CNLU students win retired judge as interim VC, stand down for 2 days • Ex-VC keeps self locked away in residence

First small victory for CNLU students
First small victory for CNLU students

CNLU Patna students won a first small concession today in their fight opposing the appointment of NUJS Kolkata vice chancellor Prof Ishwara Bhat to head up their institution, suspending their protests for two days, according to two student sources.

With CNLU vice chancellor A Lakshminath’s term having expired yesterday (19 March), CNLU has now appointed retired Patna high court judge, Justice Mridula Mishra, to be the institution’s interim vice chancellor “to look after the day-to-day work of the University” until further notice, according to the notification dated 20 March.

The initial plan had been to extend Lakshminath’s term for another month, according to students, but their opposition to his extension as well as to his replacement, Bhat, both of whom have been unpopular with students.

A delegation of CNLU students met the university’s chancellor, the Patna high court chief justice Rajendra Menon, today, with one student telling us: “He sympathetically entertained the grievances of the students of CNLU and affirmatively assured that an inquiry commission would be constituted within a span of two days to investigate the charges levied by the CNLU students against the administrative mismanagement.

“Meanwhile on assurances so given, the CNLU students show cooperation with the chancellor and have decided to stand off the protest for two days.”

While some oral assurances had reportedly been made to students by the registrar that Bhat would not be appointed to CNLU before the inquiry committee’s report was made public (as it had been alleged that the unfavourable report had been buried by the Bhat administration), one student told us they would not back down until they received such an assurance in writing.

Instead, students claimed that Lakshminath had allegedly had himself locked into his residence since the protests started on Saturday, refusing to engage with students, with security guards telling students that the outgoing VC was not on the premises.

We have reached out to Lakshminath for comment by phone, but have received no response.

“Everywhere the kids are sitting down, everybody is sitting in scorching heat, while they’re [the administration is] sitting inside, and not even talking to us,“ one student told us today from the protest.

However, in the afternoon today Lakshminath emerged and also went to see the chancellor with the registrar, with an appointment after the students. We understand that he has now returned to his campus residence, with the doors locked again.

However, he has still not talked to students.

Update 23:28: A press statement from protesting students below

Press statement from protesting students
Press statement from protesting students

Comments

Firebrand 20 Mar 2018, 14:17
+33 -7
Whether Bhat gets his appointment later or not, one thing that CNLU students proved is their resolve and unity. They did the entire thing peacefully, without any vandalism or hooliganism, discussed their grievances with the authorities and refused to budge till their voice is heard. NUJS students should learn something from them, as should the other so-called top tier law schools, instead of simply holding armchair token protests.
Waterbrand 20 Mar 2018, 14:46
+15 -30
Which incident of vandalism / armchair protest by NUJS students are you referring to? You seem to have a grudge against top tier law schools. Only if you had prepared well for the entrance exams instead of spending time on your dissertation on means of protest!
Firebrand 20 Mar 2018, 15:12
+18 -13
Clearly, you lack the necessary English knowledge to figure out what I said. Please give your top-tier law school-going brain a rest. Incidentally, given your linguistic and interpretation skills, chances are you are still a student, in which case, I've graduated from The Law School at a time when both you and your law school dreams were just a twinkle in someone else's eyes, kid. So give it a rest and maybe try to take the constructive bit away from my comment, if you can get someone else to interpret it for you.
Kaka 21 Mar 2018, 05:50
+6 -10
Then why are you anonymous, tell us your name and what dreams are twinkling in your eyes because your comment suggests you are [...] and slightly jobless.
2011 21 Mar 2018, 16:22
+2 -1
Bhat has unleashed his followers on social media. I wonder who are these people.
Guest 20 Mar 2018, 18:23
+13 -4
Agreed. I really hope CNLU gets an excellent VC because such a sincere, united and dedicated student body deserves it. As for NUJS students, you guys and Bhat really deserve each other, just as the earlier batches deserved Menon and MP Singh. ZERO sympathy for the present lot of students at NUJS.
Kaka 21 Mar 2018, 05:43
+1 -8
Congratulations CNLU now you get a retired judge who will do nothing for you rather than a proactive VC who could take your institution to new heights with his connections and previous experience of running a much better institution than yours. You jumped the gun. You started protesting thinking he is corrupt. Then you relaised it's a patently wrong charge and won't stand any chance. So to save face you are now claiming you don't want him because he is unpopular. Well, popularity changes with time. Who thought BJP will lose Gorakhpur. There are very few people who would want to move to Patna. Bhat was stupid to even apply there. I am glad that Bhat will stay back in nujs now
Guest 21 Mar 2018, 07:15
+6 -4
KR and MM, please stop your barrage of pro-Bhat comments. I request my friends at CNLU not to be affected by this ,Students and NUJS stand firmly behind you, and some of us will issue a public statement soon (independent of our SJA).
Sauron 21 Mar 2018, 08:56
+6 -1
If you are so enamored with him, why don't you keep him, instead of trying to thrust him down the throat of other NLUs? For that matter, why is he leaving NUJS in the middle of his tenure anyway if the students and faculty are having such cordial relationships with him as you seem to be suggesting?
Guest 20 Mar 2018, 15:10
+11 -2
Congratulations to CNLU students. This should be a lesson to some of the so-called top tier NLU students who tolerate incompetence and corruption and only protest through feeble petitions.
Know All 20 Mar 2018, 15:24
+12 -0
So this means the NUJS review committee report (which Bhat has suppressed) will be crucial. My prediction is as follows:

