Bimal Patel gets wrist-slap on last day as GNLU director for apparent poaching of staff to new gig • Successor to focus on int’l + research

Bimal Patel reign at GNLU ends (though not without controversy)
Bimal Patel reign at GNLU ends (though not without controversy)

One day before stepping down as director of GNLU Gandhinagar, Dr Bimal Patel was chastised in an official letter for apparently poaching three staffers of GNLU to Gujarat Maritime University (GMU), which operates on GNLU’s campus and is currently being run by Patel.

According to the Indian Express and Times of India, GMU registrar Sharad Daran sent the following email to Patel on 14 July:

The emails dated 13th July 2019 sent by you has been brought to the notice of Shri Mukesh Kumar, IAS, Provost, Gujarat Maritime University.

With respect to your rapid, unusual and untimely acceptance of resignation of certain employees of GNLU assigned charge at Gujarat Maritime University, I am directed to instruct you that, as the outgoing in-charge director of Gujarat Maritime University, you may refrain from taking any decision pertaining to Gujarat Maritime University without consulting the President/Provost of Gujarat Maritime University.

Reportedly, three staffers of GNLU who had been on deputation to GMU, where Patel is director in charge, had sent letters of resignation at GNLU 13 July and quickly accepted by Patel - in one reportedly within just over half-an-hour of having been sent.

Patel’s tenure as GNLU director ended on Monday 15 July, and he handed over to the new director Prof Sanjeevi Shanthakumar by Tuesday, 16 July.

Patel also has a new gig as officer on special duty at Raksha Shakti University at Lavad, Gandhinagar, expected to be director general soon, according to the Express report.

Prof Shanthakumar’s plans for GNLU

Patel successor sets out plans in Indian Express interview
Patel successor sets out plans in Indian Express interview

Patel’s GNLU successor Shanthakumar told the Express in a separate interview that he wanted to internationalise GNLU.

He said he would by next year attract the very first foreign students to the university, as well as activate the strong alumni network and use his contacts to attract foreign guest faculty and create international opportunities for GNLU teachers.

In-part, he said, he was keen to put in a bid to get GNLU a spot in unnamed “world rankings”.

“I know it would be difficult to get students from European countries or the United States but I have a good connect with law schools in southeast Asian countries such as Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines, Taiwan, and Cambodia. So from next year, you will see foreign students at GNLU,” he told the Express.

The latter, is probably a reference to the similar ambitions of NLSIU Bangalore and the recent success of JGLS Sonepat to crack the QS global university rankings.

However, as we had reported above, getting into the QS rankings appears possible purely on two criteria, such as faculty student ratio and international faculty, rather than necessarily being a signifier of university quality.

That said, being on the ranking probably does attract more foreign students, so it could create a virtuous circle and also fill universities’ coffers with the fees paid by foreign students.

Finally, Shanthakumar also told the Express that he wanted to address the poor research at Indian universities: “In the field of law, we can create knowledge because content is indigenous and we don’t need to look to the West for content.

“So I am going to motivate each and every teacher to write a lot and publish articles so that we are known outside as a great research institute.”

Comments

Guest 17 Jul 2019, 19:32
+10 -16
Totally biased article. Here is what LI is not saying: Prof Shanthakumar also gave an interview to TOI where he said as follows:

[i]GNLU is one of the best law universities in India today and our aim will be to attract talented students. Professor Bimal Patel has set a great precedence in terms of infrastructure and administration and we will continue the momentum. [/i]

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/putting-gnlu-on-world-map-is-our-priority/articleshow/70252465.cms

Thus, because of your bias against Prof Patel you are not mentioning how he has laid a wonderful platform for the new Director. Any future achievements by the new Director, including world rankings, will be because of Prof Patel.
Daaka 18 Jul 2019, 06:41
+22 -1
Would you expect a boilerplate press release by the new director to say "BimPa ruined everything now I have to untangle a decade's worth of irregularities"?

