New Nalsar VC plans academic revolution: Widen curriculum, cater to industry, lure alumni to teach

Faizan Mustafa: Big plans
Faizan Mustafa: Big plans
Exclusive: Nalsar Hyderabad’s newly appointed vice chancellor (VC) Prof Faizan Mustafa plans to make drastic changes to the undergraduate law degree syllabus and credit system, introduce new courses designed by practising lawyers, and target alumni faculty recruitment.

Mustafa said that 20 out of the 50 courses of Nalsar’s five year LLB degree would become optional, as 17 new papers would be added to the current list of three elective courses.

“I am going to give a huge choice to my students in terms of electives,” he said.

In the present scheme, there are 47 compulsory papers out of a total of 50, despite the Bar Council of India (BCI) rules requiring only 30 compulsory papers, which Mustafa said was “not a healthy state of affairs”.

“I feel a university which does not offer too many courses cannot truly speaking claim to be a university in the real sense of the term.”

Reforming Shameerpet
Reforming Shameerpet

The number of lecture hours allotted to every course would also change under the proposal. One credit would be awarded for every 16 hours of taking a course, and hours for each course would be re-allocated based on the number of credits required.

“In the best universities of the world credit is given on the basis of the number of lectures which you take for the course,” said Mustafa, explaining that the new system envisaged a total of 80 credits from the electives, out of the total of 200 credits that are required to obtain the LLB degree.

The move is aimed towards introducing easy credit transferability, a system which is compatible with leading international universities, he said.

He told Legally India that the proposal, details of which were chalked out in a faculty meeting this month, had received an enthusiastic response from students and would be tabled before Nalsar’s academic council.

No more mismatch between teaching and industry needs, vows Mustafa
No more mismatch between teaching and industry needs, vows Mustafa
He also noted that new courses would be introduced that met the immediate requirements of the legal industry, which would be designed by practicing professionals from the industry.

“There has been a mismatch between the demands of the industry and the courses offered by law schools. I had a long talk on this with Khaitan & Co when they came for recruitment yesterday and with Luthra & Luthra and Amarchand few days ago. We want to have a very close relationship between the industry and the university.”

Mustafa also planned to bring Nalsar alumni back to campus as faculty.

“I have been in touch with our alumni. They need to come back to Nalsar in order to take it to the zenith of academic excellence. And I am glad to share with you that my alumni from Oxford, Yale, LSE, Berkeley have given an overwhelming response. They are quite enthusiastic about the changes we propose to make at Nalsar.”

“We have innovated selective schemes which can be implemented only when we get good teachers. There are some big plans for recruitment as well, in the next coming academic session.”

A 3-judge panel investigating into the university’s affairs last year had noted that applications of competent Nalsar alumni returning from Oxford and other prestigious LLM universities, for appointment to faculty posts at Nalsar, were rejected despite student grievances about a wide gulf between course design and course execution at Nalsar.

Not hiring Nalsar alumni was reportedly justified citing older University Grant Commission (UGC) norms that prescribed a two-year LLM as the minimum qualification for professors. Those requirements were abolished in 2010 with new regulations.

Mustafa said he now looked forward to alumni involvement in his various proposed curricular experiments. “Just like IITs and IIMs alumni, they are to be involved in all our programs in a big way.”

Mustafa was formerly the VC of NLU Cuttack Orissa (NLUO), from where he resigned to assume the post of VC at Nalsar from 1 April 2012. NLUO’s new VC Chandra Krishnamurthy was selected yesterday.

He noted that the distinct multidisciplinary approach adopted in the undergraduate law curriculum at NLUO was instrumental in giving the “third generation law school” its current standing of a “true university”.

Comments

Sarkar Raj 27 Apr 2012, 10:28
+1 -0
Sarkar
Noojie 27 Apr 2012, 10:33
+0 -0
And in NUJS, the opposite happened.
New VC removed the credit swapping system.
NUJS Acad 27 Apr 2012, 18:09
+3 -0
That's not true. From July 2012 credit courses will be reviewed and assessment patterns will be examined before hand in order to ensure that credit courses are of a particular standard. This measure was initiated because a particular visiting faculty member would announce easy credit courses right at the fag end of the term which resulted in some students opting for the easier credit course that carried no project-work and proper assessment.
From July all credit courses offered in the term would be announced prior to the start of the term along with optional courses and students have the opportunity to opt for the credit courses offered in the term in lieu of the optional courses announced in the term.
NUJS 27 Apr 2012, 18:14
+2 -0
Credit courses will be announced at the beginning of the term along with optional courses and students will have the option of taking up credit courses in lieu of optional courses. All credit courses will be reviewed as one of the visiting faculty offered multiple credit courses which did not have adequate project-work and assessment. In order to ensure standard and quality NUJS will review the course outline and assessment pattern and announce all credit courses offered in the term at the beginning of the term itself.
asd 27 Apr 2012, 10:38
+2 -0
Brilliant stuff! - NLS student.
Curious 27 Apr 2012, 10:38
+5 -0
LI - the significance of the lady in the nude being painted or drawn, evidently in an art class, is not immediately forthcoming. Could you clarify?
kianganz 27 Apr 2012, 14:15
+2 -0
Thought the caption was fairly self-explanatory, no? In case it wasn't, it's about law schools teaching skills that industry doesn't require...

