NLU Delhi students publish wishlist for new VC: Should tick usual boxes, ‘foster trust’ with student body

Who will succeed Prof Ranbir Singh? And will they be as successful?
Who will succeed Prof Ranbir Singh? And will they be as successful?

A group of NLU Delhi students has [the first to try and take a more active role in the selection of a new VC.](<https://www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/nls-students-put-out-wish-list-of-what-they-d-like-of-their-future-vc-much-research-faculty-hires-alum-outreach-20190705-10711 emulated NLSIU Bangalore’s] in trying to have a say in the future of its institution, particularly in the process of appointing a successor to their hugely influential founding vice chancellor (VC) Prof Ranbir Singh.

A number of students collectively calling themselves “Students’ Body National Law University Delhi” sent an email to Singh, the VC and the convenor of the VC selection committee, with a three-page attachment outlining what they would like from a new VC.

The email, which was sent from a Gmail address, stated:

>The process to appoint the next Vice-Chancellor of National Law University, Delhi has officially been initiated with the constitution of a three-member Selection Committee.

The Student Body of the University believes that it is their responsibility and their right as major stakeholders to be involved in the upcoming process to appoint the new Vice-Chancellor.

In furtherance of the same, the Student Body would like to make public their official Charter of Aspirations (attached to this email) hope that it will influence the selection process in a positive manner.

Regards NLU Delhi Student Body<

We have reached out to the body via its email adddress but have not been able to confirm at this time whether the initiative is part of NLU Delhi’s official student council, for which elections were held on 10 October 2019 and which governs various verticals relevant to students such as library, mooting, welfare and academics (but which lacks, as far as we understand, umbrella student council positions such as president and vice president).

Our guess would be, not.

##Aspirational aspirations

dc:Nevertheless, in its “charter of aspirations”, the full PDF of which is attached below, the body expressed “its wholehearted indebtedness to him for his every single contribution in raising the University to its current stature”, but also added that it would like to “assert itself as an important stakeholder in the current search and selection processes that have been initiated to appoint a new Vice Chancellor to our University”.

Its preferences for a new VC include:

  • “fostering better environment for research” to “grow and not diminish” the relatively high existing research standards,
  • “improving quality of academics and initiating academic reforms”, by taking “steps to hire motivated faculty and foster an atmosphere of academic freedom, where modern and progressive methods of teaching are employed”.
  • “expanding infrastructure”, as certain needs still remained to be met, including making the campus more accessible,
  • “encouraging and facilitating sports facilities, cultural activities, and co-curricular activities”,
  • “creating a safe and inclusive space for all students, and special efforts for minority groups”, referring to an “increasing frequency of incidents of casteism, sexism, and homophobia in universities” (but not specifically NLU Delhi). They’d want a VC, they wrote, who would:

>a. stand in support of women, bahujan & adivasi persons, the differently abled, persons belonging to religious and sexual minorities;

b. is open to concerns raised by persons of all identities and ensures that affirmative action is taken to empower those who are persecuted due to their identities/choices; and,

c. ensure by conduct, policies, and action, that sexism, homophobia, casteism, and other forms of discrimination are clearly discouraged<

  • “ensuring proper management of funds and favourable administration of student affairs”, adding that “the Student Body has stood in solidarity with students of other universities in their protests against the injustices meted out to them by their college administrations”.

Along the vein of the last point, the note concludes that more than the above, they would request the selection committee to also bear in mind a few looser parameters and an eye on candidates’ track record:

>Notwithstanding our faith in selection of the next Vice Chancellor, we hope that the Selection Committee will bear in mind the reputation of integrity and transparency which the University has come to exemplify.

Prior allegations of discriminatory actions against minorities, academic irregularity or mismanagement of funds on a candidate are strongly disapproved of by the Student Body. It should warrant further scrutiny to ensure that the appointment is in consonance with the dignity and esteem which the post demands. Further, it is paramount to consider the nature of the relationship that the candidate shared with the Student Body at their previous institution. Their ability to foster mutual trust and transparency is an uncompromising requirement for the Student Body.<

##Precedent

dc:NLU Delhi students aren’t>)

NLS students had [https://www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/nls-students-put-out-wish-list-of-what-they-d-like-of-their-future-vc-much-research-faculty-hires-alum-outreach-20190705-10711 sent out a similar note in July ahead of their VC selections, which seems to have had some success in assisting (by most accounts) one of their preferred candidates, Prof Sudhir Krishnaswamy, eventually getting the gig.

That said, Delhi’s alumni base is much younger than NLS’, so the sway of students may be more limited.

Nevertheless, no reasonable argument can be made that expressing their preferences could be a negative.

Also on their side is the job description for the job, which we had first reported on in October, as not explicitly requiring 10 years of professorship unlike most.

This could throw open the field to some unexpected candidates that could impress both selection committee and students.

