JGLS scoops 3 former vice chancellors as profs: Baxi, MP Singh, Chimni + BB Pande to boost research, teaching, PhDs

Professors Baxi, MP Singh, BB Pande, Chimni join Jindal (left to right)
Professors Baxi, MP Singh, BB Pande, Chimni join Jindal (left to right)

JGLS Sonepat has hired Prof Upendra Baxi, Prof BS Chimni, Prof Mahendra Pal Singh, and Prof BB Pande as professors who will teach and conduct research at the law school full-time.

Three have been former vice chancellors (VCs) of universities: Baxi was formerly Delhi University’s vice chancellor, Singh was former VC of NUJS Kolkata from 2006 until 2011 and Chimni was Singh’s predecessor VC at NUJS from 2004 to 2006.

Pande was former professor-in-charge at Delhi University’s Campus Law Centre (CLC).

They will join JGLS and its parent Jindal Global University (JGU) as:

  • Baxi: Research Professor of Law, Distinguished Scholar in Public Law & Jurisprudence,
  • Chimni, Distinguished Professor of International Law, Member Law School Doctoral Committee,
  • Pande: Research Professor of Law, Distinguished Scholar in Criminal Law & Criminal Justice, and
  • Singh: Research Professor of Law, Distinguished Scholar in Public Law & Comparative Law, Director, Centre for Comparative Law & Chairman, Law School Doctoral Committee.

Founding VC of OP Jindal Global University and JGLS dean Prof C Raj Kumar told us that all four would be teaching as well as doing research: “For example, Prof Baxi and Pande will teach one course each; Profs MP Singh and Chimni will teach courses, but will also take academic administrative responsibilities.”

Singh would chair JGLS’ doctoral committee, according to Kumar: “We have a doctoral programme but one of main challenges [in Indian legal education…] is poorly developed doctoral programmes.”

“You’ll find the top crop of students are largely in regular undergraduate programmes, then you get the next round of LLM and by time you come to PhD, there is a lot of mediocrity deeply embedded in doctoral programmes,” he added. “If you look around the world the doc is feeder into academia.”

“One of our goals is that we have a really strong doctoral programme,” he explained, noting that there was no one better than Singh - who has had both civil law and common law experience - to chair, and Chimni to be a member of the committee.

The four won’t be resident on the Sonepat campus but would travel to campus from Delhi, though they may stay in Sonepat during their teaching duties, said Kumar.

When asked about whether any of the former VCs would be taking over the running of the law school from him, he said: “They have been my mentors but they’re coming here for a different purpose, a calling that has brought them for non-administration.

“Their main goal is to inspire young people, both young people and students, and research for their publications.”

Statements

In a press statement, Kumar said: “They are outstanding professors of law and have mentored generations of lawyers, law professors, judges and many other individuals who have shaped the law and justice systems in India and around the world for nearly half a century. It is a proud moment for JGU that they have decided to spend the important years of their life and their future dedicating to the cause of higher education and legal education mentoring the students and faculty of JGU.”

Baxi, who is also Professor Emeritus at the University of Warwick, with an undergraduate from Rajkot (Gujarat University), and LLM degrees from University of Bombay and University of California at Berkeley (from which he also obtained a Doctorate in Juristic Sciences), said in a statement:

It seems like yesterday that we launched the Jindal Global Law School. But it was ten years ago when I said that a new era in legal education in India was beginning and it will be known as Naveen–Raj epoch. That prophecy is happily proved correct. Since that event, eight other faculties have been created, many centres of high quality research have been established, many laurels won by colleagues and the class, and a different glass ceiling has been broken by JGU being recognized as an ‘institution of eminence’ and achieved many a breakthroughs in the world education ranking systems. For the rapid expansion to a full-blooded university, its incredible faculty and students, its Indian and overseas placements, and global ranking, the one person primarily responsible is Professor C. Raj Kumar. Far from just being an island of excellence, he has given a new meaning, in such a short time, to educational process and change in India. It is difficult to believe that such a miracle has happened, but it has. No amount of the stress and strain of routinization can now interrupt this incredible and worldwide charisma that JGU has acquired as its symbolic capital. For a decade now, I have been a proud witness of this miracle and among those who helped along its academic growth.

