JGLS hires ‘unparalleled’ 104 new teachers, incl 27 NLU LLBs at Rs 20-40L avg pay

JGLS Sonepat bulks up to 9:1 student faculty ratio
JGLS Sonepat bulks up to 9:1 student faculty ratio

JGLS Sonepat has hired 104 faculty members in its law school starting in January 2020 improving its student-faculty ratio from 12:1 to 9:1, hot on the heels of the the grant of Institution of Eminence (IoE) status to it in September.

More than half of the hires - 72 - are made up of the more junior end of the academic ladder with 38 senior research associates and 34 research associates, which would be roughly equivalent to lecturer designations at national law schools .

The next greatest number of hires has come in with 27 joining JGLS at assistant professor rank (more on these designations and remuneration below).

Finally, at the highest levels of seniority are 3 new associate professors and 2 professors (see details of new hires below).

The new hires put the total number of Jindal Global University’s (JGU) faculty members available to teach at its law school at 328, for around 2,900 law students, according to the university’s press release.

“At a university [and law school] level it has already… 9 is to 1,” said JGLS founding vice chancellor Prof Raj Kumar about the student to teacher ratio, noting that this already far exceeded the Bar Council of India (BCI) minimum requirement of a student faculty ratio of 40:1. “We want to hover around 8 to 9 [to 1 ratios], because this is good enough to pursue our research and all,” he added.

Only five faculty members out of its total of now-328 faculty members at Jindal Global University’s law school had left in the last 12 months, noted Kumar. Law school student numbers would not increase in the next academic year, he said.

The hiring spree follows JGLS’ September 2019 hire of 75 new faculty members, of whom 22 had obtained LLBs from NLUs (as well as former vice chancellors (VC) Prof MP Singh, Prof Upendra Baxi, Prof BS Chimni and BB Pande).

Making the latest hires would enable JGLS to “qualitatively improve the entire experience of students: more research, more faculty engagement,” he said. Hiring so many faculty members at one law school was “unparalleled in the history of legal education in India”, Kumar added in a press release, which seems a realistic claim, considering NLSIU Bangalore, for instance, recently advertised for only 13 faculty members for the first time 12 years.

New Profs

Prof Sam Garkawe is joining JGLS as a full professor from Southern Cross University in New South Wales, Australia, where he was an associate professor of law specialising in international and national criminal justice.

Garkawe also holds an LLB from Monash University, LLMs from the University of London and Sydney university, and a BSc from the University of Melbourne. Garkawe is also a California-qualified attorney and Australian barrister and solicitor and had worked in private practice, a legal aid lawyer and

The second professor joining JGLS is retired Supreme Court Justice and National Green Tribunal (NGT) chairman Swatanter Kumar, is joining as a “distinguished jurist professor” rather than a full-time role.

Swatanter Kumar was a practising lawyer from 1971 until 1983, when he was appointed as additional district and sessions judge in the Himachal Pradesh high court, and then resumed practice as an advocate in the Delhi high court until 1994 when he rejoined the bench at the Delhi high court, followed by Punjab & Haryana and the chief justice position at the Bombay high court in 2007. In 2009 he was appointed to the Supreme Court as a judge and on retirement in 2012 until 2017, he was chairman of the NGT.

In 2014, while chairman of NGT, he had filed a defamation case in the Delhi high court against several newspapers and a female lawyer, who had alleged that Kumar had sexually harassed her while she had been an intern. As of April 2019, that case had seen 19 hearings and adjournments, mostly to decide on what to do with the intern’s transfer petition to the Supreme Court.

It is understood that Swatanter Kumar’s position as distinguished jurist professor at JGLS would not be a residential or full-time position.

New associate profs + NLU grads

The three new associate professors joining JGLS are:

  • Prof Dr Saurabh Jain (NLIU Bhopal LLB, LLM from University of Aberdeen, PhD from Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand),

  • Prof Dr Saumya Uma (NLSIU Bangalore LLB, LLM from University of Mumbai and University of Nottingham, and a PhD from NLSIU), and

  • Prof Dr Sandeep Kindo (NLSIU LLB, an LLM from University of Notre Dame in the US, and a JSM from Stanford University and a PhD from University of Wisconsin).

In total 27 of the new 104 new hires, including the above, have LLB degress from Indian national law schools, with five each having undergraduates from NLSIU, NLU Jodhpur and GNLU Gandhinagar:

Faculty with LLBs fromNumber of faculty
NLSIU Bangalore5
NLU Jodhpur5
GNLU Gandhinagar5
RMLNUL Lucknow2
CNLU Patna2
NLU Odisha2
NLIU Bhopal1
WBNUJS Kolkata1
RGNUL Punjab1
NUALS Kochi1
NUSRL Ranchi1
DSNLU Visakhapatnam1
Total27

Full list of all hires further below.

Tiers & pay scales: Around double UGC on average

Research associates and senior research associate positions at JGLS are approximately on par with lecturer positions at NLUs, explained Raj Kumar.

“Research associates for teaching law subjects are usually faculty members with LLM degrees,” added JGU director HR and chief operating officer (COO) Jitu Mishra. “Senior research associate and assistant professor positions are offered to faculty members who have some industry or teaching experience apart from the LLM degree.”

Meanwhile, associate professors and professors would be faculty members with “substantial teaching and research experience or who have distinguished professional experience in the field of law”, according to Mishra.

Salaries of all JGLS faculty members were “competitive”, “more than the UGC pay scales… decided on the basis of experience and qualification of individual faculty members”, said Mishra, with “research benefits comparable to the top international universities along with comprehensive health and accidental insurance coverage, accommodation near the University Campus, staff development allowance, research grants, research rewards for publications and other benefits”.