NLU Delhi student charter of aspirations for new VC

Comments

Guest 22 Nov 2019, 10:44
+1 -0
About f***ing time. I hope lessons will be learnt from the NLSIU and JNU protests and drastic action will be taken if the process is rigged.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 10:46
+3 -5
Legally India is trying to interfere and provoke students once again. I request students not to be influenced because Legally India has its own agenda and will push certain candidates.
Tere naina 22 Nov 2019, 11:20
+1 -0
U r right bro...it is....Lets see if they publish my comment...
btw u urself push candidates when u eat cashew almond during interviews.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 10:47
+4 -0
What is there to stop the committee from saying that they have duly considered all these points and believes PSJ is the ideal candidate to address all of this effectively? You guessed right, nothing!
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 12:08
+0 -1
Polite warning: We at NLUD are willing to not only go on hunger strike but repeat what is happening in Hong Kong if our demands are not met. We do not support violence, but sometimes the only solution to tyranny is violence. We are following Gandhi now, but we may follow Bhagat Singh if you keep oppressing us. If you see bullets, bombs and blood, the fault will not be ours.
kianganz 22 Nov 2019, 12:12
+5 -0
Lol: good trolling, presumably? :D
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 15:00
+1 -0
Might not be. It's Dilli after all. Everything goes.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 12:11
+0 -0
NLUD made a spectacular debut in NIRF and is on the verge of overthrowing NLSIU and becoming #1 in just 10 years. But a bad VC can ruin it.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 12:50
+5 -0
Overthrow? Watching a few too many WWE videos, it seems. Settle down. I would have advised you to take a few deep breaths, but...Delhi.
Apropos of nothing 22 Nov 2019, 13:28
+5 -0
Kumar Gaurav had also made a spectacular debut in Love Story. By the time Love Story 2050 was released, nobody even remembered him.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 12:37
+3 -1
You fools, Jaswal is assured of the post.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 12:49
+2 -5
What is this obsession with gays and minorities? Most of these SJWs are doing it for CV building to get LLM scholarships abroad. Most of them are hypocrites. One NLSIU grad (supposed champion of oppressed classes) was exposed as serial predator. We also had the Lawrence Liang case. As for the women, they will claim to fight for the poor but wear Gucci clothes and refuse to date any guy who is dark skinned, poor and cannot speak English well. Sick of this BS.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 13:30
+3 -1
So fighting for someone's basic rights means that I also have to date him? By that logic, do you date all your clients? Or would like to? On second thoughts, don't answer that question, I am probably better off (and less creeped out) not knowing.
Guest2 22 Nov 2019, 15:02
+4 -0
I agree. Some of them might be genuine, but the vast majority are self serving clowns. Feel bad for people who do real work, rather than this virtue signalling.
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 17:01
+2 -0
Why don't you try doing the former and avoid doing the latter yourself? Lead by example, instead of spending your valuable time passing snide comments on others' actions. Let's see how good you are at it. Those who can't do, criticise.
UdharKaLadka 22 Nov 2019, 13:22
+1 -0
Wish race as an issue was also explicitly acknowledged....not a lot of comments for people from the north east...disappointing representation in the top law schools....
Guest 22 Nov 2019, 14:03
+1 -1
True. Mostly the ones via ST quota or the IDIA candidates.
Guest 24 Nov 2019, 16:30
+0 -0
Reliable sources saying #GharWaapsi soon for NLSIU alumni teaching at NLUD, NALSAR and JGLS.
Guest 24 Nov 2019, 17:50
+2 -0
Do they also say that foreign firms are going to be allowed in another month? And that All India Judicial Service exam ads are gonna be released next week?
Another NLS Alumnus 24 Nov 2019, 20:10
+2 -0
This can only happen if Prof. Sudhir Krishnaswamy does the following things:
(a) issues an advertisement to fill up permanent teaching positions by February/March 2020,
(b) holds the interviews before a Selection Committee within a reasonable time, let us say around April/May 2020, so that the selected teachers can join from July 2020.
(c) offers fair service conditions to applicants by recognising the teaching/research experience accumulated by them at other institutions. For instance, those who hold PhDs and have taught for more than 8 years should be directly recruited at the rank of Associate Professor. Similarly, those with lesser experience can be recruited as Assistant Professors and given the salary increments based on their existing teaching/research experience. No one will come if they are asked to start from scratch.

