Gov't to create IAS/IFS-style Indian Legal Service (ILS) to attract 60 top law grads

Delhi
Delhi

The law ministry is planning to start up an Indian Legal Service (ILS) styled along the lines of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) in a bid to entice top law graduates away from high-paying corporate law firms.

Law minister Veerappa Moily will shortly announce a scheme to introduce a national written and oral exam styled along the lines of other civil services entrance exams, according to Indian national papers Indian Express and the Financial Express.

Moily told the Indian Express: “Our wish is to have the best young legal brains working for the government in different capacities. Not all bright lawyers want to join law firms and shun courts. The ILS will give such lawyers an opportunity to work for the government in good positions.”

An unnamed law ministry source told the Financial Express: “The law ministry has already finalised the framework for the ILS. The UPSC will hold a written exam, followed by viva voce on the same pattern as the civil services examination. Our aim is to have at least 60 ILS officers every year,” said a law ministry functionary.”

“Basically, the aim is to have these officers be our lawyers in various courts as well as give tender legal advice to the government. In order to make the service more lucrative, we also hope to provide for a way for ILS officers to join the higher judiciary on the same pattern as district and sessions judges,” added the source.

ILS officers would have the opportunity to become legal advisers to the central and state governments.

The papers did not report on whether pay-levels of ILS officers would be on par with private practice.

Comments

Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 18:39
+7 -3
Pay levels can of course not be on par with private practice!!!
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 18:52
+6 -3
Will Rainmaker conduct these exams too?
josh 11 Jun 2010, 18:55
+5 -4
Where can we get more details about the same.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 18:57
+5 -5
Phenomenal step for Law graduates..
But govt. should also do "Something" good for Law schools as it does for IITs! :|
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 19:31
+5 -3
@4
I would like to add that N'nal Law Schools should be made central educational institutions like IIMs and IITs...this is extremely urgent in the light of more and more State Governments pressing for reservations based on state domicile.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 19:37
+1 -0
... and that would be to open up the legal services industry! :P
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 19:59
+0 -1
This is a good move. However it will be very demoralising for the lawyers who are part of ILS if Advocate Generals, AG SG etc are again senior counsels appointed by governments and these counsels are not from ILS. Yes, this cannot happen overnight but after a period of about 10 years from now, it must be mandatory that AG/SG/ASG etc should be only from ILS. Then best lawyers will want to apply to ILS.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 20:11
+0 -0
It is surely going to be an important step in the field of law by the government if it will be implemented. We the entire law students would definitely be thankful to Mr. Moiley for his effort of introducing Indian Legal Service.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 20:13
+1 -0
This proposal has been there for decades. I will be surprised (pleasantly) if the bureaucratic lobby finally allows this to happen. Can you imagine in this bureaucratic country a chief lawyer of a ministry/department shooting down the proposal of the bureaucrats? This will inevitably happen in 30 years time when these young ILS officers rise to Chief Secy levels. Even if this service is created, the IAS lobbly will ensure that they remain powersless and simply do the job which the various 'law officers' keep doing in the present ministries.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 20:21
+1 -0
@7 not necessary....the best legal minds available should be made AG/SG etc. For top positions, the govt should be allowed to appoint the best people for the job. For example, Montek of Planning commission, RBI governors, economic advisor to the PM, national security advisor, national scientific advisor...they don't need to be IAS etc.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 20:56
+1 -0
I donot want to be sound less ambitious but I have been law practise for three years now. I feel that apart from being 'good' which offcourse is a prerequsite, you have to train with right seniors to actually turn out to be a good lawyer at the end. So the exam should aim at hiring experienced people at a reasonable salary rather than hiring from law school where you would in all probabbility would be able to hire only such people who did not have great offers from Law firms.

Further the questions that are generally asked in UPSC exams for law papers are to say the least is not challenging. They are generally pure memory game. needless to say when you are in profession or actually practisitng the game reverses and its all your small little minds application rather than its capacity to store junk that becomes relevant. Accordingly the exam should also be application based rather than a memory test.
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 21:02
+0 -0
good move...just hope the government notifies it...
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 23:59
+0 -0
all because of NUJS kids...thanks all of you.
Anonymous guest 12 Jun 2010, 00:08
+0 -0
why NUJS?
Anonymous guest 12 Jun 2010, 00:59
+2 -0
What a shame, both the reporting and the comments show complete illiteracy and lack of knowledge about the facts. Indian Legal Service already exists, has been existing since ages, Union Law Secretary and other officers under him belong to this service, The position of top law officers that is AG, SG, Advocate General cannot be manned by any Service since these are Counsels mandated by the Constitution, they are not Govt Servants which ILS officers are as Central government civil servants. Plus State Govts are under no obligation to employ Central Civil Servants for giving them legal opinion, so no question of working for States. What is needed is an All India Cadre of District Judges for which Rajya Sabha which has the authority to create All India Service, ILS is already around, if recruitment is stepped up, so will stagnation as ILS pyramid has very few positions at Joint Secretary level and up.
Anonymous guest 12 Jun 2010, 01:05
+0 -0
knowing moily this could be empty talk. besides, if there is gonnna be reservation it is better not to have the ILS.

the ILS was proposed in the 1970s and it's supposed to coem into force now. i guess this means that the other major reform, i.e. foreign law firms, will be implemented in 2040 approx.
Anonymous guest 12 Jun 2010, 02:22
+0 -0
Reservation is not an excuse to avoid ILS. I think its a great move and although its been proposed way back there there is no use bringing pessimism for even if its implemented now it will change lives of many... in a good way.
aritraroy 12 Jun 2010, 03:00
+0 -0
As far as I remember, the Indian Legal Services has existed right since 1950s. Do not remember the exact year. It is open to all advocates with an experience of over 10 years of practice. They need to sit through an (already existing) examination conducted by the UPSC. The individuals selected in the ILS become the members of the three departments(Justice, Legislative and Legal Affairs) in the Law Ministry. This was the conventional route taken by most graduates and judicial officers with required experience to join the ranks of the Central Government. They also become the legal consultants/counsels for the various Central agencies. The only change that this move would do, would be to give fresh law graduates a chance to join the Central Government by removing the 10 year limit. Although this move is to be applauded, it is just another eye wash when it comes to adequate remuneration vis-a-vis other job offers which an advocate might have.

@kian; Please edit the post, if possible, as it's read by many prospective law students who would be ill informed if they don't know that such a body already exists.
Anonymous guest 14 Jun 2010, 04:58
+0 -0
congratulations to the Hon,ble Law Minister,but with the suggestion that only the advocates having at least 7 years practice and of age 30 to 40 years be allowed to appear in the proposed examination and the selected one should be paid HAG grade.
Anonymous guest 14 Jun 2010, 15:47
+0 -0
I remember a suggestion by former CJI Y K Sabharwal...............of branding the law schools.........like IIT, IIM he proposed Indian Institue of Law (IIL)...........but seems that remained an idea only............
Anonymous guest 24 Jun 2010, 17:29
+0 -0
well it is very good idea, still the implementation for this exam takes time, so i would like to say is give a lawyers opportunity in the way of ILS let it happen soon, so that the talented advocates will come up in this corrupted world.
Anonymous guest 4 Sept 2010, 16:36
+0 -0
ILS..... still a distant dream.
vips 8 Sept 2011, 08:57
+0 -0
Very welcoming thought in the right direction. Actually this should be the system in all professional services e.g. Indian Electrical Services, Indian Water Sesorce Services, Indian Mining Services, Indian Aviation Services, Indian Road Services etc. so that all these professional and highly technical fileds should be headed by the professional of respective fields only.