NLU Jodhpur may soon have an elected student body, confirms VC Poonam Saxena

NLU J VC Poonam Saxena in favour of student councils
NLU J VC Poonam Saxena in favour of student councils

NLU Jodhpur may soon start its very first elected student body, said vice chancellor Prof Poonam Saxena.

“I’ve always supported a student body, never resisted it,” she told us by phone today.

NLU Jodhpur does not have a formal student body, although it does have a “student chief” and “vice-chief”, selecting from fifth- and fourth-year batches two students with the highest CGPA their respective previous semester.

Saxena said that this was an “inherited legacy” system and that she was all in favour of an elected student body, having been at Delhi University previously (where she had headed up Law Centre II before joining Jodhpur in 2013).

Students had approached her again this year about the idea of reforming student representation. “I’d be really happy, I had given my go ahead in April,” she said.

In July, students had approached her again and she told them to continue with the process.

“I think they’ll be starting whole process maybe tomorrow, or day after,” Saxena noted about students discussing the next steps. “There should be [a student council], why should there not be?”

“It takes a lot of load off the administration if you [students] are interested,” she added, saying that student preferences regarding hostels or other issues should be framed by such a body. “If you have an elected body, that can also look into ensuring discipline by laying clear rules that should be practically enforceable uniformly.”

Any recent rumours that she had resigned as VC from NLU Jodhpur were not true, she clarified.

Last year, NLIU Bhopal had started its first student council.

However, several national law universities such as GNLU Gandhinagar, NLU Delhi and RGNUL Patiala do not (though the RGNUL administration has in theory agreed to the idea).

Comments

Guest 27 Aug 2019, 16:24
+15 -4
[...] if she was so student friendly then why didn't she agreed for the student body and constitution when approached in the first place.

I still believe nothing will happened, the process will die after a few time.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 17:01
+7 -20
Welcome NLUJ to the 20th century. Hopefully you'll reach the 21st century a bit sooner.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 17:09
+7 -9
NLUJ and GNLU are the only NLUs not to have staged a protest. Guess why?
NLUJ student 27 Aug 2019, 18:04
+27 -2
Don't guess. It's because of vindictive administrations. The administration has time and again ignored or downright threatened individuals who asked for one. It is only now, that the students have banded together have these demands been taken seriously.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 19:25
+4 -21
Sorry, but the reason is that NLUJ students have no guts to protest. Don't make lame excuses.
Mx. X 28 Aug 2019, 08:58
+0 -0
Sorry, but your comment cannot be taken seriously (unless you are/ were an NLUJ student).
Mx. X 28 Aug 2019, 08:59
+0 -0
Sorry, I just read the comment to which you were replying. You may have a point.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 17:15
+3 -16
Won't make a difference [...]. This is the ultimate sanskari NLU where students touch feet of professors, go to pubs to drink nimbu pani, wear kurta and salwar kameez etc.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 18:07
+36 -1
your comment makes me believe that you have never ever been close to even 50 km radius of NLUJ
NLUJ Alum 27 Aug 2019, 18:34
+22 -3
Seeing is believing. PPS has been at NLUJ for 6+ years now, and always promises that such things will happen but all that the students have gotten batch after batch is a knife in the back.
I hope this finally happens because it is honestly long long overdue.
Bloo 28 Aug 2019, 09:02
+4 -2
PPS has been there for 6+ years. There were others before her. You were purportedly an alumini. Yet nothing happend. You are one of the reasons its long long overdue.
NLUJ Alum 28 Aug 2019, 11:31
+4 -0
Yeah I'm an alumnus, and PPS was my vice-chancellor.
If you are/were a NLUJ student, you'd know that there have been multiple concerted efforts to push through reform. We even had an entire student constitution drafted by a representatives of the 2016 and 2017 batches, if I'm not wrong.
The main reason that it's been difficult to move forward on this has been that the students have been negotiating in good faith while the admin seriously doesn't give a flying ... They know that they have too much stuff to threaten us with, and at the end of the day, make a small concession on one of the demands and that satisfies enough people and momentum is lost.
Hopefully that doesn't happen this time.
Lolwa 28 Aug 2019, 11:45
+6 -2
I am a recent alumnus of NLUJ and I tend to agree with the sentiment expressed here. The alumni of our college (when they were a part of the college) did absolutely nothing to help change things. Batch after batch worked with the regressive system to engender a culture of complete compliance and subjugation. Personal interests mattered more and led to development of coteries around the SCC/ VSCC to navigate the system, rather than change the system. Over the years region based groups popped up for collective bargaining - people from the east went to Prof. Banerjee to curry favours and people from Rajasthan went to Prof Daga for parleys. Thankfully, that has stopped now.

The people who spoke out against all this were undermined by the students themselves who actively connived with the administration. Admin would unleash their pets in any given batch to undermine genuine free thinking and action on such vital issues.

We've been a fairly petty lot - typical of the crab mentality. Anyone who disagrees with me should stop and look at the absolute shambles in which our alumni outreach efforts are - you will find people from NLUJ gleefully running each other down for their personal grudges while other law schools have an honourable code - never run down your own in front of other college people.

