[UPDATE: VC’s press statement] NLU Shimla VC: Prays for patience to solve issues, state funding meagre • Cops only ‘observing’

VC Prof Nishtha Jaswal appeals for dialogue
VC Prof Nishtha Jaswal appeals for dialogue

Update 20:06: VC Prof Nishtha Jaswal has released a press statement, responding to some of the student demands, and reiterating some of the below points she had made during our interview yesterday.

However, strikes are still ongoing and Jaswal repeated her call for students to call off the strike and engage in dialogue with the administration.

NLU Shimla press tatement

As HPNLU Shimla continue into their fourth day of strikes, vice chancellor (VC) Prof Nishtha Jaswal has appealed for students to “call off” their protests and to interact with her to try and find solutions to problems, though she warned that none of these would be solved overnight.

“My pleas and appeal to my students, whom I love a lot: we are trying to go higher. We are in a better situation than we were two months back, we are much better now,” she told us by phone earlier yesterday.

The administrative block, where students are protesting, remained officially closed and police has been called to campus, according to student reports on social media.

However, Jaswal said: “The police is there, but has been expressly instructed not to harm any students. They are there to observe so that no issues should be there, clear instructions are there.”

Jaswal said that washrooms and water purifiers in the academic block had indeed been closed, as had been criticised by students on social media, but that this was because the administrative block had been officially closed (the administration had shut down the university until 25 September in a bid to stop the strikes).

Jaswal noted that washrooms and facilities were still available in the hostels, which are up to 15 minutes walk away from the academic block.

Bus services to the hostel block were currently unavailable due to the shutdown, said one student.

The main demands from students are:

  • Better mess facility,
  • Improved internet access (which is offline most of the time),
  • availability and maintenance of hostel facilities.

VC’s response: Problems won’t be solved overnight

Jaswal she said she was aware there were problems with infrastructure on campus.

However, the problem was not easy to solve. The university had only received a total of Rs 36 crore since its founding, she said, with the last release of funds only having been made in April 2019, and more support from the state did not appear to be forthcoming any time soon (HPNLU had started with Rs 20 crore promised by the state government in 2016).

That said, when she had joined in November 2018 the situation had been much worse than it was now, she said, and the academic block had since become available, as well as hostels for students.

Regarding the quality of mess food, which students had alleged was causing them to fall ill, Jaswal said: “We are managing and doing our best. I did verbally speak to the caterer, and said I should not hear that kind of complaint and to taste the food and not to serve it [if not to standards]”.

However, she added that “all my teachers and non-teaching staff are eating in the same mess and many times I also call for [food from the mess]. There is no such issue as such.”

Regarding wireless internet, she said that “I can’t say tomorrow we will get the [new] WiFi”. Part of that work to wire up the campus had been delayed due to rainy weather in Shimla, for instance.

“I am dependent on the [other] sectors, where the process is already going on. I feel that my students should have this much patience,” she said.

HPNLU Shimla did not have an elected student body at the moment, but Jaswal said that she had talked to students and explained the situation and they had seemed satisfied.

However, one student told us: “We did have a conversation with the vice chancellor on 16th followed by 17th, the result of which, was highly unsatisfactory since she has only considered a few of our suggestions.”

Comments

rightsviolations 19 Sept 2019, 20:51
+10 -3
Yet another NLU enters into protests. More importantly, another Jaswal! But what makes this protest unique is the draconian way in which Nishtha has handled these protests.

Students have no washrooms, no food, no water and starting tomorrow no place to stay and what do they ask for in return basic rights and accountability. Her behavior alone should be enough for the students to get her thrown out.

Stay strong HPNLU students.

Shame on you, Dr. Jaswal.
Nujs Alumni 19 Sept 2019, 22:53
+12 -1
35 crores of funding is less. In the first 7-8 years Nujs was extremely fund starved and had a hige loan to repay but both the admin and the students worked wonders with the limited resources.

In NUJS also we would face the problems of very poor quality food. The Mess Committee had conducted a thorough check. Almost like an audit and found huge discrepancies. They took up the catering responsibility upon themselves. Our VC then allowed it.

For internet too we had a cyber com. Though their hardwork slowly and steadily over the years we had 100% Lan connectivity in all hostel rooms. Acad block too.

HPNLU should allow students to get involved as they are direct stakeholders. Will help resolve both the issues
Agree 20 Sept 2019, 10:54
+0 -16
Agree with you. students should end protest and peacefully attend sessions. Thats why they are here for and not for protest. Admin is experienced and knows how to tackle the situation. Strongly urge the students to not take law in their hands and infact study tenets of law under experienced faculty members of hpnlu.
Nlust 20 Sept 2019, 12:38
+5 -1
Did I hear experienced? Ad hoc teachers from Delhi favourites of Professor Rana, you do not have a single professor teaching students. Only two professors one VC and other Registrar and the rest who were struggling to get job at Delhi and other places and joined this institution due to their connection with Mr Raina. The quality is poorer than so called traditional universities.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 03:01
+0 -16
I once again state on Legally India that the administration can have no hand if a third party involves the police. I warned it yesterday and now police are indeed here. Students did not listen. Students are thus advised to call off the agitation in view of harm to their careers if any police action is taken. Disciplinary action can be waived in lieu of apology and peaceful behaviour. Talks can solve any outstanding issues. The administration are elders who care for you and take the role of parents.

