First(ish) NLU grad to run a college: NLS’ Nigam Nuggehalli shares plans for Hero’s BML university law school

Prof Nigam Nuggehalli takes over as first academic NLU-grad head of an Indian law school
Prof Nigam Nuggehalli takes over as first academic NLU-grad head of an Indian law school

Nigam Nuggehalli, a 1997 NLSIU Bangalore graduate and former visiting professor there, has been appointed as dean of the new BML Munjal University law school.

While not the first NLSIU graduate to run a law school (that honour technically goes to Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officer V Arun Roy, who temporarily took over the running of Tamil Nadu National Law School Srirangam in 2015), Nuggehalli will be the first academic educated at a national law school to be in charge of an Indian law university.

“Our plans are to develop this law school into a place where we can nurture and encourage what we call leaders of the legal profession,” he told us by phone earlier today.

Nuggehalli had been visiting professor in tax and jurisprudence for the last year at his alma mater, NLSIU Bangalore, before which he was at Azim Premji University’s school of policy and governance as associate professor from 2014, also heading up its new LLM programme.

He had also been a principal lecturer for the LLM at London’s BPP Law School - which administers the professional practice courses for English barristers and solicitors - from 2008 to 2014, and before that had worked as a tax associate at a New York law firm (having passed the New York bar).

He holds a 2012 DPhil and a 2006 MPhil from Oxford University (where he also taught, was associate editor of the Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal for a year, and won several scholarships); he also has a 1999 LLM from New York University’s School of Law in taxation, and a 1998 LLM from Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.

But - although his CV is extensive - he probably wouldn’t have qualified for the NLSIU VC post, which was advertised as requiring 10 years of professorship experience; another NLSIU grad - Prof Sudhir Krishnaswamy is incidentally in the running for that position.

The newest private law school

BML’s law school - which follows the 2014-founded and Hero Group-backed university’s engineering and management schools - has started this year with 22 students nearly evenly split between its five-year BA LLB and BBA LLB (including management and business) this year; it has received Bar Council of India (BCI) approval for a maximum of 60 law students per batch.

Its campus is located between Gurgaon and Manesar in Haryana, around an hour-and-a-half from Delhi.

Nuggehalli said that the student had been selected by a mix of Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) scores and personal interviews, and would increase in future batches.

“Our plans are to develop this law school into a place where we can nurture and encourage what we call leaders of the legal profession,” he said, adding that he’d been thining over the years as a student and professor about “what kind of law student I would like coming out of law school”.

Primarily, he said, he would like BML law graduates to have four qualities: to be “persuasive, effective, innovative and empathetic”.

While India had a “thriving practice culture” in the legal profession, “we don’t have a culture of public intellectualism in the law, or at least a very nascent culture”, he noted.

Faculty & research

BML currently had five law teachers, including himself, but would look to hire more, Nuggehalli said.

He would teach introduction to law, as well as his pet subjects of tax and jurisprudence, while professor emeritus MC Sharma also guiding legal education.

Of the three other faculty member assistant professors, two had done their LLMs abroad, and one had an LLM from NLSIU Bangalore (though none had been NLU under-graduates).

Research would take a central role at the nascent law school, though exact parameters about the exact research output requirements of faculty were still being formulated, according to Nuggehalli.

“Research is really important to any law school and it’s particularly important to any law school that’s interested in doing good teaching: good research leads to better teaching,” he said. “On its own its’ important to us but also as an important feeder to good teaching practices.”

Nuggehalli himself had been active in research on tax laws, in particular.

Future growth

Priorities for the future would include growing the faculty - BML paid above UGC pay scales though not quite as much as JGLS Sonepat, for instance - “but we are very serious about recruiting good faculty” and salary “should not be a problem” for the right candidates, according to Nuggehalli.

Tuition fees were currently pegged at Rs 2.55 lakh in the first year, increasing to Rs 3.45 lakh by the fifth year, which was “not prohibitively expensive”, though some “students will find these high”, he said.

Several scholarships were available (and currently availed of), though he did not have exact figures to hand at the time of our conversation.

