112 GNLU students, alums, volunteers call 6,000 stranded workers to help them get home: Appeal for others to start nat’l movement, pool resources

However, the GNLU students have reached the limits of what they alone can achieve and are keen to help other law schools start a wider movement

GNLU students organise transport for 6,000 migrant workers (photo of special refugee train 1954, Government of India)
GNLU students organise transport for 6,000 migrant workers (photo of special refugee train 1954, Government of India)

Around 40 GNLU Gandhinagar students in addition to 72 volunteers, including GNLU alumni, has started a project to assist migrant workers to return home.

The students and volunteers had individually contacted and assisted around 6,000 labourers catch the so-called Shramik (labour) special trains home, fifth-year student Varun Srinivasan, who is volunteering in the programme, told us (more details and success stories are contained in the PDF included in the article below).

The project is similar in ambition to the Mazdoor Mitra website set up by NLIU Bhopal students, which we had reported on earlier this week, as well as other ad hoc projects law students at other schools have been involved in.

GNLU’s Srinivasan said that over the last days, the GNLU Centre for Law and Society (GCLS), co-ordinated by GNLU students Abhishek Vyas, Shashwat Shrivastava, Aayushi Jain, Chinmay Mehta, Dushyant Thakur and Disha Devadas, had begun assisting the Zenith Legal Aid Clinic in Shivpuri, Madhya Pradesh on its work.

“As GCLS members began the work, they were startled by the difficulties faced by labourers and quickly threw open the project to volunteers from the entire University,” he said, noting that the 40 students in the society had quickly enlisted more volunteers, to number a total of 112, who had been working “around the clock” to “assist labourers to get home, for stranded victims to get food, rations and supplies”.

“The story has been remarkable,” Srinivasan said. “The initial project was to contact labourers who were given a seat in the special shramik trains who had otherwise been unable to get confirmation. These led to follow up calls to track and map labourers who were unable to take the train, aggregating their locations and providing that information to the Maharashtra government so they could make informed decisions on where and when to ply trains to maximise its impact.

“Over a few days, our phone calls (now numbering over a thousand) exposed issues of food shortage, employer abuse, shelter issues. The volunteers began an trial and error approach of cold calling government departments, civil servants and NGO’s to help resolve these distress situations which has now ballooned into a concerted attempt to map food shortage issues from all migrant labourers who have registered for shramik services and connecting them with NGO’s and government departments who could assist them.”

Scaling the project: Not without other NLUs

While the project grew haphazardly initially, the students have now begun to systematise efforts, leading them to wonder if the project could make a greater impact if more law universities could participate, since a Times of India report from today suggested only 30% of labourers intending to return home have managed to do so safely.

Each could take one state under its wing and work across a common playbook and pool their lessons, contacts, NGO networks and experiences gained form this process of acting as bridge between distressed labourers and relief-providers, suggested Srivinasan.

“If all law schools come together, adopt a state, and coordinate with each other in developing a NGO and governmental network, the volunteers work on mapping where the distressed labourers are, we believe law schools will have provided a critical service in this troubled time,” he added.

Volunteers have been spending around three to four hours per day making calls and updating collaborative worksheets (though coordinators were working all-day, back-to-back, particularly in organisational work and trying to connect to government and NGOs).

“We’re aiming to have each law school take up their own similar project and oversee it themselves, while coordinating with each other on the results, lessons, and share their contacts/NGO networks etc,” Srinivasan said. “Once more law schools are on board, we are looking to set up a database of government officers and NGO’s working to provide relief in an area.

“At the end of the day, we can send the list of distress situations we identify to them en masse. While current GCLS structure is amenable to oversee about a hundred or so volunteers and solving the distress situations that come from those, I don’t think we would be able to coordinate the NGO’s and governments for all volunteers pan India. We envision this is a movement of projects by law schools, than one big project by one law school.”

