Khaitan makes work-from-home default till 2020-end • Bigger office plans on hold

Ghost towns, not just for lawyers
Ghost towns, not just for lawyers

Khaitan & Co has made working-from-home from a distance the default until the end of 2020, bearing in mind a variety of factors and routines upended by the Covid-19 pandemic.

“We have decided that we will give everyone the work from home option till end December 2020,” Khaitan director HR, Amar Sinhji, said after we contacted him for comment following an announcement at the firm made earlier this week.

“So we felt that it was just a common sense, practical and safe thing to stay with work from home until December 2020. If something (like a miracle vaccine) changes the situation before that, we will see. However, as optimistic as I may be, that seems highly unlikely,” he added.

There were several reasons for the firm’s internal strategy.

One was about staff who may have family members in other parts of the country and would prefer to be (or be stuck) in cities were Khaitan did not have an office.

“Let us say that your hometown is Chennai but you are stuck in Mumbai, with no clue as to when things will get back to normal / open up completely. So you now have the option to go back to Chennai and be with your family or at your family home where the overall family / social support systems make life far easier and you just continue to work from there,” Sinhji said.

The long game: Emotionally and physically tiring

Furthermore, most big firms appear to have at least somewhat been able to get used to remote working.

“The physical location of the workplace in the current context, has become irrelevant,” commented Sinhji. “Use of technology can create your playground wherever it is now convenient for you to play the game from - you no longer need to go to the stadium!

“Lots of people like that, especially those who live alone or are struggling without any domestic help, with young children or have parents who are alone and many who come from smaller towns can now take the call to go to their family / home for a longer period of time and get some stability and support. Many were physically worn out and this should give them an option to readjust and settle in for a longer period of time.”

Uncertain times

Then there is the problem that no one - neither politicians, nor public health professionals, nor law firm managing partners - seem to know exactly how long the ‘new normal’ will last and exactly how it will pan out.

“There is also the uncertainty of complete lockdowns whenever the spread becomes uncontrollable,” said Sinhji. “As an example, a couple of weeks ago we opened up Bangalore - up to 50% attendance - but with a complete lockdown there now, nobody can go to work. And nobody can tell when the lockdown will get eased up.

“And of course there is very limited public transport - so it is only when the suburban rail networks start that we can say things have truly opened up.”

How did opening offices go?

Khaitan had tried in June to tentatively open its offices to very limited capacities, so we asked how many people actually took up the offer of going to work physically.

“Calcutta and Bangalore had quite a substantial attendance, almost 30% of the total strength was present,” said Sinhji, but added: “Bombay and Delhi the attendance was wafer thin - less than 10%, for the obvious reasons of lockdowns / containment zones and the fact that there is no public transport (suburban rail).”

“There’s no point going to office,” added Sinhji, mincing no words. “You risk being infected during the commute to and fro, and certainly being in a closed and centrally air conditioned environments is not recommended.

“Also most large commercial complexes and individual offices are operating with no or minimal services and bare minimum staff. So if one was in office - it would be a struggle to get basic support services that we once took for granted.

“Some of the bigger complexes are a shadow of the beehive of activities that they once were - almost like ghost towns today.”

Mumbai expansion on hold: so could firms give up on office space and save some cash?

Sinhji said: “I think it’s too early to take that kind of a call, of changing a business model overnight that’s been running for more than a 100 years [with physical offices].

“We will not give up existing property in the near future. We have invested heavily in a certain level of infrastructure and we would be very careful before we dismantle all that.”

That said, things are not the same as they have been for 100 years either.

“We were planning to take some extra space in Mumbai, which we may not take now, but I don’t think anybody is at the stage where they will give up their offices completely,” explained Sinhji. “We will certainly rationalise physical space going forward, now that we know that work from home is a very viable and practical option for quite a few functions / roles and may actually make life easier in terms of time wasted in commuting long distances.

“The long held belief that it could be possible for a large majority to work remotely has now become a reality. However, everyone needs to think this through rationally and with some long term vision before rushing to create new operating models.”

Comments

Oak Law 17 Jul 2020, 14:14
+49 -1
Good they came out and said it and ended the uncertainty. Some very valid and practical points have been made by KCO.

Now hopefully other law firms will follow suit and follow this example as well, in the same way the are all tripping over themselves to revise compensation structures.
Guest0000 17 Jul 2020, 17:15
+29 -1
That's an amazing move from Khaitan!
Incite Insight Inside 20 Jul 2020, 19:26
+19 -6
Some discussion about New Joinees.
What's the excitement about? Enjoy this time.

Here's a sneak peek into your future.

.. First, you enjoy the $$. Your litigator friends make jokes about their poverty. You feel happy.

.. Soon, Associates with high potential & drive start to leave.
By 2nd & 3rd year, over HALF of the really smart ones quit. It doesn't make sense.

