Spice Route publishes 0-7 PQE pay bands from Rs 9.7 lakh to 50.4 lakh (w/ bonus) [UPDATE-1]

Spice Route Legal pay scales (via LinkedIn)
Spice Route Legal pay scales (via LinkedIn)

Three-partner firm Spice Route Legal, which had been founded in 2016 by former K Law partner Praveen Raju, has revealed its remuneration for associates from 0 to 7 years of post-qualification experience (PQE).

The pay levels are (including an assumption that each scale equates to a level of PQE):

Presumed PQEAnnual compensation, incl. bonus, in Rs lakhY-o-y percentage increase
Associate 109.72-
Associate 2116.267
Associate 3221.0630
Associate 4325.9223
Senior Associate 143639
Senior Associate 2539.610
Senior Associate 364514
Senior Associate 4750.412

According to the firm’s LinkedIn post of yesterday, which was also inviting job applications from lawyers, the firm said: “We thought we would do our bit for pay transparency, and so - below is our revised salary scales for 2021.”

According to the graphic with the “compensation scales”, the figures are “inclusive of annual bonus”, which we would assume means that this is the maximum possible compensation paid out, if a fee-earner manages to get 100% of the bonus.

We have reached out for comment to Raju about whether the bonus amounts were fixed or variable and what the previous pay scales were but he declined to comment.

Update 10 December 2020: Partner Mathew Chacko told Bar & Bench today that there had been no significant increase in its pay:

It isn’t a major revision in the pay structure, it is an annual revision. It was a year in which we expected things to go south, but we did quite well, and we decided to share the rewards with lawyers at the firm.

We are a small firm with around 30-odd lawyers and we’ve only been operational for about four years. Whatever rate we have been going at in the past few years, we have gone at during this year, so there has been no real difference.

According to its website, Spice Route Legal now has 3 partners and a total of 14 fee-earners (including partners). It has offices in Bengaluru, Delhi, Mumbai and Kochi.

Nevertheless, it is an interesting look inside fee-earner pay structures and the first time an Indian law firm has revealed those.

At many international law firms, the base salary for at least the first few years is known and disclosed internally, with the bonus element acting to differentiate performance.

At most Indian law firms, however, the base pay bands for even associates after the first year of PQE begin diverging widely, and more so with increasing levels of seniority.

We have recently reported that Nishith Desai had raised its fresher pay to Rs 16.2 lakh plus a fixed bonus of Rs 1.2 lakh generally paid out 18 months after joining for first year’s:

[In 2015], Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas (SAM) had announced a revolutionary base pay without any bonus component of Rs 15 to Rs 16 lakh per year (though in some cases the firm strangely ended up paying freshers less than promised, as we had reported in 2017).

SAM had followed Khaitan & Co hiking its base pay to Rs 14.4 lakh (excluding up to Rs 1.8 lakh of bonus).

Trilegal had pushed up to Rs 13 lakh plus up to Rs 2.2 lakh of bonuses, while Amarchand Mangaldas Mumbai (as it was back in April 2015, was on a base of Rs 12 lakh and a maximum bonus of Rs 3 lakh).

Hat-tip to a reader for pointing us to this.

Comments

Uncle SAM 8 Dec 2020, 11:52
+14 -2
We pay far less to our people, even though we are a top tier firm. These people seem to be have been affected by the crazy COVID-19 virus, hiking their pay to such hefty amounts. It doesn't make sense to pay such high amounts in the job providers market.
Dilli ki garmi 8 Dec 2020, 12:07
+2 -33
Vertices Pays more than this at each level. Senior Associate there is at 55 L- 40 fix and 15 L bonus
Joke 8 Dec 2020, 13:53
+34 -0
I know people who have gotten jobs as SA there. At max they pay 28L for someone with 8-9 years experience. One can even become a partner there in 7-8 years who have bad quality and are paid poorly. Some partners ex partners have interviewed at our firm, so we know exactly how much they earn. It has a horrible work atmosphere. Not many from vertices even get jobs in other decent law firms
Not a bad joke 8 Dec 2020, 14:15
+2 -25
I have only heard good things from the recruiters about the firm. Some told me that its a stellar organisation with very strong pedigree founders. All of their alumnis also are in support of the firm.
Faku 8 Dec 2020, 17:32
+9 -0
One of the recruiters themselves told me not to apply to vertices because she has heard bad experience from all people who have joined there. Also said they cannot pay what I am already getting (30 lakhs for 6 years experience). Also mentioned about a particular partner who is "difficult" to work with. She said with my experience I'll get anything better. Obviously I did and not through her. And if a firm wasn't paying more than 30L it makes no sense to apply. Also, if the firm is so great I wonder why they have a vacancy throughout the year at all levels! Recruiters have been calling me till around a week back!