Singh, who has an LLD from the University of Lucknow, LLMs from Columbia Law School the University of Lucknow and BA LLB. from Agra University, was also formerly dean at the Faculty of Law of the University of Delhi. He said:

The essence and processes of law and legal systems around the globe are immensely interesting and challenging requiring lifetime commitment even to grasp a tiny element of it. Having engaged in this exercise in different institutions in the East and the West let it have its final destination at O.P. Jindal Global University and Jindal Global Law School, founded and led by one of our most illustrious former student Professor Dr. Raj Kumar. I am indeed looking forward to working with many outstanding faculty members from India and around the world who have made Jindal their home. I am looking forward to be part of JGU in the next few months. Hope it will be my final and best destination in my long journey in academics.

Pande, who has a BSc, LLB and LLM from the University of Lucknow, said:

Law is a complex as well as a dynamic phenomenon. Its complexity lies primarily in the multiple factors that go into its making, interpretation and enforcement, all of which are influenced by the ideology, thinking and attitudes of those responsible for the law in action. The dynamic element of the law in a product of everyday construction and de-construction of the law in the court-rooms and in the class-rooms, as well as police stations and prisons. The dynamism of law in-turn influenced by the perceptions of the one who is exposed to the law- the teacher or the learner. As a teacher of Criminal Laws my perceptions about the law have undergone significant changes over the period of the six decades. I deem it a privilege that I will have the opportunity of pursue some of these enquiries in my forthcoming assignment with the Jindal Global University early next year. It has been possible because of the dynamic Vice Chancellor Professor (Dr.) C. Raj Kumar’s vision to expose the young and inquisitive students of Jindal Global Law School to the generational understanding and changing perceptive of the ‘power’ of the law, coming straight from the experiences of the one who has faced the change himself. Hope this inter-face provides new insights to the understanding of the theory and action relating to the rule of the law in the coming new India.

Chimni had retired in 2017 as Professor of International Law, School of International Studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University.

Comments

Old Boy 6 Sept 2019, 08:22
+18 -2
Wow this is big!
No! 6 Sept 2019, 09:49
+7 -5
Profs. M P Singh, Baxi and Pande are moving from NLUD! Prof. Singh teaches full time, the other two are distinguished professors. That's a big loss for NLUD at one go. Are they all leaving because Ranbir Singh is leaving?
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 09:52
+15 -20
I acknowledge that JGLS faculty could be best in India, but the ultimate worth of a law school are the students. Please compare placements, LLM scholarship stats and moots with tier 1 NLUs.
Kashmir 6 Sept 2019, 10:36
+25 -5
Random topics discuss karne hai to Kashmir or 370 pe bhi charcha kar lete hai?
Kid Twist 6 Sept 2019, 11:14
+9 -17
Yes, the constitutional law, criminal law and international law will come in handy while drafting share purchase agreement.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 10:17
+14 -1
No, but they will come in handy when the owner of the company flees to London and faces extradition proceedings.

[img]https://i.imgflip.com/qo3fu.jpg[/img]
Alias 6 Sept 2019, 13:41
+13 -3
Yes, please let's compare stuff that we know we're good at thanks to our highly selective entrance exam (which guarantees that we get only the brightest students so that we dont have to do much), our extensive alumni network who have been brainwashed into believing that life beyond the NLUs dont exist and our 25 year head start.

