Hunt on for new NUJS VC, academic preferred; MP Singh retires to write book on nature of law

Professor (Dr) Singh: Academically minded
Professor (Dr) Singh: Academically minded
Singh: Academically minded”)Exclusive: NUJS Kolkata vice chancellor Mahendra Pal Singh, who is due to retire on 30 November to pursue personal legal writing projects, said his successor should have a strong academic background while also having to be deal with infrastructure and other problems at the college.

Singh said: “I would wish that whoever is appointed is a person of some academic intuition and not purely an administrator. But at the same time the person must also be ready or willing to give up some of his personal interests or academic interests in favour of the university.

“Whoever accepts vice chancellorship, the university must be the first priority; personal academic ambitions and his engagements must come next.”

Singh, who taught at the University of Delhi 1997 to 2005, said that during his five year tenure at NUJS he had tried to make some improvements on the academic side both “at the level of the faculty and engagement of the students in serious research”.

“But at the same time there are a number of things where further improvements are needed. [And on] infrastructure we are weak in a number of ways – particularly the space where we are is very narrow and we are facing serious problems particularly for hostels, since the university is residential and most of its facilities are open 24 hours.”

He noted that the college did not have any space on campus but was expecting the state government to grant a “convenient place where we can move further and expand”, although only preliminary suggestions have so far been received that have not yet been taken further.

Singh added that there was also a lot of scope for expanding programmes of study in the social sciences space. NUJS was planning to start a degree on law and management, as well as start up a center for law and public policy, which had already been approved. “There is a need to attract persons from other disciplines to the university, which are aligned disciplines.”

Singh told Legally India that after his retirement he would privately like to continue with research and writing, not necessarily in any academic institution.

“There are a number of areas in which I have been thinking [of researching further] apart from some of the books I have already done that need to be revised

One is [VN] Shukla’s Constitution of India, which I have been revising for the last couple of years,” he said.

“And for a long time I have been thinking of writing something on the nature and understanding of the Indian legal system. That appears to be sort of a lifelong plan which I have been dreaming about for a long time.”

He said that he would retire on 30 November but his sympathies would always remain with the college and he would assist whenever there was anything he could do even after his retirement.

Singh was head and dean of Delhi University’s faculty of law from 1994 to 1997, having also taught at Meerut from 1964 to 1970, and having held fellow and visiting professor roles at colleges such as University of Heidelberg in Germany, and universities in Hong Kong, Osaka, Singapore, Berlin and Beijing.

Comments

A great VC and a great man 5 Aug 2011, 12:00
+3 -0
Prof. Singh is a great man: humble, intelligent and inspiring.

It was under his tenure that NUJS had a huge recruitment of top notch faculty from around the globe!

NUJS has largely been a student lead college; but still, I hope another dynamic VC replaces Prof. Singh.
NUJS Alum 5 Aug 2011, 12:10
+3 -0
A revolutionary indeed he was. Shall always be a great inspiration.
Anonymous 5 Aug 2011, 12:16
+4 -0
He is irreplaceable.
Dushyant K. Mahant 5 Aug 2011, 14:04
+4 -0
I feel proud that Prof. Singh taught me at CLC during my three years there. He was very helpful during my admission to UQ for my Masters as well. Teachers like him are in short supply.
Admirer 5 Aug 2011, 16:16
+4 -0
We need more academician-administrators like Prof. Singh. Thanks to him, NUJS can boast of one among the best faculty compared to other NLUs - Prof. Sudhir Krishnaswamy and Prof. Shamnad Basheer to name a few.
dissent 6 Aug 2011, 05:40
+7 -0
Sorry but I disagree. I do not think he will be missed. He may have been a better VC than BS Chimni but he was still unsatisfactory and way behind Prof Menon. He made no improvement to infrastructure, hiked fees, promoted socialist ideas, was against corporate sponsored chairs and tie-ups foreign universities on the grounds that only "rich" students woudl benefits (uh hello? this is the market economy. And why do you charge so much fees then?)

NUJS needs someone like Ranbir Singh. Some snobs scoff at the fact that he is not a well-known academic and "shamelessly" woos corporates and politicians, but that is the kind of person you need. There is too much commie thinking in NUJS.
Shamnad Basheer 6 Aug 2011, 07:09
+9 -0
Dear Dissent:

A couple of quick clarifications. I've worked quite closely with Prof Singh over the last couple of years, and have not till date, spotted an anti market sentiment in him. Of course, he may not be as market savvy as Prof Ranbir Singh. But he's never stood in the way of a good collaboration or a good idea. I've never heard of him refusing a chair opportunity. Or a collaboration with a foreign University--in fact, as we speak, we are actively pursuing two tie ups..and Prof Singh has been extremely supportive. So not sure where you are getting this sentiment from?

