NLU Shimla EVICTS all students from campus after food, infra complaints spark yet another NLU protest [UPDATE-1]

Admin
Admin

Update 19 September 2019 01:59: HPNLU Shimla’s administration has effectively kicked all students out of campus after students did not stop protests as the administration had requested.

According to the notice by the administration dated 18 September, the university announced that all administrative buildings would be closed until 25 September, and that “all the students must vacate the University with immediate effect”.

“If any student still prefers staying in the University Campus during night, he/she will be staying at his/her risk and responsibility,” added the admin, and, seemingly contradicting the previous paragraph, noted ominously: “It is further directed that residents of all hostels shall vacate [by 20 September] failing which strict action will be taken.”

It is understood that the university’s mess has stopped serving food and the logistics of how exactly all students are expected to leave campus at such short notice is not clear.

Previous developments

HPNLU Shimla students have gone on protest yesterday demanding an improvement in facilities and food, as the latest national law school to face strikes by students.

According to a student Twitter account:

Since birth HPNLU is lacking in basic facilities including safe drinking water, hygienic food, habitable conditions of hostel rooms etc, till date. Students had protested in March, unaddressed, which is resumed.

In the name of infancy, HPNLU been excused for 3 yrs but now this excuse is used by the admin to cover the facts In the name of lack of funds, students are denied essentials such as moot courts, seminars, fests, sports fests, etc. No funds!

Students have claimed that the mess has been operated unhygienically, resulting in “diseases such as diarrhoea and even hepatitis in students”, according to the students’ accounts.

Meanwhile, the administration has warned students to cease protesting or “strict action shall be taken against students who are found indulging in such activities”.

The registrar in his letter invited two student representatives from each batch to “come and put their grievances before the University Authorities in proper and decent manner”.

The university was “ready to accept, redress all genuine grievances of the students which are possible within the geographical and infrastructural constraints in which the University has to function”.

We have reached out to the HPNLU registrar Prof SS Jaswal for comment.

Shimla’s NLU had started out ambitiously, with its previous founding vice chancellor Prof Subash Chander Raina vowing in 2016 that new courses would be introduced and that the location would be a draw.

However, he said, the government had only provided Rs 20 crores and a lot of land (as opposed to erroneous press reports of Rs 400 crore being earmarked for the college).

Raina was succeeded by Prof Nishtha Jaswal as VC.

Only in July, NLU Odisha students had gone on protests over “uninhabitable conditions of the girls’ hostel, the dismal state of the sports shed and failure to provide a suitable library” and a fee-hike, according to numerous reports.

Admin warns off students, invites student nominees for dialogue
Admin warns off students, invites student nominees for dialogue

Comments

Lawstu123 18 Sept 2019, 13:07
+0 -0
SS Jaswal? Any relation to Nishtha or Paramjit?
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 14:45
+0 -0
Apparently not.
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 13:15
+24 -3
If you're from HPNLU and you're reading this, please don't let this threatening notice scare you.

You are merely asking for what is rightfully yours and as long as the protest is peaceful, you are Constitutionally protected to do so.

Please get your rightful demands accepted in writing and then call of the protest. Please acknowledge the power of student unity as was seen in HNLU, NUJS, RGNUL, CNLU, etc. You're powerful together and so don't let them play you.

