Shardul Amarchand Bangalore PE/VC partner Siddharth Nair resigns (Roshan Thomas stays) • UPDATE: Resignation not (yet) accepted

Nair to leave SAM, details TBC
Nair to leave SAM, details TBC

Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas (SAM) Bangalore private equity (PE) and venture capital (VC) partner Siddharth Nair has resigned, we understand from sources.

He counts a number of major start-ups and investment houses as his clients, having worked with Lendingkart, Pepperfry, Swiggy, Faasos and Westbridge Capital, according to our deals directory.

Nair had joined in 2017 as part of SAM’s national absorption of BMR Legal.

M&A partner Roshan Thomas, who had joined with Nair in Bangalore, both having also worked at Themis Associates together before joining BMR, is understood to remain with the firm.

Both had been a coup for SAM when they had joined its Bangalore office, with its first Bangalore partner Karthik Mahalingam having left the firm in 2018.

Nair is a 2005 NLSIU Bangalore graduate who had begun his career at ALMT Legal, worked in-house at Old Mutual for a year in 2008, and then set out on his own for three years, under the Law Offices of Siddharth Nair banner.

He had joined Themis in 2012.

We have reached out to Nair and SAM for comment.

Update 00:53: We have received SAM’s comment, reproduced in full below:

Bangalore based salaried partner Siddharth Nair tendered his resignation from the firm on 30 April 2019. His resignation has not yet been accepted and will be handled in accordance with the Firm’s policies.

In any event, the Firm continues to have a robust presence in the Bangalore market, under the supervision of Amit Khansaheb, senior equity partner, who has been overseeing the operations in Bangalore following the departure of Karthik Mahalingam last year. Khansaheb, with support from Regional Practice Head – Corporate, Raghubir Menon, and locally based partner Roshan Thomas, continue to drive our strong Bangalore based M&A, PE and VC practice and neither the Firm’s clients nor our associates will be impacted in any manner.

Update 08:43: Nair commented:

Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co has been an incomparable platform and a wonderful place to work. I am and will remain deeply grateful to Mr. Shroff and the other lawyers at the Firm for the opportunities afforded to me during my tenure here.

I have tendered my resignation so as to explore an engagement with the practice of the law in a manner and at a scale more compatible with the personal issues that I am facing.

I reiterate my gratitude to the Firm for all the wonderful memories that I will take with me into the next phase of my career.

Update 6 September 2019: Nair’s quote above has been amended on request since publication.

Comments

Tuti phuti 1 May 2019, 04:03
+17 -4
Bhai - Who was the issue? SAM or Sid or both? SAM needs to rethink their HR policies.
Guest 1 May 2019, 04:08
+3 -17
Unbelievable ! Within the field of VC and PE work Siddharth Nair is comparable to ex-football player Guttuso of AC Milan
Bike 1 May 2019, 04:29
+76 -11
Major loss to SAM. Great lawyer and has a great reputation among clients
Insider 1 May 2019, 06:54
+3 -31
Bhai what are you smoking
Former Intern 1 May 2019, 04:41
+14 -3
Had a call back from SAM (through Sid). And now this.
Sully 1 May 2019, 05:25
+4 -1
Heard he is moving to the dark side.
detroit 1 May 2019, 05:26
+6 -6
who next? Khansaheb ?
kianganz 1 May 2019, 07:01
+3 -1
This comment had just been reported as naming individuals, so I wanted to share reason for not moderating. In short, it's not pretending to make a credible claim about someone leaving or sharing insider information, but seems to be merely making a rhetorical point. For what it's worth, we have no information that Khansaheb is looking to leave any time soon.
Loss 1 May 2019, 05:43
+35 -8
Big loss to SAM. Sid knew the Bangalore market having been on his own earlier as well (before BMR). Its a tough market and few firms like Indus, Tatva, JSA etc have managed to crack it with local presence and local clients.
CR 1 May 2019, 05:49
+8 -23
Aah the billing pressure got to him. Wonder if his "team" goes with him or stays.

