Cyril Amarchand jettisons complex 15-committee admin structure, makes new practice heads post Rau exit

Cyril Amarchand 2.0 nimbles up
Cyril Amarchand 2.0 nimbles up

Bar & Bench first reported that Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas has streamlined its complex internal structure that was first launched in September 2015.

Legally India has confirmed the development but understands the process of national practice heads is not yet complete.

The firm has reduced its 15-odd administrative committees to only three, and appointed new national practice heads, with regional practice area heads SR Patnaik (in tax) and Nisha Uberoi (in competition law) becoming national heads in those practice areas.

With the impending departure of corporate partner Ashwath Rau to AZB & Partners with three other partners, a reshuffle was inevitable: Rau was on three of the old administrative committees, co-head of the national corporate practice, and Mumbai-region investment funds head (there was no Delhi investment funds head).

Vishwanathan to take over capital markets chair from Cyril

Managing partner Cyril Shroff and projects partner L Vishwanathan remain chairs of the practices, though Vishwanathan has taken over from Shroff as chair of capital markets, and continues as chair of banking, projects.

Shroff continues as chair of corporate, tax, competition, financial regulatory practice (FRP), private client practice (PCP), real estate, intellectual property (under the 2015 structure Shroff was nominally chair of general corporate, capital markets and dispute resolution).

Vishwanathan is one of the most senior and experienced non-family partners at Cyril Amarchand, running a strong independent profit centre in his project finance practice (similar to Rau, who has left with his team of three partners).

New national practice heads

  • Reeba Chacko has become head of general corporate, which under the old structure was chaired by Cyril Shroff (who continues in that role), with co-heads Rau, Harry Chawla (in Delhi) and Chacko.
  • Santosh Jankiram is now heading up projects, having previously been co-headed with partner Jay Cheema. The chair of the practice remains partner L Vishwanathan.
  • Yash Ashar now heads capital markets, which was previously co-headed by Ashar and Bangalore partner Arjun Lall. The chair is now Vishwanathan, having previously been chaired by Cyril Shroff.

3 regional practices become national

  • Nisha Kaur Uberoi (Mumbai) now heads competition nationally, which was previously only a regional structure practice area.
  • SR Patnaik (Delhi) heads tax, which was previously also a regional practice area.
  • Ipsita Dutta (Mumbai) has become head of the financial regulatory practice (FRP), which was previously also a regional practice.

All three of those areas, when they were created as regional in September 2015, were missing a second head at the time in their respective locations.

Internally leaner

In 2015, Cyril Amarchand had announced a grand total of 15 committees, which spanned partner promotions, conflicts, technology strategy, regional executive committees, young partners, young leaders and a prevention of sexual harassment committee.

Those have now been scrapped and replaced with a much leaner structure of three overarching committees:

  • Core Advisory

    • L Vishwanathan
    • Reeba Chacko
  • Markets and Clients

    • Yash Ashar
    • Nisha Kaur Uberoi
    • Arjun Lall
    • Ipsita Dutta
    • Harry Chawla
    • Rishabh Shroff
  • Talent and Remuneration

    • Leena Chacko
    • Gauri Rasgotra
    • Nivedita Rao
    • VP Singh
    • Rishabh Shroff

Photo by Albert Bridge

Comments

Headless 2 May 2016, 11:55
+21 -0
Haha Heads are without chair and Chairs are without heads!
Retention strategy 2 May 2016, 12:05
+4 -1
Conserve CAM star partners : Project Tiger. Make them national heads and put them on important committees. Follow SAM National Head model? Yash will now report to LV?!
RS55 2 May 2016, 12:15
+62 -5
No, everyone reports to Rishabh, who reports to Cyril who reports to Vandana.
Hi Dr. A 2 May 2016, 12:09
+6 -1
No it's a hydra headed family occupying the only chair.
Knocked down 2 May 2016, 12:17
+3 -1
Do these things like Chairs and Heads have any significant meaning.....or are they pure semantics.......
Bahubali 2 May 2016, 13:31
+9 -0
Pay close attention to the constituents of the Talent and Rem Committee and your answer will be clear. Crystal clear.
ConfusedDazed 2 May 2016, 12:18
+13 -2
How can you have a head when you have a chair. Aren't both apex positions? Hellooooo, anyone English speaking here?
LP6 2 May 2016, 12:40
+6 -0
there is no Litigation head??!! Seems that practice area is non-existent.
New Bee 2 May 2016, 12:54
+2 -1
Hey! Does CAM has any offsites now? I will join them later this year
Tell us 2 May 2016, 13:03
+0 -1
Kian, weren't associate promotions also on the card, any idea??
bored intern 3 May 2016, 10:48
+0 -0
Yes any update on this?.? was it only committees or what? Kian plz con-firm
Arrrgh 2 May 2016, 13:07
+1 -0
Thoda pahle karna tha boss!
Old Bee 2 May 2016, 13:09
+12 -1
@new bee : The only off sites that CAM has are those nights you will spend at the client's office trying to review and summarize 100s of badly drafted contracts thrust upon you as part of due diligences. Very intellectually stimulating and spiritually uplifting work. Bon Voyage and Cheerio!
Demotion? 2 May 2016, 13:27
+25 -1
Interesting to see Arjun being removed as co-head of Capital Markets practice, in spite of brilliant performance by his team last year.. there is some big news coming, I guess!
anan 2 May 2016, 15:02
+1 -1
may be as an incentive for Yash clinching the vodafone IPO mandate!
Guest 2 May 2016, 18:50
+2 -1
He lost that to SAM
Dil Do 3 May 2016, 04:20
+0 -0
Wow!! Thats some insider information.
Britney_Spears 2 May 2016, 13:33
+2 -0
Oops I did it again!
The week ahead... 2 May 2016, 14:10
+0 -0
Compat, SEBI and RBI! Get the gist
Beedi jalaile 2 May 2016, 14:39
+9 -0
yeh sab kya ho raha hai beta Duryodhana?
CAMchor 2 May 2016, 14:57
+13 -2
One minute silence for removal of Mr. C from Projects co-headship. Big loss.
Please try again later 3 May 2016, 04:20
+0 -0
Who is Mr. C?
Just maybe 3 May 2016, 05:19
+1 -0
...you could read the article. pay some attention to detail, buddy boy
RK Puram 2 May 2016, 15:12
+3 -0
How's the weather in RK puram?
Daughters are Better 2 May 2016, 15:19
+9 -2
This is very unfortunate. Everyone knows Cyril for being meticulous (in addition to be very commercial). He has completely failed in this instance. While he continues to stick with his 'thrust upon' single leader concept, the 15 committees couldn't survive for even 10 months! What a shame!!! Son cripples you...daughters are better ...and shame on all those who continue to be in such a professional services firm in this day and age!
Sacchai ka saamna 2 May 2016, 16:24
+3 -1
That's because you are assuming these decisions are being taken by Mr. C.