Faculty? Who cares?
Research? Who cares?
A 10 year old law school that takes in (allegedly) mediocre students and still gets them to compete with the exalted NLUs? Pssh! Not even RR could conjure that story!
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 14:47
+15 -1
Let's make this clear. You want good faculty with stellar CV to teach you instead of staying at the industry, you need to compensate them accordingly. You want faculty to do research, you have to pay them to do that and reduce or eliminate their teaching workload. To do all that, you need more resources than any NLU has at present. Either the government needs to pay up, or the students need to bear the cost. For example, if JGLS hikes its fees, no student would demand that the university gets research projects to pay for its expenses. Do it at an NLU and all the students would be up in arms. Now it may be inequitable to have to pay through the roof to have access to quality education. Then elect a government that would foot the bill. If you can't do either, then sadly you are out of luck. Nowhere in this world quality education is available cheaply or without government subsidy. NLUs may still have a few good teachers who continue to stay there out of idealism or for the sake of better student quality. It can't be expected of everyone.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 12:58
+10 -0
It is a mistake to think that people move to jindal or other private universities only for money. There are many other reasons why some of the new private universities are attracting people who have spent their whole lives in public universities. Apart from better pay, they provide more research support, support for attending conferences, non-interference, etc. They also have collaborations with universities across the world (meaningful not sham collaborations) which provide new research opportunities and intellectual growth. Some of these places like Jindal, Ashoka, Azim Premji also offer administrative support so that the work load of the faculty is reduced and they can focus more on academics. Can NLUs match these things? Possibly, but requires vision which most VCs don't have. And money, of course. If you look at the success story of NLUD, that was only because some of these things were offered to faculty. NLUD is also and example of another reason why professors tend to flock to well-performing universities - if you have good people you will attract more good people because then you will have a bunch of serious academics to engage with and learn from. By the same token, if a place is no longer able to provide that kind of atmosphere conducive to research (again NLUD seems to be a case in point and also NUJS under Bhatt) then people will leave, and as people leave, more people will leave. Don't begrudge people they career choices. See what your institution can do to attract quality faculty.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 03:53
+1 -0
Well said.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 13:00
+3 -0
Jindal is on a big expansion spree. Expect many more big moves from NLUs in the coming year.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 09:55
+12 -18
It is unfortunate that such socialist-minded professors who people look up to for inspiration have joined a private law school catering to the rich 1% of India. All these professors were at DU and three of them were at NUJS (two as VC, one as Ford Chair professor). Should they not try to help DU and NUJS in difficult times, as well as guide new NLUs?
Arre 6 Sept 2019, 10:13
+21 -4
Why can't they do that from Jindal? Also don't see DU or NUJS asking for their help!
Unwanted guest 6 Sept 2019, 13:43
+14 -3
Yes, because once you've worked at DU and NUJS, you can ONLY work at DU or NUJS.

Oh wait, didnt we abolish bonded labour sometime back?
Alumni 15 Sept 2019, 03:57
+2 -0
Rich 1%?
I thought one needed to pay tax or something if they were so rich. Guess, I'm just not taxable :/
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 09:57
+13 -1
The legends have joined Jindal. 2 of the 4 have taught me, brilliant teachers they are.
Florentino Perez 6 Sept 2019, 10:33
+23 -3
Jindal is building its own galacticos squad
NALSARite 6 Sept 2019, 10:45
+25 -2
Their vice chancellor took JGU becoming the Harvard of India too seriously. Kudos, I see people hating on the law school for no reason. What you guys have done in 10 years is unprecedented I guess in the world
troll in the dungeons 6 Sept 2019, 10:50
+12 -13
Is JGLS now a retirement home?
Lion 6 Sept 2019, 15:56
+0 -0
So what?
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 22:36
+7 -2
Dear troll, two of them are younger than your beloved PM Modi.
NUJS 6 Sept 2019, 11:33
+3 -1
Prof Singh is bestest
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 11:45
+7 -0
JGLS poached some star NUJS profs and alumni and now this. Insult to injury!
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 11:47
+4 -7
Post Sudhir, NLSIU is likely to have the best faculty of all law schools. Many NLU alumni will ditch JGLS, NLUD and NALSAR.
Lion 6 Sept 2019, 15:57
+9 -0
Proof of pudding is in eating. Lets see what happens
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 12:04
+4 -1
Holy F !! Baxi, Chimni and MPS at Jindal of all places!!
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 12:13
+12 -9
This is very unfair. NLUs are getting second-class treatment from the govt and this college for elites gets a special status and such good faculty. The reason they cannot join an NLU is because NLUs have restrictions in designating such emeritus/part-time people as professors and paying them.

I am sorry but this is very depressing, because JGLS students do not deserve such professors, while NLU students who are much smarter are stuck with bad faculty.
Tywin 6 Sept 2019, 14:32
+7 -3
[img]https://roadtowinning.files.wordpress.com/2017/08/game-of-thrones-quotes-4.jpg[/img]
nope 7 Sept 2019, 17:56
+5 -0
what restrictions? except for the restricted intellect that these NLU VCs (and most senior professors) have? They dont want good people to join because they are jealous and insecure. Even of 1000 crores is given to each NLU they will remain in a ditch - because the current leadership in almost all of these places dont even deserve to be professors in the first place. they are only good at sucking up to judges and running a circus of coteries and hence they will use all that money to hire even more mediocre people and perpetuate their clout.