[quote]Any future achievements by the new Director, including world rankings, will be because of Prof Patel.[/quote]

Bhimal, pls stop it with the anon comments and go back to work.
Pakalu Papito 19 Jul 2019, 12:33
+2 -0
Bimal Patel was a shroud politician. The things that GNLU has achieved is only because of the quality of the students and their hard work. Prof. Patel's disregard for legal institutions and rule of law is appalling to see as the head of an NLU. Dr. Shanthakumar sure seems like an upgrade.
Guest 17 Jul 2019, 19:39
+5 -1
[quote]However, as we had reported above, getting into the QS rankings appears possible purely on two criteria, such as faculty student ratio and international faculty, rather than necessarily being a signifier of university quality.
[/quote]

I do not think this is correct. Research output matters. The Indian universities in QS are the old IITs and IISC (in higher tiers) and new IITs and Manipal (in newer tiers). They all have decent research output. As for JGLS, their faculty-students ratio is not that great, as they have large batch sizes. Also, I think only 10 or 15% of their faculty must be international. So they must have scored decently in research output. The research output at NLUs is not that high, though they are superior in placements and student achievements.
Guest 17 Jul 2019, 19:42
+2 -11
[i]Another student requesting anonymity said, "Today, the stature achieved by GNLU is thanks to efforts of Bimal Patel who structured the administration in such a way that we could freely approach as students."
[/i]

Tight slap to Legally India and some indisciplined students planting fake news to Legally India.

https://ahmedabadmirror.indiatimes.com/ahmedabad/education/director-takes-charge-at-gnlu/articleshow/70251238.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst
Alumnus17 18 Jul 2019, 06:49
+10 -0
This is a tight slap to no one. He was anything but accessible to most students other than a select few
Mr Lawman 17 Jul 2019, 20:13
+4 -12
Please refrain from blaming Bimal Patel unnecessarily for every incident taking place.
Observe 17 Jul 2019, 21:30
+8 -0
Very nice and ambitious plan of Prof Shantha....All the best
Alumni 17 Jul 2019, 22:03
+9 -0
LI Now leave Bimal Patel, its old pages of story. GNLU is in new age under Prof. Shantha Kumar.
Guest 18 Jul 2019, 05:03
+1 -19
GNLU stands with Professor Patel.
Learned Academician 18 Jul 2019, 05:37
+7 -0
Prof Sanjeevi Shanthakumar has great vision to bring GNLU in the world Map, unlike Bimal Patel who spend half of his tenure fighting the matter in Courts.

I think GNLU is in safe hand, nor pray for Raksha Shakti University.
CommonCause 18 Jul 2019, 07:19
+15 -3
BimPa may have flaws but what he did for GNLU, of course along with the faculty, admin staff and students, is and will always be appreciable. He steered it for 10 years- largely for good. GNLU was operating from old NIFT building (5-10% of its current size) when BimPa got there. He built the organization ground up. From there to the new/large enough campus and overall growth in brand-value, outreach and maintaining institution's overall standing - credit must be given where it is due. Running a law school is not a child's play and anyone who is out to do something above average faces criticism and roadblocks; and even sometimes falters along the way. The smear campaign I see here is no different than what one sees daily on news channels for political personalities - just the scale is different (this being not anywhere close to TV/politics). However, the common theme is the professional ethics, integrity and independence of reporting media - or rather, should I say, lack of it.
kianganz 18 Jul 2019, 07:38
+6 -7
In part, I would probably agree: compared to many other NLU VCs, overall he's performed quite well and helped build a solid institution at GNLU, as opposed to running it into the ground (although, either way, it should be noted that success or failure is also in large part a function of the support and funding a state government provides rather than purely a VC's admin skills).

That said, there have definitely been legitimate issues and gripes around the way he had run the institution in a very autocratic and non-transparent manner, as evidenced by episodes such as the one reported by the IE and TOI above, for instance, as well as statements made by high court judges in several orders and policies surrounding disciplining students, etc. And at the end of the day, in our limited experience, Patel was never very sensible in dealing with or responding to bad news, criticism or disagreement that are part and parcel of NLU admin, which could explain some of the bad PR surrounding his tenure in the mainstream media as well as LI.

In any case, all the above are legitimate stories that media should be covering at public institutions such as NLUs. By contrast, ignoring those stories and instead showering praise on a law school administration and writing puff pieces, would not evidence "professional ethics, integrity and independence" in media, but quite the opposite.

