Legal Rhodes scholars 2012: Nalsar ICC fan Arushi Garg & NLSIU’s Anupama Kumar

NLSIU-Nalsar alumni network grows in Oxon
NLSIU-Nalsar alumni network grows in Oxon
Exclusive: Two lawyers – Arushi Garg from Nalsar Hyderabad and Anupama Kumar from NLSIU Bangalore - have won the prestigious Rhodes scholarship alongside three non-lawyers.

Garg, who was notified of the award yesterday, told Legally India that the feeling of having won the Rhodes was “still sinking in”.

“It takes a while to get used to being a Rhodes scholar,” she mused. “Right now the tentative plan is to come back and teach international criminal law at some point [in India].”

She added that she would hope to complete D.Phil. at Oxford after her BCL and M.Phil., which would take three years, followed by some time practising international criminal law in the field.

Having studied the subject while on exchange at Urbana-Champaign, University of Illinois, Garg said she was “thrilled” about the area of law and having the opportunity to study it further at Oxford.

“Both the US and India have very strong objections to the International Criminal Court but their objections are motivated by different paradigms. “I feel is that the Security Council has been given a disproportionate amount of power - I am not in complete agreement with that objection, although the balance is slightly skewed in favour of the Security Council.

“But it’s very easy to sit and crib that the system is politicised; the better thing is to see what you can do as a lawyer to minimise that. I feel that the focus should be in coming up with constructive solutions.”

Investigative procedures by the state in India often do not deliver results, she said, citing the post-Godhra riot investigations. “People feel that justice has been delayed to the point that it’s been denied.”

In such cases, where a domestic justice system has proved itself unable to successfully prosecute the wrongdoers, she explained, the ICC would step in and assist without being subject to the same political pressures.

Garg noted that she was a strong proponent of India signing up to the ICC’s jurisdiction.

Garg confirmed that Kumar was the only other lawyer who was awarded the scholarship yesterday, but was not reachable for comment at the time of going to press.

Garg said that three other students were also selected for Rhodes scholarships in India: one arts student, one energy systems scholar, and one economist.

The Rhodes scholarship entitles recipients to study a subject of their choice at Oxford University for at least one year.

Last year NLSIU Bangalore student Vrinda Bhandari was the only Indian law student to have won the Rhodes. In the three years before that two lawyers were selected for the scholarship in each round, with 2009 and 2010 again seeing one student each from NLSIU and Nalsar get the nod.

Comments

On HMs Secret Service 25 Nov 2012, 19:46
+10 -1
There are just two law schools in India.
Pacaman 26 Nov 2012, 06:43
+3 -1
Love the name. keep it up 7.
On HMs Secret Service 26 Nov 2012, 18:29
+2 -1
[quote name="Pacaman"]Love the name. keep it up 7.[/quote]

Thank you.

Couldn't place you though.
Ouch 19 Dec 2012, 05:10
+1 -1
You must be from the Rhodes selection committee :)
Om Mendel 25 Nov 2012, 20:58
+1 -1
The real 'ICC' is in Paris !

Congratulations Girls.

Om, Son of Som.
NLUO 26 Nov 2012, 04:31
+1 -1
congrats.
kianganz 26 Nov 2012, 05:44
+0 -0
Apologies for the typo in Arushi Garg's name - fully unintentional caused by sleep deprivation, it's been corrected. Thanks to everyone who pointed out!

Best wishes,
Kian
Neutral observer 26 Nov 2012, 08:50
+3 -0
Kudos to NALSAR. NALSAR is now at par with NLSIU in terms of faculty, placements and quality of students. In the past 7-8 years. NLSIU got complacent and had the misfortune of having some arrogant directors while NALSAR caught up. The person who says there are now only 2 law schools in India is indeed right. The only other law school which can join the club in future is NLU Delhi. NUJS, NLU-J and NLIU Bhopal will remain tier 2.
I hate Arnab Goswami 26 Nov 2012, 10:05
+2 -0
Looks like the war shall begun
Casca 26 Nov 2012, 13:24
+1 -0
[quote name="Neutral observer"]Kudos to NALSAR. NALSAR is now at par with NLSIU in terms of faculty, placements and quality of students. In the past 7-8 years. NLSIU got complacent and had the misfortune of having some arrogant directors while NALSAR caught up. The person who says there are now only 2 law schools in India is indeed right. The only other law school which can join the club in future is NLU Delhi. NUJS, NLU-J and NLIU Bhopal will remain tier 2.[/quote]

Placements better than NUJS? S#!t me not!
sour grapes 26 Nov 2012, 16:02
+1 -0
Sorry. Nalsar outdoes NUJS in every single category. There was a time when NUJS was doing well but it went downhill due to bad administration. The quality of faculty is also very poor.
Just a Thought 26 Nov 2012, 10:13
+3 -0
Since when has Rhodes Scholarships started to decide the caliber of a law school? Majority of law students do not even apply as they prefer a law firm job, e.g. those in NUJS!
Name! 26 Nov 2012, 12:18
+2 -0
[quote name="Just a Thought"]Since when has Rhodes Scholarships started to decide the caliber of a law school? Majority of law students do not even apply as they prefer a law firm job, e.g. those in NUJS![/quote]

