick, Leeds, Oxford and so on for prestigous LLM. I request Kian report this story more neuterally and expose the hollowness of India Today's story.

Best Regards,

Confused ILS Lawyer
Guest 20 Jun 2013, 11:34
+0 -0
You are making the presumption that they base this ranking on actual fact.
Modi 20 Jun 2013, 09:00
+0 -1
FM is doing a good job at NALSAR it seems. But nonetheless the present report makes India Today's rankings even more un-credible. NALSAR may be good but displacing NLSIU, which won the Jessups last year means there is somehting wrong in the rankings. FM at his usual best- ensuring publicity is there of his name and works.
Scooter 20 Jun 2013, 10:34
+2 -0
NLS no.1 coz of Jessup? lol
Guest 20 Jun 2013, 11:35
+0 -0
When you pay for ad space for your ranking, none of the other facts matter really.
Inexplicable preferences 20 Jun 2013, 14:34
+2 -1
If you compare the current state of the faculty at NLSIU with NALSAR, the latter is clearly much stronger. So between those two, I think India Today got it right. Good performances in moot courts cannot be a replacement for shoddy classroom teaching. NLU-Delhi and JGLS will also show up in these rankings once their first 5 year batches' graduate.

And before you question my locus, I must clarify that I am an NLSIU alum who is not particularly proud of recent events in that campus. If I was giving the CLAT this year, I would have certainly preferred NALSAR above NLSIU.
Doubt 20 Jun 2013, 19:57
+0 -1
I was wondering why NLUDelhi is not part of these rankings?
I mean, it is one of the premier institutes of the country; so why are they not even placed anywhere. There are surely better than most of the schools on that list.
Guest 21 Jun 2013, 05:02
+2 -0
No NLU-D ad in this special edition of India Today
RS short of funds?
irhsabed 21 Jun 2013, 10:36
+0 -0
quote name="Doubt"]I was wondering why NLUDelhi is not part of these rankings?
I mean, it is one of the premier institutes of the country; so why are they not even placed anywhere. There are surely better than most of the schools on that list.[/quote]

Becuz nlu d has not alumni yet!

On the other hand ILS has thousands of alum and they are doing well. Azb and amss also hired 2 in last 2 years. So why ils is not in the top 3.
glc 21 Jun 2013, 14:29
+0 -0
Ranking glc at number 14 is just absured below amu and bhu and symbi. It prouces top notch counsels snd corporate lawyers. Students go for llm top the best colleges. It has all the necessary infrastructure. It is affordable and has the best location. Academics is decent placements are very good. The rankibgs should be nls nalsar nujs nlu j nliu bhopal nlu d glc gnlu ils symbi
Doubt 21 Jun 2013, 16:02
+0 -0
So just because NLUD has no alumni base; it's not a good enough university?