I also request students of other NLUs to to repeat such behaviour.

For information, I am a neutral party with no interest in the matter.
NLU_Nagpur 20 Sept 2019, 04:43
+13 -2
It seems that you are a faculty member of HPNLU or any third party who is threatening students everyday on legallyIndia at the behest of Prof. Nishtha Jaswal.This is not UILS Chandigarh or some other traditional university.

Your gimmicks won't work. Brace yourself (All the sycophants of VC) for the rough time which is yet to come.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 03:09
+3 -9
I cannot understand why media is trying to provoke students in all NLUs and make it like JNU. Yesterday we saw a shameful incident where a respected minister of the government was assaulted by [...] of Jadavpur University in Kolkata. Kindly keep NLUs out of it .
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 04:04
+9 -3
That 'respected minister' used his goons to assault students, destroy university property, cause arson, distastefully abuse the Vice Chancellor and finally had to use his party's 'pet' governor to get himself rescued. If we are blame gaming, let's have all the facts out here. To clarify, I was actually on the spot. I have no party affiliation either, nor do I support any heckling said minister had been subjected to. I am fairly certain you weren't there.
Guest 21 Sept 2019, 02:45
+0 -2
Utter rubbish. I think I know who you are. A certain faculty member from an NLU who posted a message in Facebook about this. Please open your eyes. Babul Suprioy's hair was pulled and a female BJP politician was sexually assaulted.

https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/kolkata/babul-supriyo-thrashed-jadavpur-university-kolkata-6011022/

https://www.news18.com/news/india/bjp-leader-agnimitra-paul-physically-abused-her-clothes-torn-off-by-rowdy-crowd-in-kolkata-2317189.html
Guest 21 Sept 2019, 06:18
+2 -2
Paid and fake news. None of the people who wrote this had been on spot. I'm not arguing Babul wasn't hit. I'm saying he also did his fair share of assault, cussing, calling goons from outside (not his security) to put university gate on fire, trash university rooms and property. In fact, bjp goons kept roaming outside the university and picked up random passers-by as ju students and assaulted them long after the event.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.telegraphindia.com/amp/states/west-bengal/jadavpur-university-union-room-ransacked-fire-outside-campus/cid/1706215

And this is what your 'responsible' party leader had to say. He's nothing but an uncultured two bit goon, who compared the female students with prostitutes.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.telegraphindia.com/amp/states/west-bengal/wait-for-surgical-strike-on-jadavpur-university-bjp/cid/1706410
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 05:14
+8 -2
Any NLU would be considered lucky to be 'like JNU'. In every ranking and quality test that counts, the latter is miles ahead of every single NLU in the country at present, be it faculty, research, infra, or student quality.
Special 26 20 Sept 2019, 10:33
+2 -8
Hpnlu is one of the most promising Univ currently. Students should not protest but work together with adminstration to take Univ to greater heights. Hpnlu can be new nls nalsar nluj nujs!


Students should focus on studies and make their presence felt in nlu community. Protest will harm the reputation of the Univ and it will be the students who will be most affected. I also request the VC and admin to work for betterment of institution of this national stature. Let the peace prevail and camaraderie take shape.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 13:15
+1 -5
Such foolish students! Even if the VC resigns do you think the problems will go away? The root cause is that NLUs do not get central funding like IIT and IIM.
Agree 20 Sept 2019, 14:11
+0 -9
agree with you. students are harming their own interests by doing this.. they should get back to classes, be disciplined and obey their teachers. How can we expect these students to obey law and implement law as advcates/judges when they themselves are breaking it.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 15:14
+4 -0
None of the NLUs do. They are still mostly providing acceptable standards of food, water and basic infra, unlike hpnlu and its VC. Any VC who forces students to vacate hostels doesn't deserve to stay in power.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 17:10
+1 -0
My prediction is that the students will give up by Monday after some judge or minister will visit and give them a lot of BS which they will believe.
Guest 20 Sept 2019, 17:14
+2 -1
Here is a ranking of NLUs in terms of the effectiveness of student strikes.

