NLS registrar OV Nandimath resigns post Sudhir appointment controversy

NLSIU Bangalore registrar Prof OV Nandimath has resigned from his position but will remain as part of faculty, according to a number of press reports (see below).

Students had publicly blamed him for delaying the appointment of new vice-chancellor (VC) Prof Sudhir Krishnaswamy last week.

Nandimath had told us earlier this month, however, that he had not been to blame and was just a “messenger” and that delays had been caused by delays in the system.

Nandimath did not respond to a message seeking comment today.

After the controversy over the delay in the appointment of the new Vice Chancellor of National Law School of India University (NLSIU), the Registrar of the university on Saturday submitted his resignation from his administrative post.

The Hindu

However, his appointment to the position of a registrar in 2013 was controversial even then, with the NLSIU alumni contesting his appointment, because his selection had been made outside established procedure and because other, more senior candidates had been passed over, according to a letter by NLSIU alumnus, Vikram Raghavan in July 2013…

According to senior students at NLSIU, this entailed him submitting incomplete documents to the Chief Justice of India, and introducing a clause asking for confirmation of receipt of the appointment letter from members of the EC, which was no part of the protocol…

A copy of his email, which was given to DH, showed him asking to be recused from the responsibilities of the appointment process. “This will probably instil confidence in the student body,” he had written, in an email dated, September 16, 2019. However, this offer was rejected by Professor Ramesh.

Deccanherald

Comments

Guest 29 Sept 2019, 19:20
+4 -1
This Nandi got his Math wrong. Understood ethics late. And BCI had to eat grass https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/bangalore/bar-council-of-india-chairman-urges-nlsiu-students-to-limit-protests/article29549457.ece

Someone tell BCI that it better burnish its own credentials first before lecturing us. And that too from its current leadership. There was a time (just like the acche din that were or will come) when BCI was headed by respected jurists etc. Now the less said, the better. If the MCI could be disbanded what about BCI?

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/karnataka/national-law-school-varsity-registrar-resigns-from-post/article29546269.ece

https://www.deccanherald.com/city/top-bengaluru-stories/controversial-registrar-of-nlsiu-resigns-764808.html

Nandi wanted to brazen this out. I am surprised what happened to taking Sudhir to court for the irregular Professorial appointment at NUJS; conflict-of-interest involving Pro MP Singh etc. Is that litigation happening or not?

At this point I would rather be Nandi roaming streets elsewhere. But as eloquently expressed "those who can't, teach"
Who next? 29 Sept 2019, 19:50
+1 -0
What are the predictions for the new Registrar? Will it be someone internal? Sarasu? Rahul Singh? That'll make for a good alum combo. Or someone from outside? Mrinal? Chauhan - I know he is not a professor, but does the Registrar have to be a professor? Arun Thiruvengadam, his old colleague from Azim Premji? All these possibilities are so exciting!
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 02:15
+4 -0
Chauhan :-D
Guest 29 Sept 2019, 22:40
+4 -3
It seems ironical that Nandimath's appointment was contested by alum on the ground of more senior candidates having been passed over, while his resignation was triggered by his inability to stomach a more junior candidate being selected (for VC).
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 03:42
+2 -0
Congratulations once again to the students and alumni! I hope other NLUs take heed and similarly weed out incompetent and obstructionist faculty/admin.
RRRRRR 30 Sept 2019, 03:46
+3 -5
I would like to ask Prof Sudhir if he will be student-friendly if certain other NLUs submit petitions to him (as an ex officio member of the CLAT consortium and governing body of various NLUs) and go on strike. He has clearly supported the NSLIU strike and petition, now he must show the same attitude when other NLUs go on strike and send petitions to him.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 03:48
+1 -0
The welcome beginning of the alumni taking over NLSIU and the "traditionals" being kicked out. Expect similar alumni versus trads battles elsewhere.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 03:48
+0 -1
Can't imagine Nandi staying after this humiliation. Will try for VCship elsewhere.
rightsviolations 30 Sept 2019, 04:30
+1 -1
NLUD?
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 12:14
+2 -0
Good chance he'll apply to NLUD. Might even get it, depending on who else applies. But if I were a betting man, I would say the front-runners are PJ and SKD Rao. PJ is very close to RS and to Vijaykumar who is on the selection committee. SKD Rao is an internal candidate, and also close to RS. And he is close to SC judges who sit on the NLUD bodies. So, one or the other. PJ possibly has a slight edge. But for sure, there won't be any 'edgy' candidate like Sudhir K at NLUD. Even if they apply, the selection committee is so staid, it is highly unlikely they'll do any out of the box selection.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 05:11
+7 -1
BREAKING NEWS: Sources confirming that NLSIU putting an application for Institution of National Importance status this year. Karnataka govt and BCI will both support it.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 05:47
+1 -0
[quote]“I’m not going anywhere. But ethically, I had to step down. Considering what happened with the Student Bar Council which accused me of delaying the appointment of Professor Sudhir Krishnaswamy as VC, it was impossible for me to continue,” he said.
[/quote]

