Jindal U outsources student housing to Goldmans for Rs 900 cr cheque to help with IoE compliance, expanding campus from 80 to 300 acres

PE-backed GHS to run student hostels (picture via JGU website)
PE-backed GHS to run student hostels (picture via JGU website)

OP Jindal Global University (JGU), the parent organisation of its largest (law) college JGLS Sonepat, has entered into a sophisticated outsourcing deal with Goldman Sachs-owned student housing and services company Good Host Spaces (GHS), as first reported by Mint on 10 June (hat-tip to several of our commenters who alerted us to this somewhat old but nevertheless interesting piece of news).

The deal will give JGU around Rs 900 crores in cash with which to expand, while GHS will “manage and operate the non-academic services such as student housing, dining services and laundry facility for the benefit of the students on campus”, according to JGU chief financial officer (CFO) Arun Kumar Jain.

The deal only covers existing student housing and does not include any “future student housing to be built on JGU campus”, said Jain.

Jain explained more about the deal and he explained: “This is in tune with the current global practices by many universities in USA, UK, Europe and Australia for the purpose of efficient management of non-academic services.

“In India also currently some universities have entered into such arrangements as JGU.”

The deal would also be a “resource mobilization process in order to strengthen the financial governance of the University in the form of acquisition of land, construction of new buildings and overall expansion of the campus”, said Jain.

“This will also support JGU to fulfil its plans and commitments to expand schools and programmes pursuant to the Letter of Intent received from the Ministry of HRD, Government of India, recognizing JGU as an Institution of Eminence (IOE) in August 2019.”

Balanced profit motives?

IoE and greater ambitions aside, GHS, being a business owned by one of the world’s largest private equity funds, did not enter into the agreement as an act of charity but presumably as something it can generate a healthy profit from.

So had JGU secured any assurances or terms in the deal so that charges or service levels of accommodation, mess or laundry, for instance, will not increase excessively in price and above historical levels to students?

“JGU has its own policies relating to fee increases and this agreement is in line with our policies, which is very much keeping in mind factors relating to affordability, accessibility, and inclusion, which are duly communicated to all students of JGU at the time of admission,” explained Jain.

The change in day-to-day functioning would not be overly drastic though: accommodation, dining and laundry and related so-called “non-academic services” had always been outsourced to external agencies and independent contractors by JGU, according to Jain. “They will henceforth, be managed by Good Host Services.”

According to JGU’s website, Sodexo is currently running its catering function while several other mall-style restaurant chains have also set up shop in a food court area.

In terms of who exactly will own the JGLS land and real estate, Jain said that the “terms of the contract are subject to NDA”.

“However, it is useful to mention that the resources are being used by JGU to purchase over 200 acres of additional land for the expansion of the university,” he added. “This will augment the campus capacity from our existing land of 80 acres to nearly 300 acres in the near future.

“This has been done with a view to fulfilling the requirements of the ‘Institute of Eminence’ (IoE) process. There is a requirement under the IoE to establish an IoE Endowment Fund and that has also been created through these resources, which is part of the compliances under the IoE.”

The move follows JGLS also aggressively pushing into other areas, aided and abetted by the IoE tag, such as offering entirely online LLM degrees for at least 100 students.

Due disclosure: JGLS is an advertiser on Legally India.

Comments

LOL 22 Jun 2020, 16:09
+3 -13
On the one hand, Jindal pretends to be a leading university. On the other hand, it does trashy things like making GS run hostels.
Tired of Sonipat 22 Jun 2020, 16:27
+2 -12
Dear Professor Raj and Mr Naveen Jindal,