Raj Kumar added that while individual compensation levels of faculty were confidential, it was “accurate to say that the average cost to university (CTU) of Professors is Rs 40 lakhs per annum, associate professors is Rs 30 lakhs per annum, assistant professors is Rs 20 lakhs per annum,” excluding research and publication benefits.

NLSIU’s recent recruitment advert for professors under University Grants Commisssion (UGC) 7th Pay Commission bands were around Rs 17 lakh annum, around half the average at JGLS.

Associate professors at 13A pay band would receive Rs 15.8 lakh at NLSIU (again less than around half of JGLS’), while the assistant professors at the lowest pay band would be getting Rs 6.9 lakh per year at NLSIU.

Full list of new hires

Name of HireDesignationLLBLLMOther Qualifications
1Prof. Justice Swatanter KumarDistinguished Jurist Professor of Law and Justice Former Chairperson of National Green TribunalPunjab University--
2Prof. Sam GarkaweProfessor of LawMonash UniversityUniversity of London; Sydney UniversityB.Sc. (University of Melbourne)
3Prof. (Dr.) Saurabh JainAssociate ProfessorNLIU, BhopalUniversity of AberdeenPh.D. (Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand)
4Prof. (Dr.) Saumya UmaAssociate ProfessorNLSIU, BangaloreUniversity of Mumbai; University of NottinghamPh.D. (NLSIU, Bangalore)
5Prof. (Dr.) Sandeep KindoAssociate ProfessorNLSIU, BangaloreUniversity of Notre DameJ.S.M. (Stanford University); Ph.D. (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
6Prof. (Dr.) Vinod Kottayil KalidasanAssistant Professor--B.A. (University of Calicut); M.A. (St. Thomas College, Kerala); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
7Prof. (Dr.) Anindita JaiswalAssistant ProfessorNLU, JodhpurNLU, JodhpurPh.D. (University of Edinburgh)
8Prof. (Dr.) Wasiq Abass DarAssistant ProfessorPune UniversitySouth Asian UniversityS.J.D. (Central European University)
9Prof. (Dr.) Aditi SinghAssistant Professor--B.B.A. (University of Lucknow); M.B.A. (University of Lucknow); FPM (IIM Lucknow)
10Prof. Raabia Abuzer ShamsAssistant ProfessorCNLU, PatnaUniversity of Essex-
11Prof. (Dr.) Dhiren BorisaAssistant Professor__B.A. (Mohanlal Sukhadia University); B.Ed. (Mohanlal Sukhadia University); M.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
12Prof. Prashant GuptaAssistant Professor--B.Tech. (Punjab Engineering College); M.A. (Pune University); M.Phil. (University of Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
13Prof. Sagnik DasAssistant ProfessorNLU, JodhpurHarvard University-
14Prof. Kanishka SewakAssistant ProfessorRGNUL, PunjabUniversity of Turin-
15Prof. Akmal Handi AnsariAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeUniversitas Sumatra UtaraUniversitas Sumatra Utara; Queen Mary University of London)-
16Prof. (Dr.) Olayinka Oluwamuyiwa OjoAssistant ProfessorEkiti State UniversityCharles UniversityPh.D. (Ghent University)
17Prof. (Dr.) Ishan AnandAssistant Professor--B.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.A. (Hyderabad University); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
18Prof. (Dr.) Anjana ThampiAssistant Professor--B.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.A. (Hyderabad University); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
19Prof. Nidhi SharmaAssistant ProfessorGuru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, New DelhiNLIU, Bhopal
20Prof. (Dr.) Gunjan SinghAssistant Professor--B.A. (University of Delhi); M.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
21Prof. (Dr.) Mosarrap Hossain KhanAssistant Professor--B.A. (University of Burdwan, West Bengal); M.A. (University of Hyderabad); Ph.D. (New York University)
22Prof. (Dr.) Prabhu AlokeAssistant ProfessorCochin University of Science & TechnologyNLSIU, BangaloreM.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
23Prof. (Dr.) Niyati SharmaAssistant Professor--B.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.A. (University of Delhi); M.Phil. (University of Delhi); D.Phil. (University of Oxford)
24Prof. (Dr.) Lisa ThomasAssistant Professor--B.A. (Mahatma Gandhi University); M.A. (Kerala University); M.Phil. (Pondicherry University); Ph.D. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
25Prof. (Dr.) Manmeet KaurAssistant Professor--B.Com. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.B.A. (Amity University); Ph.D. (FMS, Delhi)
26Prof. (Dr.) Biswanath GuptaAssistant ProfessorTripura UniversityWBNUJS, KolkataPh.D. (IIT Kharagpur)
27Prof. Amit UpadhyayAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeGuru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, New DelhiFreie Universitat, Berlin-
28Prof. Neha MishraAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeUniversity of DelhiNLSIU, BangaloreB.A. (University of Delhi); M.A. (University of Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (NLSIU, Bangalore)
29Prof. AmanAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeNLU, JodhpurOxford University-
30Prof. Radhika ChitkaraAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeNLSIU, BangaloreHarvard University-
31Prof. Dolashree K MysoorAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeUniversity Law College, BangaloreUniversity College London-
32Prof. Divyangana DhankarAssistant Professor of Legal PracticeUniversity of Delhi-J.D. (University of New South Wales)
33Abhimanyu SinghSenior Research AssociateNUSRL, RanchiThe Australian National University
34Devyani MouryaSenior Research Associate--B.Sc. (Holkar Science College, Indore); MHRM (Mohanlal Sukhadia University); FPM candidate (IIM Indore)
35Krittika SinghSenior Research AssociateGNLU, GandhinagarTufts University-
36Savita DahiyaSenior Research Associate--B.Sc. (Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak); M.B.A. (Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak); Ph.D. candidate (IIT Roorkee)
37Arijeet GhoshSenior Research AssociateGNLU, GandhinagarUniversity College London-
38Maxime ChevalierSenior Research AssociateUniversite de RennesStockholm University-
39Santwana DwivedySenior Research AssociateNLU, OdishaCentral European University-
40Gautam MohantySenior Research AssociateNLU, OdishaCentral European University-
41Anurag BhaskarSenior Research AssociateRMLNLU, LucknowHarvard University-
42Divya TripathiSenior Research AssociateB.Com. (University of Lucknow); MHR&OD (University of Delhi); FPM candidate (IIM Lucknow)
43Dharmita PrasadSenior Research AssociateNLU, JodhpurUniversity of Johannesburg-
44Madhav MallyaSenior Research AssociateSymbiosis PuneMcGill University-
45Praggya SuranaSenior Research AssociateNLSIU, BangaloreHarvard University-