.. Not long before you feel like a circus monkey doing the same tricks in a loop.
But you keep at it. Why?

They make you feel like - no way you could survive in any less $$
Getting no personal time must be important for success
Getting health issues is a normal part of adult life
Thoughts about quitting a job must be normal

You think you could quit anytime & take control of your life again.

.. "Milestones" are placed cleverly so you keep pleasing the masters.
They are ALL your heart beats for.

MEANWHILE

Your litigator friends... they didn't stay poor

.. some started their own chambers
.. some have public visibility
.. better contacts, working hours, independence
.. self-reliant & answer to themselves
.. they choose their work & some even contribute a great deal to society
.. some are headed for politics, appear on TV, etc

It doesn't take long to realize. Kid, you got played.

IF your offer is rescinded, don't worry child
You might be better off
Mx. X 21 Jul 2020, 06:40
+1 -4
You lost me at '[N]ew'.
Batch of 2020 17 Jul 2020, 23:07
+10 -3
What about new joinees?
Insider 18 Jul 2020, 04:40
Troll Contested
+19 -41
All offers are likely to be cancelled. The firms are struggling. It is a genuine request to future joiners to consider alternative career options like rights activistism. as rights activists one contributes so more to the society.
GenCor 18 Jul 2020, 05:14
+37 -1
You had us in the first half
Someone in the know 18 Jul 2020, 15:57
Troll Contested
+5 -14
Yes that is infact true. Many RCCs of NLUs have received emails stating that offers are likely to be cancelled. Firms have also communicated a hiring freeze till end of 2021.
What the hell 19 Jul 2020, 04:04
+6 -1
Are you just making stuff up to scare people or what? You should at least lend some credibility to what you're saying. Which NLUs have received emails to that effect, pray tell?
Someone in the know 19 Jul 2020, 08:18
+1 -7
Why would I scare? It's not a joke. The pandemic has had serious effect on the firms. Infact if you have any doubts you get check with the specific firms itself.
Seriously? 19 Jul 2020, 10:54
+8 -3
Yeah then why would they call up the joinees to inform them of joining in October? And even the RCCs of NLUs have said that they still expect offers for day zero after speaking to the partners, who themselves are saying it's not as bleak as it seems.

No one's denying it hasn't had an effect on these firms but saying that they'll revoke offers looks extremely bad for these firms especially in terms of market reputation and would severely impact the relationships they have with these NLUs. At least for Tier-1 NLUs it doesn't seem like your doomsday foretelling is based on a shred of truth.
Additionally 19 Jul 2020, 10:56
+3 -0
It would really help if you could provide some credibility, even if vague, to what you are saying. Based on inside knowledge of which type of firms? Which tier of NLUs? What makes you think that they would cancel so many offers considering the extremely high attrition rates these firms have?
Simple 19 Jul 2020, 15:38
+5 -4
Lawfirms don't have any original demand as such. Their work depends on how much work the corporations they work are generating. The financial markets as well as all other sectors depends to a great degree on how the tertiary sector is doing. As the tertiary sector is the ultimate driver of the economy.
The pandemic and all the lockdowns have not only severely affected demand ( layoffs across companies and sectors) but has also changed the consumer behaviour. The entire global economy including India will contract severely. Now what does that mean? It means instead of growing the demand will actually decrease.
Why do lawfirms hire everyear? Because as they grow their demand increases and hence the need for more employees. Now since there is no growth there is no need for those new hires. And on top of that the demand has contracted. Which means even some of existing employees should lose work. But instead of layoffs the lawfirms has done paycuts. Basics.
All partners will try not to create panic and say they expect to honour the offers and hire in future. But it's just not in their hands.
New joiner 20 Jul 2020, 18:10
+3 -3
New joiner here. No firms have cancelled offers yet.
Smug 17 Oct 2020, 18:05
+0 -0
Most firms have started the onboarding process. Comments like these caused so much stress to those who were waiting to join. How frustrated you must be to do this. Shame on you, you louse.
Kudos 18 Jul 2020, 05:16
+26 -1
Fantastic that KCO is willing to broaden their thought process and look at human needs. Work is not going to miraculously increase by placing associates in desks.