We request you not to buy adjacent land in Sonipat but rather a building in central Delhi where classes can be held on 10 days every month. This can allow students in NCR area (who are the majority) to stay at home more often, while students from other cities will have easier access to shopping and eating out. Alternatively, maybe the campus can be shifted to Delhi entirely for 4th and 5th years, so we can also do internships? And if the law requires you to stay in Haryana, then why not Gurgaon?
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 19:33
+13 -5
Give these suggestions during one of those umpteen webinars. Why here?
vocal for local 25 Jun 2020, 14:14
+3 -3
Doesn't Sonipat have a district&sessions court and lawyers chambers? Why must you run to Delhi for everything? Make some useful contribution to the place that hosts you.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 16:33
+21 -5
Modi govt must answer why NLUs are not being given any special status while a school for the wealthy gets such pampering. Mukesh Ambani's Jio University got IOE status without even a building. Time to bring down this government of crony capitalists.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 16:36
+10 -2
Very disturbing news. There is no way Goldmans can recoup 900 crores without increasing hostel fees even further. What was the need for this deal? Why does a law school need to buy so much land?
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:54
+1 -0
It can if JGLS admin was already overcharging to begin with.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 16:39
+7 -3
[quote]In terms of who exactly will own the JGLS land and real estate, Jain said that the “terms of the contract are subject to NDA”.
[/quote]

Sorry, but RTI overrides NDA and you are subject to RTI as JGLS was created by a statute. We want the full facts. No one will pay 900 crores for laundry and mess service only.
Patrakar 22 Jun 2020, 16:52
+1 -5
Let me tell you the real story behind this. In March 2020, Indian Express reported that IOE was wrongly granted to the private universities, as they equated the personal wealth of the owner with the endowment of the university. The newspaper reported that JGLS claimed to be worth Rs 3,000 crore, but that was the net worth of Naveen Jindal, not JGLS. Same thing was done by Jio University and Shiv Nadar University. The most dishonest was KIIT, which added up the net worth of thousands of members of its society and claimed to be worth Rs 10,000 crore!! So, imagine if you own are a member of the Arya Samaj and the organisation starts a college adding your personal net worth to the university endowment fund!!

Thus, all these IOEs have to increase the size of their endowment and this is one way of doing it. This is easy for JGLS, Jio and Shiv Nadar, but certainly not for KIIT. The matter of KIIT should be raised in Parliament and KIIT should be stripped of IOE status.

https://indianexpress.com/article/education/institutions-of-eminence-kalinga-institute-of-industrial-technology-kiit-odisha-vellore-institute-of-technology-vit-tamil-nadu-6296407/
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 19:07
+3 -3
A 'Letter of Intent' for granting the IoE status was issued to seven private universities in second round - Amrita Vidyapeetham and Vellore Institute of Technology in Tamil Nadu, Odhisha's Kalinga Institute of Industrial Technology, Jamia Hamdard University in Delhi, Satya Bharti Foundation''s Bharti Instiute in Mohali, JGU in Haryana and SNU in UP. Marketing by these Universities put aside, they have not been granted IOE status and their final inspection is pending. UGC has till now only forwarded the recommendation, hence the scramble by JGU and I believe the rest will follow in the same direction.

https://jgu.edu.in/jgu-recommended-by-ugc-for-institution-of-eminence-tag/

https://mhrd.gov.in/sites/upload_files/mhrd/files/PR_IoEs.pdf

https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2020/jun/05/private-institutes-with-eminence-tag-to-be-inspected-committee-to-improve-international-rankings-on-2152760.html
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 23:27
+4 -1
Absolute nonsense 6.1. Only the greenfield colleges (by Ambani and Airtel) have the letter of intent, rest all have the status.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 09:12
+3 -3
I hope you read the official notification and not news bits.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 17:23
+16 -6
If NLSIU had 900 crores, it could truly become the Harvard of the East.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 19:32
+18 -0
Sudhir would have found it difficult to patrol the whole campus everyday in that case. Keeping his eyes peeled for any effort to undermine his authority and dilute the number one position.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 20:09
+1 -0
Ha ha!
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 17:24
+2 -5
Arey golmaal hai bhai sab golmaal hai!
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 17:33
+6 -0
Campus size rankings:

1. IIT KGP: 2,100 acres
2. JGLS: 300 acres
3. NLU Ranchi: 63 acres
4. NALSAR: 55 acres
6. GNLU: 55 acres
7. NLUJ: 55 acres
8. RGNLU: 50 acres
9. RMLNLU: 42 acres
10. NLIY Bhopal: 40 acres
11. NLSIU: 23 acres
12. NLUD: 12 acres
13. NUJS: 5 acres
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 19:30
+8 -0
The number of programmes being offered should also be a factor. Along with location. You can't get the size of land in Mumbai that you can in KGP for example. Unless you are Mukesh Bhai.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 20:13
+3 -0
NLUD and NUJS are small because of location. In the case of NUJS, it's in an area that is very good (and the campus will soon be 8 acres, not 5).
Guest-2 23 Jun 2020, 07:58
+4 -2
Weird excuse for NLUD since it's in the middle of nowhere (Dwarka) with empty land all around it where kids play cricket. Doesn't even work as an excuse since it's across the road from a University that's around 10 times bigger than it.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:53
+2 -0
Depends on how much the government wants to shell out.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:52
+6 -0
Apparently, Menon had been offered 5 acres for NUJS at Salt Lake, or 50 acres in Kalyani, back then a remote location of Bengal. He chose the former, and as a student, I am glad he did.
Bijnes 23 Jun 2020, 11:46
+0 -2
NUJS was established in 1999. IIIT Kalyani was established in 2014. Going by the current trend by 2028, IIIT Kalyani would be way ahead of NUJS. It is not just about the location. PPP model works pretty well, and central funding is way way better than state funding. Location has very limited say in the overall scheme of things.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 13:53
+4 -1
If only the government at the centre realised that their funding is so much better and provided that readily! Maybe you'll form part of the government by 2028 and nationalise all the NLUs and open the Treasury. We live in hope.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 20:07
+4 -13
It's not fair that the rich law schools get richer and the poor law schools get poorer! Goldman should be taxed at 40% for this transaction and the money should be distributed to NLUs.
Okay 23 Jun 2020, 07:58
+7 -0
Great plan - since JGLS is funding the NLU why not also make the NLU accountable to JGLS admin? Anything else you'd like to add on to demean the community further?
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:51
+0 -2
Goldman would be funding you mean.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 20:14
+4 -0
900 crores is an obscene amount of money.
Caution 22 Jun 2020, 20:20
+3 -1
We need full transparency from the JGLS admin on how this money will be spent. It cannot be diverted to Naveen Jindal's personal wealth or to the university management's salaries. It must be spent on improving existing infrastructure and scholarships. It is already worrying that this news was not disclosed until now.
Guest 22 Jun 2020, 20:22
+4 -5
Enough is enough! Stop favouring private colleges and give INI status to all NLUs!!
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 00:04
+6 -1
According to sources, the expansion will happen on the eastern side, eventually leading to a merger with the land where Jindal Global City is located. This is a gated community being developed by Jindal Steel, were professors and staff currently stay (map and pics below).

[img]https://newprojects.99acres.com/projects/jindal_realty/jindal_global_city/maps/1i9dzsgg.jpg[/img]
[img]https://property.magicbricks.com/microsite/premium-ms/jindal-realty-sonepat-global-city/images/ele-1.jpg[/img]
[img]https://property.magicbricks.com/microsite/premium-ms/jindal-realty-sonepat-global-city/images/ele-2.jpg[/img]
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:50
+2 -5
Jindal PR at work. You can just hand over the pictures to Kian, who would do the needful. Help a fellow businessman out. Why all this subterfuge?
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 05:22
+7 -11
NLSIU deserves this money, not JGLS.
Right 23 Jun 2020, 07:59
+8 -0
You're right. NLSIU should outsource its hostel to Goldman Sachs too, and make sure students can't afford it anymore. Great plan
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:49
+1 -1
Nagarbhavi municipality ftw!
. 24 Jun 2020, 02:16
+5 -0
Yeah man, you're absolutely right. NLSIU deserves JGU's money, I'll ask Raj to buy NLSIU as well.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 07:07
+3 -1
Best of luck with RTI. First, the PIO and FAA will through Section 8 at you. Not to forget contact tracing and other intimidation tactics. If somehow you get some "third party" to front your RTI, the Jindu guys have friends in SIC and PH HC (just look at the way both these "hallowed" institutions have helped PJ cement himself in RGNUL). And do you really see something different happening at SC? If nothing else there is docket power to keep the matter pending indefinitely...till the time is right for divergent interests to converge for profit - needn't always be pecuniary.