Either ways, good luck Sid!
VJ 1 May 2019, 06:16
+41 -6
Hardly think it was billing pressure. By all accounts he was always ahead of his targets.
Haha 1 May 2019, 12:02
+6 -11
The team he moved with left long back! Apparently a brand new team.
Accounts Team 1 May 2019, 14:55
+21 -6
Considering that he had met his Financial Year target by November itself, it’s surprising to see a comment stating that “billing pressure got to him”.
René Higuita 1 May 2019, 06:17
+33 -2
Big loss but best of luck, Siddharth. Hope you find a great place with a sustainable working environment in tune with your needs.
Incomplete 1 May 2019, 06:33
+4 -1
Kian the following sentence seems incomplete: "M&A partner Roshan Thomas, who had joined with Nair in Bangalore, both having also worked at Themis Associates together before joining BMR". You may want to add something like "...before joining BMR, continues to be associated with SAM".
kianganz 1 May 2019, 07:16
+1 -2
Thank you, have corrected that sentence :)
Observer 1 May 2019, 07:24
+7 -1
Wonder what he s doing with his team!? Has he left them in a lurch!?
Spellcheck 1 May 2019, 08:19
+37 -6
SAMCO B'lore office bye bye. It's quite a sad state of affairs when the Chennai office has more fee earners than B'lore.

All the very best to Sidd! He had a great run at SAMCO and the firm should introspect into why it has had really high levels of attrition over the past year.
Guest 1 May 2019, 09:02
+56 -7
Sid- One of the best transaction lawyers in India. All heart. Huge loss for SAM
Uhh 1 May 2019, 09:52
+83 -9
Isn't the reaction by SAMCO really obnoxious - "we haven't accepted the resignation of this [i]salaried partner[/i] yet, and in any event, we have XYZ people so this resignation will impact zero people."

SAMCO HR/PR/Management should really get their acts together and learn to handle exits with a little more grace.
Cai 1 May 2019, 11:58
+39 -3
Agree with this 100%, especially given how gracious his quote is.
Jaiho 1 May 2019, 10:13
+5 -0
[img]https://media1.giphy.com/media/3orieT3S6lY6x7zoJ2/200.gif[/img]
FormerSAMy 1 May 2019, 12:06
+27 -4
This response clearly shows the firm's outlook towards its retainers and constituents - i.e., almost like bonded labour. My own exit was made extremely difficult and awkward by SAM, and I wasn't even a partner! While SAM can privately discuss and (possibly) enforce whatever notice period / gardening leave he may have agreed to, surely it doesn't think it can stop him from leaving altogether by not accepting his resignation.

This press statement is unclassy, and frankly SAM needs to do much better in terms of its messaging - especially if it hopes to hire and retain real talent. Many other / smaller firms have managed to gracefully respond to partner exits and announcements, and it isn't too much to expect from SAM.
Illogical? 1 May 2019, 12:49
+15 -2
Strange that SAM press release has no reference to the regional managing partner
Illusion 1 May 2019, 15:15
+15 -3
Unfortunately, SAM is a place which has a delusional sense of how an institution should be created. If modus is to pressurise people based only on targets, it is anyone’s guess how long they will remain.
Jalianwala 2 May 2019, 05:07
+4 -1
with no targets, SAM will also become a Boutique Law Shop
Illogic 1 May 2019, 17:06
+14 -3
Managing Partner for regional office is Natasha Shroff - in absentia.
Associate 1 May 2019, 18:44
+31 -6
Met him a couple of times. Stellar chap with a sense of humour. Good luck to him, things can only get better after SAM - which should seriously get an attitude adjustment to retain talent.
Elite Uppish Dilliwala 1 May 2019, 22:58
+5 -14
Peasants and country folks,

[...] Culture sucks in an all [...] lawyers. Too late for them to do anything but send people on leave.. [...]

Wonder how much Sid made? He made 100 crores we hear, got 10 crores bonus..
100 Crores 2 May 2019, 07:13
+31 -0
There is no single corporate partner in India, who has a team billing of 100 Crores.