good that theres a place like jindal and lets hope more of them come up - they provide competent people with a good academic space. The NLUs meanwhile can continue with their march to mediocrity.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 12:23
+7 -1
[img]https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/AvengersEndgame-2.jpg[/img]
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 12:37
+2 -5
Today is a said day is the history of Indian legal education. Middle-class students at NLUs suffer while a law school for Ambani/Birla types has got IoE status. And the legends of legal education have turned their backs on the colleges they once mentored.
nonsense 7 Sept 2019, 17:58
+3 -0
well professor chimni retired almost a year back and Dr. Baxi and Prof. Panda was not with any institutions. Why the hell did a single NLU not get in touch with them /request them to be at thier place???
Entitlement much?! 6 Sept 2019, 13:03
+26 -2
What kind of rubbish comments are these! These professors have spent their entire lives in public universities. Now after retirement (and that too, many years after retirement) they have decided to move to a private university. What gives anyone the right to question their choice? Maybe we should be asking why they left public academics and what attracted them to Jindal, instead of expecting them, or anyone else, to sacrifice themselves for public universities that might not space for them in the first place. The level of entitlement of these nlu kids!
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 12:14
+11 -0
Exactly what I was thinking! It is one thing for NLU kids to say that they have the best faculty (whether they actually have it is another thing). It is quite another to say that not only do they deserve the best faculty, but that anyone who doesn't want to teach at an NLU is somehow blameworthy! Who the hell do you think you are? At least these people are in academia. How many of you will follow that path rather than run for corporate jobs yourselves? And if your only argument for why profs such as these should teach at an NLU is that it is a public university, then traditional universities have a better claim to these resources. They admit people from even more diverse backgrounds, have much bigger student bodies (and therefore can impact a larger part of society) and most students don't run to corporate jobs! So all the criticism here towards professors who choose to teach at a private university can be made against professors who choose to teach at a NLU. Don't be so full of yourselves you all. Just because you cracked one exam, the world does not owe you jackshit!
Populist 6 Sept 2019, 16:03
+6 -11
Robber baron money hiring Marxists to teach kids of the professional super rich. Modern world.
Wuh! 6 Sept 2019, 18:14
+7 -3
As opposed to corrupt, colonial, exploitative state money hiring Marxists to teach kids of the mostly professional super rich (and legitimising the state to boot)? Lazy analysis. If they had gone to an ivy league private university which are all also built on robber baron money, would you have said the same thing?!
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 20:14
+1 -3
The government is pampering JGLS and allowing it to attract such star faculty, but NLUs continue to be underfunded with bad faculty. This issue must be raised in Parliament through opposition MPs. The government is just favouring the moneyed and elite.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 20:15
+2 -8
Big deal. NLSIU will soon match this with Sudhir, Mrinal, Aparna and Sid Chauhan, with a half a dozen alumni professors at Oxford and Ivy Leagues teaching as visiting professors.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 12:26
+2 -3
I hear that Sudhir is already in advanced discussions with faculty from other law schools including JGLS. Add to the list of people who are likely to be moving - Arun Tiruvendagum, Anup Surendernath, Yogesh Pai, Daniel Mathew, Saurabh Bhattacharjee, Prabhash Ranjan. Plus some of Sudhir's former students from Azim Premji.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 13:42
+3 -0
Stop making up random stuff and spreading fake news! At least three of the people you've named here haven't got any such proposal nor are interested to move away from their current positions.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 20:17
+6 -3
The root of the problem is the cut-price cost of NLUs education and the refusal of kanjoos students to pay more. You may dhaba prices you will also get dhaba quality teachers. You pay Taj prices you will get Taj quality teachers.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 20:32
+0 -0
Interesting Twitter fight on this happening, started by securities lawyer and former IIM prof Sandeep Parekh.

