BCI to develop cheap or free anti-plagiarism software for law schools

photocopier_by_alancleaver_2000
photocopier_by_alancleaver_2000

The Bar Council of India (BCI) is in talks with government agency Software Technology Parks of India (STPI) to automate BCI internal processes and design cost-effective or free anti-plagiarism software for law schools and other legal writers.

It is understood that the BCI has conducted research that has shown that plagiarism is a major concern at law schools, although the statistics and results of the research are not available for released to the public.

The STPI, which is a governmental agency focusing on information technology development, has been assisting the BCI in selecting either public sector or private sector vendors to carry out the project after interviews and tender, according to a source with knowledge of the development.

In a press statement BCI chairman Gopal Subramanium said: “Indian academics and members of the bar have, in the past, produced some of the best examples of legal literary work. A lack of appropriate standards in legal writing and education has however, unfortunately, resulted in a sharp decline in the production of good quality, original legal writing in the public space.”

“The Bar Council of India requests all law colleges to take adequate steps to prevent plagiarism in any publications and academic writing in the public space,” added the statement.

However, the plagiarism prevention software is not intended exclusively for law schools but could also be used by anyone doing legal writing in the public space.

It is understood that no final date has been fixed for roll-out of the software or whether the software would be open-source or proprietary.

In May NLSIU Bangalore bought licences to commercial plagiarism prevention software “turnitin”.

Legally India student blogger sss discussed the issue of plagiarism and potential solutions in the post The Plagiarism Menace.

Photo by alancleaver_2000

Comments

Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 21:15
+4 -0
they can never get to me !
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 21:36
+1 -0
The students of SLCU have been uploading their papers and using turnitin.com since 2007. However, its use is mostly limited to online resources and not commentaries.
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 21:38
+0 -0
How do i nw submit my projects if dey get dis piece ......
kianganz 9 Jun 2010, 21:52
+0 -0
Hi - we did not link to the excellent blog post by john2010 on Plagiarism as it was too much fun to be linked to in a serious news story.

However, for those interested in reading more about plagiarism, have a look:

http://www.legallyindia.com/902-how-comrade-whistle-blower-lost-his-ethical-virginity
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 22:19
+0 -0
STPI for free software? BCI is technologically bankrupt as it is not even aware how to use internet? Some institutions have been using this technology for years and that also free and BCI needs STPI to do this job for it. wake up BCI and have some basic computers knowledge.
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 22:26
+0 -0
thanks God...i have completed my 5 years...may God have mercy on the law school students....
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 22:53
+0 -0
Plagiarism in the legal industry can never be eliminated. If copying from a source without proper attribution is plagiarism, arguably every lawyer and judge, in every jurisdiction, regularly plagiarizes. All lawyers plagiarize. Don't they work from a template while drafting a contract? Don't they borrow texts from other briefs while drafting their own briefs? Don't they sign off on opinions drafted by their colleagues/juniors? Don't they have papers that they present at seminars/conferences prepared by their juniors? Did you know that a good percentage of orders and judgments passed by judges in state and federal courts in the US were never authored by them at all? Instead - it's invariably a clerk who does all the hard work of reading the briefs, researching the law and drafting the final order, which many judges just sign as their own? Isn't that plagiarism? In fact, the entire purpose of "knowledge management" is to enable plagiarism at some point in the future. Plagiarism in the legal industry will never cease.

Legal Dodo
Anonymous guest 9 Jun 2010, 23:16
+0 -0
Legal Dodo what you have described is exploitation that is unfortunately considered to be part and parcel of a job of a person of inferior position and acceptable to him. Then there is copyright violation and finally plagiarism. All these concepts are wrong in one form or other. If i use a material that is freely available for all (like draft) does it makes it plagiarism. No it does not. But if i use a major portion of your work without proper attribution, it is plagiarism. If i use the entire article of yours without your name and attribution, than it is copyright violation.
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 01:25
+0 -0
LOL.. who will check the teachers? most of them have so-called publications in cheap indian journals which are all copied from elsewhere. i have also seen a BOOK by a teacher that was a copy-paste job (this person has lectured in all the "Big Three" NLUs and I think is still on the permanent faculty of one of them)!!
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 02:33
+0 -0
shastriji what will you do now beta?
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 02:35
+0 -0
you cant turn idiots into original thinkers by catching them. cumon, its human nature to inlcine towards mediocrity..dont try to be too smart BCI
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 03:57
+0 -0
NLIU's going to introduce Turnitin, says the library notice board since 3 months... hope the BCI software helps too though :-)
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 04:03
+0 -0
Now we're screwed. Hamari maa chudne waali hai.
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 04:17
+0 -0
@ 13 - Mind you language. and Legally India - mind your comments.
In NUJS itself thesis of so called lecturers have been rejected by publication houses on grounds of plagiarism. Judges as someone above rightly said, copy taxts from foreign judgments. Lawyers try to copy from web journals. there is always plagiarism. it cannot be stopped. it is a necessary evil in the legal profession.
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 04:57
+0 -0
I know of cases where lecturers from NLS and NALSAR have faced plagiarism lawsuits and their publishers have settled amicably. My former senior advised a publishing house with respect to one case.

It's funny, I have seen books written by STUDENTS from NLS/NUJS/NALSAR that are original!I guess our students are better than teachers.
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 16:38
+0 -0
they can fight it..................but they can't stop or eliminate it..............cut copy paste zindabad...............
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 19:12
+0 -0
GNLU already has the software that NLS is braggin about... for a long time now...
Anonymous guest 10 Jun 2010, 21:09
+0 -0
so does NUJS bro...we dont care right??
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 12:54
+0 -0
ha! the NALSAR profs also claim to have a "software" sadly (or fortunately for me at least) this software dosen seem to be working i guess...
Anonymous guest 11 Jun 2010, 15:32
+0 -0
@19: most law profs in india do not even know how to use a computer
Anonymous guest 13 Jun 2010, 23:57
+0 -0
Turnitin is ineffective.
Anonymous guest 21 Sept 2010, 04:49
+0 -0
Turn It In is the best plagiarism check software
Anonymous guest 21 Sept 2010, 16:31
+0 -0
I have tried Turn-it-in, this is an ultimate solution. STPI may develop a software, but cannot have the database to check the submissions against. Without the database any anti-plagiarism software is useless.