28-year old law firmite inks 1000-page tome in spare time

Big book
Big book

Luthra & Luthra senior associate Shishir Jose Vayttaden has written and published a 1000-page book on SEBI Takeover Regulations, which is touted by the publisher as the best commentary on the topic.

The book entitled SEBI’s Takeover Regulation was launched to hit the book stalls on 26 January 2010, but Vayttaden first entered into a contract for publication two years ago with LexisNexis Butterworths Wadhwa group.

NLSIU Bangalore alumni Vayttaden joined Luthra & Luthra soon after completing his LLB in 2005 and has been with the firm since then.

The transactional work carried out by Vayttaden while servicing clients in the M&A space was what laid the foundation for his manuscripts, he explained, which was in turn converted into a book after extensive research that he undertook for over two years.

Vayttaden said: “We had worked extensively with an international law firm which was advising a foreign acquirer and for several months we were answering very detailed questions, minute details that the foreign counsel would go into, so for two to three months it was as though we had completely fleshed out the takeover code.”

“After the transaction got over, I just happened to take a look at my notes,” he continued. “It seemed to me to be like a book, and that was way back in 2007.”

“In hindsight it’s an amateurish view to have had that those notes were anywhere close to a book,” he concedes, “but in 2007, standing where I was, I thought if I could polish those notes a bit, I could have a book ready.”

“The unique thing as far as I’m aware is that there is no commentary on the takeover code; there was a gap in that space. I’m hopeful that my book will be able to fill in the void,” he said, adding: “Academically, to write on the common takeover code as an exercise is to write about other legislations / areas of law which may not be central to the code but are nevertheless important.”

Vayttaden would take out time to finish the book on the weekends and on other holidays, apart from writing during free hours at work.

“Sometimes I would carry a laptop and would work on my ride back home in the metro,” he said.

The publisher’s blurb on the book reads: “Until this publication, there was no work that wove the jurisprudence of SEBI, SAT and court orders with the rich source of industry practice found in published public announcements and the practical insights of practitioners. This provision-by-provision commentary on the Takeover Regulations can safely claim to be the most exhaustive work on its subject.”

Photo by alancleaver

http://www.flickr.com/photos/alancleaver/4122176776/

Comments

Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 02:20
+4 -0
I've had the opportunity to read some parts of this book and I must say it absolutely phenomenal. Rarely does one get to see commentaries such as this on Indian corporate laws, and the fact that Shishir has done this inspite of his workload at Luthra is simply amazing. I have little doubt that this is soon going to be recognized as an authority on the subject.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 02:58
+3 -0
Amazing achievement Shishir!

I work at a similar law firm and I can barely catch up on my sleep on weekends - don't know how you managed to write a book on your weekends!
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 05:38
+0 -0
??????????????????????????
2006: Contract for publishing of the Book with Lexis Nexis.
2007: Comes up with the Idea of writing a book, while going through his notes.
?????????????????????????????

[Yes, sorry, that is a clear mix-up on our part - we have now corrected this. The contract was negotiated two years ago, I believe. -Ed]
rajiv luthra 18 Feb 2010, 07:00
+1 -0
Shishir has done it!! #3 get some syrup,(yr cough may stop). in my lifetime i have not seen a person of this age produce 'this' Quality.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 14:17
+1 -0
This is simply incredible, Shishir! Congratulations!
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 15:36
+1 -0
Congratulations. There is a need for more such commentaries from well experienced lawyers on different areas of law. Hope others follow suit.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 15:59
+0 -0
This is certainly an inspiration for other lawyers.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 16:37
+0 -0
I would like to purchase it. Where do I get it/
What is the price and title.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 16:57
+0 -0
how many of the above persons have read the 1000 pages to pronounce on its quality?
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 17:05
+0 -1
client research which the client has paid for is being used for personal commercial gain - tsk tsk!
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 18:24
+2 -0
Shishir, if you are reading this, I salute you, and not like those 'salutes' in that I made in the corridors of Himalaya seven years ago. This is quite awesome, wish it does really well academically and commercially. Cheers
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 19:01
+1 -0
Have not read the book so cant speak about its quality but whatever said, to publish a book by working on weekends is quite an acheivement.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 20:21
+0 -0
Whether or not the said book contains quality or will be authority on the subject-matter, authoring a 1000-pager book alongside the hectic corporate law firm job, I believe is an achievment by itself.

Congratulations! Congratulations, once again.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 20:33
+2 -0
Commendable effort. Congrats to Shishir.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 21:37
+1 -0
@10

1. If your average 'client research' (which I assume you're viewing as research compiled in the course of a transaction) led to voluminous and authoritative commentaries on a particular area of law, then wouldn't our bookshelves be better endowed with commentaries on Indian corporate law?