God bless.
Lawstu234 18 Sept 2019, 14:04
+26 -1
This was bound to happen. The Universities should not cash on their National tag to bring students and forget them. It is highly unfortunate that the judiciary is part of this scam. The chief justice of India is the visitor and the chief justice of state is Chancellor but it appears that they had never cared for them. What is the idea of lending name to the institution if you are unable to take care of them. I hope that they will do something to rectify the situation and will provide the promised facilities to the students.
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 14:46
+14 -2
I don't think anyone ever associated with an NLU would disagree with this comment. Not even trolls.
sesquipedalian 20 Sept 2019, 06:54
+3 -2
One more reason why GLC is better. No question of evicting students when they're anyways not present, but busy interning in firms around South Mumbai !
Close low rung NLUs 18 Sept 2019, 16:51
+19 -1
HPNLU Shimla and similar new NLUs have always sucked. This was bound to happen. They started a new NLU without anything. No campus, no money, useless VC, below average faculty and getting students just because of NLU tag. Such schools need to be closed. Max 10 good NLUs need to be nurtured and made top class Institutes. Can you imagine such NLU becoming NLS, Nalsar or NLU Delhi even in next 50 years??
MKM 19 Sept 2019, 06:22
+4 -0
One wonders how such an NLU even cleared the BCI inspection since they clearly don't meet even the most bare minimum infra requirements. Would be interesting to see what an RTI in this regard would throw up
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:41
+1 -1
Filed one yet? Do share the results.
Student 123455322 20 Sept 2019, 01:12
+1 -0
There isn't a RTI portal, this is also a reason (Lack of transparency from The administration's part,))
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 16:58
+11 -1
Such protests will keep happening and keep failing unless there is a pan-India #NationaliseNLUsProtest jointly done by different colleges. I just cannot understand why this is not happening. NLSIU and NALSAR may not be interested, but there are over 20 NLUs. Why can't at least 10 new NLUs do it? Why can't a peaceful march in front of the state High Courts or the Supreme Court happen?
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 17:07
+1 -56
The students must stop the strike and focus on studies. Sometimes things may be said by elders to students harshly, but they are ultimately there to care for you. Even your parents can scold you sometimes. If the strike goes on it will harm your careers and life. Suppose a third party from outside the college files a police complaint then it can stain your chance of placement and can be a ground for debarring from UPSC/judicial service exam. No one can have control over third parties, but if you stop the strike then obviously no third party can complain to the police. Remember that all issues can be solved through peaceful talks.
Lawstudnetww 18 Sept 2019, 18:13
+27 -0
Please shut up.
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 18:22
+6 -0
What placement? What career? What life? You probably don't have had any of these if your knowledge of law says a third party not associated with the NLU can file a police complaint about a student strike inside the NLU.
Lawstudent59999 18 Sept 2019, 20:45
+10 -0
Please don't mislead students of law. No such case can be filed for participating in a protest in consonance with the Constitutionally protected Right to Association.

Stop giving people any more negativity that they already have. Any such case filed is bad in law and cannot affect any career choice of UPSC or judiciary, etc.

Please stop.
lmao 19 Sept 2019, 06:23
+10 -0
Uncle ji baith jao please
Beloved DM, CJI 20 Sept 2019, 13:58
+3 -0
Please read Avtar Singh v. Union of India. Your doubts would be clarified over debarment and stigma through an FIR out of an act of protest.
Saddened 18 Sept 2019, 17:16
+10 -0
Forget faculty or infrastructure. It's really sad if the students have to protest about something as basic as food!
guest1 18 Sept 2019, 17:26
+4 -1
This is why students should think before joining lower NLUs. People shove the 'NLU Tag' in brains of these students and send them to these low tier colleges. Better go to Symbiosis, even Noida or such leading private universities.
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 20:16
+20 -6
[img]https://i.imgur.com/SFablSR.png[/img]

[img]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DONfHmKUQAAA8yz.jpg[/img]
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:48
+5 -3
Your persistence is remarkable. However, let's test if even a few people are willing to do what might seem a minimum in support of this idea.

You have names of 14 NLUs on your poster. Fair to say these places shall have at least 7000 LLB students. Why is it that you never get a 'like' from 1% of them (70 likes) when you post this idea on almost every other story on LegallyIndia? Could it be that they are not in the least interested? Not even 1% to log-on here and click like? How do you then believe they will 'march' and 'petition'?

Though, it seems you are taking on board this lack of interest, and have removed the 'sing' and 'dance' (that some of your older posters had) as activities to generate awareness.

