Amarchand Delhi senior management committee partner Harry Chawla to leave

Chawla & Co: Destination unknown
Chawla & Co: Destination unknown
Exclusive: Senior Amarchand Mangaldas Delhi equity partner Harry Chawla, who also co-heads the Delhi corporate practice and is one of four non-family partners on the firm’s national management committee, is understood to have resigned from the firm.

According to several sources, Chawla tendered his resignation earlier this week. Delhi principal associate Niti Paul, who is married to Chawla, is understood to have resigned earlier in November.

After graduating in 1990 from Kurukshetra University, Chawla had been at Kochhar & Co before joining Luthra & Luthra in 1995.

He left Luthra in 2000, poaching several associates, to start his own firm Chawla & Co. Paul joined the firm in 2001 from an in-house role at Rolls Royce India.

Both joined Amarchand in October 2008.

Chawla, alongside Delhi partner Gunjan Shah and Mumbai partners SH Bhojani and L Viswanathan, is currently one of four non-Shroff family member partners on the firm’s management committee, which also includes Cyril Shroff, Shardul Shroff and Barathi Shroff, as well as two members who are not part of the firm.

He also co-heads the corporate practice in Delhi with Shah.

Legally India could not confirm Chawla’s future plans at the time of going to press.

He did not return any calls or emails for comment and Paul was also not reachable.

An Amarchand Delhi spokesperson declined to comment on his departure.

Comments

Bhangi TA Treepaty Coromandal 14 Dec 2012, 14:11
+0 -0
Never mind...these lawyers and drivers in India can be changed anytime-said owner of an international Indian firm!
ROFL 17 Dec 2012, 06:57
+0 -0
As true as your comment may be, what is an international Indian firm?
Fooled Lawyer 21 Dec 2012, 06:35
+0 -0
I fully agree! And they don't need to be paid also becasue of lack of regulations on engagement of members of these two communities.
Vakil 14 Dec 2012, 18:58
+0 -0
This isthe second non family senior member of AMSS Delhi to quit the firm and the Management Committee in the last 2 years. Ciccu Mukhopadhyaya had left earlier. Harry is a big loss and will clearly take clients with him. Shardul and Pallavi need to focus on non family management and learn to manage and retain talent unless it's all about loving the family. The famous two wheel bicycle concept is not meant to work with a remote control.
Justice League 15 Dec 2012, 08:11
+0 -0
While i am not aware of the reasons for his departure- surely a big loss to AMSS.

I preach- If you dont value and respect your Rainmakers then you lose them, which in todays cut throat world is a competitors gain!

Applies across the board!!
Chulbul Pandey 15 Dec 2012, 09:16
+0 -0
Heard he is joining AZB, Delhi.....
Smart _SS 15 Dec 2012, 10:57
+0 -0
Left before Shroff's distributed equity ...?
abc 15 Dec 2012, 11:00
+0 -0
Quiz question: What connects the following: the Indian National Congress,the Pakistan People's Party, NALSAR, and a famous Indian law firm?

A)Politics
B)[...]
C)Powerful bahus
D)Dynasty
E) All of the above
F) None of the above
lol 17 Dec 2012, 06:04
+0 -0
[quote name="abc"]Quiz question: What connects the following: the Indian National Congress,the Pakistan People's Party, NALSAR, and a famous Indian law firm?

A)Politics
B)[...]
C)Powerful bahus
D)Dynasty
E) All of the above
F) None of the above[/quote]

Why was this comment allowed? Isn't it SPAM?
Anon 20 Dec 2012, 10:34
+0 -0
[quote name="abc"]Quiz question: What connects the following: the Indian National Congress,the Pakistan People's Party, NALSAR, and a famous Indian law firm?

A)Politics
B)[...]
C)Powerful bahus
D)Dynasty
E) All of the above
F) None of the above[/quote]

What is your problem with NALSAR? Jealous much?
Sweety 15 Dec 2012, 11:36
+0 -0
Times are frustrating for non-family lawyers, partners and non-@partners. Firms in india just don't have a clue about management. Its the same story at amss, luthra, trilegal or azb. In mu short stint abroad I was amazed at the manner in which employees are treated and nurtured and trusted from day 1. Here it is the opp. Partnership is totally based on years in the firm (supposed test of loyalty) dissent in any form is squashed flat and snooping / spying culture is everwhere. In a competitive prof firm, the shroffs, etc wouldn't last two minutes and its ppl who grew from the bottom like Harry Chawla that will rule.