Meanwhile other firms are doubling down on increasing physical attendance in office for no good reason.
Hilarious 18 Jul 2020, 05:33
+0 -0
Hilarious. Good one
Hungry 18 Jul 2020, 16:20
+3 -4
But does activism pay the bills?
Guest yours 18 Jul 2020, 18:42
+3 -6
Yes it does. You don't need to lead a luxurious life to be happy. Keep your wants in check and you will be fine. And in the process you will create a life worth living for many underprivileged people.
New Joinee 1 18 Jul 2020, 05:16
+3 -1
Or you can probably pontificate under disguised unemployment like Insider.
L&L Insider 18 Jul 2020, 05:47
+24 -5
Luthra please learn. It’s high time now. Be a little humane and let your associates breathe. Even if they’re at home, they have a life! Understand that.
Lootera 18 Jul 2020, 07:04
+17 -6
They have learnt. No one is buying a new Bentley, 7 Series, SUV or farm house this year. They are going to smoke their old batch of cigars and drink purana single malt. Others will eat dry roti with salt and onion.... if at all they can afford such luxuries.
Simple 18 Jul 2020, 15:56
+7 -2
Dry roti and salt and onion is good enough. Stop inflating the definition of good life.
Azad6955 21 Jul 2020, 06:18
+3 -0
Heard CAM CFO bought a Mercedes?
No 21 Jul 2020, 11:56
+2 -1
Aukat nahi hai boss. He works for a lawfirm not an investment bank.
Ex KCO 18 Jul 2020, 05:49
Troll
+2 -5
This [...] and the firm is a sham
Guest 18 Jul 2020, 06:42
+6 -1
Deep State, Big Law and Paid News are hiding the true extent of the damage caused on the legal economy.
NLU Stud 18 Jul 2020, 07:15
+6 -6
Are any Tier-1 law firms hiring?
Monkey baat 19 Jul 2020, 22:33
+12 -1
Trilegal is still offering PPOs somehow lol
Ex-KCo 18 Jul 2020, 08:31
+5 -2
Any idea of the address of the new NOIDA office? Joining AZB, who was alone suffering the shithole that NOIDA is.
JSA Gurgaon 18 Jul 2020, 19:31
+3 -2
Come to Gurgaon guys.. kind of lonely to be the only big league law firm there
Jan ki baat 19 Jul 2020, 07:06
+3 -6
Son, Trilegal Gurgaon sends warm regards.
Mannkey baat 19 Jul 2020, 17:25
+18 -2
Big league bola bhai
Ex-KCo 19 Jul 2020, 11:02
+1 -1
Don't AZB, Trilegal & SAM have offices of varying sizes in Gurgaon?
Incoming a0 18 Jul 2020, 10:34
+3 -7
What about new joinees ? Will WFH be for them as well from october ? Hearing rumours that joining is going to be postponed to January and OBVIOUSLY the salary till then.
Ghost 18 Jul 2020, 11:27
+31 -11
What the hell is this sense of entitlement with new joinees ???? Y do you behave as if you have been adopted by the firms for taking care of all your expenses from July every year( relieving your parents) ? Grow up.
Guest 18 Jul 2020, 12:19
+4 -5
Why do you think Incoming is a new joinee and not a troll? Because he claims so? New at LI, are you?
2015batch 18 Jul 2020, 14:42
+10 -7
I guess you never had a job offer that you had to worry about. Also, worrying for job and sustainence is called growing up.
Insider 18 Jul 2020, 15:53
+5 -16
So then please tell us why can't you pursue social rights activism?
Why can't you do something for this world/society?
Instead of just thinking about money all the time. If you make 15k per month then also you can sustain yourself. Stop making these excuses. You are just a misguided student thinking that money is necessary for happiness.
wut 19 Jul 2020, 15:52
+1 -0
Not sure if troll or stupid
Simple 18 Jul 2020, 15:54
+0 -1
Just email your firm and ask?
Another A0 20 Jul 2020, 18:15
+5 -1
Why is everyone so excited to join? Use these months to chill out and relax at home. Anyway it's unlikely that any firms have interns right now so you'll most likely be allotted intern work.
Guest 18 Jul 2020, 11:16
+43 -2
This model cannot be followed by CAM. Since all offices are first bought by CSS and family and leased at double the rental rate to the firm.

Family earns money from rental, 74% equity and travel company.

I don’t think KCO follows that model.
Insider - CAM 18 Jul 2020, 12:25
+10 -0
Look deeper at the travel company and you will understand what the true business model is.

See where the Shareholders and Directors of Aero Agencies lead and you will understand.
Interesting 19 Jul 2020, 10:49
+3 -0
You are right. I think even JSA's Gurgaon office is owned by Jyoti Sagar.
Azad6955 21 Jul 2020, 06:13
+1 -0
And how do you know that the rental rates are double?
KCO Associate 18 Jul 2020, 14:29
+20 -1
At least now i'll be able to terminate my lease agreement and save upto 6 months rent (which is quite a bit in Mumbai!
Undekhi 18 Jul 2020, 15:48
+20 -2
Damn ! They should have told you in March itself so you would have saved 9 months of rent. And also made a baby. Bad management yo !
Azad6955 21 Jul 2020, 06:15
+2 -3
So you expect Managing Partners to have a vision superior to Trump and Modi ? Are you really a lawyer ?
Tbh 21 Jul 2020, 19:50
+3 -2
A lot of people have a vision superior to Trump and Modi
Tera Baap 24 Jul 2020, 07:39
+0 -0
but you have to come back some day no (unless otherwise)!! Finding a decent house is always a pain
Prayersnvaccines 20 Jul 2020, 06:59
+4 -0
Any idea when Tri and SAM gonna say something? Many of us are paying rent for nothing in cities like Mumbai and Delhi
Sinsinati 24 Jul 2020, 13:34
+0 -0
I can feel you
FOR KIAN 20 Jul 2020, 07:05
+3 -1
Hi Kian,

Maybe you'd like to look into the Bar Exam and see if there's a story there which LI would like to cover.