1. NALSAR v Veer Singh
2.HNLU v Dukhpal
3. NLIU v SS Singh
4. NLU Ranchi v Nirmal
5. NLU Assam v VK
Doyen 23 Sept 2019, 17:27
+2 -1
The corrected truthful version is given below:
1. A few teachers of NALSAR v Veer Singh
2. A few teachers of HNLU v Sukhpal
3. A few teachers of NLIU v SS Singh
4. NLU Ranchi v Nirmal
5. A few teachers of NLU Assam v VK

Stop blaming students for protests. They are exploited by a gang of teachers and victimized by the Vice Chancellor.
Guest 21 Sept 2019, 02:42
+0 -2
Strike will be called off today. Students have come to their senses and realised the foolishness and futility of such protest.
Guest 23 Sept 2019, 06:42
+2 -3
I have so far been giving polite advice to HPNLU students. I am now giving a serious warning that it they do not call off the protest then anything can happen, including not only rustication but also arrest. It is "warning" in the sense I am not personally giving it or administration will not do it, but outside forces will get police involved. It is an advice of an elder and well-wisher.
Guest 23 Sept 2019, 10:02
+2 -1
You are no longer elderly, you have actually reached your dotage and accompanying senility. The students have not broken any law so far. Peaceful assembly and protest is a right. It is the VC who's actually broken the law by accepting hostel fees and then closing down the hostel in the middle of the semester.
Going Ape 24 Sept 2019, 00:30
+0 -0
If only there was Nishtha in providing HPNLU with a clean, transparent and efficient administration. Then again what's in a name? State and judiciary also lack Nishtha. And faculty are self-serving. Be that as it may, remember Caeser? While Julius lost it, the apes (at least in the movie) eventually understood "Apes together. Strong" Please stop apping or yapping and ape this.

PJ aside (RGNUL students failed; over to NLUD) here are certain things we may not have considered.

1. We should certainly demand and gain access to all EC, FC and AC agenda notes and minutes https://thewire.in/law/uncloaking-the-rule-of-opacity-in-national-law-universities.

2. Our university does not even mention basic RTI details - who is the PIO and FAA? who to address the DD etc? Even basic compliance with suo moto disclosures under Section 4 is missing. This needs to change and included in the list of demands.

3. Hard data helps. Can we ape NUJS? https://www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/nujs-students-win-access-to-1-8gb-of-long-hidden-admin-meeting-minutes-from-madhava-menon-times-to-date-nearly-20190218-9895

4. Can we have the Registrar and VC show proof that the Chancellor gave written instructions to threaten and evict students? I am assuming that he was busy with matters relating to elevation. If indeed the Chancellor instructed (strongly doubt) that will really tell us something. My guess is that the Registrar and VC are doing what they do best. Lie.

5. The situation at NLSIU including the much talked about "slap" from the SC judges is vastly different from the one we are facing. Also given the recent embarrassment at NLUD someone is expected to be concerned especially when NLSIU students and alumni had written letters in protest. Will be interesting to see what happens there next.

6. In Jadavpur University, the VC offered to resign to resist police deployment. Despite peaceful protests, a Nisthavan better half got police vans just because the woman behind a "successful' man is ordained to follow.....

7. Has anyone tried writing to the then Chancellor or the new one or even the Visitor? Apparently Prof Faizan Mustafa had once lamented that RGNUL students hadn't reached out to him because he would then have used his CLAT position to persuade his friend PJ. RGNUL students don't believe him (possibly rightly). But we can consider writing an open letter to Prof Mustafa who is touted to favour clean, transparent and open administration.

8. Has anyone spoken to folks in HNLU? They too faced a hostile university administration including VC and Registrar acolytes and an apathetic state government. But they persevered and it seems their hard work paid off.
Agree 24 Sept 2019, 06:54
+0 -8
HPNLU will soon become institution of eminance. Students should get back to the classes, work hard and make HPNLU even better than NLSIU. Students have a power to do so only when they channelize their energies in the right direction. I request students to listen to VC and admin and get back to normalcy.
NJ Must Go 25 Sept 2019, 13:41
+2 -0
The VC knew the demands and drawbacks of the job while taking the Chair. Trying to shift the blame on state government will not fly. If NJ felt that the government is being deaf to the needs of the institution and students, she could have even resigned. She could have even communicated transparently to us how the state is blackballing.

NJ is not going to come clean on anything. And this mess is her doing but also institutionally supported by other powerful players inside our campus and elsewhere. If there was any doubt creeping regarding what to do next, the good news at NLSIU should inspire us.

NJ must go and we must seriously consider the points made in Comment 11 (Going Ape)
Special 26 27 Sept 2019, 09:29
+0 -2
Nlu in such a beautiful city of Shimla. I think this is more than enough. If students want to party, make merry, create politics , then they should choose other irrelevant institution but not hpnlu. The institution is newly set up and it will take time for it to gain momentum in every sense , be it hostel quality, food, teaching etc. I direct students to have faith in administration and they should give their best and good the flag high. Else, they are thwarting their own destiny. God help in that case