Then again, no VC is perfect and yes, running a law school is a tough job and, yes, it could have been much worse...
CommonCause 18 Jul 2019, 11:06
+7 -2
State funding is not automatic. It needs a solid lobbying and relationship management with those who matter in government. Something BimPa did very well when compared to his peers. If state funding is as simple and the enabler without 'VC's admins skills' as you say it, all NLUs and many other fully controlled government education institutions would have fared well. Also, I am not sure where you go with 'VC's admin skills' - VC is not the administrator; registrar is. VC or Director in any NLU/IIT/IIM has far bigger mandate than just administering the institution on a dotted line using state's money.
Correct. 18 Jul 2019, 07:48
+3 -0
Agreed, 100%. Kian, your takedowns of Bhimal are a bit aggressive, no? He wasn't perfect but nobody ever is. GNLU owes its current stature entirely to his efforts and the new VC has acknowledged as much.
kianganz 18 Jul 2019, 08:09
+7 -6
I think our comments had crossed at the same time, so I refer you to my earlier response above. Re: "Entirely to his efforts" - no, that's probably an overstatement. I think the equation of current stature is probably more likely 33% Patel and faculty, 33% the state government's funding and support, and 33% students.

Regarding 'takedowns', I disagree. Patel clearly has had a tendency to ruffle feathers during his tenure - why else did the GMU registrar send the above letter? Why did a high court judge say in a judgment that Patel had turned GNLU "into an oligarchy where all decisions are taken, reviewed and implemented by a select few, and students are casually denied basic human rights and natural justice"? https://www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/bimal-patel-has-turned-gnlu-gandhingar-into-a-human-rights-violating-oligarchy-agrees-hc-overturning-malafide-unreasonable-illegal-frisking-decision-20160505-7556

And there are many other similar ones in our archives.

So pray tell, exactly what should IE or TOI or LI or other media have done about true and factual stories such as the above? Bury them because overall he's mostly done a good job? Sweep such stories under the carpet, because it's not nice to be critical? Soft pedal on them because it might upset Patel or his supporters? Not report them because Patel doesn't comment on negative stories? Only copy-paste fluffy GNLU press releases about how hunky dory things are? Include some subjective non-journalistic boilerplate into every negative story about how Patel has also done some good things?

At the end of the day, negative news is going to be part and parcel of any VC job (or other jobs with a position of power, such as BCI chairman, politics, etc) and it's one of the media's highest duties to report on negative things that the powers would rather were not reported. Nearly everything else is just PR, and, in my view, somewhat optional.

So, if a VC doesn't know how to handle bad news, such negative coverage should be on the VC and the facts themselves, and not the media...
bimpa fan 24 Jul 2019, 07:51
+0 -0
One thing that is totally wrong is that be build the new campus. When he joined the design, contract and budget of the new campus was already approved and work had already started. this was mainly due to the efforts of the then in charge registrar and the campus development committee.
Boaring 18 Jul 2019, 08:37
+2 -1
We get same comments since years. We wish to know about new Director
Guest 18 Jul 2019, 15:15
+3 -6
GNLU in world rankings? What a joke!
House. 18 Jul 2019, 18:19
+2 -0
Is there a punchline I am missing here?
nottheonlyobstuse 20 Jul 2019, 08:35
+1 -1
It is a plan/vision. May or may not happen. You seem to be jumping guns quite too soon mate. Happens to recent graduates - you'll learn not to jump the gun in due course.
vcsout 18 Jul 2019, 16:56
+1 -0
Kian.. Birds are saying Jaswal is next up for NLUD. Can you confirm?
Guest 18 Jul 2019, 18:30
+1 -3
Bimal Patel might be the next NLUD VC.
LLB Degree 19 Jul 2019, 04:17
+5 -0
First Bimal has to get LLB degree for him to be work for institution who award LLB degree
No, 19 Jul 2019, 07:21
+2 -0
This is categorically untrue. Bimal will be taking over Raksha Shakti and is not even on the NLUD EC list.
Guest 19 Jul 2019, 05:06
+1 -0
Jaswal has been the frontrunner for NLUD for a long time, but we don't know if the recent protests at RGNUL will hurt his chances. Also, those who lose the NLSIU race will apply to NLUD. VC Vivekanandan as well. Tough fight ahead.
Post college 19 Jul 2019, 12:46
+1 -3
Such bubbles students stay in. I did too. Nobody really cares in the real world (law firms or corporates) about what's happening in any college anywhere.
Guest 19 Jul 2019, 17:26
+3 -0
Kian, why are you silent on the recent NALSAR casteism story in the Wire? Why are NLSIU and NALSAR never seriously targeted by you?
Guest 20 Jul 2019, 04:02
+1 -0
Why not Ved Kumari as NLUD VC?