Practical challenges

The broad set-up GNLU students had followed included the following, according to Srinivasan:

Each state has set up a task force to oversee the travel of migrant labourers. We got in touch with the team in Madhya Pradesh - a group of 9 IAS officers tasked with this, with one nodal officer. This officer, through Zenith Legal Aid Clinic, provides us with an excel sheet of labourers who have applied for the shramik trains and their contact info.

Universities adopting a particular state should contact this task force or nodal officer and offer their assistance. Each state’s problem could be unique and consequently, the aid offered to that State could involve a different task.

In the experience of the GNLU project, there had been “significant delay in waiting for these trains to get organised for thousands”.

Volunteers would individually call these labourers, “inquire whether they still need trains or have already reached MP, and in case of the former, whether they are facing food/shelter shortage or some other distressing situation like employer abuse etc. in the time that they wait”.

“We collate the distress situations, (90% of our cases are food shortages) and set a group of people in charge to resolve them on an individual basis,” said Srinivasan.

After that, “the distress team first contacts the nodal officer or government officer in charge of the location where the labourer is situated”, he explained. “At the same time, we try to identify any NGO which operates where that labourer is currently located, and relay the information to them so they can deliver food or medicine to that person. We then follow up with that NGO or [government] officer as the situation is resolved.

“The distress resolving is a little ad hoc right now as we encounter different situations, but as we do more and more we are finding ways to streamline it.”

For those interested in getting in touch with the GNLU students, they can do so via email on or contact one of the following by phone:

  • Abhishek Vyas (+91 8469681997)
  • Disha Devdas (+91 9408168318)

[documentcloud GNLU Centre for Law and Society (GCLS) success stories assisting migrants

Photo via Wikipedia

Comments

Tai 22 May 2020, 15:30
+5 -8
Seems like only NLU students are doing something worthwhile in these times
Hey! 22 May 2020, 17:29
+4 -1
Chief! You could have skipped the "only", and this could have been so much better! Peace out!

-NLU alumnus
Arbitration_bhaiya 27 May 2020, 14:04
+1 -0
You sound like Sambit Patra. Yahan bhi NLU NLU dhoondh le.

Tch. tch.
Hey! 22 May 2020, 16:09
+1 -0
Good stuff guys! Keep us the spirit!
Happy to see 22 May 2020, 17:21
+0 -0
Fabulous job. Thanks for covering this.
train 22 May 2020, 19:49
+0 -0
i find the people on traintops very disturbing.
i remember seeing these scenes at railway stations till late 90s maybe later- not seen recently. has it stopped? also how dod they manage to stay safe?
Guest 22 May 2020, 23:38
+3 -0
Kian, are you going to do an article on the NLUO students who have written to the MEA seeking permission to sue China through a domestic worker? It's on bar and bench. A real laugh riot.
Axe 23 May 2020, 11:41
+1 -3
Dear Chinese Lefty Puppet,

China is 200% liable under international law and it is possible for individuals to bring claims.