https://twitter.com/SandeepParekh/status/1169960925991817216
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 20:44
+2 -0
Kian, when will you do a report on the state of faculty at NLUs? You can simply call the student body presidents and get the updated list of professors and their CVs.
Guest 6 Sept 2019, 22:45
+9 -0
[img]https://i.imgflip.com/39wbbg.jpg[/img]
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 00:32
+4 -5
Am I dreaming? Internationally renowned professors and leftists like Baxi and Chimni joining a luxury law school for pampered kids ?? And Baxi praising it so highly?? Why did they not join NLUs? It makes me lose my faith in humanity.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 00:55
+7 -0
Let us face the truth. They did not join an NLU as the state of faculty and admin at NLUs is really pathetic. There is also a lot of dirty politics in NLUs, where people are hostile both to such renowned senior profs and younger profs graduating from NLUs. In contrast, the Jindal VC is their former student with a Rhodes scholar pedigree and publications in reputed journals. He also gives red carpet to them, and also has a policy of hiring NLU grads as teachers (including many former students of Chimni, Baxi and Singh from NUJS). They thus feel comfortable with him.
Hail JGLS - NLU Tier 2 7 Sept 2019, 08:29
+4 -2
Guys this is a BIG change. It does not look far fledged that smart students who have the money and maybe not (on scholarship) will head towards sonepat all guns blazing. NLUs will remain the tier 2 place to go - smart students - but not JGLS smart and/or not that resourceful - NLU becoming the feeding ground for labourers to the amarchands and khaitans - top notch research and the real social lawyers coming up from JGLS.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 09:39
+4 -2
Name one graduate who has done anything in those lines yet. There are at least five batches out already. And quit harping on those scholarships. Care to give any data about exactly how many scholarships are available every year as opposed to the total batch strength and what sort of fees even those getting various scholarships end up having to pay? Even the JGLS admin is tight lipped about it, other than vaguely saying all deserving students get it. Because they know the availability and coverage are far less than what they want to portray. Social engineers graduating from JGLS after staying in AC hostels with swimming pools for five years and shelling out over 20 lakhs in fees! What a joke! Given your disparaging remarks about law firms, one would assume JGLS students don't try to intern there or get a job there at all? As if! Student achievements speak for a university ultimately, nothing else. I'm not saying JGLS can't eventually do what the NLUs have already done in terms of that. Maybe they can. But this fanfare of them surpassing everyone else every year is premature and ridiculous. They have offered thrice the salary, some academics have shifted there. Good for them. Let their students get the benefit of the teaching of these people and do something to set them apart. Then brag about it. Not before.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 09:45
+3 -0
Oh, God! That last line cracked me up. Enough for a whole week's worth of jokes, if not more. Good one, pal!
G 7 Sept 2019, 09:05
+4 -1
It's like VS Achyutanandan, Budhdeb Bhattacharya, Manik Sarkar and Prakash Karat joining the BJP Govt.
Guest 7 Sept 2019, 09:58
+0 -0
LOL.
Bhale Sultani 7 Sept 2019, 11:41
+2 -2
Excellent strategy for marketing and boosting research, if they are still doing it. But theoretical law is only one part of the legal practice. Legal practice is so much more than academics
MPS_BB pupil 7 Sept 2019, 13:43
+3 -3
MPS and BB Pande - great for the students at JGLS. Other two cannot say....Baxi's articles in legal journals -- a pain to read and not too invigorating either.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 04:00
+1 -0
Sudhir, Mrinal and Aparna from NLUD were approached by JGLS many years ago. They declined. Maybe they could join now.

Interestingly, in terms of NLU alumni at JGLS, #1 is actually NUJS.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 08:46
+2 -2
I am fairly certain NUJS alumni right now rank the foremost among all NLU alumni in terms of numbers when it comes to teaching law in India at least. I would have thought more NLSIU alumni would actually have joined Indian legal academia eventually, but most of them prefer to go abroad it seems. That too, most of the NLSIU alumni I know who have joined academia seem to be from their earlier batches. Rarely have I come across any of the young ones graduating after 2008-09. Before the trolling starts, I hasten to clarify that this was just a factual observation and not meant to be a positive/negative reflection on any of these groups. There are at least 30 NUJS alumni (LLB alumni I mean) teaching at various levels in India at present I think. The more, the merrier, I'd say. NLU alumni should seriously consider giving back to the country through research and teaching too. Only then can the state of legal education in the country be improved upon.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 10:15
+1 -2
Totally rubbish and fake comment. NLSIU alumni teach abroad because they get PhD scholarships and job offers at top universities, while NUJS people are stuck in India. Also, in terms of numbers there are a lot more NLSIU alumni in academics. Even in India, there are more NLSIU alumni, typically foreign returned. As for NUJS around 10 or 12 are teaching in Jindal and maybe 4 or 5 in NUJS itself. The figure of 30 is in your dreams.

