Amarchand Mangaldas split done deal: To be announced in Bombay high court tomorrow

Mediated outcome: Two Amarchands
Mediated outcome: Two Amarchands

The mediation between Amarchand Mangaldas co-managing partners and brothers Cyril and Shardul Shroff has completed today, with the Bombay high court to hear tomorrow at 11am that they have agreed to split the firm in two, according to two authoritative sources.

It is understood that both parties reached an agreement in mediation today after the end of the negotiations has been repeatedly extended.

The mediation began after an explosive Bombay high court hearing on 14 November 2014, after which the brothers agreed to mediate their differences.

They selected as their three mediators Nimesh Kampani – the JM Financial founder – with Cyril proposed senior counsel Harish Salve and Shardul nominated Justice BN Srikrishna.

Legally India had reported on 20 November 2014 that a break-up of the firm was nearly inevitable.

At its core, their dispute revolved around the brothers’ late mother’s will, which allegedly bequeathed all her assets, including her largest single equity stake in the Amarchand Mangaldas law firm.

Cyril claimed that equity in the firm was not hers to bequeath, as the family’s equity holdings in the firm were governed by partnership and family framework agreements, while Shardul claimed primacy of the will.

We have reached out to Cyril and Shardul Shroff for comment.

Comments

God bless u 5 May 2015, 12:57
+9 -1
May god bless other law firms.
S-C-AM 5 May 2015, 13:00
+9 -3
SCAM SCAM SCAM SCAM... Best of Luck!!!!
All izzzz well 5 May 2015, 13:03
+6 -3
its happening... Acche din aane wale hain :P
Law firm premier league 5 May 2015, 13:05
+6 -3
In the coming weeks finally there will be a legaue table of which law firm suffered the most and the pipeline... Food for thought for Kian ;)
RSG 5 May 2015, 13:12
+2 -2
When's the big announcement from Shardul Amarchand about Mumbai?
Way to go 5 May 2015, 13:35
+19 -13
Congratulations CAM. No longer stuck to the fools
JIPMER 5 May 2015, 13:38
+12 -5
Don’t want to get personal but once again we Indians have shown what we are REALLY good at : in-fighting, politics, lack of organizational skills and disunity. Not surprised - expect more of the same in times to come.
One doesn’t have to look too far back – our history is replete with stories of foreign invaders ruling over us and our land/wealth/resources, because various kingdoms/factions/lords could never unite against them.
Someone rightly said, 1 Indian = 5 Japanese (or whatever), but 5 Indians = 1 Japanese.
Guest 5 May 2015, 18:02
+4 -1
Nothing to do with our country my friend. Family feud is not only unique to our nation. ADIDAS and PUMA a case in point.
SCAM 5 May 2015, 13:49
+0 -1
Is (S)CAM recruiting freshers?
Rahul 5 May 2015, 14:22
+3 -1
The fact that Kian published comment 6 shows which side he is on. Of course we know [...]
kianganz 5 May 2015, 14:31
+4 -1
You could write the same generic comment about CAM from SAM's perspective if you like.
Bollywood 5 May 2015, 14:52
+34 -2
Frankly, I'm more interested in what happens to Salman Khan in court tomorrow...
Vakil 6 May 2015, 05:49
+0 -0
Salman convicted! Now's lets focus on the SCAM :P
Aston 5 May 2015, 15:26
+0 -1
At last!!!!!!!

which firm has suffered the most in this AMSS bloodbath??
anon 5 May 2015, 17:33
+5 -2
AMSS itself
Anon 6 May 2015, 08:17
+1 -3
Khaitan clearly?
Court Corridors 5 May 2015, 15:53
+3 -2
The NoM is on board at 923 in the Court of Gautam Patel tomorrow. Kian - maybe you should have someone reporting the proceedings live :-)
vakil 5 May 2015, 16:32
+2 -0
or maybe enterprising lawyers can use hashtag #scamsplits and kian would pick it up. :-)
ABC 5 May 2015, 16:34
+4 -0
Kian, how come no more hard-hitting investigative reports on law schools? Is it because you are now advertising law schools on your website and have thus become "pro establishment"?
Outsider 6 May 2015, 06:23
+1 -0
This is actually a valid point, Kian. I know of the resource constraints you operate under, but previously you still managed to bring forth the problems inside law schools on a fairly regular basis. An investigative report is not equivalent to yellow journalism, after all and they do the schools more good than harm in terms of ensuring greater transparency. Take for instance, the NUJS financial issues. You carried fairly detailed reports when it began and the registrar was suspended, but you never followed it up. Same is the case with many other NLUs, too. Is any pressure being applied that is preventing you from doing the same?
Surya Kiran 5 May 2015, 17:27
+1 -0
Finally...back to the normal routine.
Banerjee 5 May 2015, 18:03
+4 -4
I think by the end of it only CAM and SAM will survive with their deep pockets and army of stellar lawyers. Rest of the firm wouldn't even realise what hit them!
Correction 6 May 2015, 04:20
+4 -4
SAM had deep pockets and CAM has empty pockets. He should have watched Baghbaan.
Trolling! 6 May 2015, 04:00
+7 -0
Yey! Samarchand and Camarchand are the latest startup's in the market.
Anon 6 May 2015, 06:28
+0 -0
Any update?
kianganz 6 May 2015, 07:24
+2 -0
Hearing delayed - Css and SSS waiting outside court...

Correction: Css waiting outside, SSS inside court room.
Curious 6 May 2015, 07:51
+0 -1
Hi kian, any updates on the decision of the high court today?
Curious 6 May 2015, 07:57
+1 -1
Sorry.. Didn't see your comment.. Will wait! Might be lunch time now.. Cheers!
Law Firm Chronicles 6 May 2015, 08:48
+21 -1
All said and done, this was a Firm with heft. Yes, it had a multitude of issues and what not. But they laid the road for others to follow. As Mick Jagger once said about the Beatles - "they kicked the door open and we held it open" The other Firms have had no choice but to hold the door open and provide career opportunities and compensation for lawyers that was unthinkable at the turn of this century. RIP AMSS - this was not the way for the Firm to have been obliterated from history. On either sides now, the next generation of the Family cannot measure up to the present Managing Partners. CAM or SAM their time is limited if they do not change their structure. These Firms only hope for survival beyond the working life of their respective MPs is to let the other Partners in and structure a coherent and transparent manner in which these Firms will operate.
Well Done 6 May 2015, 09:21
+4 -1
Kudos for writing the most balanced and sane comment on this thread.
kianganz 6 May 2015, 10:00
+0 -1
FYI, press release now out announcing split that everyone knew was coming officially for the first time, ever, in six months:
http://www.legallyindia.com/Law-firms/live-the-final-moments-of-amarchand-mangaldas-as-we-know-it-in-bombay-hc