Best wishes
Kian
Abbaa 27 Apr 2012, 14:42
+5 -0
[quote name="kianganz"]Thought the caption was fairly self-explanatory, no? In case it wasn't, it's about law schools teaching skills that industry doesn't require...

Best wishes
Kian[/quote]
Why you so arrogant? Chill maar. There is nothing wrong in clarifying a doubt patiently.
Waah 7 May 2012, 14:15
+0 -0
Bhaiya Kian, They Don't teach drawing nude pictures in Nalsar or other law colleges in India-yet.
Kahin hota ho to please batao, worth seeing

Best wishes
ABC
please update 27 Apr 2012, 10:54
+0 -0
this sounds brilliant. other colleges should take a cue for change from outdated school-type curriculums.
G 27 Apr 2012, 11:04
+2 -0
This is an excellent idea, congrats to nalsar and the vc on this!
Sandipan De 27 Apr 2012, 13:28
+3 -0
Excellent times ahead at Nalsar.

"Let's compete in excellence and not mediocrity."
siddhart 27 Apr 2012, 15:17
+0 -0
surprising LI can see something positive at nalsar.
Gorilla 27 Apr 2012, 16:16
+0 -0
Chill maar!!
Zeal 27 Apr 2012, 17:13
+3 -0
If this zeal continues, NALSAR could truly become a world class institution.
kamal 28 Apr 2012, 15:08
+0 -0
Young people can think of innovative things.Prof.Mustafa is quite young and thus full of energy. His classes are full of energy. Learning becomes such a fun with him.
Blore Lawyer 30 Apr 2012, 18:00
+2 -0
I wonder why he didn't do practically anything when he was the VC of NLU O
ka234 1 May 2012, 05:26
+7 -0
I regret to stike to a dissent note. This idea of modelling LLB courses to cater to industry (i.e. corporate law firms) would completely destroy whatever little is left of genuine legal education at these premier law schools. After 5+ years at a top tier corporate law firm what i still cherish is the sound fundamentals (so i hope!) of the law i grasped at law school. I hope our enlightened academics realise there is little legal principles involved in FDI policy and Press Notes, or for that matter even sector specific enactments such as electricity act and allied guidelines, or in nice-sounding practice areas such as project finance, private equity, etc. Wish, in this mad race for law firm placements, Universities dont compromise on the quality of legal eduction. Ultimately, we as lawyers will agree there is no comparison between the Cairn-Vedatanda deal and Minerva Mills ('82SC).
Danish 1 May 2012, 14:49
+2 -0
Absolutely agree with you. I'm all for academic innovation and am glad Mr. Mustafa is revitalizing the institution, but the last thing we need is for our law schools to churn out even more corporate lawyers - they do enough of a good job on that front without the requirement for "industry oriented" courses. Let the law school be the bastion for legal education and not a primer for law firm work life.
AJ 2 May 2012, 07:30
+1 -0
"Industry driven" is not really the emphasis of Mr. Mustafa's proposal, not at least the way they were presented to us students. The emphasis is on maximising choice. Incidentally, most of the excitement in NALSAR was at the prospect of more courses related to legal theory, and with an inter-disciplinary character.
Danish 2 May 2012, 09:13
+1 -0
Thanks for the clarification AJ. That makes it sound much more promising than the segment we've seen reported here.
Haha 2 May 2012, 07:11
+0 -0
Ummm, ultra-academic dude, Minerva Mills was 1980. Evidently, the litigators don't take much from law school either.
ka234 2 May 2012, 09:02
+0 -0
@12.2 - thanks very much for the correction. admit it was a poor attempt to recall citation from 2nd yr law school days. by the way, i'm still in a corp. law firm doing the transactional stuff (SHA, SSA, PPA & the like) - so, i hope u will agree there is no need of any apology!
kamal 1 May 2012, 16:58
+1 -0
well said. law schools are too much corporate driven.mustafa did talk of litigation lawyering at nluo.nluo prospectus does talk of it.
Hope 15 May 2012, 07:30
+0 -0
And what about litigation oriented courses? Did he say anything about that?