[quote]Senior and current students who spoke to DH said they were pleased by how things had turned out. “We could not be happier,” a student said.
[/quote]


https://www.deccanherald.com/state/karnataka-politics/outgoing-nlsiu-registrar-denies-any-wrongdoing-765076.html
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 06:20
+2 -0
If it is impossible for him to continue as Registrar given the student body's accusation, how is it any more possible for him to face them everyday as a teacher either? The students weren't complaining against the ex-officio Registrar, they were accusing him as a person to have abused his power! Now he would be teaching them principles of law while knowing that they believe him to have flouted those very principles? That can get a bit too difficult to digest. People may start thinking he is doing this only because he doesn't want to cooperate administratively with Sudhir. As only a teacher, the need to do that would be minimal at best.
CocaX 30 Sept 2019, 06:16
+4 -0
Sudhir K will now learn soon that educational institutes are political war zones.
Without a good registrar, he will be handicapped in doing what he wants to.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 06:39
+0 -0
Sarasu next registrar.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 06:51
+2 -0
Today is the last day for 2020 NIRF rankings submission. I hope NLSIU's submission did not get affected because of all this??
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 07:15
+0 -0
Extensions are usually available for up to a month.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 07:49
+0 -0
Today is just the last date for registration. Not submission. All institutes having been part of last year's data set are already pre-registered.
Registrar Watch 30 Sept 2019, 09:11
+1 -0
Nandi had defeated Liz who was then supported by the alumni to be the Registrar. After the recent turn of events it is more likely that Liz may try to scuttle Sarasu's chances of becoming Registrar. Then again, we are assuming that Sarasu is interested in that position. It is entirely possible that Sarasu who is probably four batches senior to Sudhir, may prefer to continue as a Professor with Registrar responsibilities. The Registrar position may help her later for VC positions at NLS or elsewhere, again assuming if she is interested.

I am not sure if Sarasu has additionally been made the Ford Chair Professor or is she administering the Chair? We know she is working on a Ford Foundation project. But the Chair and project are different. Can someone throw better light on this? If Sarasu is formally the Ford Chair Prof, she will likely have little incentive to become Registrar. Sudhir would also prefer it that way.

RS and other young academics with Associate Prof rank may get tapped. I have heard that Registrar is a Professorial rank position. But nothing explicitly rules out an Associate Professor having the required number of years under his/her belt.

Now that Nandi is gone, the rest of the [...] should be cleared. Possible places where Nandi may go are CNLU Patna, NLU Assam and like where the VCs are unlikely to take or get extensions.

Why do I get a feeling Nandi will stay on and plot trouble.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 12:31
+0 -0
NSLIU will retain the # 1 position in NIRF, so nothing to worry. The controversy will make no difference.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 12:32
+0 -0
CNLU is a possibility for Nandi.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 12:37
+0 -0
By the end fo the year, NLSIU will easily have the maximum number of alumni as faculty, far outstripping NLUD and NALSAR. In fact, some will leave NLUD and NALSAR and join. This is how things are likely to pan out by the end of the year.
Guest 30 Sept 2019, 13:33
+2 -0
Yes, I hear Sudhir is already in talks with some of the NULD, NUJS and NALSAR faculty. Expect some big movements soon!
Registrar GoT 1 Oct 2019, 03:57
+3 -0
Sarasu has indicated several times over the years to batches of students and alumni, that she's not too keen on playing the politics of administration. So, I wouldn't be too sure. But in all fairness, I think the best Registrar would be Somu - tough, but fair. And an extremely smooth operator, which he'll surely need to be, dealing with GoK and BCI and SC. Let's hope that the fact that he teaches Economics, and not Law will not hold him back.

As for [...] one would hope [...] to at least not angle for registrar after all the failed plotting [...]