Three new Khaitan & Co Mumbai partners; Associate bonuses 30 to 50%

Mumbai
Mumbai

Khaitan & Co has promoted Mumbai associates Joy Jacob, Ashwin Mathew and Savita Singh to its partnership and announced associate bonuses of as much as 90 per cent of annual salaries at the top end.

Jacob specialises in infrastructure, Mathew in private equity and corporate and Singh is a real estate practitioner.

Khaitan & Co has also announced its 2009-10 financial year associate bonus payments, which on average ranged between 30 and 50 per cent of annual salaries, although in some cases reached 90 per cent, according to associate sources.

Partner Rabindra Jhunjhunwala said that despite the recent aggressive lateral hires the firm did not want to stop growing. “The idea of taking our lateral hires to keep growing, strengthening our existing team, complementing our core areas and to be truly full service.”

He conceded that managing last year’s growth at the firm would be difficult but that senior partners would have to spend more time on management to bed down the process.

He added that the firm would have to show it was transparent in its internal partnership career progression by rewarding good and competent associates.

Mathew, who had been with Khaitan & Co for three years after finishing an LLM in Cambridge, said: “It’s been a long road and it’s a very good feeling.”

In respect of internal promotions vis-à-vis lateral hires he noted: “The volume of work is such that what they’re doing makes complete sense and the hiring in areas which are viewed as growth areas of the future.”

All three new internal partners are Mumbai-based. Jhunjhunwala said that the promotion process across the firm’s offices was complete for this year.

Khaitan & Co operates an all-equity partnership where shares are determined by a variety of factors.

Khaitan & Co associate sources told Legally India that associate bonuses for the past financial year were slightly better than last year, when the firm had taken a more conservative view of market conditions.

It is understood that the majority of bonuses ranged between 30 and 50 per cent of annual salaries, although in some cases this figure rose up to bonus payments equivalent to 90 per cent of salaries.

“Truly there is no upper limit,” commented Jhunjhunwala. “It is entirely dependent on associate performance, at whatever level he or she may be. We like to reward our people and we like to make our people feel that at the end of the year they are going to be paid what they are due or elevated to what they are due.”

Typically, five-year qualified associate salaries at Khaitan & Co can be around Rs 20 lakh ($45,000) per year or higher, according to data from Legally India’s associate engagement survey from late 2009.

For newly qualified associates the standard annual salary at Khaitan & Co is between Rs 10 lakh to Rs 11 lakh ($22,500), according to the firm. [Correction: starting salaries were originally erroneously stated as being 6 lakh]. [clarification 2: the Rs 10 to 11 lakh figure provided by Khaitan included potential bonuses and other benefits]

According to associate engagement survey data, most bonuses at Khaitan & Co in the 2008-09 financial year were between 20 and 30 per cent of annual salaries.

Comments

Anonymous guest 6 Apr 2010, 15:37
+2 -0
Is the Legally India survey ready and available?

[Hi, I had unfortunately underestimated somewhat the difficulties of keeping responses confidential but still extracting meaningful data and it is taking more time than originally planned. I know it has been months now and I am chipping away at it to put it into a presentable format but not quite there yet. I hope to integrate them gradually into stories and coverage and soon be able to publish something comprehensive.

Apologies for the ultimately inexcusable delay again. - Kian]
Anonymous guest 6 Apr 2010, 16:18
+2 -1
Congrats Savita...Keep it up..Proud of you....
Anonymous guest 6 Apr 2010, 18:44
+1 -1
"Typically, five-year qualified associate salaries at Khaitan & Co can be around Rs 20 lakh ($45,000) per year or higher".

Associate for 5 years .... isn't that unusual? As in, don't most people become senior associates in 3-4 years at bigger firms like Amarchand etc.?

At the bigger firms like AMSS etc., is the senior associate (4-5 years) salary above 30 lacs?
Anonymous guest 6 Apr 2010, 20:07
+2 -0
Other growing law firms should take cue and give their associates bonuses and other incentives in order to retain them. What is the growth of the firm for if the associates who worked hard along with the partners are left out of the fruits of their hard work? Keep up the good work Khaitan & Co!! One of the many reasons why people would like to work with your law firm.
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 00:23
+1 -2
I keep on meeting managaing partners of international law firms and they dont does it! And this is why we also dont does it!
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 04:42
+0 -0
90% of annual salaries as bonus for top performing associates....hmm....wonder how many top Indian law firms or for that matter any foreign law firm match the number??
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 06:04
+0 -0
Kian, seems you have accepted retainership or henchmen cuts from some of these law firms, who advertise through you website. You represent the celebrated mouthpiece thrusting dollar hungry lawyers who left UK before it became too wise!!

