The Economic Times’ research arm, the ET Intelligence Group, surveying more than 1,800 listed companies, has revealed that their legal spend was Rs 21,906 crore ($3.5bn) in the 2013-14 financial year, an increase of more than 17.5 per cent on last year.
Out of the five biggest spenders on legal fees in 2013-14, Ranbaxy more than doubled the fees paid to lawyer to Rs 844 crore ($137m), according to the ET, as Reliance Industries, TCS and Larsen & Toubro legal spend increased by a third or more.
In the top 5, only Infosys managed to keep its legal costs under control at Rs 504 crore, down Rs 2 crore within a year.
Top spenders, via ET:
| 2013-14 legal spend (Rs cr) | 2012-13 spend | % change y-o-y | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reliance Industries | 1184 | 876 | +35% |
| Ranbaxy Laboratories | 844.54 | 416.45 | 102% |
| TCS | 613.61 | 460.54 | 33% |
| Larsen & Toubro | 526.52 | 363.84 | 45% |
| Infosys | 504 | 506 | -0.4% |
By sector, according to ET data, it emerged that on average the 25 companies in the oil and gas sector spent the most, at around Rs 73 crore per company on average, dwarfing the next-biggest – the pharma sector – where 106 companies spent an average of Rs 32 crore each.
Finance companies - the largest sample size amongst the biggest sectoral spenders in the ET’s survey, with 200 companies - spent only Rs 7 crore on average on legal advice.
| Sector | 2013-14 legal spend (Rs cr) | 2012-13 spend | Number of companies | Spend (Rs cr) / company | Increase y-o-y (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oil & Gas | 1831.3 | 1399.5 | 25 | 73 | 31 |
| Pharmaceutical | 3371.8 | 2540.4 | 106 | 32 | 33 |
| Infotech | 3065.3 | 2703.6 | 115 | 27 | 13 |
| Capital Goods | 1754.1 | 1612.6 | 126 | 14 | 9 |
| Finance | 1363.1 | 1188.4 | 200 | 7 | 15 |
The methodology for arriving at the figures was not disclosed in the article.
Read the full news report at the Economic Times, with comments from several law firm partners.
Comments
I think this would include in-house teams, not sure - can someone shed a light on what the 'legal fees / costs' head in audited accounts usually includes?
Unless they keep most of the legal 'employees' as 'retainers' and show these as fees/costs.
Whichever way, the 20,000 Crore (+) annual legal expense appears crazily high.
This may just be a mighty scam brewing, welcome to the Indian way of madness.
Large corporates getting billed by lawyers who for a tiny fee here and there, arrange the pass-through and organize big-ticket 'things'.