46Jadumani MahanandSenior Research AssociateM.A. (University of Hyderabad); M.Phil. (University of Hyderabad); Ph.D. candidate (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
47Bhavneet KaurSenior Research Associate--B.A. (University of Delhi);M.A. (Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai); M.Phil. (University of Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (University of Delhi)
48Ayushi AgarwalSenior Research AssociateNLSIU, BangaloreUniversity of Oxford-
49Sharmin KhodaijiSenior Research Associate--B.A. (University of Delhi); M.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
50Ammar HafeezSenior Research Associate--B.Com. (University of Delhi); M.B.A. (Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (IIT Roorkee)
51Pulkit TalujaSenior Research Associate--B.E. (University of Delhi); M.B.A. (IIM Kashipur); FPM candidate (IIM Calcutta)
52Harsh Vardhan BhatiSenior Research AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityLewis & Clark Law School-
53Nalamala Chandra Bhanu MurthySenior Research Associate--M.A. (University of Hyderabad); M.Phil. (University of Hyderabad); Ph.D. candidate (University of Gottingen, Germany)
54Divya GuptaSenior Research Associate--B.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.A. (University of Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (University of Delhi)
55Josey TomSenior Research Associate--B.A. (Christ University, Bangalore); M.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
56Rashmi GuptaSenior Research AssociateAmity UniversityUniversity of California, Berkeley-
57Sriparna Dutta ChoudhurySenior Research AssociateUniversity of DelhiUniversity of CambridgeB.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi)
58Surendra KumarSenior Research AssociateRMLNLU, LucknowSOAS University of LondonM.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
59Nakul NayakSenior Research AssociateNLU, JodhpurUniversity of Pennsylvania-
60Abhisek SurSenior Research Associate--B.Sc. (Hons.) (University of Calcutta); M.Sc. (University of Calcutta); M.B.A. (ICFAI Business School, Kolkata); FPM candidate (IIM Ranchi)
61Piyush PranjalSenior Research Associate--B.Tech. (B.P. University of Technology); M.B.A. (Gandhi Institute of Technology and Management); FPM candidate (IIM Ranchi)
62Sandrine De HerdtSenior Research AssociateSaint Louis University, BelgiumCatholic University of Louvain, Belgium-
63Aditi SinghalSenior Research Associate--B.A. (Hons.) (University of Delhi); M.A. (University of Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (University of Delhi)
64Aparajitha NarayananSenior Research AssociateILS PuneLeiden University-
65Sahiba MaqboolSenior Research AssociateUniversity of KashmirGeneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights-
66Vaibhav ChadhaSenior Research AssociateUniversity of DelhiQueen Mary University of London)B.Com. (University of Delhi)
67Varsha MohanSenior Research AssociateChrist University, BangaloreTel Aviv University-
68Shivangi SinghSenior Research AssociateGNLU, GandhinagarUniversity College London-
69Balu G NairSenior Research AssociateWBNUJS, KolkataMelbourne Law School-
70Aparna Babu GeorgeSenior Research AssociateNUALS, KochiUniversity of Cambridge-
71Krusha BhattResearch AssociateAuro UniversityUniversity of East Anglia, UK-
72Tanya GoyalResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityZhejiang University, China-
73Medhavi SinghResearch AssociateUniversity of DelhiPennsylvania State University-
74Konina MandalResearch AssociateKIIT Law SchoolUniversity College London-
75Bhavinee SinghResearch AssociateNirma UniversityEmory University School of Law, Atlanta-
76Simran BhinderResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityUniversity of Melbourne-
77Malika Galib ShahResearch AssociateUniversity of KashmirUniversity College London-
78Rohit SarmaResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityCentral European University-
79Asmita SinghResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityHumboldt University of Berlin-
80Esha RanaResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversitySOAS University of London-
81Shilpa Singh JaswantResearch AssociateGNLU, GandhinagarUniversity of Hamburg-
82Abhilasha RamakrishnanResearch AssociateKarnataka State Law UniversityKing’s College London-
83Mayank KatariaResearch AssociateSymbiosis PuneQueen Mary University of London-
84Dhwani MainkarResearch AssociatePravin Gandhi College of Law, MumbaiQueen Mary University of London-
85Kanishk RaiResearch AssociateBharati Vidyapeeth UniversityKing’s College London-
86Abhinav MehrotraResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityUniversity of Leeds-
87Surabhi SharmaResearch AssociateSymbiosis PuneGeneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights-
88Mansi RathourResearch Associate--B.A. (University of Delhi); M.A. (Kurukshetra University); M.A. (Leiden University)
89Anjana RamanathanResearch AssociateDSNLU, VisakhapatnamLeiden University-
90Mohammad AquilResearch Associate--B.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
91Shambhavi ShivaniResearch AssociateCNLU, PatnaTrinity College Dublin-
92Auroshikha DekaResearch AssociateKIIT Law SchoolQueen Mary University of London-
93Ayushi VashishtResearch AssociateArmy Institute of Law, MohaliErasmus University, Rotterdam; University of Hamburg-
94Jigisha BhattacharyaResearch Associate--B.A. (Presidency University, Kolkata); M.A. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); M.Phil. (Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta)
95Malcolm KatrakResearch AssociatePravin Gandhi College of Law, MumbaiErasmus University, Rotterdam; University of Hamburg-
96Samudranil GuptaResearch Associate--B.A. (University of Calcutta); M.A. (University of Calcutta); M.Phil. (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi); Ph.D. candidate (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)
97Phil M RajuResearch AssociateChrist University, BangaloreQueen Mary University of London-
98Aditya Raghu RayeeResearch AssociateBharati Vidyapeeth UniversityQueen Mary University of London-
99Aditya GandotraResearch AssociateUniversity of JammuQueen Mary University of London-
100Anmol DiwanResearch AssociateGuru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, New Delhi)USG School of Law-
101Ashwathy Nair SureshResearch AssociateTNDALU, ChennaiUniversity College London-
102Shreya ShreekantResearch AssociateGNLU, GandhinagarQueen Mary University of London-
103Arunima SarafResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityO.P. Jindal Global University-
104Karanraj Singh BhatiaResearch AssociateO.P. Jindal Global UniversityLondon School of Economics, London-