[Thanks for your comment but sorry, I fail to follow your reasoning or argument on that one... -Kian]
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 06:15
+0 -0
#6 to answer your question - many. Several law firms do, sometimes at 100%. Also, Khaitan is not exactly amongst the highest paying firms in India - not in the same league as AMSS, Luthra and AZB - for junior associates at least, don't know about senior guys there
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 07:08
+0 -0
Kian - hats off to you for posting that comment on #7. It only goes on to show LI's integrity and that you truly believe in what you are doing. Kudos.
Anonymous guest 7 Apr 2010, 17:31
+0 -0
I agree with # 8. I have also heard that Khaitan does not pay as much as AMSS, AZB or Luthra. But at the same time I have heard that the work culture at Khaitan (at least Bbay office) is much better. How does one account for that?
Anonymous guest 9 Apr 2010, 06:45
+0 -0
Well, I know for a fact that the starting salaries are not 10 to 11 lakhs.

Kian, you were closer with the 6 lakhs figure stated originally...
Anonymous guest 9 Apr 2010, 16:19
+0 -0
definitely not 10-11 lacs atleast not in Kolkata..actually starting package for a frsh graduate is 5 lacs..M dure!
Anonymous guest 9 Apr 2010, 16:43
+0 -0
No way. Kian you were right the first time. Khaitan definitely does not offer 10-11 lakhs to fresh graduates.
Anonymous guest 9 Apr 2010, 21:09
+0 -0
I know for a fact that some of my batchmates are joining Khaitan for 10+ starting package
Anonymous guest 9 Apr 2010, 22:44
+0 -0
this may differ from city to city .... like in kolkata they pay around 25-30 a month .
Anonymous guest 10 Apr 2010, 07:39
+0 -0
I am in and would be joining soon. The exact figure for a fresher at KCO, Mumbai (which pays the highest) is 8.7 lacs. This is the revised scale. Last year they reduced the pay of the freshers to 6 lacs from 6.6 lacs. The point-to-point exact figures! Probably would help you for your survey too.
Anonymous guest 11 Apr 2010, 06:59
+0 -0
Kian, who feeds information to you? What is your source of information? Is it Partners of law firms who run surrogate campaigns on your website? How come you never run critical news headings on your website?

Leaving that task only to anonymous posts? Agreed, that you dump all these anonymous posts as comments, but thats a very lame excuse for journalistic discretion.

In fact, you will discover a pattern, the anonymous posts offer much better information than the gushing headlines that you create.

No doubt, you will get enriched in the process, but quite soon you will lose all credibility.

[See #19 below for response. -Ed]
Anonymous guest 11 Apr 2010, 22:35
+0 -0
@ #16 - Maybe they're paying you better (which is quite unlikely) because from what I know, KCO Mumbai pays freshers about 65k a month which is around 7.8 lakhs a year minus deductions. So ultimately in hand, a fresher at KCO probably gets about 55k a month. But I hear this year, they've increased pay scales of associates who have been there for about 2-3 years to about 12 lakhs a year, which is great and well deserved for the most part.

Congrats to Ashwin Matthew (a truly exceptional legal genius), Joy Jacob and Savita Singh. And a very big thumbs up to Kian for his comment to #7! :D
kianganz 13 Apr 2010, 09:42
+0 -0
Dear @17,

Thanks for your comment and some of the valid points and thought provoking points you raise - apologies for the delayed response, which I hope addresses some of your queries.

Journalism is based, to a large extent, about building long-term relationships where you find out whether you can trust sources and rely on the information they give you.

A lot of this is based on gut-feeling and experience as it is impossible within time constraints to triple-check every single piece of information when it comes from a normally trusted source.

In this case, we have actually spoken anonymously to several associates to confirm the actual bonus figures and other details. However, we are investigating the starting salary and will come up with measures to deal with and correct this, if necessary.

The anonymous comments by their nature are able to be much more critical than any balanced news article ever can be. Part of the reason these go up largely unmoderated is so that there can be transparency about news and things that are wrong can be highlighted by readers.

Hopefully, they also help in bringing out the truth through reasoned debate.

However, I disagree that we only ever run positive stories - we regularly publish a number of stories that point out difficulties in firms or other organisations when there is sufficient evidence for it.