1) It will be a mixed report against Bhat, partly because Mohan Gopal and Faizan Mustafa are on good terms with Bhat.
2) Bar & Bench will highlight the positives and write a pro-Bhat piece, try and blame Menon, Chimni and MP Singh regimes (all are now old and retired, and of no use to Bar & Bench).
3) Legally India will try to be more balanced and highlight the negatives, but Bhat's troll army will flood the internet and social media and distort the narrative. They will also force Kian to make edits.
4) Among MSM, Telegraph will give a pro-Bhat slant, TOI will highlight the negatives.
5) Bhat will stay on at NUJS for another 2 years, wait for things to die down at CNLU, and then shift to CNLU after retirement. Justice Mishra will look after CNLU for 2 years.
6) Before leaving, Bhat will promote will cronies in the faculty (some of who have been furiously supporting him on Legally India).
Nujs alumnus 21 Mar 2018, 05:30
+0 -4
Where and how does Bhat get a troll army. Really strange
Sauron 21 Mar 2018, 05:48
+2 -2
He's recovered the One Ring to bind them all from Mount Doom.
Guest 20 Mar 2018, 16:59
+9 -0
Lakshminath is fond of getting himself locked. When he was the Chancellor of DSNLU and students were on protest for its inclusion in CLAT, he literally ran away from the public gathering, when he couldn't answer the questions posed by some studeand got himself locked in the VCs cabin. Even Courage wasn't this Coward!
Bobby S. 20 Mar 2018, 17:31
+8 -2
Bahar se koi andar na aa sake/ Andar se koi bahar na ja sake/ socho kabhi aisa ho toh kya ho, etc. etc.
NUJS Student 20 Mar 2018, 20:34
+3 -8
I am a great supporter of collective action and its success at CNLU is definitely refreshing. However, I do feel it is my duty to set the record straight on a few facts of Prof. Bhat's tenure at NUJS. From the messages I have gotten from students at CNLU, they are basing their distrust in Prof. Bhat mainly on the ground of the "no-confidence" petition of the SJA. It is important to note that this petition was merely a letter that was thrown out of the Executive Council (EC) meeting that had amongst others the Chief Justice of India. Their reason simplistically being this - we will objectively determine whether Prof. Bhat deserves an extension or not. On that objective determination it was noted that in his tenure the NUJS did achieve greater glories than the past, including but not restricted to - a waiver of loan by the State Government along with a grant of land for a very small campus; the development of scholarships for students; setting up of two research centres including one with the UNICEF; starting of new Chairs; engagement of credit courses; overhaul of academic rules; an increased endowment for moots; him personally going for funding for students and most importantly being away from corruption. These were primarily the reasons why the EC decided outside of the unfairly motivated petitions, Prof. Bhat deserved an extension.
I do think most important for the students in CNLU to know is this - everything set and done, as hard as it may be to believe, Prof. Bhat is definitely student friendly. In fact, in our college when the other bodies of faculty and administrators refuse to accept the most genuine requests of students Prof. Bhat has always given a kind ear (at least a hearing, every single time!). More importantly, his role in ousting a corrupt Registrar cannot be exaggerated. In fact, his relationship with the previous SJAs was very cordial and very mutually beneficial. It is a testament to the student body that NUJS achieved 100% placements but I do feel the same would be impossible with a VC being portrayed as terribly as this. Don't mistake his mild demeanour for inaction and please do not fall prey to old agendas. It makes for good news pieces but might not necessarily be true!
Guest 21 Mar 2018, 02:18
+6 -4
Please do not be swayed by the pro-Bhat propaganda that has been mysteriously flooding the internet in recent days. Remember that even Lalu Yadav and Mayawati have loyal supporters, as they doled out favours to certain people, and the same holds true for Bhat. The undisputed facts are that there were two strongly worded no-confidence letters directly blaming Bhat (including one written six months ago), there was an online no-confidence petition signed by students and alumni a few years ago, the infrastructure at NUJS fell behind during Bhat's tenure, there was an exodus of good faculty, the NUJS website is awful and was not updated for several years (only recently there was a minor upgrade, after the review commission pointed it out) etc etc etc.

