Just what J&K needs right now: Another NLU!

Jammu and Kashmir Governor Satya Pal Malik on Tuesday approved a bill to establish a National Law University in the state, PTI reported, quoting an official spokesperson. — Scroll

The proposal owes its origin to the resolution moved by the ‘’All India Law Ministers Conference’’ in mid-nineties, resolving to set up a law school in each state modelled on the National Law School University for improving the quality of professional legal education, he said. — Indiatoday

Great news.

First of all, a law school approved by a governor under President’s Rule, in a state that is currently effectively operating under martial law since the revocation of Article 370, will no doubt make for some interesting field case studies for first years.

Also cause for celebration: this will be at least the 24th (correct us if we’re wrong) national law school to mushroom as state governments have fallen over each other to plant an NLU flag on their turf.

Though it’s worth remembering that the vast majority of NLUs see little to no support from state governments and have few employment or academic prospects to offer students, as in-part evidenced by a raft of protests.

The latest NLU that has become recently operational, seems to be NLU Sonepat in Haryana (also known as the Dr BR Ambedkar National Law University, or DBRANLU Sonepat), which has apparently taken admissions for the 2019-20 academic year and commenced classes on 7 August 2019.

Comments

Sarky 2 Oct 2019, 11:13
+0 -3
I fully support this decision and would like to propose the names of Prof [...] and Prof [...] as the founding VC and Registrar respectively of this NLU. One is a certified expert in interpretation of statutes, while the other is a socially conscious feminist and liberal scholar. A perfect combination for the state during this period of legal and social transition.

If there is also a plan to start an NLU in the new UT of Ladakh, I would like to propose the names of Prof [...] and Prof [...] and VC and Registrar respectively. One is an expert in environment law, which is a very important subject for Ladakh during this period of climate change. Another likes students to cover themselves, which is perfect considering the weather in Ladakh.
Jiowala 11 Oct 2019, 21:12
+0 -0
Wow... Great names... Bhai ek nlu apne ghar me bhi khol do.. Wahan ke vc khud ban jana aur Registrar apne frnd ko bana lena
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 11:15
+3 -0
Interesting that Haryana chose Sonipat as the location for their NLU, instead of Gurgaon. Any connection with JGLS? Is JGLS loaning faculty there?
Guest2 3 Oct 2019, 03:31
+3 -0
Nope. NLU Sonipat can't afford em.
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 11:23
+8 -0
The remaining states without an NLU are:

1. Arunachal
2. Goa
3. Manipur
4. Meghalaya
5. Mizoram
6. Nagaland
7. Sikkim (proposal announced)
8 Tripura
9. Uttarkhand (proposal announced)
woahhh 2 Oct 2019, 12:50
+4 -0
What do you mean, "apparently started classes"? Doesn't NLU Sonepat take through CLAT?
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 13:24
+1 -0
They haven't officially joined CLAT yet, but they have used CLAT score for this year's admission I believe.
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 13:33
+1 -7
Yes, it is bad reporting by LI. They know nothing about NLU Sonepat so they wrote some nonsense . It has full NLU status and is very much a part of CLAT. The Haryana govt has assured full support and top 10 NLU rank by 2025. Here is the website http://dbranlu.ac.in/home/
Good Luck 2 Oct 2019, 14:18
+4 -2
Cheers to that. Part of election spiel? I prefer things here and now. And the website says a lot. Get the drift, eh?
Gurugram 2 Oct 2019, 14:14
+3 -1
Yes, NLU Sonepat is using CLAT. I believe it has the Governor as Chancellor or Visitor. NLU Haryana is actually sited fairly close to JGU and other private universities. Will be very interesting to see how it thrives or survives with an IoE next door.

Depending on local political exigencies, WB will likely have another NLU in North Bengal, irrespective of green or saffron. That's definite. There is a toss-up whether one or two more NLUs should come up. Someone has convinced CM "if you build, they will come" approach is a good way to garner votes and also distribute favours through large construction etc tenders. Also increasing gross enrollment ratio needs to be upped. Hence the frenzy to open universities. Output quality et al be damned.

And let's not forget individual and/or collective interests (often petty couched in professional) of the state HC judges.
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 14:37
+4 -0
What's this obsession with WB and law colleges down there that people have to bring those up in every post here?!
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 15:00
+5 -0
NLU Sonipat campus is under construction. Here are photos from the website of CBIX (real estate company making the project). The design looks sensible to me. Lots of storeys and designed like an office building to maximise space, instead of wasteful courtyards, foundations, pillars etc.