All the best to Harry. Hope he goes somewhere befitting his status.
thorin 16 Dec 2012, 11:38
+0 -0
Umm .. I see JSA is missing from the list..So sweety are we cool with JSA?
Sweety 17 Dec 2012, 04:12
+0 -0
[quote name="thorin"]Umm .. I see JSA is missing from the list..So sweety are we cool with JSA?[/quote]

JSA too. I havnt come across a single desi firm that is run like a professional org. They're all either pathetic, obnoxious or borderline criminal in the way they treat associates and partners who are not family or non founder.
Thorin 17 Dec 2012, 12:34
+0 -0
While i agree with your views - a large part of this maliase can be attributed to clients. You see ultimately the big ticket MNC clients go to AMSS due to the shroffs (i am talking about the billion dollar deals) becoause of their comfort levels (read more of an insurance policy for inhouse guys - where if something gets screwed - it was vetted by the finest legal minds - so dont blame us scenario - so on and so forth)..one lawyer leaving here and there wont make any difference - atleast to the clients - and if the clients are not disturbed then the family gives a rats ass.

How do you survive - (a) either have a considerable number of clients and contribute materially to the firms revenues - then the firm will hold onto you as it does for dear life (yes i have not referred to knowledge of law intentionally although it can be an added advantage) or (b)if you are on the bottom of the food chain - be patient, do your work properly, nod your head always and believe the journey is the destination in itself. Over a period of time or sooner or later you will hit (a).

In short - no point in complianing about desi firms - this is India man and you have to adapt
Sweety 18 Dec 2012, 01:18
+0 -0
Thorin, In Indian service industry clients are always merciless and demanding, but does it always translate into the service providers being so? Not always. Sure there will be sweat shops and call centres but that is what distinguishes the best from the rest. Ogilvy, PWC, McKinsey, Nomura,etc there are so many firms at the top of their space that produce quality work (at least comparable to say a london peer), care about employees and have a robust person independent structure in place. Indian law firms are nowhere near this. Be it AMSS or AZB all are run on the whims of the shroffs or zias have offices filled to the brim with politics, abusive bosses and bad blood and frankly the truth is that 70% of the folks still working at these places do so cos of the TINA factor. In a magic circle firm, partners have to be watchful how they behave with associates and stand up for them in front of clients. Here partners simply pass on the buck and make associates scrapegoats.

There is nothing to prevent our indian firms from changing the way they work and it has nothing to do with clients.
From the topunns!! 18 Dec 2012, 09:30
+0 -0
[quote name="Sweety"][quote name="thorin"]Umm .. I see JSA is missing from the list..So sweety are we cool with JSA?[/quote]

JSA too. I havnt come across a single desi firm that is run like a professional org. They're all either pathetic, obnoxious or borderline criminal in the way they treat associates and partners who are not family or non founder.[/quote]

Second this in toto!
Yosemite 15 Dec 2012, 17:26
+0 -0
Couldnt agree more with Sweety@7. Bang on.
Goofball 15 Dec 2012, 18:00
+0 -0
Sweety (No.7) hit the nail on the head!

@ Kian - have you taken the 'Recommend' button away or is it just me who can't see it (on this post at least)?
kianganz 15 Dec 2012, 18:21
+0 -0
Hi - it's actually a technical error that made the button disappear. We hope to be able to get it back soon but may have to upgrade the entire sites back-end technology - hopefully this will be done over the winter break, finger's crossed...
Avinash Gupta 15 Dec 2012, 20:46
+0 -0
Its really surprising how many eminent & performing lawyers (who have & had their own standing as individuals) have quit Amarchand in the last year or so - Ciccu Mukhopadhay, Aseem Chawla, Niloy Pyne, Paku Khan & now Harry Chawla. It appears strong, non-compromising persons cannot last long in the organization. The managing partners & other controlling heads should introspect.
Reality Check 16 Dec 2012, 06:04
+0 -0
[quote name="Avinash Gupta"]Its really surprising how many eminent & performing lawyers (who have & had their own standing as individuals) have quit Amarchand in the last year or so - Ciccu Mukhopadhay, Aseem Chawla, Niloy Pyne, Paku Khan & now Harry Chawla. It appears strong, non-compromising persons cannot last long in the organization. The managing partners & other controlling heads should introspect.[/quote]