Let's concentrate on better firms and wish Algo thr best rather than firms that have themselves become trollish on LI. That's the lowest one can sink. Also, considering the regular departures at junior levels, and the constant trolling on LI, this is definitely happening from senior levels or management. LI needs to ensure that such trolls don't spread misinformation to gullible others. Mere speaking with a recruiter is enough to know that they don't even offer 30L to a senior SA.
Realitybites 12 Dec 2020, 07:56
+1 -0
Have you gotten a job?
Alumni 8 Dec 2020, 17:36
+6 -0
Ohh please! None of us have anything good to say about the firm! We would not leave otherwise. The others there are ones who cannot get anything decent. Horrible experience and pay. Don't drag us for your benefit if you know nothing about what we have been through. There's a ex vertices group too where we rue the day we chose it
Question 8 Dec 2020, 16:36
+2 -0
Are we saying that the way Vertices behaves with its lawyers and the amount it pays them does not deserve any drum rolls? :)
Ex vertices 8 Dec 2020, 21:02
+5 -1
Hold on joker. Just go and check where are people who left vertices are currently employed. 90% of them are in a tier 1 law firms.
Booster 8 Dec 2020, 21:22
+0 -0
Hahaha
Plum 9 Dec 2020, 05:51
+2 -0
And why did they leave exactly? The work culture there is quite well known
Exvertices 9 Dec 2020, 11:23
+9 -1
The founding partners are not the best people to work with honestly - they are downright horrible. (Can't say the same about Vishal though - super mentor) Truly the work is extremely taxing, hours are super long and bosses are extremely demanding. On a level of balance in life, work and the salary offered - the firm will extract the shit out of you. Hence, no good experience for anyone working there.

Having said that, this also (I am laughing inside - that's life) makes the people at Vertices extremely hard working and experienced - and helps get the best out of the year spent there. I honestly feel that my current work load in the tier 1 firm I work with is laughable.

P.s. it's true. Ex-vertices people have been poached to AZB, SAM, CAM, JSA, Khaitan etc. A LinkedIn crawl will tell you that - also the reason I joined the firm. Perfect training ground and also perfect ground to move up the ladder if you haven't had the best law school or the best resume. Poaching works well too - people want to escape the pressure induced work atmosphere, and recruiters usually find the talent for tier-1 as each person had handled deals closely - explaining the high attrition.

(P.S. been some time since I exited the firm. Can't speak on the current environment).
God 9 Dec 2020, 15:54
+1 -1
I agree with this person. Yes Vishal is the only go to person of you need some guidance or knowledge. So learning and guidance is limited to an extent now in comparison to what was there before. All the talented people have left the firm and therefore quality of work has now gone down.
holi 11 Dec 2020, 16:00
+2 -5
At Vertices you grow based on your hard work. I know a person who became Associate Partner from Associate in 2 years.
Interview 9 Dec 2020, 07:06
+5 -0
Many have come here for interviews. We know their packages. Even the APs hardly make 40 lakhs. They didn't get the job too. Tier ones SAs with 4 years experience are better than vertices partners
Drum Roll 2.0 9 Dec 2020, 08:10
+1 -0
Let the "drumroll continue" by sharing "strategic insights" of constant calls of "more power to you, my friend" *giggle*
Parrot 9 Dec 2020, 14:43
+2 -3
Only a firm (or person) with low self esteem or self confidence would want to hijack every post even unrelated to them. Funny thing is that they even put out wrong information. If you want so much limelight, why not disclose your own salaries to LI for publication? Why write stupid comments on others reports? If you do something good it will be reported. No one cares about these random comments. If you are not good enough to get limelight on LIs headlines, stop stopping to such levels or commenting hoping that it will attract talent. It will not. Let the firms mentioned in the article get their due attention
Wannabe patent attorne 8 Dec 2020, 12:59
+6 -21
Matthew checko of srl is terrific guy. No doubt the firm is growing by leaps and bounds.
Guest 8 Dec 2020, 12:59
+3 -5
Will LI change the old definition of Big 7 Law Firms now?
paywall 8 Dec 2020, 15:54
+3 -1
How does the pay at SA level at SRL compare to Big 7?
Random 8 Dec 2020, 20:38
+3 -1
I think the pay at most of the top firms after around 3 years are almost comparable. I think the numbers publicized are the highest ones. But if you look at average salary (including bonus) you'll realise at any decent firm the pay isn't much off from the others.
But... 8 Dec 2020, 22:33
+17 -0
An important set of questions that need to be asked, in relation to these figures are:

(1) while they have mentioned the pay inclusive of the bonus, what's the break-up between the fixed and the bonus component? Is the break up consistent across the board (unlikely) or does it vary? It's all well and dandy to say, that one can get X in paper, but what does one get in hand?

(2) what are the ranges of the percentage of bonus actually provided to the retainers? It's great to say that the annual pay is X per year, but what portion of the variable/bonus component is generally given (for performers at the median level of performers and top-level performers)?

Without answers to these questions, the figures, while helpful on some level may not be nearly as meaningful as they can be. That the firm representatives declined to comment on these aspects is telling (though completely understandable).