Summary: Bhai tu post like hi karvaale, yeh march warch to nahi ho raha.
Guest 23 Sept 2019, 03:37
+0 -0
0.25% likes so far. Despite your persistence, and my goading that law students aren't even good enough for this much.
Guest 18 Sept 2019, 20:21
+3 -16
2.5 lakhs a year is peanuts. People pay crores to stud medicine and engineering. NLU students are really spoilt. You want five star luxury like JGLS (12 lakhs a year) by paying local law college prices.
NLU_Nagpur 19 Sept 2019, 04:51
+7 -1
Are you suggesting after paying even 2.5 lacs the students should not demand basic amenities like Potable water, Hygienic food (let alone the taste)and inhabitable hostels (unlike the current hostels which are shady and stinky)?

HPNLU students are paying for moot court, Journal, and other Co-curricular and Extra-curricular activities. However, There is no sign of such activities in the university. Due to hostile attitude of the administration, the students could not able to develop ADR culture in the university. There is no faculty exchange programme, no visit of eminent personalities, however students are paying a hefty amount for all these activities.

If you think 2.5 lacs a year is peanuts and the students are demanding a luxurious lifestyle then i think either you are a student of a private university/college who could not secure admission in an NLU or you are a privileged rich kid.
lawstuddent 18 Sept 2019, 20:47
+17 -1
Shame on you Dr. Nishtha Jaswal for kicking your own students out. Students must ask for her resignation.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 05:08
+1 -4
So, a law school for the rich like JGLS is given Eminence status while NLUs are denied funds and students deprived. Are NLU students going to do a joint protest or not??? Only then will the government hear.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:48
+5 -1
NOT.
Ok 20 Sept 2019, 05:53
+2 -0
Let me tell you a truth. However harsh that is. Top NLU students hardly even give a flying f*** about NLU shimla Or other lower NLUs.
Do we? 19 Sept 2019, 05:18
+3 -0
This prompt me to ask a question I have been pondering for long. Do we need this many NLUs?
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:49
+6 -0
NO.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:52
+4 -0
There are just as many IITs and IIMs FYI. But they do not strike as they get central govt funds for infra and faculty. This is the only solution.
Jackal 19 Sept 2019, 06:46
+7 -0
I think it's high time students/ parents/ counsellors smarten up a bit and smell the coffee before shelling out lakhs (and more importantly invest the 5 most important years of one's life) on such new "NLU"s. NLSIU was started in 1988, right before the first generation reforms. By the time the first batch graduated, the private sector was experiencing exponential growth and the economy was in need of transactional lawyers like never before. This led to the formation of the next batch of NLUs which could find suitable employment for students as long as the economy was growing till the early 2000s. Those days are long gone now. Looking at the state of the present economy, even the graduates of the earlier established NLUs would struggle to find suitable employment, let alone these newer ones. There's just not enough growth. And lawyers are essentially ancillary professionals, they cannot create something out of nothing. They aren't manufacturers, innovators or inventors. Stop attending random law schools and wasting money and time. There are better things to do in your late teens/ early 20s than protesting at law campuses.
No 1 NLU 19 Sept 2019, 14:42
+6 -0
And here I am sitting in a law firm wondering how many more people will fit in the same office. The market may be down, but firms still need a lot of people. Just look at any big banking and finance team right now. If you look in the partner offices you'll see that most of them came from NLUs that were written off at the time or older law schools.

I used to sit on on a high horse about the top rung NLUs being better but working with some of these people will give you a new found respect for how hard they work and how much they like what they do.