Paku Khan?? No one even knew of him before he joined AMSS. Strangely, even at Khaitan Manas continues to be the real head of the practice. Ciccu, Aseem and now Harry, will be massive losses to Delhi. There are two other partners moving out soon. Shardul clearly does not seem concerned. These exits and the CLB goof up are signs of a badly managed firm.
Alcatraz II 16 Dec 2012, 06:31
+0 -0
@10 (Avinash): Well said. Please add to that list Mr. Himanshu Narayan. It would be no exaggeration to say that this list constitues (ed)the cream of the non-family partnership in AMSS....really there is no denying it.
NRI Lawyer 16 Dec 2012, 07:36
+0 -0
@10. Avinash - very aptly put. I am out of India for a few years but being from Calcutta, I can say that you have forgotten one name - Krisnava Dutt. These are big names and the loss is certainly AM's. Having worked with Niloy Pyne during his Khaitan days and having interacted with Krisnava briefly, I can only imagine what a potent combination they would have been in Calcutta for AM ! Same for Harry Chawla at Delhi. AM may be still ok as a firm but the individuals' glamour and presence is really waning. Its only the Shroffs now really and a very few others. By the way, are you the Avinash Gupta from New York ?
Corp lawyer 16 Dec 2012, 11:15
+0 -0
Having worked with Krishnava while he was at AMSS, I can say for certain that his departure was a massive loss. The AMSS kol office still hasnt managed to find its feet. It seems that Krishnava has now moved to Mumbai so was wondering who is running the Kolkata office of his firm?
Kol Lawyer 16 Dec 2012, 13:29
+0 -0
Don't hear anything about AMSS kol office after Pyne's departure. Are they shutting down or already done so ?
john the baptist 17 Dec 2012, 08:36
+0 -0
[quote name="Kol Lawyer"]Don't hear anything about AMSS kol office after Pyne's departure. Are they shutting down or already done so ?[/quote]
Sidhartha Dutta is running the office .. he is trying his best to keep the flock together..
Kol Lawyer 18 Dec 2012, 19:09
+0 -0
[quote name="john the baptist"][quote name="Kol Lawyer"]Don't hear anything about AMSS kol office after Pyne's departure. Are they shutting down or already done so ?[/quote]
Sidhartha Dutta is running the office .. he is trying his best to keep the flock together..[/quote]
Who is that ? Never heard of him at all. Has he been here for long ? In fact, I asked around. Nobody really seems to have heard of him. Is he from Kolkata ?
Natl Lawyer 16 Dec 2012, 17:49
+0 -0
@ Kol Lawyer - I think they are still there at Kolkata. They cant close down as it would cause serious embarrassment. But agree with NRI lawyer that the glamour and sheen is lost. They have shown a knack of not being able to keep their best people for long.
anon 17 Dec 2012, 08:30
+0 -0
Well, well..everyone seems to have forgotten the biggest departure ever to have happened at Amarchand when the Bharuchas (MP Bharucha & Alka Bharucha) left amss a few yrs back to form their own family firm (with their children Justin Bharucha and Ayesha Bharucha). God knows what's happening with that firm. Apparently, they will soon overtake AMSS and AZB.
barely legal 17 Dec 2012, 13:41
+0 -0
[quote name="anon"]Well, well..everyone seems to have forgotten the biggest departure ever to have happened at Amarchand when the Bharuchas (MP Bharucha & Alka Bharucha) left amss a few yrs back to form their own family firm (with their children Justin Bharucha and Ayesha Bharucha). God knows what's happening with that firm. Apparently, they will soon overtake AMSS and AZB.[/quote]

Are you referring to the attrition rate? Going by the wrath of mighty 'M' that is quite a close possibility.
All law firms are the same 17 Dec 2012, 20:41
+0 -0
Hum is moh maya se nikal gaye hain...joining an investment bank soon !!
ABC 18 Dec 2012, 03:46
+0 -0
Bang on barely legal!
Lawyer 19 Dec 2012, 14:03
+0 -0
Where is Niloy Pyne now ?
NRI Lawyer 19 Dec 2012, 19:16
+0 -0
[quote name="Lawyer"]Where is Niloy Pyne now ?[/quote]
Had bumped into Niloy Pyne in London a couple of times in last few months. He was here for some pvt equity matters, I on behalf of my firm was acting for the Fund. There is a strong rumor that he has entered into a tie-up with a UK firm and they have opened or about to open in India with him. Some Supreme Court of India judgement that doesn't permit opening of such offices in India, is posing some obstacles I believe.
Anon 20 Dec 2012, 10:41
+0 -0
[quote name="NRI Lawyer"][quote name="Lawyer"]Where is Niloy Pyne now ?[/quote]
Had bumped into Niloy Pyne in London a couple of times in last few months. He was here for some pvt equity matters, I on behalf of my firm was acting for the Fund. There is a strong rumor that he has entered into a tie-up with a UK firm and they have opened or about to open in India with him. Some Supreme Court of India judgement that doesn't permit opening of such offices in India, is posing some obstacles I believe.[/quote]

"Some Supreme Court of India judgment..posing obstacles..." - Are you serious?!