Comments

Eagle 7 Feb 2020, 10:46
+10 -0
Good that Jindal is recruiting young NLU grads. In comparison, look at the track records of Veer Singh, Ishwar Bhat, Rao, Bimal Patel, Jaiswal, SSS, Dukhpal etc etc. Look at how Sudhir was opposed tooth and nail, and now a lobby is working against Srividhya at NLUD.

In most NLUs, the admin resists hiring alumni because of jealousy and insecurity. They give excuses like absence of UGC NET, lack of seniority, etc. No attention is paid to quality of publications, industry experience, international exposure etc.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 10:48
+5 -3
Kian, many readers are requesting you to get a confirmation of how many alumni are teaching at different NLUs (both as full-time and visiting). We need this to name and shame certain regressive and nepotistic VCs. Please do it.
22 8 Feb 2020, 04:50
+2 -2
'many readers are requesting'
AAP 7 Feb 2020, 10:52
+8 -12
Shame on anti-middle class Modi govt. They gave a private law school IOE status but not NLUs for the middle-class. Even in the budget common man got nothing. This party will soon get a big slap in the Delhi elections.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 10:56
+5 -12
Only 1 NUJS grad and zero NALSAR grads were hired as punishment for students from these colleges writing toxic comments against JGLS on LI and social media.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 16:33
+19 -2
You got one part right. They were indeed hired as punishment.
Inside Story 7 Feb 2020, 11:04
+8 -0
The pay bands are not totally correct. Certain assistant professors get more than associate profs, such as those heading research centres or doing deanships/admin work. Also, there are factors like NLU LLB degrees, prior teaching ex at a good law school, publications etc. Also, social sciences profs get lower scales than law profs. There is also a type of reverse racism where foreigners get high payscales. JGLS needs these people because Eminence status and QS rankings are linked to international faculty.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 11:09
+12 -4
Please note: Majority of "star" JGLS faculty teach soft law subjects like human rights, feminism etc. Not many teach "hard law" subjects.
Jiggles 7 Feb 2020, 14:10
+5 -4
BB Pande's Teaching Advanced Criminal Law
Gudmundur Erikson is teaching International Law.
Plenty of star profs teaching core subjects
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 15:10
+4 -6
[COMMENT REPORTED, ACCURACY DISPUTED]

BB Pandey only visits the university once a month for 3-4 days ever since he's taken charge. How is he offering a full paper? He's there to oversee research, not to teach. Please stop spreading fake news.
JGU 7 Feb 2020, 17:20
+16 -0
[b]This is unfortunate that people who have no information relating to the faculty members at Jindal are making wild assertions and inaccurate statements. Professor B.B. Pande is teaching a full fledged course entitled: [i]"SEMINAR ON ADVANCED CRIMINAL LAW"[/i] at Jindal from this semester. It is a regular course with [b][b][b]60 hours of teaching and will have 4 credits[/b][/b][/b] for the students who compete the course successfully. Professor Pande has given a detailed statement that he is joining Jindal after 6 decades of teaching elsewhere. Let's celebrate the fact that Jindal has recruited the best of minds from India and around the world - all full professors and globally renowned scholars - Upendra Baxi, Shiv Visvanathan, M.P. Singh, B.B. Pande, B.S. Chimni, Ramin Jahanbegloo, Armin Rosencranz, Vesselin Popovski, Eiriksson Gudmundur, Michael Davis, Kenneth Holland, Sam Garkawe and 320 more! Every law school in India and beyond should aspire to emulate Jindal as we will have to think about India as a provider of high quality legal education. Jindal has become a world class law school and we need to accept this with a deeper sense of pride for India![/b]
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 07:26
+3 -0
If only it could actually have done this without fleecing the students. But I guess that's not possible in this country with the government having no desire to spend on quality education. Private players would end up spending more and charging more. Having said that, you seem to be clubbing all Jindal faculty within the same group. Nothing can be further from truth. There are marquee names for sure like the ones that you've mentioned, but the bulk are still freshers without experience or established research credentials. It remains to be seen how they fare, because chances are that they would have to shoulder the bulk of responsibilities at the university.
UGC 7 Feb 2020, 11:19
+2 -0
Here are the conditions for Institution of Eminence:

- lt should preferably be multi-disciplinary and have both teaching and research focus of an exceptionally high qualitY.

- lt should have a good proportion of foreign or foreign qualified faculty

- The faculty student ratio should be not be less than 1:20 at the time of notification issued declaring an lnstitution as an lnstitution of Eminence and should increase over time so as not to be less than 1 :10 after five years of this date

- There should be a transparent merit based selection in admissions, so that the focus remains on getting meritorious students.

- The admission process should be need-blind so that once a student gets admission purely on merit, such a meritorious student should not be turned away for lack of financial ability.