[img]http://projects.cbix.in/uploads/677135790-1333469402/thumbnail/ml/66d0b0af-e689-4816-9412-0e750bf17871.png[/img]

[img]http://projects.cbix.in/uploads/677135790-1333469402/thumbnail/ml/d6917ce2-1c95-487a-967e-a9b49c9b2bfd.png[/img]

[img]http://projects.cbix.in/uploads/677135790-1333469402/thumbnail/ml/26c02939-0f3e-4d76-8e05-83459c656c64.png[/img]

http://projects.cbix.in/projects/dr-b-r-ambedkar-national-law-university-575
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 15:04
+3 -0
There is a controversy raging over whether the NLU will be in Jammu or Kashmir. Jammu is obviously safer, but there will be claims of bias if it is not in Kashmir. The new IIM and IIT have both been given to Jammu, while Kashmir only has an NIT (in Srinagar).
Guest 2 Oct 2019, 15:06
+3 -0
Bar & Bench reported NLU Uttarakhand foundation stone laid, so J&K will be #24. Sikkim will be #25. After that, possibly Goa.

https://barandbench.com/come-in-no-23-foundation-stone-laid-for-nlu-uttarakhand/
kianganz 3 Oct 2019, 04:09
+1 -0
21 on are listed on the CLAT website as part of the consortium, which excludes NLU Delhi and NLU Sonepat, making 23, and J&K would be 24 by that count. However, if Uttarakhand is taking admissions (which seems unlikely), then J&K could be 25th. But it's quite hard counting NLUs as there are probably quite a few that have been sanctioned on paper, haven't got off the ground, or have started construction but not yet admissions or are in differing stages of existence / publicity.
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 04:51
+1 -0
Only 3 have been sanctioned on paper and not started: J&K, Uttarakhand and Sikkim. In the next 5 years all of these will be operational, taking the count to 25 (including NLUD). I expect Goa will be #26. I can't see any of the small north eastern states setting up one.
kianganz 3 Oct 2019, 04:59
+5 -1
Are there any actual concrete plans for NLU Goa? Because once it opens, what are the odds that it would debut in the top 10 in the CLAT preferences immediately? :)
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 05:07
+4 -0
Classes on the beach, lunching at the shack? I can get behind such a life.
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 05:06
+2 -0
Tripura is planning one apparently.
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 06:52
+2 -0
NLU Goa (if established) will possibly be the only new NLU with a reasonable shot at reaching the top 10 within 10 years. Apart from being in a beautiful and "happening" location, It is also close to Mumbai and firms may visit for recruitment. Goa is also under the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court and is actually a circuit bench. Also, the location means good faculty will also join.
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 06:59
+2 -0
Google search for NLU Goa led me to this quote from the Principal of Salgaocar Law College. One option could be to upgrade Salgaocar to an NLU. Building already taken care of, so less expenditure.

[quote]He has been advocating the need for a national law school in Goa. “We need a national law school in Goa to improve competitiveness among students and professionals in Goa. Getting such a project sanctioned requires the will of the government. I am always open for suggestions and discussions if needed,” says Pinheiro.[/quote]
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 14:26
+1 -0
NALSAR alum's take on #NationaliseNLUs:

[quote]The NLUs are placed under the law ministry and not under the higher education ministry which, I believe, is a major cause of their neglect. For the law ministry, the administration of the NLUs become a secondary concern.
... There have been demands in the past to grant the Institute of National Importance (INI) status to the NLUs which will help in solving the problem of fund crunch as the INIs get funding directly from the central government under the Ministry of Human Resource Development’s budget for higher education.
[/quote]

https://livewire.thewire.in/campus/the-plight-of-national-law-universities-in-india/

NLU students and alumni should all support the HECI Bill and suppose the BCI. I request LI to cover this issue properly.
Rajju 3 Oct 2019, 15:10
+1 -0
As overwhelming majority of NLUs have Chief Justices of state as Chairpersons, the Law Ministry of that state regulates NLU. If the NLU is under the state government, the Education Ministry of the state controls it.
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 15:49
+4 -0
While I agree with most of the points made in the article, the quality of English leaves a lot to be desired, especially when the author is trying to write an unsolicited piece referring to 'deplorable quality of faculty'. Statements like "The problems are...many folds" are just sloppy and while a first-year student can be pardoned for that, especially if the student hails from a vernacular medium school, it is still unbecoming of a graduate of an institution like NALSAR.
Pashmina Wool 3 Oct 2019, 15:39
+2 -0
1. Can the students from Gilgil, Baltistan and PoK avail NRI quota or not, since they are officially our part but also
officially not our Part?

2. Will Kashmiri Pandits be eligible to Minority quota in NLU-J&K or would they fall under national Gen category?

3. Am I allowed to wear Kangri inside classroom, if they fail to provide centrally air heating facility?
Guest 3 Oct 2019, 17:17
+3 -0
Some years ago JK Law Minister and other officials had visited NLS and began the spade work for NLU JK. There is a rumour doing rounds that RVR or even Nandimath may get a chance to be the founding VC.

Also A&N Islands Admin had also signed up some sort of agreement with NLS. There were whispers of upgrading the govt law college there to NLU status. But that probably went nowhere.
Guest 13 Dec 2021, 14:50
+0 -0
It's been 2 years & no one has even mentioned NLU kashmir.
Guest 14 Dec 2021, 13:38
+0 -0
People in that region are struggling to stay alive and. Anything else is a luxury.