Thanks,

Shamnad Basheer
A 6 Aug 2011, 07:42
+2 -0
@ Dissent - are national law schools only made to cater law firms and companies ?
@A 6 Aug 2011, 07:59
+3 -0
Well according to NUJS students everything is all about law firms and companies. But yet, he is a better VC than the one at NLIU. NLIU's director is more of a dictator than a director. I hope LI covers a story on all the [...] and a lot of other allegations on the director of NLIU which have been by the UGC as well as the ministry of higher education of MP. When the UGC gave a show cause notice to the university, some questions were not answered whereas others were not satisfactory (as stated by the UGC) I hope LI doesn't censor this part and seriously cover a story on this, which is anyway reported almost regularly in state newspapers. MP Singh is anyday better than SS. Singh.
le 6 Aug 2011, 15:54
+3 -0
yes, given the money NLUs charge why should students be interested in joining bar and give up easily available 9at least in top NLUs) law firm jobs.
2.8 Km 6 Aug 2011, 14:24
+4 -0
oh god.
When will Veer Singh retire!
le 6 Aug 2011, 15:57
+0 -0
it would be great to see a management and law course in NUJS, i reckon GNLU is the only NLU which offers BBA LLB degree. i am sure more nlus would move to management supplement to produce more business and commercial oriented law students. i am sure there would be detractors who would harp on the social aspects of law, just to clarify i am asking for students be given a choice to either study social sciences or management.
libya 6 Aug 2011, 16:11
+1 -0
I wish Balraj Chauhan (VC, RMLNLU) retires soon... change is good...
aa 6 Aug 2011, 16:35
+3 -0
Shamnad Basheer should be the new VC. He fulfils all the requirements given in the ad

http://www.nujs.edu/downloads/notice-for-vc-nujs.pdf

There is no requirement of 15 years teaching experience or anything like that. It wil be great if NUJS can have a young VC.
Agree 9 Aug 2011, 05:47
+1 -0
This feeling is shared by many students and alumni. A young VC can work miracles in terms of doing away with age old red tape and coming up with unconventional ideas. Moreover, having been the right hand of Prof. Singh, he can take the reforms started by the former to their conclusion without interruption.

I have already sent in a nomination in favour of Prof. Basheer. All others who think on the same lines are requested to take concrete steps by sending in nominations [http://nujs.edu/downloads/notice-for-vc-nujs.pdf] and not merely comment on legally india and let the issue rest.

I hope the fact that Prof. Basheer has long and non-gray hair does not count against him
Noojie 7 Aug 2011, 21:06
+0 -0
Maybe Prof. Singh got inspired by his students and wants to start up and give vent to his entrepreneurial instincts.

Once a Noojie always a Noojie.

Oops! Got to get going. Lots of plates to wash.
soooooooooooooooooooooooo funn 9 Aug 2011, 05:49
+1 -0
when you have nothing to contribute to a discussion, just keep shut
Real Fun 22 Aug 2011, 18:26
+1 -0
This is real fun, I tell you. At Law School nowadays Noojie bashing is a favourite pastime.
They start up so often. What's the next start up and when is it coming up? When will you start the next LPO, Octopussy or whatever else you guys start?
law firm associate 8 Aug 2011, 08:46
+2 -0
I did not have much time left in NUJS when Dr Singh came on board but based on what I have heard from my juniors in NUJS, he was a damn nice fellow.... Its indeed sad that he is leaving.... I wish you all the very best Sir....
Big fan 8 Aug 2011, 14:14
+7 -0
Prof. Singh, you will be missed. The only real life head of an educational institution who was as good as Albus Dumbledore. I love him for the respect with which he treats students. He may not have waved a magic wand; but under him we felt like the college was ours
baba ramdev 20 Aug 2011, 11:38
+0 -0
Why the hell is TK Oomen in the 3-member selection panel? He is not a lawyer. He is only a sociologist and that too in the notorious commie bastion JNU.