And it is also a fact that during MP Singh's tenure the faculty had Shamnad Basheer, Sudhir Krishnaswamy, Pritam Baruah, Chinmayi Arun, Vishwas Devaiah, Danel Mathew etc etc ---- compare with the faculty today.

And during Madhav Menon's tenure the faculty had Vikramjeet Banerjee, who recently became additional Solicitor General.

As for moot funding, the other VCs also wrote to lawyers and arranged it. No big deal.
At last 21 Mar 2018, 07:41
+4 -0
If Bhat has achieved so much at NUJS, why is that he is desperate to move to CNLU
2011 21 Mar 2018, 16:30
+2 -3
Obviously he wants to improve CNLU. One state, one NLU at a time he will save them all
At last 22 Mar 2018, 05:38
+1 -0
He destroyed the academic atmosphere of NUJS and reduced it to a war zone and he can do the same at CNLU. Best wishes
Studboy 21 Mar 2018, 03:38
+6 -0
Guys, look at this,. 60 universities have been granted autonomy by the UGC today. Most of the NLUs are there except NUJS as NUJS did not apply for NAAC on time. A huge tragedy fo the college and further proof of Bhat's incompetence. Please do not get swayed by the pro-Bhat propaganda his stooges are indulging in.

http://zeenews.india.com/education/60-educational-institutions-get-full-autonomy-is-your-college-on-the-list-2092048.html