This delay is something we've all contributed to - in our own way and in varying degrees. That's the ugly truth.
Alum 29 Aug 2019, 20:57
+4 -0
You must have graduated when PPS headed the college. I was in college before that time - actually at a time when it was just "NLU", not "NLUJ".

I find our alumni is far friendlier and likely to help each other than any other law school. I've happily called folks who are now partners in other firms and asked them the questions I wasn't able to get resolved in-house. The college folks in the firms I've been in have always willingly gone the extra length for me - and naturally I've done the same.

So, at least my experience on that account has been vastly different.
Guest 27 Aug 2019, 21:29
+1 -28
Professor Poonam Saxena ji is one of the best VC with a holistic vision. This Legally India is having a one sided agenda of criticizing administration of law schools.
Nlufac 28 Aug 2019, 06:24
+0 -0
Here comes the calvary from the university. Just like on all LI posts, it's easy to figure out who's compromised and who isn't.
B.Lal. 28 Aug 2019, 09:04
+4 -0
Or you could be wrong. Or it could simply be a 'woosh' moment.
Nzi 28 Aug 2019, 11:52
+0 -0
Yes, by the number of grammatical errors in one sentence.
NLUJ student 28 Aug 2019, 03:35
+5 -6
Here's what actually happened, the VC didn't agree to anything on paper until the Students surrounded her vehicle and the administrative block. Now she's saying this is what she wanted all along. No doubt this is another one of our illegally appointed [...] "professor"s machinations (our very own Rasputin and a close aide of the VC).
Ringo Starr 28 Aug 2019, 09:05
+3 -0
NLUJ students surrounded her vehicle you say? Impressive!
NLIU B 28 Aug 2019, 03:36
+0 -0
NLIU does not have a student council in place as of now.
NLUJ student 28 Aug 2019, 04:14
+6 -0
"If you have an elected body, that can also look into ensuring discipline by laying clear rules that should be practically enforceable uniformly.”

Lol who is this discipline for ? Will it be enforced against the admin also or just the students as usual? The admin was let off easily earlier because even the students had a lot of liberties. These have been eroded over the last five years. Now there's nothing stopping the students.

#ReleaseTheAccounts
RGNUL-ite 28 Aug 2019, 06:06
+1 -0
RGNUL Admin agreed in theory to give us a body but then the VC goes ahead and maligns the General Council and delays approval of Constitution of RGNUL SBA! They created a Committee comprising of individuals, viz. Justice Mahesh Grover, NLUD VC Ranbir Singh and NLS VC Venkata Rao - who are against any collective student entity which can raise their voices against the ills of the Administration. Don't be under any illusion. They may say howsoever much that they will welcome a student body. But the truth is that they can't bear the thought of yielding power to someone who can effectively keep a check on them.
Raj. D 28 Aug 2019, 16:43
+1 -0
You say...."the thought of yielding power to someone who can effectively keep a check on them...."
But, SBA is neither to enjoy power nor to keep a check on the administration. It is a fallacious concept. The SBA is to involve itself into a "cooperative venture" with the administration for the benefit of the students. It must not behave like a labour union. Form your SBA with positivity in your thoughts and actions.
NLUJ2020 28 Aug 2019, 06:12
+4 -0
Kian, why did you take down the 'sanskaari', 'nimbu paani' comment :(
We were all getting a great laugh out of it..
Guest 28 Aug 2019, 07:42
+0 -8
I request Legally India to remove comments by some rowdy students maligning the administration.
Guest 28 Aug 2019, 22:27
+1 -12
Shame on student for posting misogynic comment against Prof Saxena as she is a lady and shame on Legally India for allowing it. She is one of the pioneer VC among the NLUs and first lady VC.
kianganz 29 Aug 2019, 04:58
+6 -0
If a comment is hateful or relates to gender in any way, please press the report button and we will remove it. But the comments in this thread don't appear to be personal but merely generally about the institution.
Guest 8 Oct 2019, 11:03
+0 -0
Any updates? Or are the students too meek/unconcered to protest?
Guest 8 Oct 2019, 16:05
+0 -0
The latter. The meek shall inherit the law firms (like Luthra) and then go berserk.
Guest 8 Oct 2019, 19:46
+0 -0
NLUJ is a dream destination for a VC. Such shy and sanskari students that there is no chance of a protest or any indiscipline.
NLUJ-student 8 Sept 2020, 15:39
+0 -0
This is extremely misleading. There was a protest. After numerous struggles she finally had to give in to students demands. We got to know of the acceptance of our demands through LegallyIndia for the first time. This is a joke.
PartnerView 8 Sept 2020, 18:00
+0 -0
A joke it must be.

Seems NLU-J has some world class web infrastructure, complete with Internet Explorer & Windows 95.
Guest 8 Sept 2020, 19:05
+1 -1
SJA at NUJS is the most active, functional and vibrant student body across NLUs. Administarton works in tandem at NUJS and students are actively encouraged to form new societies and conduct various activities. Other NLUs need to take a clue from NUJS.