- The lnstitution should have reasonably large owned campus with adequate space for expansion.

- The lnstitution should have teaching and research collaborations with a reasonable number of global universities figuring in the most reputed global rankings.

- The lnstitution should be known for promoting a culture where faculty are encouraged to publish regularly in peer-reviewed journals ... Any papers published in international publications which are included in SCOPUS, Web Science or similar international agencies can be counted.

https://www.ugc.ac.in/pdfnews/2170800_Guidelines-for-Educational-lnstitutions-as-lnstitutions-of-Eminence-2017.pdf
Gag order 7 Feb 2020, 13:23
+16 -0
Swantanter Kumar. Really now.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 17:14
+5 -1
Meanwhile, 50% quota at NLUD, 47.5% at NSLIU, 30% at NUJS and 85% coming up at NALSAR. It's almost as if the govt is hell-bent on JGLS overtaking NLUs.
Snoop 10 Feb 2020, 05:51
+0 -4
And JGLS students sometimes get convicted for rape of college mates .. government to blame ?
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 21:33
+6 -2
BB Pande is indeed teaching a proper course. Go away haters!
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 21:52
+0 -0
The article does not say how many NLU alumni in total teach at JGLS in total. My guess is around 75 existing + 27 new hires = 102.
Guest 7 Feb 2020, 21:54
+0 -1
Why Swatanter Kumar? Controversy aside, he has never been a scholarly judge, like a Ruma Pal or a
Rich man’s Symbi 8 Feb 2020, 01:44
+4 -1
If only hiring this many people could improve the quality of students. Unfortunately it takes years to get the best students. At some point they’ll have to break out of the mould that only those ppl go who don’t get through the Tier 1 or 2 law schools.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 06:35
+15 -18
The student quality at JGLS is terrible. Even if JGLS hires the full faculty of Harvard Law School it will still not reach top, as you need to have good quality students.
JGLS 8 Feb 2020, 19:16
+18 -8
JGLS students have done phenomenal peformance in various Moot Courts at World Level including Jessup, Willem C. Vis (twice), ELSA WTO, HSF-King's London, Oxford Price, FDI, Stetson, Red Cross, DM Harish, NLS Arbitration etc. At Willem C. Vis, only JGLS, NALSAR, NUJS and NLSIU have ever made it to the Final Rounds of the Willem C. Vis Vienna Moot. Moreover, just last week JGLS was Runners-up in Jessup India Rounds, where we beat almost all NLUs, including the likes of NUJS, NLS, NLIU etc., and had an Oralist in Top-2.

As far as Placements are concerned, Khaitan has hired the most from JGLS in 2020 Graduates as compared to all NLUs. Similarly, overall 60+ students from the 2020 Graduating Batch are all placed at leading Tier-1 and Tier-2 Firms, Judicial Clerkships, Big UK Firms, White & Case etc. Compared to NLSIU which started 23 years before JGLS did, JGLS is doing a better job.

As far as Publications and Undergraduate Research Assistantships are concerned, the sheer number of JGLS students publishing and doing RAships beats all NLUs combined by like four times (should you even consider the top-7 NLUs, i.e. NLS, NALSAR, NLIU, NUJS, NLUJ, NLUD and GNLU, it'd remain the same). One Aditya Vora from the 2019 Graduating Batch and four others in the 2020 Batch having 15+ journal publications can even beat the shit out of Ivy League Faculty in National and International Publications.

Should this post (and this comment) to you (potentially a NLU reader) feel terrifying already, we can go on to cite 100 more examples to tell you how JGLS is superior to all NLUs combined. :)

Moreover, most Law Firm, Litigation or Judicial Interns in Delhi, Bombay and Bangalore are from JGLS. Multiply their batch strength to 15 years. That's a figure crossing 10000 students being Salaried Partners, Settled Advocates/AORs and the like across all fields of law in India. They'll have a presence in aborad as well.

Considering your "reservations" in NLS, NLUD, NUJS etc. etc., we know which institution will be wiped out from all rankings soon enough. :p

While this comment is nothing compared to the efforts of the Editors of this post, I hope that this information I put can give a "reality check" to NLUs and others about the "student quality" at JGLS.
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 05:04
+7 -7
Just one thing. Cite the actual numbers instead of making hyperbolic claims. May make your boast actually have substance. If these claims are accurate, why doesn't your university or your student body actually come up with these stats? Nobody can say JGLS is publicity-shy. Some of your words seem rather immature, such as your claim of intern-partner conversions. And when you talk about 60+ day zero placements, that's still around 10% from your batch. All the leading NLUs have better figures. So, your claims of superiority seem rather hollow at this point. Your students may as well turn out to be very good and even surpass others in future, I can't say. But it hasn't happened yet. So maybe reserve the boasts for now. One thing is for certain, given the fees that your university charges (even after the vaunted scholarships, about which no official stats has ever been provided), it is unlikely to beat leading public institutions in terms of merit based student intake anytime soon.
Sceptic 9 Feb 2020, 07:19
+0 -0
Please name the 60+ firms. Thanks.
14.1 10 Feb 2020, 11:22
+0 -0
are bhai marketing waale aa gaye, but i agree you guys have done a good job
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 06:44
+3 -1
Prof Pande is teaching full time. I condemn the fake news against JGLS by outsiders who have no knowledge. I have reported the comment and hope LI will take it down as per journalistic ethics.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 09:56
+1 -2
He is not teaching at Jindal full time. In order to do that, you need to reside on campus. He does not. He might be offering one special seminar course though. You have no concept of what teaching full time at a university means.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 15:38
+2 -2
What a dumb troll! Most JGLS profs commute from Delhi.
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 05:08
+1 -0
And Pande himself has said to several people that he does so once a month for about a week. So either you are ignorant of the actual events, or calling him a liar.
Doubt. 8 Feb 2020, 12:58
+2 -0
What exactly does a "Senior Research Associate" do? That doesn't sound like an assistant professor. Sounds like a research scholar at some centre attached to JGLS.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 14:57
+1 -0
I think Jindal only gives the AP position to people with PhDs or prominent CVs? The rest are made SRAs at entry level. They often do teach paper together with other senior people, but not by themselves.
lol 9 Feb 2020, 02:47
+1 -0
How on earth can you boost your faculty numbers with them then? Nothing wrong in having RAs, but this PR blitz by JGLS makes it seem like all these NLU alumni are actual teachers.
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 05:06
+4 -0
You said it yourself. It's PR. Technically, most of them do teach and help reduce the workload for APs and higher ups, I'm guessing.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 15:37
+3 -0
Instead of attacking JGLS, why don't you people question NLU VCs for not hiring enough alumni, or mistreating them? Some of the VCs who did this have now left after protests, but is the new guard any better? Why does no NLU have more than 10 alumni teaching?
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 02:17
+2 -0
Ten would have been great, there are hardly ten in any. Ten would have meant about 1/3 of total faculty. JGLS has that ratio I think.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 15:41
+16 -0
NLU nibba while in law school: JGLS profs are shit.
NLU nibba after US LLM: I wanna be a JGLS prof.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 15:43
+1 -4
The ranking of JGLS in terms of student preference and placements is currently 5 (after NLSU, NALSAR, NLUD, NUJS).
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 16:44
+4 -0
Placement-wise, certainly not. NLUJ and GNLU still have better placements proportion-wise compared to JGLS.
Guest 8 Feb 2020, 15:48
+0 -0
NEWS ALERT: Livelaw has released domicile figures for all NLUs.