One would hope that the fact of (relatively) smaller firms such as NDA and SRL would induce some of the bigger players (who have made their lawyers slog much harder during the pandemic) give the much needed/deserved hikes, or risk bleeding talent.
HSA 9 Dec 2020, 02:59
+28 -1
That's not how you run a firm! How will Matthew Chacko buy Aston Martin(s) if he pays his associates such high amounts?!!
Guest 9 Dec 2020, 03:06
+24 -2
For many years LI has done NLU placement analysis by giving Big 7 firms topmost importance and ignoring jobs at smaller firms, companies, lawyers chambers, think tanks, academics, UPSC etc. In the first few years of LI's existence it was the undisputed market leader and had a readership 10 times higher than Bar & Bench. Thus, students, parents and coaching centres all got the impression that a job at AMSS (in those days), Khaitan, AZB etc is the be all and end all of law school. This has caused irreparable damage and we continue to see the effects today.
Tier1 what 10 Dec 2020, 04:45
+2 -6
The reason they are also called the "big 7" (in college no one includes JSA, so they are called big 6 is also because of the quality and value of deals they work on. While Spice Route may once in a while work on a big transaction, the big 6 work on the best transactions in the country and that's why they command the respect.
Correct 9 Dec 2020, 06:31
+0 -6
And here is the video of Lexygen management recruitment talk which I mentioned before where they are stating the salary numbers -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69MVENaFqt0&t=3183s
Correct 9 Dec 2020, 07:32
+0 -3
Sorry, I have posted this in the wrong article. I wanted to post this on my comment on the Nishith Desai article.
Verna 9 Dec 2020, 12:16
+4 -4
Absolutely. The promised fresher level pay is Inr 15 lakh at Lexygen, which is highly competitive. Unfortunate, that this information is not widely available and accessible. The work-life balance often makes up for the balance difference between the pay across firms and if some is still left - boutique corporate firms have to step up pay (near tier 1 levels) to retain talent and avoid poaching from recruiters. Honestly - the amount of LinkedIn lead generating exercises by recruiters is (ugh)
ImBalance 9 Dec 2020, 16:11
+0 -0
Balancing since 2006
BigLaw 9 Dec 2020, 15:32
+2 -2
With 9.7LPA for freshers, aren't SRL paying less than tier-1?
Notsure 9 Dec 2020, 15:45
+5 -0
Yes, but from 2nd year onwards they are paying almost the same as tier 1 firms do.
levante 9 Dec 2020, 15:46
+24 -3
Seems more like a publicity stunt w.r.t to the salaries !!
SRL 9 Dec 2020, 19:08
+28 -4
The thing to understand is that they have only one SA until now.
Tier-1 9 Dec 2020, 21:30
+8 -0
Are these salaries even sustainable in the long run? Even tier-1 firms don't pay as high as 36 lakhs to SA1.
Transparent but select 10 Dec 2020, 03:10
+24 -0
What the firm has selectively left out is their compensation for six month trainees (who are fully qualified lawyers btw and this is a mandatory path to becoming an associate). Trainees are paid nothing and this has been a bone of contention even internally for a while. Important to note that the firm has more trainees than associates or senior associates (one). Full transparency would be to include this information, and breakup of fixed and variable component. But the pay scales as a whole look attractive.Questions that time will answer: will bonuses be paid out in full, are these pay scales sustainable and especially if the firm is to start paying its trainees (associates at any other firm) which it really should. They are good founders, hope they do this well.
Bhola99 10 Dec 2020, 05:14
+15 -1
Money is worth it if you're left with enough time, energy and enthusiasm to put it to use in a manner you deem fit (i.e. money earned within 50-60% of one's conscious hours). If one is having to slog for 90-95% of his/ her conscious hours slogging, then what does he/ she do with it as there's no time but to sleep? That's the problem with the Indian sweat shops.
Trainee lives matter 10 Dec 2020, 07:07
+6 -0
Trainees are paid 30-40 k.

Trainees= A0 in any other firm..

The salaries are inflated.

And are you saying a 2017 grad is making 36 Lac? If yes, we have nothing to worry about.
Trainee 2021 28 Jan 2021, 15:42
+3 -0
This year, trainees are unpaid. This announcement was a sort of a PR thing by the firm. They went to tier 2 law schools a few weeks after this announcement, and started offering the six-month traineeships to final year students. Until last year, the trainees were paid a decent stipend, but this year there isn't going to be any.
The dangling carrot was that last year all the trainees were absorbed. But again, past performance is no guarantee of future results.
A man can only hope.
Tired one at the Tier1 10 Dec 2020, 11:04
+1 -1
Are the salaries at same PQE levels gonna be same at SAM/CAM?
Kat Diya Tier 1 Ka 14 Dec 2020, 06:21
+3 -1
Tier 1s after sucking all energy barely match these numbers. They have weird policies to ensure that money never reaches the resources but fills the coffers of the MPs
Guest Post 10 Jan 2021, 12:40
+0 -0
Whats an average salary of an A2 in litigation or sectoral practice team of tier 1 law firms? Thanks in advance.