GNLU calls cops on campus to solve firecracker prank, debars final year students from exams, Guj HC referees yet again

GNLU Gandhinagar has notched up another in its tally of high court orders that direct its administration to reverse its actions, this time in the case of four final year students suspected of bursting firecrackers during a classroom lecture, as first reported by Ahmedabad Mirror.

The Gujarat high court has directed GNLU to allow the four students to appear for their end of semester exams after the students, suspected of the firecracker prank and suspended and debarred from exams without a hearing, had moved court against the law school.

We understand from our sources that after the crackers allegedly went off during a classroom lecture on Friday 20 April, GNLU informed the police after which around seven uniformed personnel visited campus.

Four students, who were the only ones found near the spot where the crackers had burst, were called out by the administration but without giving them a hearing they were sent a notice of their suspension at midnight that day.

They were summoned for a disciplinary probe after the afternoon of Monday, 23 April, but before setting up the probe GNLU had already debarred them from the end semester exam, thus allegedly denying them a fair opportunity to defend themselves, we understand further.

Since the exams were scheduled from Tuesday 24 April, the suspected students approached the high court, according to the Mirror.

Gujarat high court justice RM Chhaya heard their plea at his residence late on Monday night and passed the interim order directing GNLU to allow them to take their exams, however Chhaya did not stay GNLU’s order of suspension and also ordered that GNLU could not declare the results of the suspected students without the high court’s permission.

The next hearing in the case was yesterday.

Comments

Friend of GNLU 1 May 2018, 08:56
+14 -25
The administration has made the right decision by calling police. It is an act of serious mischief. In these days of terrorism one can also cause stampede and alarm by such acts. As Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes has said, freedom does not mean you go to a cinema hall and scare everyone by shouting there is a fire. If this happened in USA they will send the students straight to FBI anti-terrorism cell.
Friend of GNLU 1 May 2018, 09:23
+6 -13
In furtherance of my last mail I wish to share few news items. It is said in one that "40 injured at French resort after people mistook firecrackers for terror attack"
http://www.thejournal.ie/france-firecracker-panic-juan-les-pins-2928821-Aug2016/

It is said in another one that "Firecracker triggers stampede in Italy" after people mistake it for terrorist attack
https://tenplay.com.au/news/national/june-2017/firecracker-triggers-stampede-in-italy

It is keeping this in mind that police was called because safety of all is paramount. I am also giving exact quote of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes from the Wikipedia: "The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater
Foreign Director 1 May 2018, 12:36
+18 -2
Any Indian examples.

Why you didn't call police in case of sexual harassment of Students by your security officer.
Foreign Director 1 May 2018, 12:34
+9 -3
It is always risky to bring Director from foreign land as he always compare everything with foreign. The Director should be quickly sent to foreign.

Just sack him it's too much.
Namsleyy 1 May 2018, 13:31
+24 -1
Calling the police is good but to barred them just because they placed a firecracker in class is nonsense. Atleast GNLU can set up a committee and ask about the incident but they registered FIR against those students doesn't make sense.
Spoiling Careers 1 May 2018, 14:35
+11 -2
One should think hundred time's before filing FIR and specially young students beginning Career.

This Director doesn't have Brian and zero Administrative knowledge


Students should remove him or he will continue to spoil Careers of Students.

Just throw him out...
Guest 2 May 2018, 21:16
+0 -0
Why? Should adults not be held accountable for their actions?
Accountability 3 May 2018, 13:16
+2 -0
Than catch hold of BIMPA he is wasting crores in legal expenses.

To make up the same he in increasing fees of only SC/ST students, it's true kindly see this year fees compared to last year fees.

This person will just ruin legal education.