900 crores will be recovered from increased hostel fees etc. When a univ is perceived to host mostly "rich kids" and soon NRIs/PIOs and foreign students who will need to pay even higher fees, why shouldn't GS invest and Jindu recover sunk costs? That was always the plan. Nothing "evil" in it.

Also a word on student loans. Yes, there are many who may have put a lot on the line. But it was a conscious choice. Loans were issued because it could be serviced. There is collateral attached if things go south. There is of course pressure on the student (and by extension the guarantor) to ensure that "performance" continues so that scheduled loan repayments take place. The loan was taken out to study in a place which is expected to better career opportunities. Sure there is PR spin etc. Then again caveat emptor, your own "performance", social capital, network/connections. Nothing vastly different from what one would do at a NLU
Lookatallthebile 23 Jun 2020, 07:12
+15 -2
Wow! Just look at all the bile (read: envy) being spewed at JGLS. There's nothing wrong with a university entering into arrangements which may positively impact the overall experience of its students. The cheap-mindedness of some of the comments here (e.g., the suggestion to tax the transaction at 40% and distribute the proceeds to the NLUs - not even sure if this is serious, or satire) are ridiculous. Class envy much?

For the record, JGLS does offer significant fee waivers for folks who kill it in the LSAT-India (and who may not otherwise be able to afford to study there, js)

Bottomline is: while the average student at JGLS may not be of the same intellectual calibre (by far) as someone from a top NLU, the reality is: smart students would stand to benefit far more from being in Jindal than in most NLUs given that she will be in a good position to make full use of the infrastructure - academic and non-academic, provided by JGLS. And I say this as a graduate of a top NLU.

While purely from the standpoint of graduation outcomes (measured in terms of placement) and other academic achievements of students (and not faculty - which most NLUs don't have, the reptiles teaching there being unworthy of being called faculty for the most part), JGLS isn't anywhere close to being a top college at least as of now (notwithstanding the QS rankings), it's going about improving its position in the market very proactively. Credit, where due, must be given.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 08:48
+2 -2
"May positively impact the overall experience" being the key word. Not that I approve of the hatred. It is a private institution, not a public one. Therefore, it can and will take decisions based on profit motive. People currently studying there or who plan to study there know that very well.
Bijnes 23 Jun 2020, 10:14
+4 -0
It is simple maths
JGU currently charges 2.4 lakh for non-academic services per student per annum
JGU current strength is 5,000 students
Total Revenue per annum = 2.4 lakh * 5,000 = 120 Crore
JGU current vendor was Sodexo which operates at 6% profit margin
Let's say GS is able to optimize it to 10% (not an easy task but still), Net profit per annum = 12 Cr
Clearly, the model doesn't work so either fees will increase, or facilities will decrease, or student strength will increase. Most probably, it will be a combination of all 3. Let's see how this plays out.

For it to be a sound investment, GS needs to make 90Cr just to break even (Recoup cost of capital).
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 17:55
+0 -0
You missed out a fourth factor: staff and faculty salaries will decrease.
Bijnes 24 Jun 2020, 05:50
+2 -0
No, that won't get impacted. JGU tutiton fee is separate from non academic fee and is a considerable sum (varies from course to course).
Obviously, JGU won't share that pot with GS so staff and faculty salary won't get impacted. It might decrease for the contract staff which is doing housekeeping but then they are already at sort of minimum wage.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 10:20
+7 -3
Let's be blunt. The comments here are by those resentful of wealth and privilege.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 10:57
+4 -4
Nope. Just exploitation.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 10:29
+6 -3
Those hating on JGLS, I hope you realise that campus expansion, QS rank etc is the ammo that the college is building up to debut at NIRF at 1. When that happens, you people better find a shelter to hide your faces.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 10:56
+5 -1
Didn't know you need a stadium and swimming pool inside campus to get NIFT rank one. Those NLSIU kids aren't getting any of these!
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 14:27
+0 -0
They, sports facilities/infrastructure, do play a part.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 15:24
+1 -0
After a point, it is just excess.
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 18:14
+2 -1
JGLS has committed suicide through this deal. Here is why:

If Goldman invested 900 crores, then they will want to earn back 900 crore + a profit of 100 crores in 10 years = 1,000 crores in 10 years.