Friends let us start a campaign to have a young and modern VC. If Shamnad Basheer has applied for the post the students should start an andolan and lobby for him.
Bawa Sir 23 Aug 2011, 05:41
+0 -0
NUjs should get someone fron GNLU, just look at the progress GNLU has made in last 3 years.
p.s. I am not from GNLU
noojie 29 Aug 2011, 09:23
+1 -0
Prof. Singh will be missed. He was very approachable and was open to new ideas. He tried his best to make the University a better place.
Subhajit 29 Aug 2011, 12:05
+0 -0
It was indeed an hounour and a priviledge to be a part of NUJS when Prof. M.P. Singh was around. The college has seen much improvement in all respects apart from infrastructure, maybe.

But there is not much one can do in a given space of 4 acres. It is the government that needs to take the blame primarily. The hiked fees was another issue that received stiff retaliation , but as a VC he tried to address the issue favourably for the students as far as possible, but there wasn't much he could do as the costs of running the university also went up.

All in all I saw a lot of positive changes in the university and I am glad that Prof. Singh was my VC.

Shubho
Well wisher of NUJS 30 Nov 2011, 08:43
+0 -0
On 30th Nov 2011 Prof M.P.Singh is completing his tenure as VC of NUJS, Calcutta. As he steps out from NUJS he leaves behind him the illegal acts that happened during his tenure as VC. We all look forward to Prof Ishwara Bhatt the newly appointed Vice Cancellor of NUJS Calcutta to address the illegalities that happened in NUJS during the tenure of Prof. M.P.Singh as VC which is also known to the members of EC and GC.
Prof Singh: A great tenure 30 Nov 2011, 10:23
+1 -0
Prof. Singh's farewell yesterday spoke clearly of what he stood for. With 2-3 days left for exams, the auditorium was packed with students; they knew they just couldn't miss it; a farewell to a man who had done so very much for the NUJS family.

Prof. Singh's humble, soft-spoken, person and a father-like treatment for his colleagues and students has won many a hearts. People respect him as an academic par excellence, an administrator with traits unmatched. The also adore him as a man of caliber, a fatherly figure.

NUJS today easily has the best faculty among all NLUs. Prof. Singh takes away all the credit for ensuring that. He gave the professors the academic freedom complete freedom when it came to offering, structuring and evaluating courses. His towering presence, as a leading constitutional and comparative law scholar in itself, was an incentive to many a great professor.

Gor the students at NUJS, Prof. Singh took lots of pioneering steps to enhance the academic delivery system. Projects, class hours, course evaluation methodology were virtually revolutionized under his tenure.

Moreover, students are given complete freedom to do what their thoughtful minds can conceive of; and the entrepreneurship displayed by NUJS students or the sort of speakers (very very controversial ones, mind you) they get to their college speaks volumes for that value of freedom.

The infrastructure (new gym, auditorium, canteen) and the beautification of the campus shows that he had a 360 degree view as an administrator and did not focus merely on academic reforms. (Though I am sure the lack of space in the girl's hostels is something to be still worried about).

NUJS' tie-ups with a great many foreign universities and a top-notch relationships with leading and foreign recruiters have only been enhanced under prof. Singh's tenure.

But more than these achievements, the students of NUJS will remember prof. Singh as someone who they can look upto as a hero, a mentor, someone they'd want to idolise.

NUJS not only is bidding adieu to a great VC but also a great man; a pioneer in the legal education who stands shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Prof. Madhava Menon and Prof. Ranbir Singh.
Well wisher of NUJS 30 Nov 2011, 18:25
+0 -1
Dear Writer : Prof Singh: A great tenure
Do not make a mistake to place Prof. M.P.Singh on the same platform of Prof. Madhav Menon and Prof. Ranbir Singh. Prof. Menon and Prof, Ranbir Singh worked for the interest of the students and the legally appointed Faculty Members. Prof. Menon has built up NUJS with his hard work and with a vision of National Law School located in Calcutta which is a pride for all the Calcuttans.
Writer on Prof Singh: A great tenure says that in the farewell speech Prof.M.P.Singh spoke clearly of what he stood for. Yes, it is well known to all what he stood for but that was not in the interest of the students and the Faculty members.
Dear Writer on Prof Singh: A great tenure - Try to find it out yourself and the truth will be exposed with facts.

Dear Writer on Prof Singh: A great tenure new gym, auditorium, canteen and the beautification of the campus are also required in every colleges and Universities but such ornamental beautification cannot hide the illegalities that had happened in a NUJS a National Law School during the so called " great tenure" of Prof. M.P.Singh. Do not send wrong messages without knowing the facts and the truth.
Please read my previous comments and find out the truth yourself.