Let's label them 'Losers', then! Double the intake of NLS/NALSAR and not a single person interested in Acads? Something's definitely wrong!
Well wisher 26 Nov 2012, 12:59
+0 -0
@4 Neutral observer...Firstly u are not a neutral observer but u are surely from Nalsar so dont use such terms..Secondly are u out of your mind..NLU Jodhpur and NUJS are equal or better than Nalsar in terms of Placement, faculty, infrastructure. So stop this tier I and II nonsense everywhere.
NALSARite 27 Nov 2012, 14:07
+1 -0
The Neutral Observer is certainly not from NALSAR. He/She made the comment only to start the NALSAR v. NLS v. NUJS slug fest. So we all can ignore him.
Mooter 26 Nov 2012, 13:18
+4 -0
There will be some law students reading the post and wondering if they can make it to this big league. When I was in law school (one of the neo NLUS), I used to think on the same lines. All those who get awarded this prestigious scholarship are very well deserving, just likes the ones who get shortlisted and very much like those who can not make the cut in spite of their heavy CVs, may be because they don't have the benefit of a heavy name installed on their shoulders. But trust me, even if its true that Rhodes India is somewhat biased (if you have been a good moot court researcher you will find the story how salman khursheed got his share of Rhodes), I wish more and more law students from all law schools to apply for Rhodes until the ice is broken and its proven that wisdom is not just restricted to some chosen islands of excellence.
Anti-Rhodes 26 Nov 2012, 13:27
+2 -0
It is an open secret that the entire Rhodes selection process is controlled by NLS alums. That precludes everyone else even getting a chance to have their application looked at. Even this time, the person who shortlisted candidates called just two students from NLS and two students from NALSAR for the interview. They should make this the NLS-NALSAR Rhodes Scholarship. At least others won't waste their time applying.
Hmmm.... 26 Nov 2012, 14:14
+1 -0
Well, I was just wondering why there are no people who apply for other equally prestigious scholarships like Chevening, Gates, Clarendon etc.,

Even LI is at fault here, they don't see to it as to who all have won other scholarships like the ones mentioned above.
Haha 26 Nov 2012, 16:03
+3 -0
There was no NLS alum on the Rhodes panel this year.
Anon 26 Nov 2012, 15:13
+2 -0
As a matter of fact, a student from NUJS had won the Rhodes Scholarship in 2006 and there have been students (from non-NLS/NALSAR law schools) who had gone all the way to the final rounds. So lets not over glorify NLS or NALSAR. The students who won the Rhodes, won more because of their personal calibre and not necessarily only for the law school.
NALSARite 27 Nov 2012, 14:09
+0 -0
Specific interjection: No NUJS student has ever won the Rhodes Scholarship. Lets not make up stuff. :)
NLS 27 Nov 2012, 16:06
+3 -0
[quote name="NALSARite"]Specific interjection: No NUJS student has ever won the Rhodes Scholarship. Lets not make up stuff. :)[/quote]

I can’t make out from your comment whether you are actually making a serious interjection or being facetious.

If you are making a serious interjection, before going out on a limb and make asinine comments, you could try and check.

http://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/about/rhodes-scholars/class-of-2006

Shibani graduated from NUJS.
Devottam 1 Dec 2012, 12:56
+0 -0
[quote name="NLS"][quote name="NALSARite"]Specific interjection: No NUJS student has ever won the Rhodes Scholarship. Lets not make up stuff. :)[/quote]

I can’t make out from your comment whether you are actually making a serious interjection or being facetious.

If you are making a serious interjection, before going out on a limb and make asinine comments, you could try and check.

http://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/about/rhodes-scholars/class-of-2006

Shibani graduated from NUJS.[/quote]

Nonsense. AFAIK Nobody from NUJS ever got Rhodes. 2-3 did go to oxford but no Rhodes winners. I hope you know what Rhodes means ?
Sour Peaches 2 Dec 2012, 19:18
+1 -0
Get ur facts straight. Both Animesh (2007) and Swati (2008) batch from NUJS got to Rhodes.
@Sour Peaches 4 Dec 2012, 09:32
+0 -0
I cant see no Animesh or Swati here.

http://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/about/rhodes-scholars/class-of-2008
B&B Reader 27 Nov 2012, 04:18
+7 -0
Bunch of losers we have here. Instead of congratulating the guys who made it, you guys are discussing which law school is better. That’s just poor.
Kian obviously does not screen these comments because it gets him more readership and attention. LI is operating like TOI. All masala and no content.
With time I think people would start reading B&B and not care about what LI reports. This is just poor editorial control.


On a more important congrats to the two students. Good luck for your future endeavours.
@10 27 Nov 2012, 06:19
+3 -0
Bored and lonely B&B reader/staffer obviously. :-)
Om Mendel 27 Nov 2012, 08:23
+0 -0
This is not true. He blocked my comment.

Om, Son of Som.
kianganz 27 Nov 2012, 08:47
+0 -0
Only unintentionally Om - we've published your older comment now. :)

But yes, @B&B Reader above, you are correct in that we generally adopt a laissez faire approach to the comments. In a nutshell, comments are completely optional for readers, and I don't think it should be our place to decide what comments are 'nice' or 'worthy' or 'mature' or inoffensive enough to go up. And I don't think you'd really want us to take that call.

But this discussion has been had dozens of times in the past in the comments, forums, etc, so I won't bore everyone further:
http://www.legallyindia.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=27&catid=3&id=20&lang=en&view=topic&tmpl=index

Best wishes,
Kian
Admirer 27 Nov 2012, 13:30
+4 -0
A rare combination of beauty, brains and down to earth atitude...Arushi Garg, if I am not wrong is the same girl, who was offered an internship by LKS, after one of the moots in which she participated (and probably won) and which was adjudged by a senior partner at LKS, when she had not even completed her 1st year
A 28 Nov 2012, 06:27
+1 -0
One of the finalists for the interview was a law student from DU.
Ouch 16 Dec 2012, 10:51
+0 -0
Lol...Speaks poorly of our country doesn't it- going by the record there are just 2 universities good enough to produce Rhodes scholars. Or we could face a more sensible yet inconvenient truth, the Rhodes Selection Committee is and always has been either biased or too scared to think out of the box and choose talent regardless of where it comes from !