NOT.

They're take by MRS. C.

Who should go back to managing Mr. C's paperwork only. Rather than trying to run an institution. And drag it through mud.
proximo 3 May 2016, 10:43
+2 -26
this is motivated.. son is a promising lawyer, has had years of experience. Has traveled to all countries to meet clients..is most experienced.. check your favts, drafting or negotiating is not the only thing that makes great lawyers. Just wait, give a few years more please
He may need another 28 5 May 2016, 08:16
+0 -1
Name one:
- deal he has worked on from start to finish
- diligence he has done
- negotiation he has lead
- closing/ execution he has stayed up nights for
Jon Snow 5 May 2016, 17:12
+0 -0
he has international experience. clients love him. he's a perfectionist. all good signs i would say? Unlike some of the other lawyers who would send out mails and documents with typos?
Jon Stark 2 May 2016, 15:25
+9 -0
What is it that makes a bunch of generally very intelligent people send out press releases like this? If this was a come-back moment and a counter to all the bad press that CAM has been receiving lately - it misses the target by miles. No one is fooled by this hogwash. Egos need to be sacrificed if an institution is to be created.
Rational 2 May 2016, 15:26
+20 -0
The cat and mouse game continues. No logic in the appointments. One who threatens to leave is in the committee.
dist 2 May 2016, 16:09
+2 -4
Very happy this has happened. Now they should make people happy by elevating them at the right time. Giving them increments.
Maester Aemon 2 May 2016, 19:25
+1 -3
Finally the King in the North has emerged in this battle of the Big Firms.. Cyril is the Lord Stark.. Robb Stark!!
Cinfused 2 May 2016, 19:59
+1 -0
Kian, can you explain the difference between heads and chairs?

Also, how come CS/VS aren't on any committees?
2cents 2 May 2016, 20:33
+21 -0
All these chairs and heads are bunkum.

Till the likes of Rishabh Shroff dont earn their place on these committees, firms such as CAM are destined to peter away in the mid to long term.
Corp comm 3 May 2016, 11:02
+3 -18
What do you mean by dont earn their place??? This is his firm.. has every right to be on all committees, don't forget. If you don't like too bad, doors are open.

Family has the first right, so many egs from corporate world
Purani Haveli 4 May 2016, 03:51
+6 -0
Then for God's sake don't use the term PROFESSIONAL to describe the firm and Wear your FAMILY tag proudly.

Don't like it... Too bad doors are open... You sound like a family member. Are you?
NO different 4 May 2016, 19:12
+2 -0
HIS firm?

Havent the likes of AR or LV been working at CAM for much longer - is it equally their firm?

"Doors are open" - this attitude is exactly why people are running away from CAM like a house on fire.

Learn from Hildul and keep the nepotism secret - like majority equity reserved for family; giving SIL power behind closed doors
curious billi 5 May 2016, 17:17
+0 -0
I thought damaad and Hilly billy were supposed to stay out and not interfere. Atleast thats what I've heard. is that true? or was that a ploy?
Jhadupocha 2 May 2016, 21:00
+7 -0
The winning piece for cyril is the scale of the organization that he has built up. And losing piece is also the same - if he does not deftly manage the same. Unfortunately instead looking to pwc/ey type structures (at partnership level, flat organizations) (which are more suited to CAM), he has also gravitated towards investment banks (more key person driven) style structures.

