Shipping head Harsh Pratap quits; Clasis starts Mumbai from scratch; Aneja only co-founder left

Harsh Pratap
Harsh Pratap

Clasis Law Mumbai partner and shipping and international trade head Harsh Pratap has left the firm, shortly after the exit of four other partners of the firm in Mumbai and London, including three co-founding partners.

Pratap graduated from GLC Mumbai in 2001, obtained an LLM in maritime law from the University of Southampton in the UK in 2005, and practiced independently before joining Clasis Law in 2012.

Pratap has declined to comment since last week.

According to a source with knowledge of the firm, Clasis’ Mumbai office is now left with two associates and one partner. Former Juris Corp equity partner Mustafa Motiwala had plans to join the firm in Mumbai, as reported by Bar & Bench in late October*,* but the firm’s website has not been updated with his name.

Vineet Aneja, Clasis Delhi head and the only one of five co-founding partners remaining at the firm, did not respond to Legally India’s calls and messages seeking comment since last week.

Year of separation

Mumbai litigation partner Sagar Divekar had also formally left the firm in June to go independent.

Divekar graduated from GLC Mumbai in 1994 and followed it with stints with Shaw Wallace & Co, Wadia Ghandy and Trilegal, before joining Clasis Law as a partner in December 2011.

He has not responded to Legally India’s calls for comment since June.

In September, Mumbai project finance head and Clasis co-founder Ishtiaq Ali with partner Damodar Rao left the firm with their team to start their own firm, as reported by Legally India.

In August, co-founder and Mumbai-London partner Sakate Khaitan left with his team this year to start his own firm, as reported by Legally India.

Co-founding partner Shalini Agarwal, who was the other London co-head, had left the firm in March 2013, also to start her own firm.

Clasis was formed by ex-ALMT Mumbai partners Ali, Renu Parekh, and of counsel Rao, with Delhi partner Aneja and Mumbai-cum-London partners Khaitan and Agarwal. Parekh is no longer listed as a partner on the firm’s website.

Comments

Guest 20 Nov 2014, 10:24
+15 -10
With the amss story going on, who cares what happens at Classis and Aneja?
Ashoka 20 Nov 2014, 10:32
+7 -3
Something must be seriously wrong given that all the other co founders have since left. It would be interesting to know why the sudden spate of exits at the top level. This firm has everything going for it.
Ano 20 Nov 2014, 10:43
+4 -0
I believe certain other senior people from Delhi office have also left recently.
ACP Praduman 20 Nov 2014, 11:31
+2 -3
Lyril and Hildul have issued a gag order. No comments will be published, refreshed on the latest AMSS-update page. Is this an AMSS-conspiracy to attract mud-slingers on this page? Daya, such to gadbad hai!!
Anon 20 Nov 2014, 12:11
+3 -2
Kian, perhaps you should do a piece on the recent happenings. Is there a common trend in the indian legal market. Are we headed for a restructuring of the entire legal market? What are the predictions of things to come?

Look around... WG (Singapore shut, Ankit leaves), Zia (AJ quits), AMSS (need i say more), Classis (this story), JSA (what to say after Jyotis exit), Not so recent but Kanga... and the list goes on and on....
Law-yer 20 Nov 2014, 16:19
+0 -0
UUA has a similar story, Argus in Kolkata held a lot of promise it could not deliver on and UU needed something to be done as well - but even then it hasn't worked out.
classis/clyde 20 Nov 2014, 18:41
+4 -1
I still feel this is something to do with the Clyde relationship. The firm was started out of a break off from ALMT that saw Clyde also move and the Lindon office being open within Clyde's premises. There is definitely more to dig here.... Kian worth looking into...
law school fail 20 Nov 2014, 18:52
+2 -0
I once went to their Delhi office in Gopaldas building. The office was very nicely done up. All white desks, frosted glass etc., swipe cards etc. Istiaq ali came across as a very nice person.
Lit 21 Nov 2014, 04:24
+3 -4
When i visited the delhi office, everyone, besides ahuja came across as a nice person...maybe something to do with him or his attitude that is trickling down in the partnership.
Nirmal Baba 23 Nov 2014, 09:41
+4 -0
Ahuja? Aneja?
Guest 21 Nov 2014, 04:34
+3 -0
Harsh seems to be a good lawyer so difficult to say why he left. Mumbai never really had any leadership with everyone claiming to be the head of the office and the actual person who was to head the office didn't know head or tail of management and ultimately decided move. Others seemed to have followed.
Guest 21 Nov 2014, 06:34
+0 -1
Clasis is dead - even before it could learn to walk. Will be a huge challenge for Aneja. They all walked out of ALMT a few years back. Now they have all walked out of what they have created. Funny
Guardians of demon 21 Nov 2014, 06:35
+0 -0
Whatever happened to Shaw Wallace & Co?
Reference Republic 21 Nov 2014, 07:48
+0 -0
And so it has begun! Go Harsh!
Class less 21 Nov 2014, 10:31
+0 -0
Kian, can you please confirm if Clasis/Clyde best friend relationship is still continuing? If so, I wonder why Clyde is still partnering with Clasis, with hardly anyone left there
kianganz 21 Nov 2014, 10:37
+0 -0
I'm fairly sure it's still going on. If we can get hold of Aneja we can confirm...

To be honest, not sure if Clydes even needs such a big India presence, since the work they do can probably be handled by a handful of partners.

Look at India Law Services (ILP) and Ashurst, for example, which are also relatively small, though Ashurst has a bigger India practice than Clydes...
Chappan Tikli 24 Nov 2014, 10:38
+2 -0
Clyde & Co.'s main practice areas are marine, aviation, insurance and reinsurance. I can't think of anyone left in Clasis who would have a Clyde-level experience in any of these areas (they never did cover insurance in the first place). Of course, managing partners can profess expertise in anything and everything! So, one needs to ask again, what's happening with the Clyde association? Probably Clyde & Co. are already working with other lawyers in India and feel that non-exclusive is the best way to go. Watching this space eagerly....
Sumeet 26 Nov 2014, 10:17
+2 -4
Sakate, Sagar, Ali, Damodara & Harsh had remarkably achieved their targets for FY 2013-2014. Mumbai office was really doing well with wonderful atmosphere at office. However, Abhi Jalan of Dubai office and Vineet Aneja are the real culprits for the exit of all of the above. This is all game of control and Jealous.
Sakate 28 Nov 2014, 19:05
+3 -0
Abhi is an excellent lawyer with unquestionable integrity. It is the team assembled by him that started S & R. Vineet has grown Clasis Law brilliantly in New Delhi. The claim of targets and allegations of quest for power or zealously are clearly like a claim of sour grapes. If the quitters were as good as it is claimed, why would they firm four separate firms? It is Sakate who probably has now to base himself in either London or India and pay taxes somewhere! His working from home partners are like virtual law firm with Shalini still somewhere in the shadows!
Anon 22 Nov 2014, 09:10
+3 -4
Clasis is a glorified back office (broadly speaking).
An analysis 22 Nov 2014, 19:31
+1 -0
It is unfair to use the descriptives being used to describe Clasis, for I think they fall short. They (Clasis founders) started well intentioned, with a promising tie-up, however without the requisite wherewithal and direction to take things forward.. They are probably the best that one can make from former Fox & Mandal and Parikh & Co lawyers. ALMT was what followed and didn't last long.