[b]NALSAR- 24/120 (20%), NLIU Bhopal- 51/ 122 (41%), NUJS Kolkata- 38/127 (30%), HNLU Raipur- 80/ 160 (50%), GNLU Gujarat- 39/180 (22%), RGNLU Punjab- 18/ 196 (9%), MNLU Mumbai- 69/120 (57.55)

NLSIU Bangalore and NLU Jodhpur do not have any domicile reservations.

[/b]



https://www.livelaw.in/columns/domicile-reservations-in-national-law-universities-152475
Nlssss 8 Feb 2020, 17:37
+1 -9
How is law school professor hiring even worthy of making news???!?
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 07:18
+1 -0
Kian, why does LI not cover recruitments any more?
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 14:56
+0 -0
The NLU Bhopal VC has given an interview on the faculty crisis at NLUs.

https://www.barandbench.com/interviews/the-national-eligibility-test-has-not-brought-out-the-best-of-teachers-nliu-bhopal-vice-chancellor-prof-v-vijayakumar-on-the-faculty-crunch-at-law-schools-part-i
Darkseid 9 Feb 2020, 16:43
+4 -0
What he doesn't mention is that there is absolutely nothing in the UGC rules that prevents the NLU administration from hiring good faculty (with research experience/publications/industry experience and good teaching skills gauged through demo classes) who do not have UGC NET qualification yet. They could be given contracts of 2-3 years at a time and given the same salary that permanent faculty get or as close as doesn't make a difference. If they got such qualification during this period, they could be made permanent or their contracts could be extended subsequently. Apart from certain forward-thinking VCs like MP Singh, nobody opted for this route. I doubt Vijayakumar himself is going to do that at NLIU Bhopal either. So crying a river about this is of no use. NLUs weren't meant to stay confined within the limits of archaic UGC norms, but to go beyond those.
Op 16 Feb 2020, 10:49
+0 -0
Now Prof. (Dr.) M.P. Singh and B.S. Chimni are at Jindal.
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 16:36
+0 -0
I cannot understand why NLIU VC Vijaykumar had made the statement below. It is incorrect and ill-informed and hampers hiring of NLU alumni as faculty. Plenty of profs have taught at NLUs without UGC NET and the government has now made a rule exempting NET for graduates of top 500 ranked QS universities.

[quote] The National Eligibility Test (NET) conducted by the UGC has not brought out the best of teachers. Many of those who failed NET are better than the ones who passed the test. When you attend the interviews, you can visibly see that some candidates who have not completed NET are brilliant. Unfortunately, we cannot hire them as we are bound to follow these regulations.
[/quote]
https://www.barandbench.com/interviews/the-national-eligibility-test-has-not-brought-out-the-best-of-teachers-nliu-bhopal-vice-chancellor-prof-v-vijayakumar-on-the-faculty-crunch-at-law-schools-part-i
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 17:11
+1 -0
The exemption isn't for graduates from those universities.
Sage 9 Feb 2020, 18:22
+1 -1
Here is the deal with UGC NET:

1) Two categories of colleges do not care about it:

a) Private (JGLS, Bennett etc)
b) Institutions of National Importance with special autonomy (also JGLS, plus also IIT law school)

2) Elsewhere, you a need a PhD from a top 500 QS university to get an exemption (just an LLM won't do).

3) But this rule is not written in stone: plenty of VCs have waived it for people with just an LLM. A well known case is Shamnad Basheer, who got appointed as a full professor when he only had a master's.