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/education/jnu-among-60-universities-colleges-to-get-major-autonomy-boost/articleshow/63389305.cms
Thanos 21 Mar 2018, 08:59
+4 -2
Most of the NLUs? By my count, only 2 got full autonomy (NALSAR and NLUD), whereas 2 others got limited autonomy (RGNUL and NLUO). Apart from private universities and ILI. I mean, I still agree with your basic point, but supporting data toh thik se diya karo bhai!
NoojieStar 21 Mar 2018, 06:41
+0 -9
This is what my really problem is with the present discourse. As soon as an alternative perspective with facts comes to the fore, it is labelled as propaganda - without any realisation that they’re part of the same misinformation campaign. The two strongly worded No Confidence petitions were judged by the highest authorities in this country and were found without merit. There was a faculty exodus but one must juxtapose that with the development of more visiting professors and credit course teachers coming in, such as: Armin Rosencranz, Justice Banerjee, Umakanth amongst many others. It is clear that the best asset of NUJS is it’s student body but the successes of the student body are just not possible without some administrative support. The fact that Prof. Bhat has an open door policy with all students is a testament to that. You’re basing your opinion out of a single-source, that is word of mouth and conjecture without going into the intricacies of his tenure. The Review Commission’s Report, which I had access to notes the same and makes it a point to mention that Prof. Bhat has achieved great things at NUJS. He might not be perfect, but from all accounts he will most definitely be better than Laxminath.
At last 21 Mar 2018, 10:56
+4 -2
When the Review Committee report is under cover since 6 months how come you got access to it. First of all why it was buried and how you managed to access it. It is what is happening in the Bhats regime, only few select people who are getting everything, power, position, promotion, money, privilege, access, importance etc., Bhat made NUJS as his family and ancestral property and only his people are important for him that is very much evident in whom he promoted, sent abroad, projects given, involved in administration to mention.

Public institution and private administration
Malav Vaghela 21 Mar 2018, 08:35
+9 -0
Someone please overthrow "unpopular" Bimal N Patel as well. He is interested only in creating contacts for himself and does nothing for the University.

Long live the revolution.
Guest 21 Mar 2018, 10:39
+6 -0
If NLIU and many other NLUs could stage a protest then so can GNLU. GNLU students have been meek for far too long. A protest against Bimal Patel now will attract a lot of attention since he is close to Modi and we are nearing elections.
Guest 21 Mar 2018, 08:41
+5 -0
Did "vibrant" NUJS student body say a word in support of CNLU students?
NUJS 21 Mar 2018, 10:36
+6 -0
Friend, please don't mind the official silence of the SJA (NUJS student body) or the comments by pro-Bhat trolls on LI. 99% of students and alumni are against Bhat. Some of us are planning to issue a separate statement independent of the SJA supporting CNLU. We are working on the draft. We deeply admire the unity and courage shown by CNLU students and wish you well.
Big brother 21 Mar 2018, 11:13
+6 -0
But we aren't going to do what you all did, because we are too busy prepping for moots and parties. But don't worry, our armchair solidarity is firmly behind you. Enter the chakravyuha, we will be right behind you.
Not in the name of Bha 23 Mar 2018, 06:38
+0 -0
Ultimately what happens at CNLU and NUJS. Whether Bhat will be taking over at CNLU at some other date or will he be continuing in NUJS..........in spite of all that questions regarding his integrity and competency
Expendable 23 Mar 2018, 08:07
+1 -0
See, the inquiry committee or whatever that has been promised to the CNLU students may or may not find evidence against Laxminath, but it's doubtful they will find any cogent legal evidence against Bhat on their own. Students are mostly relying for their allegations about his lack of fitness for the job, on the NUJS SJA no-confidence motions against him, which do not prove anything legally. Nor can the committee legally decide to await the publication of the Review Commission Report to take a call on this, since the Report relates to another university and not CNLU and it wasn't technically against Bhat either (but a more general review of NUJS). So, if CNLU students don't want Bhat to take over, they simply have to rely on 'moral' argument and pressure and mass protest and bargaining, rather than any legal point. As for NUJS, the student body there has hardly been the sort to hold open protests or anything. They can probably file another petition eventually or wait till the Review Commission Report is out. Till then, Bhat is probably going to stay at NUJS, unless the CNLU authorities choose to go by the letter of the law and refuse to stay Bhat's appointment on the grounds mentioned by students. It would be an unfortunate turn of events, but probably the closest to reality.