NUJS high drama: After anti-VC petition activist students pore over financials for EC, demanded registrar resignation

NUJS student politics are hotting up the place
NUJS student politics are hotting up the place
NUJS Kolkata students have been collecting evidence of possible administrative malfunctioning at the university, including asking for the resignation of a staff member they have accused of “embezzling” university funds, and clamouring for the executive council (EC) to consider its petition of “loss of confidence” in the VC.

Students believed they had found discrepancies in the financial accounts of the college and last week, the current student body president and vice president and a few other student representatives, “barged into the office” of the college’s registrar, Surajit Mukhopadhyay, demanding his resignation, Mukhopadhyay told Legally India.

The student body president declined to confirm or deny the incident, or comment to Legally India about the matter.

NUJS VC Ishwara Bhatt said: “Students wanted information so it was made available to them.” He declined to comment further saying that the matter of allegations against the registrar was “pending before the EC”.

The registrar told Legally India: “There were students who [were given permission to] go and inspect [university documents]. The very next day they come over to my office and say, we give you 24 hours notice, we have decided you should resign. I said students can’t ask for my resignation. The executive council appoints and the executive council will dismiss [those appointed].”

“All documents were made open to them. They forced themselves into offices. The accounts office was overrun by students - students coming in and demanding that we want to [inspect] now at this very moment,” he added.

The registrar said he planned to raise the issue of this incident in the next EC meeting, which is scheduled for 8 February. He and other sources at NUJS confirmed that it is the first time in the history of the law school that students are inspecting university administration documents.

Students have so far also inspected other university records such as reports on academic standards and review of the academic staff, university sources confirmed.

Musing about the allegation, Mukhopadhyay commented: “Even today it is not fit for an academic to go into a mud-slinging match with the students. You have to dissuade them and to have to make them understand. The fact that the students were showing [as damning evidence] an audit report which is published [and not confidential] and which carries my signature along with two more signatories, shows that I am not a professional criminal and that they are so puerile.”

He added that he saw the incident as a “staged show” and an opposing faction’s “attempt to deflect attention from other [issues] at the university”, by “leaking some files” to the students.

NUJS official spokesperson Prof Ruchira Goswami commented that while the students had demanded the resignation of the registrar, after faculty engaged in dialogue the students agreed that an independent “inquiry into all financial dealings of university” and asking for “transparency” would be more constructive than demanding immediate resignations. The university has cooperated, documents have been provided to students and the matter would probably get taken up by the executive council on 8 February, she said, if the students submitted a written complaint.

The student initiative to probe accounts follows NUJS alumni having launched an online petition three weeks ago, expressing their “loss of confidence” in the present vice chancellor’s (VC) competence to run the university and requesting the chancellor’s intervention in restoring its standards. The online petition has had 428 signatories to date and sources claimed that students believe that on reaching 500 signatures it would be placed before the EC.

NUJS official spokesperson Prof Ruchira Goswami said that there was no official university position or comment she could provide on the petition.

Comments

Whatever 3 Feb 2014, 18:04
+3 -1
What is the point of breaking the news almost a month later? Also, if you really wanted details, you should've looked at the GB resolutions passed in the meeting.
I really hope next time you do some more research before coming with a news, that too almost after a month.
CBI probe needed 4 Feb 2014, 04:04
+4 -2
Few thoughts:

1. Any enquiry must start from 10 years ago, when a much-hated person was Registrar and when the CPIM was in power, and when contracts were given to businessmen with links to the CPIM.

2. The students should not wait for 500 signatories. They will never get 500 signatories. The petition has been stuck on 400 signatories for the past 2 weeks. 400 signatories is enough.

3. The students must approach someone like Amit Mitra or Derek O'Brien. As much as I dislike the Trinamool Congress, they will at least weed out the pro-CPM corrupt elements within 24 hours, and they might just push for someone neutral like Justice Ruma Pal to be made VC. I would like to see if the Registrar will show so much audacity if the Trinamool Congress goes after him.

4. The issue is now bigger than NUJS. Someone has been accused of embezzlement of public money and causing willful loss to the state. Nothing short of a CBI probe will do, and arrests must be made. It is quite possible that a Commonwealth games-like scam has been talking place for over 10 years, where NUJS has been systematically looted to fill the coffers of the CPIM, with certain officials at NUJS taking a 10% cut.