2. The client paid for the agreements, the advise and the time spent by the law firm on providing both. If you've had the good sense to the read the article, then you will see that Shishir 'polished the notes'. He has reviewed his research and added on to it.

3. Suffice it to say, that a publisher like Butterworths will not act impulsively when provided with a manuscript of a commentary and publish any random commentary if it was of the opinion that more incisive commentaries can be f produced.

4. I haven't read the commentary (and probably won't be able to go through the entire volume) and while it will bring 'personal commercial gain' to the authour, you should be aware of the fact that the authour has probably sacrificed that very 'personal commercial gain' during the weekends he worked on his commentary.

5. Also, if it is as good as Kian says it is, then it will bring personal commercial gain to other lawyers as well as provide further clarity on the Takeover Code which will lead to quicker resolutions of takeover issues and shorten the time involved thereby attracting investors and relaying further commercial gain to India which will translate into further earnings for Indian law firms including the one that you manage the pantry for.

Which means better food for breakfast, a better appraisal by your employers leading to a better word of mouth regarding your catering services and subsequently leading to other catering stints and contracts at more profligate organisations that will ensue more 'personal commercial gain' for you. That in turn will put more resources at your disposal and enable you to enroll your kid in a good university like HLS and subsequently afford him a chance at working at magic circle law firms where your son will enroll as a trainee with a 6 figure salary and work under an expert on corporate law. Say someone with expertise specifically in the Takeover Code, an expertise acquired after pleasant and benign readings of Shishir Jones' commentary on the Takeover Code.

Oh the irony of it all!

*YAWN*

*stretches his arms and look at his watch*

Damn, I'm hungry. Look at what you've done!

Now go make me a sandwich!!
kianganz 18 Feb 2010, 21:44
+2 -0
Haha, enjoy your tea, nice analysis of the circle of legal life.

By the way, on your point 5 - we have not read the book either and have no idea whether it's good or not although people who have read it say it is.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 21:59
+0 -0
10 is probably from Jindal.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 22:03
+3 -0
Come on Kian - nonone EVER 'reads' a 1000 page tome - you refer to it every now and then and let it adorn your bookshelf. If anyone says otherwise - it is a LIE. Great stuff Shishir - to get this done.... With the Lexis tag it will sell.

I was in the same class as Shishir - I can't believe it will be anything but good quality - he can do wonders when he puts his mind to something - but I can't believe anyone other Shishir has 'read' this 1000 page monster.
Anonymous 18 Feb 2010, 23:32
+0 -0
@ Drew P: Magic circle trainees and 6 figure salaries- if only!
Anonymous 19 Feb 2010, 06:23
+1 -0
Would'nt be surprised if, more then half of those so called 1000 pages are Annexures of the SEBI rules and regulations... especially since its Lexis Nexis Publishing the book...
Anonymous 19 Feb 2010, 15:57
+1 -0
To all those haters!! Lets see YOU pen down a literary work!!
We dont want to do anything on our own accord and when someone else does... all we can do is get jealous and become judgmental cynics? Why? Just because the guy did a good job and you didnt?

I think the haters need to make all of us sandwiches!!

Great job Shishir!!

Now i need to get back to my "magic circle" job... only 23 more hours to go before i go home to get ONE hours sleep!!
Anonymous 19 Feb 2010, 19:52
+0 -0
"just because the guy did a good job and you didnt?"

yes - thats how and why "Envy" is one of the 7.
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 01:42
+1 -0
Congratulations Shishir!

I have just come to know of this book. I have not read it, but having known Shishir and seen him work at Luthra for several years, I am pretty sure the work must be an excellent piece. And yes, it is indeed very difficult to achieve this feast with the workload that one (and particularly Shishir had in Luthra), but Shishir only could do it.

Well done Shishir! and all those sceptics..get your act together.. read it, before you comment on it,instead of merely conjecturing and casting aspersions on his ability. You may get some real masaala to comment on.
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 02:45
+1 -0
Guys... Kindly go through the contents (copied and pasted from lexisnexis)

Chap. I Preliminary
Chap. II Disclosures of Shareholding and Control in a Listed Company
Chap. III Substantial Acquisition of Shares or Voting Rights in and .Acquisition of Control Over a Listed Company
Chap. IV Bail-Out Takeovers
Chap. V Investigation and Action by the Board