Quantity aside there is the issue of quality. There is no way to know about quality of instruction apart from ex students, but objective metrics are publications, research grants, fellowships etc.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 12:30
+1 -1
Bro, name them, no? Which university has all these foreign returned multiple NLSIU alumni teaching in droves? I'm sure all of us would be happy to know. I bet you can't name over ten and those people would also be fairly senior like Rahul, Sudhir, Mrinal, Shamnad etc. As for your point about very few NUJS alumni teaching here, at NUJS itself, there are ten including permanent and contractual faculty. At least another ten in Jindal, more if you count the non-teaching research folks. That's 20 in two institutions. Even at NALSAR and NLUJ there are such people. Your lack of ground level knowledge is as pathetic as your mindset. Many of these people have got foreign degrees too, they have just chosen to come back to India and work here. Your sick mentality can dub that as being a loser, but given that you have actually taught in this country and not outside, maybe the joke is really on you.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 12:32
+1 -0
@30.1.1: Don't get a stroke, buddy. Facts hurt, we know. You are wrong in estimating the number of NLSIU grads in Indian academia at least.
NUJS alumnus 8 Sept 2019, 13:23
+0 -0
Just to set the record straight here, I personally know exactly 27 NUJS alumni currently teaching or doing research in an educational institution in India at present. I also know exactly 5 who are doing so abroad. The entire list covers graduates from the 2005 batch to the 2017 batch (undergraduate degrees). The total number is likely to be higher, since I obviously do not keep track of all the alumni. I have less than zero desire to engage about useless and unproductive debates or childish measuring contests about these people vis-a-vis NLSIU alumni doing similar work.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 04:07
+1 -0
The current set of NUJS students have repeatedly shown that old timers who helped build the institution are persona non grata. Former profs like MPS/Chimni/Baxi are never invited, Menon/Shamnad/Dipankar Gupta are not commemorated, and alumni are sneered at (treatment of Lawctopus, guest lecturers and permanent faculty).

Now these same people are compiling why MPS/Chimni/Baxi joined JGLS!! Did you ever bother to invite them even once? Be humble.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 05:34
+1 -0
Err...where did you see NUJS students complaining about why these people have joined JGLS?
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 04:14
+3 -1
Rumours are swirling that JGLS is trying to poach 4 star profs from NLUD, 1 from NALSAR and 1 from NUJS (in total 3 are NLSIU alumni and 3 are from NALSAR).
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 05:36
+1 -1
Maybe you should go and have a Swirly icecream. Better use of time than spreading baseless rumours.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 06:27
+1 -0
There are so many rumours flying around about possible faculty movement. As public employees, it is incumbent upon these faculty to clarify whether they are moving or in talks to move. Otherwise, the uncertainty affects the mental peace of students and the image of the universities involved. If Kian won't do this story, the student bodies of these universities should seek this response and set the rumours at rest.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 07:30
+0 -1
Nice trolling!
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 08:00
+0 -0
Jindal has just hired former NUJS faculty Tony George. http://www.jgls.edu.in/dr-tony-george/
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 09:46
+0 -0
I don't think he'd ever taught at NUJS. He did his MPhil from there as per his profile.
Guest 8 Sept 2019, 12:45
+1 -0
I dare LI to do a placement ranking comparing NLUs with JGLS.
Cut the crap 8 Sept 2019, 23:21
+2 -0
It is time the nonsense spread by non-NLSIU students regarding faculty (especially NLUD and NUJS) is laid to rest. I can give a 20,000 word rebuttal but I am giving a shorter summary.

1. First of all start with the VC, i.e. the leader of the faculty. People a Rhodes Scholar pedigree with top publications and work experience at good universities (in India and abroad) cannot be compared with certain others. We all have huge respect for Professor Menon, Chimni and MP Singh as academicians, while Prof Ranbir Singh built up NALSAR and NLUD with great networking and admin skill. But what about the successors of the first three at NUJS and rumoured successor of the fourth at NLUD?

2. When we say NLU qualified faculty, we need to distinguish between BALLB and LLM/PhD. We know the former is much better. Just see white the Jindal VC says in this article.

3. There also needs to be a distinction between faculty who have studied at tier 1, tier 2 and tier 3 NLUs. There is a big difference.

4. Instead of fighting with fake facts, please visit the website of NLSIU versus others and compare who is teaching. I cannot understand why this simple thing cannot be done.

5. Regarding permanent vs visiting professors, there needs to be a distinction. Some visiting professors teach every week or teach short credit courses. They should not be discarded from being counted as faculty. But giving one lecture every 3 years does not make you a visiting professor.

6. Similarly permanent professors on lien for long periods should not count.

7. Publications are a very important measure because they are proof that a professor is constantly updating his/her knowledge and looking into new issues. There is no doubt that publications in oversea journals/books are of better quality, but some high quality Indian ones should be considered, e.g. Socio Legal Review, IJLT, JILI, EPW and NUJS Law Review.