4) Unfortunately, many NLU VCs use UGC NET as an excuse to not hire NLU alumni. The NLU alumni do not want to give NET as it is pointless and meant for those from low-quality law schools. Those alumni coming from practice or from abroad even look down it. If you need to take 6 months to prepare for an exam, any NLU alum would rather appear for UPSC.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 01:08
+4 -1
Corrections: IIT Law School doesn't require UGC NET because they do not recruit faculty without PhD. NET doesn't really require any preparation. It's more a matter of luck. It's not factually accurate that NLU alumni don't have NET qualification in general. Plenty of them do. They may still dislike the exam, but they have cleared it, just in case. The QS thing isn't really necessary, people with PhD from almost anywhere don't need NET in India. What MP Singh did with Shamnad can't be done today without attracting litigation in the process.
Fake News Buster 10 Feb 2020, 07:15
+0 -2
Rubbish! There are permanent tenured faculty at IIT with just LLM and without UGC NET. CVs here.

http://www.iitkgp.ac.in/cv/ip-shreya

http://www.iitkgp.ac.in/department/IP/faculty/ip-arindam
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 09:05
+2 -0
@FNB: Check the latest recruitment notification yourself.
https://erp.iitkgp.ac.in/FacultyCareer/advtFacultyRecruitment.jsp
All applicants must have PhD. Assistant, associate and professors.
Guest 9 Feb 2020, 20:11
+1 -0
The University Grants Commission (UGC) has notified UGC (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and other Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education) Regulations, 2018, in the Gazette of India on 18.07.2018. As per these regulations, the National Eligibility Test (NET) or an accredited test (State Level Eligibility Test SLET/SET) shall remain the minimum eligibility for appointment of Assistant Professor and equivalent positions wherever provided in these Regulations. The Regulation also provides that the candidates who have been awarded a Ph.D. Degree in accordance with UGC Regulations shall be exempted from the requirement of the minimum eligibility condition of NET/SLET/SET for recruitment and appointment of Assistant Professor or any equivalent position in any University, College or Institution subject to the conditions laid down in the UGC Regulations.

However, the regulation also provides that Ph.D. Degree shall be a mandatory qualification for direct recruitment to the post of Assistant Professor in Universities with effect from 01.07.2021. Further, a person with Ph.D degree from a foreign university/institution with a ranking among top 500 in the World University Ranking (at any time) by any one of the following: (i) Quacquarelli Symonds (QS) (ii) the Times Higher Education (THE) or (iii) the Academic Ranking of World Universities (ARWU) of the Shanghai Jiao Tong University (Shanghai) is also eligible for direct recruitment as Assistant Professor in universities and colleges. The aforesaid regulations are available on UGC website at https://www.ugc.ac.in/pdfnews/4033931_UGC-Regulation_min_Qualification_Jul2018.pdf.

https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=181704
RGNUL SALUTES 9 Feb 2020, 21:41
+2 -1
I FEEL SO BAD BEING FROM RGNUL. JGLS IS THE BEST MAN GOTTA ADMIT IT. Aint no war of ego
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 07:07
+1 -1
IIT law school indeed hires profs with just LLM and without NET. They have also been given permanent tenured positions (examples are Prof Shreya Matilal and Prof Arindam Basu). This is because IIT is not regulated by UGC in the first place. Amazed at how confidently people give BS here.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 08:27
+4 -0
The person who made that PhD comment isn't entirely wrong. Matilal was given her job long back in 2008 when the school was just starting. Basu has his PhD now. In the last two rounds of recruitments that IIT KGP law school has held, PhD was indeed an essential criterion. Someone I know couldn't apply for that very reason. So the policy might have changed.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 09:04
+1 -0
27.1 is right. Here's the last recruitment notification for IIT KGP law school. You can check for yourself, all are required to have PhD.
https://erp.iitkgp.ac.in/FacultyCareer/advtFacultyRecruitment.jsp
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 11:04
+0 -0
Matilal is a he, not she. One or two other profs (now left) have also taught at the KGP law school without a PhD as full faculty. But now the policy has changed because after 2021 no university can hire without a PhD (as per the new UGC rule). In fact, this is possible the reason why JGLS did a mass hiring: to evade the rule.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 07:17
+1 -7
Placement wise JGLS is comparable to tier 1 NLUs and currently behind only NLSIU, NALSAR, NUJS and NLUD. JGLS is clearly ahead of NLUJ, GNLU and NLIU. Amazed at the wrong comments by haters here.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 08:21
+2 -0
Cite the stats instead of making wild claims. When has JGLS managed to place more than 10% of its huge batch yet?
Admirer 10 Feb 2020, 10:16
+5 -5
For jgls, it's all money and no play. Many of their students admit the burden of high fees. Many of their students have interned under me, and most of them were average barring selected few. Money does not make an institution. Jgls is mostly about marketing and if it so good why doesn't any student trade-off NLS for jgls ? It is good for faculty as they get paid well at jgls and only faculty is not enough.
LOL 10 Feb 2020, 11:01
+5 -1
Interned under you? LMAO. You are obviously a student posing as a practitioner. Feku.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 10:54
+2 -6
JGLS has the best faculty. Deal with it and STFU.
Guest 12 Feb 2020, 17:08
+1 -0
Hardly, if you are indicative of the students whom they produce.
Guest 10 Feb 2020, 11:06
+0 -0
In 2015, Bar & Bench had done a study on which NLU has the best faculty. Can anyone share it please?

https://www.barandbench.com/columns/law-school-insights-faculty-special-who-has-best-faculty
Guest 11 Feb 2020, 04:55
+3 -0
That study was in no way a reflection of the quality of teaching, nor research as such. They had considered four parameters, the number of professors, the number of PhD holders, the student-teacher ratio and the gender ratio. The last two are important indicators, but not of quality of teaching. The first two mean almost nothing in the Indian context. Here people would become professors after spending a certain number of years regardless of their quality. Similarly, while good PhD research is certainly happening, a lot of spurious research, especially among the senior faculty (back when there was no plagiarism check), also exist.
Guest 12 Feb 2020, 08:34
+1 -2
It is my request to Kian and LI to please supply some objective data to solve these perpetual fights over rankings. Students and PR squads of certain college keep writing misinformation here and misguiding law aspirants. For example, a total lie has been spread that a certain NLU has the best faculty, maximum NLU alumni teaching etc. The truth is that most of these profs are either on leave or just give a few lectures. Another claim made is that X NLU or Y NLU does the most research, but not a single publication is cited. Then of course we have recruitment, where many NLUs will give fake data to NIRF.