Given the large budgetary deficit at the moment, Prof. Sudhir Krishnaswamy might be waiting for the departures of some of the incompetent ad-hoc teachers hired during the RVR years. The smarter strategy is to wait for them to serve out their currents contracts and not renew them if their student feedback over the last 3-4 years has been consistently bad. The relatively better ad-hoc teachers should of course be absorbed into permanent positions with due recognition of their teaching/research experience. All of these steps will require careful planning and the support of the students.
New VC 25 Nov 2019, 03:40
+3 -0
Mrinal Satish for NLU Delhi Vice Chancellor!
Guest 25 Nov 2019, 09:44
+1 -0
Indeed. Multiple sources are claiming that MS has been recommended applying SK appointment as a precedent. Huge news if true.
Guest 25 Nov 2019, 09:43
+1 -0
BREAKING: It looks as if Mrinal has applied after all. Justice Sistani may favour him based on the NLSIU precedent and student petition. If it works out, it will be a surgical strike!
Anonymous Guest 25 Nov 2019, 11:11
+1 -0
Absolutely untrue. I have heard directly from him that he hasn't applied and isn't interested in being considered for the position at all. On the other hand, another NLS grad from one of the earlier batches has applied. I don't know her name, but she teaches in the US in the area of IP law. This comes from a very reliable source.
Guest 25 Nov 2019, 11:26
+1 -0
Did Mrinal told you that?
Anonymous Guest 25 Nov 2019, 11:56
+1 -0
About himself - yes. And I have also heard from other nlud alum who have asked him that he has said the same thing to them. About the other nls person, no. That was another faculty member at NLUD.
Guest 25 Nov 2019, 14:11
+1 -0
Comment #12 can only mean Srividhya Raghavan from Texas A&M, whose CV is vastly superior to Jaswal. Which, therefore, must mean that we must congratulate NLUD for getting the second NLU alum VC and the first ever NLU VC holding a professorship abroad.
Guest 25 Nov 2019, 14:27
+2 -0
Well done to NLUD if it manages to attract Srividhya Raghavan! Her bio is more impressive than Sudhir. Unlike him, she has held full-time professor posts abroad, published a lot and worked in industry. It's true that Sudhir got the Rhodes scholarship at Oxford while she got the Commonwealth scholarship at King's, but the Commonwealth too is a great achievement and it matters more what one does after Rhodes.

NLUD is now well-positioned for a boost in research output and a #1 NIRF ranking in the next 2-3 years.

https://law.tamu.edu/faculty-staff/find-people/faculty-profiles/srividhya-ragavan
Guest 26 Nov 2019, 00:49
+0 -0
People forget that Sudhir's appointment was actually enabled by the selection committee of MP Singh/KKV/Datar, especially MPS. The NLUD committee is totally different.: Vijaykumar, Balraj Chauhan and Justice Sistani. We don't know if Vijaykumar is "anti-alumni" like the other NLSIU profs. I don't know much about Chauhan but NLU VCs tend to stick together. Sistani is likely to go by whatever these two say, unless the students and alumni explicitly lobby and meet with them, like it happened at NLSIU.
Guest 26 Nov 2019, 03:36
+1 -3
Here is how you get to know who applied:

1. Create a gmail account under the name NLUD Office

2. Send a mail to rumoured candidates saying "We are in receipt of your application. Kindly confirm YES or NO if you are agreeable to an interview over Skype".

3. Wait and watch.

It's not a crime and no wealth is being stolen, no account is being hacked and no harm is being done. It's just like a harmless prank.
Guest 26 Nov 2019, 04:27
+0 -0
Is that what you have been advising your clients these days? Wow! Talk about NLU weed culture! Ever read the definition of fraud under IPC? Or the provisions relating to cyber crime?
kianganz 26 Nov 2019, 04:33
+0 -0
Disclaimer: That does sound like it'd be breaking at least some cyber laws against impersonating another person or entity online, would it not?
Guest 26 Nov 2019, 11:56
+0 -0
A student protest at NLUD like what happened at NLSIU is now very likely. There is a plot to see that no alumni of any NLU is made VC, even with superior qualifications than the rest. The plan is to see that the appointment happens over the holidays.
Guest 27 Nov 2019, 20:31
+0 -0
Just in: Shortlist of 3 to be drawn by next week and sent to Chancellor.
Guest 28 Nov 2019, 04:58
+0 -0
Humra VC kaisa ho? PSJ jaisa ho!
Jackal 5 Dec 2019, 10:29
+1 -0
It's a commendable effort by the students' body to address rights of the oppressed, women and minorities. But I sincerely hope (as has been pointed in a previous comment) that these are not just on paper with a selfish agenda, but genuine collective aspirations.

Having spent a lot of time at Indian law schools' campuses, I know it for a fact how vicious, sexist, elitist, violent and regressive the student bodies can be. Most of these people are children of privilege with a weird sense of entitlement. They often look down upon the less privileged (by birth). They also may speak of gender equality on paper, but rarely one would walk into a boys' hostel without hearing some sexist expletives or the other and their genuine thoughts about their female batchmates, juniors/seniors, teachers, etc. It's all hunky dowry to make lofty claims, but when it comes to taking a good hard look at oneself, the privileged children attending fancy Indian law schools often fall short.