This is how they can do it:

1. JGLS increases capacity to 6,000 students, though more non-law programmes. Thus, decline in student quality + overcrowding of campus,
2. They each pay 3 lakhs a year as facilities fee, which goes to Goldman.
3. Goldman earns 180 crores a year, out of which 80 crores will be spent on expenditure, meaning a profit of 100 crores a year. Thus, decline in quality of facilities.
4. In the meantime, to keep fees to current levels, JGLS lowers academic fee by cutting salaries for low-level faculty + non-law faculty + low-level admin staff. JGLS also starts online programmes to earn revenue and asks faculty to teach there. Thus, a dip in faculty productivity and student satisfaction, especially in non-law programmes.
Whistleblower 24 Jun 2020, 02:18
+0 -1
They're building a med school to milk the money out of students.
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 06:14
+1 -0
Not true. While a med school is the best way to earn cash, the JGLS VC has repeatedly said that the other schools will continue to be humanities and social science schools that supplement JGLS, no science schools.
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 06:24
+0 -1
Wouldn't a dairy farm have been better suited for that purpose?
Guest 23 Jun 2020, 20:42
+2 -0
I think GS will make money by having three grades of hostel rooms (deluxe suite, standard single, twin sharing) and charge different rates for each. In fact, most colleges abroad have a system where you pay according to the type of room you stay in. Some Jindal parents can easily pay 6 lakhs a year for a deluxe suite.
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 02:15
+0 -0
https://www.telegraphindia.com/india/iim-ahmedabad-launches-endowment-fund/cid/1783227?ref=india_india-page
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 06:23
+1 -0
This is a perfect comment to give a "Toh kya karun? Naachun?" react to. Kian, please arrange for such reacts too, no? Only like and object are so boring!
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 02:33
+0 -0
Irrespective of who said this https://www.indy100.com/article/people-are-using-fake-george-orwell-quotes-to-lecture-the-bbc-on-journalism--ZkEiZqtC7Z, can we please have fewer fluff pieces and more scoops that reveals the sordid state of governance across NLUs. This is not a problem affecting a narrow band of NLUs or a big swathe of TLCs. It is a systemic issue. Sustained reporting may cause someone to sit up somewhere.

Kian, you used to do it previously. What changed?
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 06:40
+13 -4
Why do people hate JGLS so much? Is it just jealousy against the wealthy? If yes, then the parents of JGLS students worked damn hard to earn their money. Many JGLS parents are CEOs of top companies who cracked JEE/CAT and graduated from IITs and IIMs, or senior doctors who cracked medical tests, or Senior Advocates who worked very hard to get where they are. It's not their fault if some could not achieve the same success and afford JGLS for their children. Go to North Korea if you want a society where people cannot earn well and give their children the fruits of that.

Also, JGLS does give scholarships and you can always take a loan and pay back.
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 15:34
+1 -3
Which fruit did you get today? Be careful, because it may attract fruit-flies and bats. And we all know these days what may happen from bats.
Son of Man 24 Jun 2020, 16:30
+5 -2
You need to realise this is the LegallyIndia comments section. :p Most of the people down here commenting wouldn't have been able to afford JGLS in any era and would've had mediocre law school lives in one of the NLUs before law even became an attractive career option. Their biggest achievement (in general) would have been to bag a law firm job that will may finally pay enough for their kids to afford coming to JGLS or the like. So their only source of excitement in their life is to come here and criticise other rising law schools.
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 06:45
+1 -1
You guys should watch this video.

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHs9_3Jvljg[/youtube]
Guest 24 Jun 2020, 22:03
+3 -2
Once again Shashi Tharoor has tweeted today congratulating JGLS for cracking some QS young universities ranking. I cannot understand why he promotes a school for the wealthy 1% all the time but ignores NLUs. Same for MP Singh, Baxi and Chimni: saying big words about social justice but teaching at a capitalist law school instead of serving NLUs. I have lost all respect for these so-called intellectuals.
Guest889 27 Jun 2020, 13:40
+4 -0
Truly unfortunate. You must question your own beliefs when you are hired by Big Law :)