Till he figures out this balance, the main msg to his employees wont be clear, regarding growth and promotions, and that will lead to disrepair.
Promotions 2 May 2016, 23:12
+3 -0
Kian - why aren't the promotions which were declared at the same meet announced?
News? 3 May 2016, 10:43
+1 -0
Kian - any update on the promotions which were announced yesterday?!
Blue eyes 3 May 2016, 17:50
+1 -0
What is there to report? Everyone knows by now that in order to retain lawyers...every tom, dick and harry got promoted. At this rate CAM will only 50 partners in next 2 years.
News? 3 May 2016, 03:37
+4 -1
Kian, any news on how many associates apart from AR and the 3 musketeers will be resigning from CAM and when they would be joining AZB? Apparently CSS had kept a meeting addressing this last Thursday.
Office 3 May 2016, 10:53
+2 -4
Rollout was great. No one will go now
News 3 May 2016, 19:49
+1 -0
Only one other person has resigned - Kashish Bhatia, PA directly working with Ashwath. Surely won't be the only one, more to follow soon, especially after this response by Cyril to the exit
cap marks 3 May 2016, 05:53
+3 -1
so yash now will report to vishwanathan.. who heads the funds practice? delicate question post ashwath exit
Big Exits Beneficiary 3 May 2016, 06:42
+3 -1
Yash was first made national head of Capital Markets when Rahul Guptan quit. He lost that position in between and now has got it again when Ashwath quit.

It's high time for lucky Yash to go take a lottery.
Why now? 3 May 2016, 07:47
+1 -1
Why now? Question comes to mind why this is being done after AR's exit. Was AR a threat? Or insecurity ? Or ego?
Guest 3 May 2016, 08:21
+3 -0
Has to be insecurity for sure. If you notice, all remaining biggies (if you can call them that) have been made national heads. Reeba, Santosh, Yash. There was a rumour about Nisha joining Ashwath in AZB - and you now see Nisha being made national head too!
Jerry Mouse 3 May 2016, 09:59
+0 -0
Kian you edit my comment about [...] on the committees leaving but let this one with names through?!
kianganz 3 May 2016, 10:02
+0 -0
Saying that something was a rumour, when in fact it was a rumour, is fine since it's a fact that a rumour was going around.

Personally don't think it's true though, as her appointment to practice head also seems to support - there has been a lot of false information floating about at the moment.
Ho hi gaya 20 May 2016, 13:39
+1 -0
Nisha has left. It's official.
50 Cents 3 May 2016, 09:15
+11 -0
i wonder when they will constitute Morale Boosting Committee ..!!
Boost is the secret 4 May 2016, 19:56
+1 -1
When Rishabh puts in his papers...
reality check 5 May 2016, 08:40
+1 -1
Really sad to see the mouths family feeds (has fed or will in future) trolling the very hand that feeds.. when change of guard happens the old nay-sayers fall by the wayside and young generation takes over ( cyrus mistry). Rishabh may lack legal experience but people management skills learnt over the years are invaluable. He has managed Delhi sucessfully and will outshine all MPs of competitors

the institution will reach greater heights and pinnacle if success under him.
Smelly cat 5 May 2016, 10:22
+1 -0
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Dawood ab raham kar 3 May 2016, 09:47
+2 -0
Will Rahul Goel now report to Nisha Uberoi ?
Jerry Mouse 3 May 2016, 12:30
+1 -0
Logical that he does. She is national head, no?
Chair - Table 3 May 2016, 10:21
+15 -0
Zia sends her regards.
Jyeshta 3 May 2016, 13:59
+11 -0
Only committees in CAM. No comity. That's the problem.
SCAMster 3 May 2016, 14:25
+4 -0
CTRL+F for "HEAD" = 42 hits!
Too many heads in the room I say. Add some more chairs to have them seated!
Kattappa 4 May 2016, 06:07
+2 -0
Join AZB. Don't prefer these scams.
Malana cream 3 May 2016, 15:25
+0 -0
[b]Which firm should I join as a fresh associate? I have offers from both..[/b]
Original stuff 3 May 2016, 18:07
+9 -0
Join both, do day job at one, all nighters at the other.... Very impt for well rounded carrier..
Yeah? 3 May 2016, 21:48
+0 -0
Kian any confirmation on this?
Yeah? 3 May 2016, 22:18
+0 -0
I meant the associates leaving? Sorry :p
Cyclewallah 4 May 2016, 11:50
+2 -0
Only if Ra-Ga had the same "talent" as this guy. *sigh* otherwise such uncanny similarity.
crystal ball gazer 6 May 2016, 19:04
+1 -0
The cat (or shall we say cats) will be out of the bag soon.
Being inquisitive 6 May 2016, 19:10
+1 -0
Bhatia will take his juniors, won't he?
Confirmed? 9 May 2016, 17:06
+1 -0
I don't think so.
Obvio 18 May 2016, 17:06
+2 -0
Bhatia promised his juniors that he will take them.Rare to find such seniors. Man of his words.
Quite true! 20 May 2016, 13:42
+0 -0
He really is a star! Has anyone left with him yet?