JSA rejigs internships to level playing field for non-Mumbai law school interns

books_edu_th_by_hashmil
books_edu_th_by_hashmil

J Sagar Associates (JSA) Mumbai office has formalised its policies of long-term interships for students and articled clerks by making these subject to regular reviews in an attempt to put shorter internship programmes on an equal footing and attract a greater variety of law students.

It is understood that previously JSA did not review long-term internships, which meant that student interns who were predominantly from Mumbai law schools or articled clerks studying for their Bombay solicitors examination often stayed with the firm for years, which created an informal expectation that they were guaranteed a job at the firm upon graduation.

Under the new policy JSA Mumbai will now review all students’ internships and articled clerkships every six months and appraise performance and decide whether each internship or clerkship should continue.

Mumbai-based partner Dina Wadia, who is also the firm’s management committee member responsible for human resources (HR) policies, explained: “The reason why we made this change to the longer term internships, to some extent, was mainly to broaden the base and not to give one particular type of student an advantage over the others.”

“We wanted to send the message that all newly qualified associates who apply to us will have the same opportunity and that by doing articles or long-term internships, you should not think you have an advantage or consider being retained as a done deal.”

JSA’s Mumbai office is understood to have previously had around 20 interns on internships of six months or longer, in addition to up to around 20 short-term interns from time to time.

It is understood that the numbers of long-term interns and articled clerks has therefore decreased at JSA over the past months as a number on internships were not extended. The firm would also be stricter in taking on new articled clerks.

Wadia noted: “This reiteration of our intern policy is for the firm as a whole though it has greater impact in Mumbai because of the higher number of the long term interns and article clerks in Mumbai.”

JSA’s regular short-term internship programme system remains unchanged.

Last year JSA’s Mumbai office for the first time visited campuses for recruitment, hiring a small number of students from NLSIU Bangalore and NUJS Kolkata, said Wadia. JSA again planned to visit campuses later this year after the firm’s staffing requirements were finalised.

Previously almost all of JSA Mumbai’s graduate recruits were hired directly out of its pool of long- and short-term interns.

Please help edit and create [[JSA|JSA’s entry on Legallypedia]].

Comments

Anonymous guest 27 Aug 2010, 23:04
+1 -0
Law firms should always choose students from the NLUs over those from B-grade colleges in Maharashtra like GLC, ILS, Symbi etc. Of course, the Thackerays could cause problems...
To you commentor 26 Jan 2018, 14:42
+0 -1
I have come across some obnoxious NLU graduates. I doubt whether they even appeared for LLB. The characters that I worked with had no knowledge of law. They looked more the paid and passed types or as usual contacts used to get in college, to pass, to get placed as group counsels/directors/SVP. Government Law College has given legal luminaries. Of course you will not know. GLC graduates are shining all over the world. I do hope Thackerays cause problem to people like u.
Anonymous guest 27 Aug 2010, 23:53
+1 -0
JSA took only a few from NLS and NUJS. With so many law schools these days getting a job has become very tough. The foreign firms have reduced their intake and people who would have otherwise had a comfortable job in London are now slaving away at AZB, AMSS etc. The Indian firms themselves have also reduced their intake. Bright graduates from NLS/NALSAR/NUJS are working at LPOs these days. It's shocking. I can only imagine the scene at DU, Amity etc.