Regards,
Democracy Lover
Guest 23 May 2020, 13:33
+4 -0
Most of the allegations lack any proof or evidence whatsoever. If negligence and delay in action are the grounds, then almost every country, ranging from the US to our very own, is guilty of that. Everybody dragged their heels when it came to suspending foreign travel and adequate testing.
p.s. I don't care about China at all, before someone randomly starts throwing allegations. Nor am I a 'leftist', whatever that word is meaning these days.
Guest 23 May 2020, 05:43
+1 -4
Please cover NLIU student-assisted petition seeking to sue China for damages.It touches upon important international law issues.
Guest 23 May 2020, 09:14
+2 -2
Kian, I request you to make your website like Wikipedia or Reddit where users can post news. You miss out many important news about good work by certain NLUs.
alias 23 May 2020, 20:03
+1 -1
Zenith Legal Aid Clinic has been started by Abhay Jain an NLUO alumnus. This foundation has been on the forefront of key issues pertianing to environment, human rights violations, manual scavenzing, etc.
Please watch this video to know more about their work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21oqxTfD6ps
Insider 27 May 2020, 01:58
+0 -1
Even NLS batch of 2000 is doing something like this for those stuck in Mumbai.
Insider 27 May 2020, 10:24
+0 -1
This has been reported today in Livelaw as well:
https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/nlsiu-alumni-network-raises-funds-to-lease-chartered-air-asia-flight-from-mumbai-to-ranchi-to-airlift-stranded-migrant-workers-157385
Aha 27 May 2020, 14:33
+0 -0
Kian and LI falling behind Mainstream Media by not covering this, looks like. While giving space to GNLU and NLIU efforts.
Guest 27 May 2020, 05:31
+0 -0
Bar & Bench is highlighting multiple NLUs. LI should do the same.
Good one But 27 May 2020, 09:40
+0 -7
Law School alumni just chartered a jet for migrant worker evacuation. So, to other NLUs trying to milk this crisis for PR (be it this effort by GNLU or some lame "sue China for damages"), real baap has come to play.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/law-grads-raise-funds-to-charter-mum-ranchi-flight-for-migrants/articleshow/76018607.cms
Guest 27 May 2020, 11:16
+9 -1
Are you for real? I really hope you aren't from Law School or any other NLU! In case you are, I'd strongly recommend every prospective student not to join that place, if that produces material like you, and lets them loose among the unsuspecting public. Turning a crisis and humanitarian responses into a pissing contest! You are a disgrace to everyone who has ever taught you.
Good one But 27 May 2020, 13:01
+1 -3
Get real. I have seen every random huckster trying to milk this crisis for PR/social media points. And alumni associations are no better. Apples to apples, just pointing out that the big daddy has also come out to play.
Guest 27 May 2020, 15:26
+0 -3
Ha ha! GNLU's publicity got dwarfed. All news media in India and abroad will have the chartered plane story.
Whut 27 May 2020, 17:15
+3 -0
Dude those GNLU kids are doing actual work so that they can help people. Not to get some PR. How insecure are you that you think this is some dick measuring contest? I feel sorry for you.
Hmm 27 May 2020, 20:11
+1 -5
Lol. I like how GNLU alumni find the need to hide behind the "kids" since they themselves don't seem to have elevated themselves to captains of industry. Most kids are doing this for some CV padding/admission essay story. Tough luck that the real granddaddy came to play, and came prepared.
Johnathon 28 May 2020, 02:46
+3 -0
You mean the real granddaddy of CV padding?
Hmm 28 May 2020, 07:13
+0 -1
Of course.
Johnathon 28 May 2020, 09:55
+0 -0
Lol.
Disha D 23 Jun 2020, 18:59
+0 -0
Usually adviced to not comment on such things. But hey, do share your email address with us shall send you our complete report till date :) This article is a little old I mean and while I wasn't aware that all us law school 'kids' are competing for something. Be it chartered plane or trains or buses or even tempos, if safe coming is assured then that's a job well done. I wish we were better at PR though hahah our current figures estimate connecting to 30,000 workers as of yesterday. But we'll take heed of your advice and put up another PR stunt soon. Thanks for the support!
Not_a_pissing_contest 28 May 2020, 09:41
+1 -0
Please don't discourage students from doing what they can by putting your own Machiavellian twist to things. I actually know the people heading this at GNLU. They don't need CV padding, they are done getting wherever they want to. These people have shown a consistent strive for community effort since their junior years. This article welcomes other NLUs efforts, it's a call to arms. The fact that NLS alum got a jet only cheers us because we know they heard the call. We're with them. Stop trying to live life through CLAT coloured lenses.
Guest 27 May 2020, 15:24
+1 -2
The NLSIU jet charter gives them the Covid PR gold medal by a long margin. Other NLUs can only hope to compete for a distant silver and bronze. This will also give a huge boost to NLSIU's reputation score in world rankings.
Whut 27 May 2020, 17:17
+3 -0
Its pathetic that you think people are seeking to score medals from the despotic plight of migrants. I applaud the NLSIU alumni for the jet charter, because they are helping people. I highly doubt any of them are doing this for some world rankings. Man, you need to get your head out of your ass and think about actual problems for a change.
I see. 27 May 2020, 20:09
+2 -3
We've got a selfless warrior here! How about you stop virtue signalling? Everything is PR, for everyone. Just be a realist. If some people get helped along the way, well and good. But don't delude everyone into thinking its all selfless. Maybe the alumni who did this are. But ask, is a jet charter really an optimal use of resources - because only 180 people traveled that way? Isn't it better to have used their clout to ensure smoother passage of buses, probably at the same cost (I don't believe Sheyl when she says buses and flights had marginal cost differences - either they didn't look hard enough or didn't negotiate well)? But no, Shuva Mandal used his Tata position to get AirAsia to make jets available. Rest of the alumni pooled the funds together. Great for Tata Sons and their legacy of being responsible. Great for Law School Alumni PR also. Even if these people had the most innocent of intentions, the consequence IS the PR boost.