The lockdowns and resultant delayed exams lead to delays in students receiving their results, and further delays in recieving provisional pass certificates required for registration. This could possibly lead to students being unable to register for the Bar Exam this year, the schedule for which hasn't been changed either for registration or for the exam itself. Furthermore, apparently in the BomHC branch of the Maharashtra Bar Council there had been reported cases due to which the office has been shut down and no fresh enrollment applications are being accepted.

Moreover this is for the persons who have received their results and have conclusively graduated. Several universities have either still not conducted final exams or released their results. GLC, Mumbai falls into either of those two categories, I believe the former. Such persons would definitely be unable to register with the State Bar and subsequently for the AIBE in time.
Darkseid 20 Jul 2020, 12:21
+3 -0
This is actually quite an important issue, especially the enrollment and declaration of results. With the enrollment, at least provisional practice can begin. But just like Maharashtra, several other state bars are also not processing enrollment applications at present.
FOR KIAN 20 Jul 2020, 16:30
+1 -0
Not much can be done about provisional enrollment considering a lot of NLUs have declared results, however, some old universities have either conducted exams very late or haven't conducted them at all. Furthermore, some are yet to declare results which can often take more time than you'd expect even in pre-covid times. They were trying to see how the UGC reacts to covid and what action should be taken consequently.

Therefore, the only solution that remains is to defer the bar exams considering joinings are anyhow being deferred, across the board.
Notworkingfromhome 20 Jul 2020, 07:29
+7 -0
Wow! what a fantastic move by Khaitan. The most sensible piece of news about law firms dealing with COVID 19 crisis. Management in some smaller firms don't seem to understand the mental and physical toll COVID 19 can taken on lawyers. I wish smaller firms take some ideas and stop forcing their lawyers to come to office (under the pretext of it being voluntary).
WFH Messiah? WTF 20 Jul 2020, 17:48
+20 -0
Work from home has become more like LIVE AT WORK. The workload seems to have significantly increased across practice areas in all the law firms.

Law firms thrive on chaos, uncertainty and ambiguity. The more clearly that the law is spelled out, the lesser is the work for lawyers. Similarly, in a stable environment work is limited (with the exception of M&A). But desperate times call for desperate measures and this has lead to tremendous demand in areas such as insolvency, debt (restructuring), M&A (attractive valuations for investors, conglomerates compelled to sell/ hive off businesses for reducing debt), employment.

Litigation has been hit. They cannot bill for the idle time wasted in courts while waiting for matters to come up. Also, there is limited scope for adjournment.

Capital markets has suffered but has been recently been busy with rights funding.

Those unlucky to have limited workload are compelled to write articles and conduct webinars!

Where is peace?

On top of that these greedy partners are now refusing to give increments (some are even shamelessly holding back the bonuses of last year). How is this fair? Will this ultimately result in people switching law firms (which gets them the increment) or reducing promotions
Azad6955 21 Jul 2020, 05:58
+6 -1
If HR ( harmful resource ) continues to justify their salaries by creating HR practices which are as harmful than Covid -19 , we may need an HR vaccine rite
Azad6955 21 Jul 2020, 06:05
+3 -0
This move shows that Khaitan HR is way ahead of CAM and Luthra HR who are only proving to be [...].
Ex KCO 24 Jul 2020, 07:41
+0 -0
oh please, CAM HR is so much more efficient than KCO's.
Bol bacchan 24 Jul 2020, 15:47
+1 -0
Bhayi SAM aur AZB kuch to bata do! Official email to daal do doston. Uncertainty me aur uncertainty na badhaoo
ALMT, Bangalore 11 Aug 2020, 09:11
+0 -0
And ALMT, Bangalore, threatens to fire its associates or not pay them if they don't turn up to office. If you do on the off chance get the opportunity to work from home they make you stand and show how you are dressed on a zoom call to 9 male partners who "eye" you to see if you are appropriately dressed. I would say borderline sexual harrasment, but what do I know. Things you love to see.
Elle W. 11 Aug 2020, 09:46
+0 -1
Do they expect the female associates to do a bend and snap too?
Guest 28 Sept 2020, 17:14
+0 -0
In the name of WFH, some partners are calling associates to work from their homes