NLSIU Professor to head Law School of BML Munjal University

· Experienced academician with experience of teaching and practice in institutions of India, UK and USA

· Holds DPhil from the University of Oxford Faculty of Law

· Prior to BMU, Professor Nigam was a Visiting professor at the National Law School of India University, Bangalore

New Delhi, 31 July 2019: BML Munjal University (BMU) today announced the appointment of Professor Nigam Nuggehalli as the Dean of its newly commenced School of Law. Professor Nigam was a Visiting professor at the National Law School of India University, Bangalore before joining BMU. Professor Nuggehalli has also taught as an Associate Professor in the School of Policy and Governance at Azim Premji University, during which he was also the head of the university’s newly founded LL.M program. BMU has launched School of Law from academic year 2019 and will be offering the programs of B.A. LLB and B.B.A LLB.

Professor Nuggehalli holds a DPhil from the University of Oxford Faculty of Law, an LLM in Taxation from New York University and a BA., LLB (Hons.) from the National Law School of India University. Before moving to India, Professor Nuggehalli was a Principal Lecturer teaching tax law and commercial law at BPP Law School, London. He led a team of academics in delivering undergraduate program in jurisprudence and postgraduate program in commercial law and international tax law. Before joining academia, he worked as a tax lawyer in New York and is a member of the New York Bar and the India Bar (Karnataka).

Dr. Manoj K. Arora, Vice Chancellor, BML Munjal University said, “We are delighted to welcome Professor Nigam as the Dean, School of law. With his wealth of teaching experience and global knowledge we are confident that he will bring immense value to the university’s program. We are very excited about the future of the new School of Law under his leadership.”

Speaking about the appointment, Professor Nigam Nuggehalli said, “It gives me a great pleasure to join BML Munjal University and be a part of an institution that’s transforming the education space. I look forward to putting my years of experience to work for this exciting law school and empower our students to be globally recognized practitioners and thought leaders in this competitive world.”

Professor Nuggehalli has been instrumental in teaching a variety of legal subjects (contracts, commercial law, corporate law, taxation) with reference to the legal regimes in the United States, the United Kingdom, and India.

Comments

Guest 31 Jul 2019, 15:32
+18 -5
This is huge game changer with more big news coming up! Sudhir is confirmed at NLSIU. His vacancy at Azim Premji will probably be filed by another alum. Meanwhile, NLUD will also get an alum after NLSIU sets the first precedent, while Shiv Nadar and Jio Institute are rumoured to be scouting for alumni for Deanship of their upcoming law schools.

It's interesting how private law schools are more progressive than NLUs. Even Jindal chose a young person like Rajkumar, who is not an NLU alum but at least a DU-Oxford-Harvard alum and Rhodes scholar (unlike the village university grads heading most NLUs).
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 02:09
+11 -0
At least a "Oxford-Harvard alum and Rhodes scholar"?

The 'law school' must be quite something.
Yeah right 1 Aug 2019, 12:58
+10 -3
You may not like folks who presently head our NLUs (many of us don't) but to say that that's beacuse they are "village university grads" is downright idiotic and ridiculous.

You belong to the small crop of students/alum from NLUs who place themselves on a false pedestal and look down at everyone not from an NLU. The rest of us know do not have our heads so far up our backside that we think that a person is defined merely by the University they graduate from.
Just Saying 31 Jul 2019, 15:33
+10 -1
In fact, VC Vivekanandan would have technically been the first alum (PhD from NLSIU) by becoming NUJS VC, had the TMC gang at NUJS not scuttled his chances and the spineless SJA kept quiet.
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 02:11
+2 -0
He was the Dean of IIT-KGP (public) and now Bennett (private). First in both scenarios - though being the first at a NLU will elude him.
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 15:37
+4 -1
I hope the NLU Students Consortium wakes up to this and demands revisions in the Vice Chancellor appointment rules!
Hydra 31 Jul 2019, 15:41
+11 -3
NLU snobs may look down at Munjal (as they do on Jindal) but the quality of faculty and admin is a 1000 times superior to the NLUs. In the case on Munjal, look who is on their advisory board: Harish Salve, Zia Mody, Ajay Bahl, Rajiv Luthra and David Wilkins from Harvard Law School!