Partly, negative stories also take much more time to fully research and stand-up and we are currently somewhat short-staffed with the volume of news that is coming out of law firms.

I would love to be able to take on a larger team, of course to be able to do proper investigative reporting, but with "enrichment" as you put it still expectedly a long, long time away, we have to do the best we can with the current resources.

In any case, our mission and aims remain unchanged to what they were when we first started less than a year ago.
http://www.legallyindia.com/legally-india-all-news-about-the-indian-legal-market

Do keep letting me know your thoughts and please bear with us during any teething problems we experience.
Best regards,
Kian
Anonymous guest 14 Apr 2010, 23:49
+0 -0
Please take it from me....Khaitan is a family run organization and as much as they claim to be corporate run...each office has a different work environment. Mumbai is the only one with decent work culture, Delhi has a haanji wheeler dealer attitude, In kolkata they are too fuddy duddy to even use computers and bangalore is too small for any sort of presence.Khaitan and co survives becoz of the Mumbai office and its dynamism therefore its brilliant for recognizing the efforts of the three partners in mumbai on the basis of the work they do and not on any other grounds....
There is nothing known as meritocracy in KCO. Its all about how well you can [lobby]. If your partner likes your face you get 110% of your sal as bonus and if not then you get nothing. It isnt fair...but where is it???
Anonymous guest 15 Apr 2010, 05:52
+0 -0
Hi ex khaitan at #20. You definitely did not get 100 or 90% bonus (or maybe you got zero bonus). Therefore you had to leave and now you are ex khaitan. case of sour grapes, huh?
Anonymous guest 16 Apr 2010, 18:02
+0 -0
I agree with ex khaitan. Grapes for sure aren't sour for me. But that is how khaitan is. [...] Most brilliant people who have come in and left khaitan get tired of the "average-ness" around! And the root to this is their forever low payscales. The moolah they have been creating over the hike is also taken by the [...] associates simply because they had not experienced any sort of increments for years. The firm got them to a level that they would be happy with anything that is not demeaning enough for them to return their cheques or just quit. That's how the story is!
Anonymous guest 16 Apr 2010, 22:57
+0 -0
I don't know enough facts to comments on #20 to #22. However, in every organisation there are people who feel this way. Perhaps #20 and #22 did not had a good experience.

At the same time, I have heard from many people that Khaitan is a great place to work (as compared to some other similar positioned law firms). Also, the way their name has come up in Mumbai in last few years is remarkable! I am told that Haigreve Khaitan is one of the finest lawyers around. I have also heard highly about Murali Neelakantan.

Also, the new people who they have laterally recruited (reported earlier on Legally India) also seem to be very capable. This should iron-out quality issues, if any.

At the end of the day and in a market like India, once cannot have hegemony of only couple of law firms. There is need of more quality law firms for competitiveness and serving clients better. I think emergence of Khaitan as an alternate is exciting and I am keen to track progress of this firm in next few years.
Anonymous guest 20 Apr 2010, 22:48
+0 -0
khaitan kolkata pays 25000 a month to a fresh graduate..Khaitan Mumbai arnd 50000 ..so depends upon place to place...But Khaitan Kolkata is not a gud place to work in.Khaitan is just a hyped up firm!
Anonymous guest 20 Apr 2010, 22:50
+0 -0
Recruitment in Khaitan Kokata is through referenes most of the tym..except for d NUJS Grads..
Anonymous guest 21 Apr 2010, 00:45
+0 -0
@#24...Khaitan has been on deal and IPO tables consistently...saying its hyped up would be incorrect
Anonymous guest 21 Apr 2010, 15:40
+0 -0
Khaitan is certainly hyped... this portal should actually be run by anonym guests rather than kian. they have a better insight on what is truly happening. couldnt agree with #17 or 20 any more!
Anonymous guest 21 Apr 2010, 15:49
+0 -0
Mumbai Khaitan Rocks Anytym..BUt apart from Mumbai, Delhi is just Average, Kolkata is Below Average and Blore barely an existence...
Anonymous guest 22 Apr 2010, 20:15
+0 -0
What about Senior Associates? Strangely the article does not talk about of internal promotions of associates - Kian, can you check if khaitan has announced another set of internal promotions as is done by other law firms including Luthra and JSA?
Cynical 11 Aug 2011, 10:52
+0 -1
I dont understand the fuss about fresher's salaries. Though peanuts are not appreciated, initially one should concentrate on the work culture as well quality of work. That becomes one of the most important factors later on.