I hope you are reading this Kian. Please take it seriously as thousands of gullible law aspirants get misguided.
Guest 12 Feb 2020, 13:35
+3 -0
If they are gullible enough to get their information from anon LI comments, then they deserve their plight.
Guest 13 Feb 2020, 19:05
+0 -1
MNLU Mumbai has just advertised for 4 faculty positions, but it is seeking UGC NET. This is totally wrong as those with PhDs are exempt and those with just LLM can still be hired as other NLUs have done so.

https://www.livelaw.in/job-updates/assistant-professor-law-vacancy-at-maharashtra-national-law-university-mumbai-152706
Guest 14 Feb 2020, 04:58
+2 -0
Please use the brain cells as you have for a change. The essential qualification is LL.M. plus UGC NET. Everyone knows those with PhD are exempted from NET as per UGC norms and they obviously do not fall under this category. If anyone has PhD, that's a HIGHER qualification and not essential. As for people with only LLM without UGC NET, I challenge you to show a single instance wherein such a faculty member has been appointed as a permanent assistant professor in any NLU in the past five years. Those did happen way back earlier at some places, but these days, all NLUs abide by the UGC norms at least on pen and paper, or else risk litigation, RTI and even student dissent (strangely).
Anand P Mishra JGLS 18 Feb 2020, 17:28
+10 -3
Thanks Legally India and Kian Ganz for this story! With approx 3000 law students and 328 full-time faculty members, JGLS becomes the largest residential law school in India and probably whole of Asia!

Our faculty size is now the largest in India and almost double the size of other leading law schools of Asia like Peking or Tsinghua University in China, National University of Singapore or SMU Law School in Singapore, Hong Kong University Law Faculty, City University of Hong Kong, or NTU or NHTU in Taiwan! I strongly believe now Jindal Global Law School should be compared with law schools internationally!

You have counted NLU graduates in our faculty, but your reporter has missed to see that NINE of JGLS graduates (maximum from any Indian law school) joining as junior faculty members, many of whom I believe, will become committed legal academicians of the future!

Lastly I invite you and your readers to read about the pursuit of scholarship and research by JGLS graduates in my following post, which speaks volumes about our student quality, many of them have actually become Inlaks, British Chevening and Commonwealth scholars in recent past! Cheers.

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/anandpmishra_jgu-jgls-activity-6635201422969401344---2-
Guest 19 Feb 2020, 14:20
+4 -1
Your Linkedin post does not seem to provide any concrete number of your graduates who have won these scholarships in course of their pursuit of higher education, as you. Can you provide such numbers for clarification purposes? How many students from your first graduating batch onward have won acclaimed scholarships like Rhodes, Chevening, Inlaks, Commonwealth, Fulbright, DAAD etc.? Just the numbers would do, individual identity or even years of graduation aren't needed. Assuming there have been around 6 graduating batches of approximately 3500-3800 graduates overall since 2014 till date. Another concrete number as to how many moots of national or international repute have been won by JGLS during this period. And a third one about how many jobs in tier one Indian law firms or foreign law firms have been secured during Day Zero in all these years. Just the numbers would do, for transparency's sake.
Guest 19 Feb 2020, 14:59
+0 -0
Oooh! *grabs popcorn*
Guest 19 Feb 2020, 15:15
+3 -0
Since comparisons are being sought to be made with foreign universities, then maybe a number of research projects with impact that have emerged from the law school too in the past decade.
Alum 20 Feb 2020, 04:24
+6 -2
To those accusing JGLS of lying, I am an alum from the older batches. From the first 2 or 3 batches, one of my friends got the Commonwealth scholar at Cambridge (Kush Makkar), another friend got the Chevening scholarship at Queen Mary (Shireen Moti), another friend got the Cornelia Sorabji scholar at Oxford (Naavya Jannu, now doing DPhil) and at least three were hired by White & Case (Theresa Puthunama, Nisha Raman, Tulika Gupta). Others can no doubt add to the list.

I also suspect that the anti-JGLS comments are actually not from the top 4 NLU students/grads, but those from lower ranked NLUs + traditional colleges + other private law schools. This category has been the most badly hit by JGLS, as their placements and LLM offers have dried up. The top 4 remain mostly stable. Also, a lot of faculty at JGLS are from NLSIU/NALSAR/NUJS, while NLUD regularly invites JGLS profs for events. Furthermore, Madhava Menon has visited JGLS many times. Also, Sudhir Krishnaswamy and VC Rajkumar are good friends (same Rhodes batch) and Krishnaswamy has also visited JGLS numerous times. We also have two former NUJS VCs (Chimni/Singh) and one former NUJS Ford Chair (Baxi). Lastly, some of the NLSIU/NALSAR/NUJS alumni who taught at JGLS were among the most popular with older batch students.
Guest 20 Feb 2020, 04:48
+1 -2
Nobody accused anybody of lying. Why are you getting so touchy when asked to provide stats to back up self-professed claims? To the extent of going ad hominem against the people who are asking those questions? That just seems like colossal insecurity issues. Also, why is it that everytime someone asks about student achievements of JGLS, the response always seems to be made up of mostly parading their faculty strength? You do know those two are different metrics, right? A JGLS official has claimed the university to be at par with foreign universities. He's been asked to provide stats on related parameters. That's a normal enough reaction. Even what you said doesn't really provide even a fraction of stats and especially if one has to compare the law school with foreign universities, then even what you provided isn't exactly adequate considering your huge batch strength. That's a fact. If you are hell-bent on manufacturing a confrontation with certain NLUs (not sure why, since your official already seems to indicate that you are far beyond national institutions now and competing with foreign ones), then do the research to provide the stats about how many students every year are dropping out from NLUJ, GNLU, etc. to join JGLS. The answer would speak for itself.