Students get up and kick him out..
Kal ho Na ho 1 May 2018, 09:26
+5 -0
Wah bhai Wah
Spoilt brats 1 May 2018, 09:44
+15 -2
These things happen when students dont know what they are going to college for. Sad to read so many cases of disoriented characters doing sexual harassment, drugs, drinks, mischief and ragging. Typical cases of spoilt brats with power money nexus and care a damn for law attitude. Wonder why they are studying law. Crackers....what next. I think 1st such incident can be forgiven together with some community service.
Godfather 1 May 2018, 09:54
+0 -1
Kian u have not done any articles on the godfathers of lawyers, partners, college teachers, GCs, students who save them from illegal immoral acts. Will be nice if you we can come to know who is whose godfather. Difficult to survive without the knowledge of this.
No godfather 1 May 2018, 12:51
+6 -0
Everyone is running from.him forced to delay General Council meeting.

Which decides his fate in GNLU.
Director 1 May 2018, 12:49
+6 -10
It happens because bimal Patel allows students to Rome in campus whloe night.

No restrictions for boy's and girls to move out of campus
Moral Police 1 May 2018, 17:06
+11 -0
I agree. How can they just Rome about? Blasphemous. They should be kept under lock and key like the fortress of Bastille. Wait, what happened in Bastille again?
Thanos 3 May 2018, 15:41
+0 -0
They should just do the Romans. When in Rome, etc. Or is it do like the Romans? These fine intricacies of these moral issues will always escape me, I'm afraid.
The fuck 3 May 2018, 12:39
+0 -0
What is wrong with you ?
Guest 1 May 2018, 12:33
+1 -5
Under what face will GNLU claim INI status with such bad students? Prof Bimal Patel has done stellar work building GNLU as a brand but these rotten elements ruin it
Aggrieved student 1 May 2018, 12:43
+5 -0
I want my degree for registration purpose but this Director to ensure that he gets time to clean up the mess he created and get time.

He postponed the Convocation till September no one to check his irregularities.

One more term for this idiot too much for decline of legal education. That is what the Government wants.
No Ranking 1 May 2018, 12:46
+4 -0
GNLU is not participating in any Ranking because it doesn't want to list at the last place
Guest 1 May 2018, 13:10
+8 -0
All were from Karni Sena?
Too Much Fun 1 May 2018, 14:33
+1 -2
Did these 4 students get PPO's? What's all the celebration about?
GNLUite 1 May 2018, 16:15
+14 -3
It was the last teaching day of the college for fifth year students. The students merely wanted to play a prank without harming or damaging any life, health and property. It was just a small cracker too but the administration took it upon their ego since they have not been able to address important issues like sexual harassment, etc. Moreover, there weren't a single cop for the sexual harassment matter but for this prank we had a riot van along with 12 uniformed cops on campus. Bimal Patel is a joke himself but he needs to learn how to take a joke! What's all this FUSS about. Those are students and not Terrorists! The administration needs to learn to respect their own students!
Guest 1 May 2018, 17:32
+6 -1
Then why aren't u ppl protesting like other NLUs?
LK 2 May 2018, 03:22
+5 -18
Prof Bimal Patel has been an excellent leader of GNLU. It is sad to see such negative comments by ignorant people and negative coverage by Legally India. The following are some of the achievements under Prof Patel:

1) Record placements
2 Moot court success
3) Success of students in getting good LLM offers and scholarship including Rhodes scholarships
4) Campus modernisation and beautification
5) New research chairs and funding
6) Support from government
7) Many international conferences
8) Many famous professors visited from abroad
9) Many good publications and research papers by faculty
10) Improvement in quality of faculty and hiring of excellent faculty
11) Good performance in NAAC, India Today etc
12) Overall improvement in reputation
13) Improvement in campus discipline
14) Improvement in syllabus and relevant courses for industry
15) Improvement in quality of postgraduate education
Start job search 2 May 2018, 06:57
+11 -0
With honest coverage of fearless media like legally India. BIMPA is scared.

Start job searching you have spoiled many families and careers, it's your turn now.

Your wife will be a reason for your EXIT.
Guest 2 May 2018, 07:29
+16 -0
As if GNLU students have the spine to protest. NLIU, NUJS, RMLNLU, CNLU, NLU Ranchi, NLU Assam... all protested except GNLU. Will never happen.
RDX 3 May 2018, 14:15
+4 -0
GNLU students = biggest wimps ever. They will never launch a protest like other NLUs.