https://www.bml.edu.in/courses/law/
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 02:12
+10 -0
Advisory board really mean nothing. That said, private institutions are attracting good faculty.
kal ho na ho 1 Aug 2019, 04:47
+5 -1
Sonu Nigam, Trump, Dwight K. Schrute also.
Facepalm 1 Aug 2019, 07:45
+2 -2
Well, it also has Lalit Bhasin, Ranbir Singh and Shuva Mandal.
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 16:53
+6 -1
Sudhir will be NLSIU VC and Mrinal Satish will be NLUD VC.
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 22:26
+5 -1
You be joking right? Even if he met the 10 year criteria (which he does not) you think the likes of JSM will let Mrinal Satish or any other NLU alum to become or stay as NLUD VC? I wouldn't be very surprised if cases are filed against Sudhur's appointment also to make sure that NLU alum don't start heading these institutions.
Sad or Happy? 31 Jul 2019, 17:54
+7 -3
Great teacher, immense conceptual clarity. Remains to be seen how he pans out as an administrator. Although his choice of university is curious. Why head out to (yet another) private law school? Jindal is basically becoming a dumping ground as a waystation for NLU academic talent (while they build up CVs for foreign PhDs).
Maybe Nigam is taking a lesson from the Sudhir experience? A higher profile at a lower university is still valid 10 years later when VC adverts are put out, so satisfy eligibility. To be sure, Sudhir seems to have moulded APU into a credible outfit in social legal academia in India.
Ladder, chaos et al. 31 Jul 2019, 18:15
+6 -0
Private universities are excellent to start off at. They pay well even at lower levels, so you can jump off to a higher position in a government institution later on without suffering too much financially. Many good administrators start off at private unis because it is far more pressure early on and a lot more accountability than in a government institution
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 18:59
+4 -0
Ten years is a long time, and it is possible that the prestige of private universities will increase by then. Even today I am sure many would prefer to head ISB over an IIM (not IIM A). In the US, the most prestigious universities are private, and India does seem to be veering towards the US model of education (interest in liberal arts for instance)
JGLS 31 Jul 2019, 19:31
+8 -7
I am sick of these ridiculous and spiteful comments against Jindal ! On placements, Jindal is behind only 4 or 5 NLUs, while Jindal students have performed well in prestigious moots, received postgrad offers at top universities (including a direct admission to Harvard Business School for an MBA) and cleared competitive exams. Please also look at the journals where Jindal profs have published and compare with NLU profs. Also, please note that Jindal hires mostly NLU talent. So if Jindal is bad it means NLU talent is also bad!
Freud 31 Jul 2019, 18:04
+5 -10
Hit like if you read fetish
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 19:35
+3 -7
The gap between NLSIU and other NLUs with get a LOT bigger once Sudhir takes over. As for BML Munjal, one can at least expect it to do better than the bottom half of the 21 NLUs. Same for Shiv Nadar and Jio Insitute, which are also looking for NLU alumni.

Bottomline: the competition between law schools are going to get a lot intense. Faculty and admin will make a lot more difference than in previous years.
? 1 Aug 2019, 06:50
+8 -1
What are you basing this on, exactly? Some of you treat Sudhir like the second coming of Christ for no good reason. He's a good enough chap but if you think he's going to make NLS do backflips so many years after its inception, you're delusional.
8chan 31 Jul 2019, 19:37
+4 -0
Meanwhile, ET is reporting that JGLS may get Eminence status. NLU grads will go ape shit if that happens, as the Law Minister has said no INI tag for NLUs!!