Annexures
Annex. I. Formats under Takeover Regulations
Annex. II. The Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992
Annex. III. Securities and Exchange Board of India (SubstantialAcquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulation, 1994
Annex. IV. Justice PN. Bhagwati Committee Report on Takeovers (Date 18-1-1997)
Annex. V. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulations, 1997
Annex. VI. Report of the Reconvened Committee on Substantial Acquisitions of Shares and Takeovers Under the Chairmanship of Justice P. N. Bhagwati
Annex. VII. Format of Public Announcement
Annex. VIII. Standard Letter of Offer for an Open Offer in Terms of the SEBI (Substantial Acquisition of Shares And Takeovers) Regulations, 1997 and Subsequent Amendments Thereof
Annex. IX. Report on ‘Reduction in cost involved in the open offers’-SEBI (Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulations, 1997
Annex. X. Report of the Internal Group on SEBI (Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulations, 1997
Annex. XI.. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulations, 1997
Annex. XII. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Investor Protection and Education Fund) Regulations, 2009
Annex. XIII. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Delisting of Equity Shares) Regulations, 2009
Annex. XIV. Issue of Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds and Ordinary Shares (Through Depository Receipt Mechanism) Scheme, 1993
Annex. XV. Standard Listing Agreement Form with Schedule of Listing Fees
Annex. XVI. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2009
Annex. XVII. Securities Appellate Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 2000
Annex. XVIII. Format of Post-offer Public Announcement
Annex. XIX. SEBI Takeover—FAQ

The last 19 items are available online free of cost....

@ lexisnexis - Then why should I shell out INR 1695.00 / US$ 84.75 for this treatise?
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 03:48
+1 -0
Kudos Shishir for embarking on this, and more importantly getting it done. Now, make sure you capitalise and consolidate on this; a lot of us fail on that count. Make sure the honchos at L&L are aware of this and put you out as the Takeover Code expert and don't really feel threatened as often happens in India!

Critics/envious "ONIDA devils", including # 24: If you haven't read/used it or don't mean to read/use it, why are you getting bothered and wasting your time commenting on this article? If you think you will read/use it, then at least wait till you read/use it and make some informed comments. The kind I expect form you is "Hey there is a typo on p. 879 (the annexure downloaded for the Sebi website)"

P.S. Kian: is "lawfirmite" a term of art, or has it been recently invented??
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 04:12
+1 -0
Good job Shishir - some parts of the commentary are really insightful and it is overall quite well-written.

I think #24 has not heard of Ramaiya, because if he had, he would have flipped on seeing the 3 *volumes* of "annexures". It is standard practice for most publishers to put all referenced legislation, regulations at the back of any legal commentary. The premise is that you shouldn't have to go around looking on Vakilno.1 every time you want to refer to the bare act(s).

I have read a significant portion of the book. The book has about 500 pages of commentary and about 500 pages of annexures. As far as paying for the book is concerned, that is your prerogative.
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 05:12
+1 -0
Credit is due to Mr. Luthra for letting one asssociate develop/ compile materail on an important aspect of corporate law in India. Most international firms (barring many US firms) have extensive library of associate/partner generated content, that has been developed over client work and firm funded time.

This is surely the first that I have heard of about an Indian firm. I hope Mr. Luthra gave the author time off for producing this book. if he did then credit goes to him.

I know of an instance where a Magic Circle firm gave time off to an Indian lawyer to edit a book (on Indian laws). Has any Indian law firm done something similar?
Anonymous 20 Feb 2010, 21:25
+0 -0
It is high time that the 'takeovercode' needs to be decoded. be it the famous acquisitions or the public announcements the the code turns out to be a sudoku to everyone. an attempt to augment jurisprudence in this isolated area is definitely a bold attempt and Shishir deserves appreciation for that.

Nonetheless, I would like to reserve my comment on the quality of the treatise as I haven't even skimmed through it.
LegalDodo 20 Feb 2010, 21:59
+0 -0
@Barely Legal and other critics:

A book of this nature necessarily needs to contain the text of the applicable rules, orders and notifications, and it is standard practice to have them as annexures. Moreover, it is not Shishir's claim that he has authored all the 1000 pages.

To write a book of any length and have Butterworths publish it is in itself a commendable achievement. Irrespective of the flaws that the book may contain, Shishir deserves all praise for his achievement. I sincerely wish him luck.

Legal Dodo
Anonymous 21 Feb 2010, 01:38
+0 -0
Congratulations. One question - how many interns spent sleepless nights on this one?! I do hope their contribution has been recognized!
Anonymous 2 Mar 2010, 20:57
+0 -0
I interned with Shishir in Luthra and read a lot on takeover code. It was indeed a great experience.

Congrats Shishir !
Anonymous guest 12 Apr 2010, 19:40
+0 -0
Champ... great going...

How about writing another book using a different set of notes on an altogether different subject:-) that is what I would suggest you do reading the inspiring words from a few "anonymous guests"... they probably are afraid of losing some of their clientele I guess...