The point here is that, EVEN in the game of seeing which alumni body has the biggest conscience or doing the highest profile work (which is clearly what NLIU tried, with this absurd "sue China for damages" - who do they think they're kidding? OR this boring NGO-coordination amateur hour by GNLU), it is Law School that is the true king of the hill. Everyone else can be also-rans.
NLS Alumnus 28 May 2020, 05:35
+3 -0
It's quite disgusting that people are turning this into a comparision of efforts and means. No half decent NLS alumnus would do that - pretty sure this is just a cheap effort by an agent provocateur to spice up the conversation.

As someone who contributed towards the Air Asia flight, wanted to clarify a few things:
- The per person cost if a bus were to be used worked out to INR 5,000. Flight cost per person came to INR 5,900. For a marginal increase in cost, the time saved and the hardships mitigated were enormous.
- A single bus would only fit ~50 passengers while a plane could carry upto 180 passengers.
- As has been mentioned in other media outlets, the connectivity between Mumbai and Jharkhand is poor. Hence this route was chosen.

Hope this clarifies a few things. NLS Alumni are not delusional to pour money into a useless PR gimmick. This is a mode that works both for the cost and time savings and we would do it with or without the PR. Here's hoping we can send more such flights to save those who sustained us.
Well well 28 May 2020, 07:18
+0 -2
As a fellow alumnus, I want to know the following: wouldn't NLS clout have been better expended on ensuring smooth passage for more than this 180 person charter luxury feel-good story? I know the Tata connection got us the aircraft and the cooperative govt machinery in Jharkhand. You're seriously saying a cavalcade of buses couldn't have been arranged, if officially endorsed by Hemant Soren? Who do you think you're kidding? Obviously some profiteering bus operator will try to charge exorbitant fares seeing the desperation. The solution to that is to exert external pressure (through corporate networks/suppliers/govt). So that the same amount of money can benefit the most. Rather, than splurge on indulgences like this. I didn't say that Sheyl lied when she quoted the fares. I'm just saying that looking for practical, scalable solutions may have been more impactful.

This leads to the conclusion that this was probably a PR move, in which case kudos. Very well executed.
NLS Alumnus 28 May 2020, 08:52
+2 -0
You clearly seen to know more than the alumni on the ground and Urhope who spent a week organising this, so here's my suggestion: Why don't you propose a scalable and practical solution? I'm sure alumni are looking for more such initiatives to contribute to.

The point is it's easier to be an armchair critic who nitpicks without knowing ground realities. There is nothing to be gained from the 2 minute fame that B&B and few media outlets confer. All of us still have the same day jobs to go back to.