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/services/education/eminence-list-to-be-slashed-to-20-institutes/articleshow/70426071.cms
Guest 31 Jul 2019, 19:42
+6 -11
The protest at NLUO was totally planned to harm Prof Deva Rao's chances of getting NLSIU VCship. Now Mr Sudhir will win because of this dirty politics.
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 05:55
+2 -1
We know that Sudhir has been cleared for NLSIU, but what about NLUD? Any gossip?
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 07:54
+1 -0
RS retires in September. He will try to hang on as placeholder VC after that for as long as he can. Search committee will be set up only towards the end or after his retirement date (September). SKD Rao is a faculty member at nlud on deputation to nluo. So it is quite likely he will come back as VC. That'll be the easiest choice. Jaswal is another strong contender. He sits on virtually every committee at nlud and is very close to RS. The Chief Justice of Delhi--some Patel is the Chancellor. Through that Bimal Patel may have a chance, who knows. Then there are many DU faculty who will apply. These people have lots of connections with SC and HC judges and senior lawyers. So all in all - an open race. It'll be someone very conventional. There is no scope for a Sudhir type appointment. Both because rules don't allow and people who make these decisions have very little imagination.
Manju bar 1 Aug 2019, 10:24
+1 -1
It is Chintu Ramesh not Sudhir apparently
Erroneous Reporting 1 Aug 2019, 11:31
+1 -0
Dr. M.K. Ramesh has been appointed as the Interim Vice-Chancellor. This is because the official appointment orders have not been issued by the CJI as yet. Sudhir will also need to serve notice period at APU.
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 12:00
+1 -5
Sudhir Krishnaswamy CANNOT be appointed VC because the advertisement itself was mala fide (age limit of 60).
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 12:08
+2 -0
NEWS FLASH: Shamnad Basheer has been approached to be Dean of Jio Institute School of Law by the VC Professor Mashelkar (who is a good friend of his)
Guest2 14 Aug 2019, 09:40
+1 -0
Well turns out he won't be accepting that offer afterall.
F
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 14:57
+0 -2
In academics, NALSAR, NUJS and other NLUs are much behind where NLSIU were at this stage. Shamnad and Sudhir were already professors by 2010, but not a single alumni of other NLUs have reached professor rank.
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 16:09
+2 -0
You need a godfather like MP Singh to make that happen. Those days NLUs weren't abiding by UGC rules anyway and litigation from faculty and others challenging such moves was almost unheard of. No VC can get away with appointing someone without a PhD as a chair professor these days, regardless of how good the candidate may be. Plenty of alumni from NALSAR and NUJS have joined academics and doing reasonably well, like those from NLSIU. In the Indian context, whether you are a professor or an assistant professor hardly matters in terms of the contribution you can make inside the classroom or through research.
Guest 1 Aug 2019, 16:27
+1 -0
They were given promotions well ahead of the general timeline in a world before the RTI.

No VC will do anything similar for another youngster, like for eg. Unni, Anup or Chinmayi (all NALSARites).
NLUD VC?? 1 Aug 2019, 19:04
+1 -0
I don't think there are chances of Jaiswal or even SKD becoming VC. Both of their chances are severely marred by the protests happening at RGNUL and GNLU. Also there seem to be no signs of Ranbir moving. Will be interesting to see what happens. Does anyone have any concrete updates?
Guest 2 Aug 2019, 06:32
+1 -0
Rumour has it that VC Vivekanandan and VK Unni may give NLUD a shot.
Lawyered..!! 2 Aug 2019, 09:00
+1 -0
"....two had done their LLMs abroad, and one had an LLM from NLSIU Bangalore (though none had been NLU under-graduates)."

Is there any reason for highlighting this or was just to satisfy NLU's master?
Guest 2 Aug 2019, 09:59
+0 -0
Kian, this is what Bar & Bench reported today. It's clear that LI and B&B are getting tips for different sources, and the NLSIU people posting on LI are getting tips for another source! Please try and clarify. Will there be a fresh advertisement with 65 as the age limit, instead of 60??

[quote]A few names proposed to take up the post of NLSIU Vice Chancellor were rejected during an Executive Committee meeting held earlier this month. The search for the NLSIU VC was chaired by former NUJS Director MP Singh, Attorney General KK Venugopal and Senior Advocate Arvind Datar.

It is understood that former NLSIU student and faculty at Azim Premji University Sudhir Krishnaswamy and Symbiosis Law School Director Dr. Shashikala Gurpur were amongst the candidates who had applied for the post of Vice-Chancellor. With the conduct of a fresh search, new names are likely to be considered.
[/quote]

https://barandbench.com/prof-mk-ramesh-vice-chancellor-fac-nlsiu/
I know 2 Aug 2019, 14:09
+1 -1
Bar & Bench is wrong. Sudhir is confirmed.
Guest 2 Aug 2019, 20:53
+1 -1
Stupid govt just gave JGLS eminence status but are saying no INI status for NLSIU. Idiots.
Plug 3 Aug 2019, 09:57
+2 -0
Friends, please follow Bar & Bench next week for a guest article on the govt's legal education policy with respect to Institution of Eminence and Institution of National Importance.