None. Zero. So stop throwing numbers you cannot understand.
Doubter 5 May 2019, 17:21
+0 -2
Doesn't Reeba team over at CAM bill 40 crores per year? If that's the case, it is not hard to imagine Zia/Shardul/Ashwath/Cyril personally billing more than double that.
Sau Crore 2 May 2019, 18:55
+4 -0
Only possible for a bengaluru based lawyer or team of lawyers to make a 100 crore revenue. Bengaluru ki jai.
Point 2 May 2019, 02:56
+3 -12
I like how the moderator has only published positive comments and not anything negative. I know you’re watching son!
Guest212 2 May 2019, 04:09
+2 -14
The moderator has published negative comments about the firm but not about the person concerned.
Agree 2 May 2019, 04:22
+7 -0
True, but more people are likely to have opinions (good or bad) about a tier 1 firm than a small-town lawyer.
kianganz 2 May 2019, 04:38
+11 -2
Just had a look - most unpublished comments are actually negative comments about the firm, plus two or so comments about the person that are personal, that we would not have published in any case.
L&L 2 May 2019, 18:27
+3 -1
Kian, I have not noticed this abstinence on your part when it comes to publishing negative comments about L&L Partners (including specific people such as MS). Honestly I have no issues in you publishing positive or negative feedback about L&L as a firm but apply the same yardstick to SAM or any other law firm. I completely agree if you are controlling content on individuals but in that regard also apply the same yardstick and not publish negative comment regarding specific individuals. Given your readers, which are mostly law firm associates and as your site is one of the only sites where anyone can come and write anything, you publishing selective negative comments about a firm and not publishing negative comments about some other firms, creates different impression of different firms whereas the truth remains that all these firms suffer from the same drawbacks (some have more and some have less) and the juniors associates should know that reality.
kianganz 2 May 2019, 18:40
+1 -0
Thanks for your feedback, though you should perhaps also see comments about Luthra that don't get published, before making a comparison. Generally, criticism of individual partners' managing styles or the way a firm operates are ok in comments. Highly personal negative comments about such a managing partner, completely outside of their professional sphere, are generally not. But at the end of the day, some firms simply attract more such 'feedback' than others.
Heh 2 May 2019, 04:32
+12 -2
[...] is that you? So your biggest issue right now is that there are no public floggings of an employee that just quit?
Guest 2 May 2019, 05:41
+39 -7
I would like to pay tribute to a great lawyer and most of all a wonderful human being. Side is an inspiration for anyone aspiring to be top in the field of PE and VC.
Guest 2 May 2019, 05:57
+6 -6
Just curious if this is the start of the end for Khansaheb's group of loyal soldiers. Any thoughts???
Guest 3 May 2019, 04:40
+11 -2
KS lost the ability to take care of his compatriots when he signed SAM. This was realised by a few in advance and so they never joined SAM along with him while moving on from BMR Legal. Those who realised later have also started to move on and quiet a few have already left.
The ones who remain are either those who are indifferent to their condition or those who are waiting for an opportunity. All of them, for sure, are crying on their fate for have become a money minting machines as contrasted from a lavish life in BMR legal.
Salaried Partner 2 May 2019, 14:10
+6 -16
Why so much fuss for a salaried partner resignation? The person maybe is a good lawyer but no one is indespensible. SAM am sure is not a boutique which will be effected with this resignation...
Hmm 2 May 2019, 16:04
+10 -3
The fuss is about the childish reaction of the firm to the resignation, no one really cares about a salaried partner quitting at a big law firm, as these places have become revolving doors anyway.
thumka 2 May 2019, 23:34
+3 -1
join a bputique law shop
localawyer 2 May 2019, 17:07
+0 -4
salaried partner?? I heard he was equity along with khansaheb and roshan when they moved from BMR Legal.
Trigger warnings 4 May 2019, 09:03
+18 -2
If only he gave less of a leash to [...]. Atleast 4 resources left [...].

Those glasses are foggy Sid, and these pretzels are making me thirsty.
Ex-insider 7 May 2019, 14:11
+1 -1
Men may come and men may go, but SAM will go on forever.

That is the sad reality, contemplating the rest is useless gossip.
Intelligence Bureau 8 May 2019, 10:02
+1 -1
I hear he will join a startup as Executive Director (Legal). He might even join the board of a start up. Let's see.
Uncle Sam 13 May 2019, 16:02
+2 -0
He's starting his own practice again probably.. life comes full circle it seems like.. all the best Sid! Don't let the leeches bring you down.. you know who I'm talking about..
Update 8 Sept 2020, 02:16
+0 -0
Shouldn’t you update this story? He still is at the Firm and has moved to Delhi and works directly with the Shroffs