Ask yourself the same counterfactual question: how difficult must the logistics be that even with the support of Jharkhand state machinery, one had to send people through a flight rather than a bus?
Res Ipsa Loquitor 28 May 2020, 09:10
+0 -2
Indeed, the counter factual you pose leads us to the conclusion that the PR gains of this would make it worthwhile. Occam's Razor would tell you that the simplest explanation is probably the true one. Rather than weakly conclude that sending by road was impossible, despite having the Jharkhand government on board.
pathetic 28 May 2020, 10:14
+0 -0
people who don't do anything expect be a key board warrior criticising people who have done what they could. period.


have you thought of how difficult it can be to travel via road from Bombay all the way to Jharkhand? Them folks handled 180 people that they could - ensuring that they have a. comfortable, dignified journey to their homes. They deserve and applause for that. end of story.
Well 28 May 2020, 10:39
+0 -1
Obviously its not easy. Who is denying that? The point of humanitarian response is to serve as many as possible in manageable conditions. Getting 500 migrants home (even if subject to a difficult, but doable journey) is always preferable to getting 180 home in more comfortable circumstances.
NLS Alumnus 28 May 2020, 14:49
+1 -0
Boss, your utilitarian philosophy sounds good as an LI comment but the simple reason why I can't take you seriously is because you have done zero groundwork. You have neither arranged for buses nor interacted with the state machinery on how to get this done but want to virtue signal and lecture about how an efficient humanitarian response should be.
Guest 27 May 2020, 15:44
+0 -0
[img]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EY_1D-9XsAMz46b.jpg[/img]
Guest 28 May 2020, 03:01
+1 -1
I agree that all law schools are using Covid for PR and virtue signalling. NLSIU has undisputedly won the contest, but it is still possible for other NLUs to save face and do something else that will grab headlines.
Guest 28 May 2020, 03:05
+0 -0
While it is true that NLSIU alumni are in powerful positions, many parents of students of other NLUs are very powerful. So the way to get big things done is through the parents network.
Sure 28 May 2020, 07:20
+0 -0
Don't know why you think parents of past and present Law Schoolites aren't in powerful positions, including at Lok Kalyan Marg.
Guest 28 May 2020, 03:10
+0 -1
Here is how NALSAR can rival what NLSIU did: buy 100 million smartphones for 100 million poor families. Tie up with a Chinese phone company desperate for good PR + Ambani Jio.
None 28 May 2020, 09:51
+0 -0
Genius. Pure Genius. NALSAR truly is the great university of opposites.
Guest 28 May 2020, 07:44
+1 -2
Other law schools are burning with jealousy after NLSIU pulled off the airline coup!
None 28 May 2020, 08:00
+3 -0
Even the migrants don't give a crap. Forget anyone else, Trollmaster.
Awful 28 May 2020, 10:18
+2 -1
The grandstanding seemingly by NLS-ites here is pathetic. Plane from mumbai-ranchi does not help migrants stuck in Ahmedabad. The GNLU students helping out there alone are best placed to help them.

Everyone should maximise their own efforts rather than claiming one law university's efforts are better than another.
Guest 28 May 2020, 12:41
+2 -0
While people here are engaging in a pissing contest, alum from various law schools (and others) are already coordinating with the nls group to see how they might pitch in or undertake similar efforts on their own. NO ONE who was working on this was thinking of publicity for NLS. 20 years after graduation, people's lives do not revolve around their alma mater! Those who are working are doing so across institutional affiliations. And this is the first of many similar efforts. The aim is to scale air transport for migrants who have to travel long distances and use other methods of transport for shorter distances.
Guest 28 May 2020, 13:22
+3 -0
Let it be. Anon trolls here will keep vomiting. People who want to get real work done would do it nonetheless. These days, the more I read griping from LI commentators about something or somebody, the more good work that person or place is probably getting done.
Guest 25 Jun 2020, 17:00
Troll
+0 -2
Now NUJS has copied NLSIU in flying back migrant workers, but failed to ge publicity because it's old news now. Waste of resources for zero PR.

https://www.telegraphindia.com/calcutta/coronavirus-lockdown-nujs-sends-uttarakhand-workers-home/cid/1783582
Guest 26 Jun 2020, 05:02
+1 -0
Thank you for making it clear that people are not doing this for PR. You yourself might.
Guest 26 Jun 2020, 05:04
+1 -0
I wish all the law school alumni would engage in similar 'copying'. Would do the world a lot of good service, far better than what your comments achieve.