It is depressing to see that LI does not criticise the oligarchs at SILF for opposing liberalisation. Job creation is a must and only liberalisation can make that happen. The vast majority of young lawyers want it. LI is burying its head in the sand and ignoring the struggles faced by law students. It is headline news on LI if Luthra or AMSS conducts a two-bit transaction or if Bhasin wins an inter-law firm gully cricket match. Not one word criticising these firms and how their crony capitalism is ruining the future of many young lawyers.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 00:24
+0 -1
#1. GLC graduates have a much better performance record that National Law Grads...
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 00:29
+0 -0
#1 Come to the market realize the diff......
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 01:19
+0 -0
#3 - And pigs fly.. So high..
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 01:42
+1 -0
This sort of petty fighting between law schools happens only in India. In the West there are enough jobs for everyone and it matters little which college you went to. I request all law students to unite and fight for liberalisation. Everyone will get good jobs if it happens. You guys should be ashamed of being so short sighted.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 02:19
+2 -0
@6 - umm have you ever read any comments section on Above the Law? the law school you go to in the USA will never stop mattering, especially in a big firm. Pettiness is universal. Also, a certain US law school (the name escapes me...look it up) is so short of jobs that it is encouraging its students to apply for jobs in Indian LPOs, and I'm not talking any superior position.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 02:35
+1 -0
@6 - The US Legal job market is in really bad shape right now! Their graduates have a very small recruitment rate even this year. As far as University of Michigan encouraging its students to join LPOs in India is concerned, Pangea 3 had approached UMich and its name was featured in the list of recruiters. Any University will do that if somebody approaches in this market. There was no encouragement from the University to join LPOs in india - that was just another blown up story from the "Above the Law" idiots.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 04:00
+0 -0
@7: The top 20 US law schools are pretty much at par in terms of faculty and the library facilities are good in US law schools. But in India there is a huge difference between NLSIU/NALSAR/NUJS and the 20th ranked law school. In terms of job prospects, a good student from a college like, say University of Connecticut or Ohio can get into a good law firm. You do not have to be from a top 5 college to get a good job. In India only a few NLU graduates end up with good salaries. The point I am making is that allowing foreign universities and foreign law firms will level the opportunities available to a guy who ranks 100 in the CLAT and a guy who ranks 600 and ends up going to a B-grade law school. SILF and the BCI are preventing this from happening.

And please don't use an exceptional scenario like the recession to prove your point. I can also say that many NLU grads were recuited by LPOs. That says nothing about the average standard of recruitment at the NLUs for the past few years.

I can't believe people don't agree with me on this!
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 04:44
+0 -0
There is nothing wrong in working for a LPO in your early years. A good LPO will provide good training in various corporate practices and chances are that these well trained individuals will have a head start once they leave the LPO's and join main stream corporate firms.

Repeated recent instances where a top international firm picked a few of its people from its contracted LPO entity into its mainstream practice (with full practice credit for years worked as paralegals) that too in these times of hiring freeze, speaks about how much this firm valued these individuals over and above people applying to it from various mainstream corporate practices.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 16:38
+0 -0
well..i dun think any change in the JSA internship policy matters much as anyways they are the ones known in the market for taking interns AND lawyers only on basis of CONTACTS (or "jugad") as many may choose to call it!! I remember this one time when JSA had 40 interns at the same time in its bombay office creating a major issue as to where the interns should sit!! I hope their revision of intern policy really means something rather than plain words..
But anyhow its good to know that they are beginning to take from campuses of NLUs..eventhough a small number...at least it may improve their image as a firm who would only take u if u have contacts with a top notch partner or are the relative of a high profile client!!!
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 18:04
+0 -0
@ 5,6 & 9 very good points. I do support you whole-heartedly. @ 2 you have hit the nail right on the head. Too much nepotism & bureaucracy existing in top Indian law firms. Foreign firms, companies & Universities should be welcome in India whole-heartedly. Recession is still on as I can see in Berkley (UCB) now. But things wii improve steadily. 2012/13 will be strong years for the global market...not my prediction but those of the top economists & market analysts worldwide. All the best to everyone.
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 19:45
+0 -0
Nice timing, just when I got thru with a non-national law skool.. I swear therz some kind of conspiracy against 2010 passouts- bar exam, CSAT for civils, new CAT pattern...
Anonymous guest 28 Aug 2010, 22:41
+0 -0
# 11 - 40 interns??haha!!!

bad man management for sure!!!

not a good sign for a firm like JSA
Anonymous guest 13 Sept 2010, 17:15
+0 -0
[...].its sad that a firm of that stature cannot even manage their internship policies,and also the question is :

wat wud b better for the firm ?
An intern whose worked with the firm for 2-3 years and knows the inside-out of hw the firm works or

A nls/nalsar graduate passout who has no clue.. which is obvious as he is new to the place and evrytin else...


Only if there was any substance in this article and the quotes in it....
Kancha 26 Jan 2018, 09:07
+0 -0
whats current JSA fresher salary ???