Your performance in an exam shouldn't dictate what you do with your life. That being said, if you look at the degree only for its returns, there's "market risks".
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 06:49
+5 -0
[img]https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/956/711/b89.jpg[/img]
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 11:28
+0 -5
Other than NLSIU, NALSAR and NLUD absolutely NONE of the other law schools are worth going to. All have terrible faculty and terrible infrastructure.
lncorrect. 19 Sept 2019, 15:26
+0 -0
That's just blatantly incorrect. GNLU has great infra and okay-ish faculty, RGNUL has decent infra and faculty, HNLU isn't too bad either although the faculty quality is severely lacking. In fact NLUD has good faculty but their cramped af campus leaves a lot to be desired infra wise.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 15:51
+3 -1
NLUD campus is full of misogyny, more than one instance of violence and since recently, a lot of infighting among the young and older faculty. True story.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 15:50
+1 -0
@16: Or just terribly misinformed trolls like you. How many law schools have you been at yourself?
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 15:56
+0 -0
In general, in terms of interns and colleagues, I've not really found any major difference between students and graduates from NLSIU, NALSAR, NUJS, NLUD, NLUJ and GNLU at least. So regardless of other factors, I'd say graduate quality of all these places are more or less comparable.
Duniyahilanekatime 19 Sept 2019, 12:00
+1 -3
I believe this is the first case in the history of our country wherein an university administration has taken such steps. This should be prominently featuring accross everything, all legal bogs, twitter, facebook groups, linkedin pages etc. I dont know what these students are doing -you have numbers - use every one of them. This unprecedented step should result in resignations.

There is only one way to do it now. Stay on campus and get those demands answered.

Or really - dont take any action and loose all respect. You are JUST another new nlu right. Ghar jao, chod do nlu ka chakkar.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 13:15
+3 -1
Unprecedented?

yeh Google ke Pehle page se hai -
https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/hyderabad-university-students-allege-they-are-being-forcibly-evicted-hostels-43584
https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india-allahabad-university-violence-students-go-on-rampage-after-being-asked-to-evict-hostel-445669

UoH and Allahabad University no less. Kya tum NLU waale kuch bhi ugal dete ho.

[b]PS: Not condoning the university's action or belittling the suffering students lot. Just pointing out the hyperbole common to these forums.[/b]
Duniyahilanekatime 19 Sept 2019, 14:10
+2 -3
Please dont compare apples and oranges. That will help you.

There is a difference on being asked to vacate premises during vacations and on being asked to do so during a full blown academic year.

Local college se lagte ho. NLU wale hote toh ye samajh aa jata.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 13:12
+0 -0
Many coaching centres urge students to pick any NLU over JGLS and Symbi, so that they can boast that so many students form their centre cleared CLAT. They say fake stuff like about colleges being really good.
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 13:24
+0 -1
Profs. Paramjit S Jaswal & Nishtha Jaswal Receive Amity Academic Excellence Award 2019

https://www.livelaw.in/lawschool/news/profs-paramjit-s-jaswal-nishtha-jaswal-receive-amity-academic-excellence-award-2019-143179
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 13:28
+4 -3
A statement of support has been tweeted from NLU Haryana. I am surprised to know there is even such a thing as NLU Haryana!

[img]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EEz-slbX4AEdMtT.jpg[/img]
Bhai chand pe hai kya? 20 Sept 2019, 08:30
+4 -0
Haryana kahan se lag raha hai bhai /bahen tujhe?
Nagpur is in Maharashtra which has 3nlus. Nagpur wo city of oranges wala nagpur hai... Aur shimla is in himachal pradesh... himachal where you have manali... Shimla ke aage... Aur aage Wahan baba ki booti milti h... Li nahi h kya baba ki booti? Ya fir abhi utri nahi h?
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 18:01
+0 -9
Students were requested on Legally India to call off strike or third parties can call police. That could happen now. You can just call off the strike and give an apology to the VC. A fresh start can be made.
nitnishtha 19 Sept 2019, 19:00
+0 -2
You're not an NLU grad are you?
Guest 19 Sept 2019, 18:08
+0 -1
This protest is very suspicious. A distinguished person who is frontrunner for NLUD VC is repeatedly being targeted. First it was done directly by a protest at another NLU. Now it is being done indirectly.
nitnishtha 19 Sept 2019, 18:59
+0 -1
Nishtha is not front runner for NLUD lol. And trust me, Jaswal is enough to get NLUD anyway. He's bought people backwards forwards.