5. I am unable to understand why the reporter has used the soft term "administrative malfunctioning". The students have accused him of a CRIME.
Be a lawyer 4 Feb 2014, 07:21
+0 -0
NUJS students should initiate legal proceedings for removal of corrupt people both at NUJS-EC level and at the appropriate (depending on the NUJS Act) court.
Up and away 4 Feb 2014, 10:53
+4 -0
We know who the TMC will appoint after weeding out the pro-CPM corrupt elements.

http://www.legallyindia.com/201301043346/Law-schools/nujs-ec-gets-fortune-teller-on-wb-cms-recommendation
anon 4 Feb 2014, 04:13
+4 -2
Hats off to the students for showing the guts lacking in earlier generations at NUJS. 8 Feb will be the most crucial day in the history of the college. I hope the media will cover the events of that day in detail. The students must call TOI over that day.
Shifting base 4 Feb 2014, 04:48
+2 -3
I think Prachi should set up base at NUJS terrace hence. That way, she will not miss other important news such as, students leaving Sudhakar's classroom or students tampering with attendance registers etc. Moreover, that will save LI some overheads as that would be direct reporting - prachi, horse and mouth.
At ease 4 Feb 2014, 10:53
+0 -0
Oh we all know where all this news originates...
Guest 4 Feb 2014, 15:50
+0 -0
[quote name="Shifting base"]I think Prachi should set up base at NUJS terrace hence. That way, she will not miss other important news such as, students leaving Sudhakar's classroom or students tampering with attendance registers etc. Moreover, that will save LI some overheads as that would be direct reporting - prachi, horse and mouth.[/quote]

We want CBI and CVC to step in NUJS and arrest all the culprits for polluting NUJS and making scam with the money of the students.
Conspiracy? 4 Feb 2014, 07:00
+8 -3
Why this sudden movement against the registrar? Did the students find any document implicating him? And if the signatures are of the VC, Registrar and a senior professor (who is now at ILI), then why is the registrar being singled out. An investigation should be done to expose all the culprits and not merely one person. This appears to be done at the behest of a [...] faculty member (used to be the [...]earlier), who is now very cosy with the VC. [...] Makes no real contribution apart from playing politics. She is trying to shield the VC by taking away attention from him and his [...] leadership. She is gunning for the registrar since she is close to [...]. The registrar played a huge role in ensuring that [...] was taken to task [...]! This lady faculty has the student association representatives in her pocket and is playing them up as pawns in her larger game. Well done [...]! You're the modern day Chanakya!
NUJS oh NUJS! 4 Feb 2014, 07:38
+4 -0
Oh god! What is going on at NUJS? One controversy after another. Kick out the present administration and get in a new one, I say! Will Prof Menon or Prof Singh return to save the institution?
Memory 4 Feb 2014, 08:57
+5 -0
This is similar to the the time in [...] when the Registrar, a very well-connected [...], was found guilty of embezzling funds and purchasing 3-4 apartments at Silver Springs (valued at Rs 50 lakhs each at least). Because she had the backing of the then ruling party she was asked to go on early retirement instead of ending up in jail as was her due.

One wonders whether the same story will happen again
Guest 4 Feb 2014, 15:13
+2 -0
So now the Financial scam in NUJS has been noticed by Students also. Why Justice Kapadia remained silent on the UNIVERSITY REVIEW COMMISSION in NUJS which EC asked for it and why the financial scam in NUJS under Prof. M.P. Singh was made to suppress when it was reported by one Fcaulty of NUJS ? Mr. Singh please speak up.......... We want your reply .........

[b]APPEAL TO HON'BLE CJI - Please direct CBI and CVC to make an enquiry and submit a report to you. [/b]
kianganz 4 Feb 2014, 15:18
+2 -0
By the way, this was just published, ostensibly by an NUJS student, explaining events apparently from the students' perspective:
http://www.legallyindia.com/Blogs/clearing-the-air-against-registrar-nujs
A 6 Feb 2014, 00:44
+2 -0
[quote name="kianganz"]By the way, this was just published, ostensibly by an NUJS student, explaining events apparently from the students' perspective:
http://www.legallyindia.com/Blogs/clearing-the-air-against-registrar-nujs[/quote]


Which raises the question: why did LI publish such a shoddy report? Shouldn't you have done your homework and published these facts? It's really sad how the quality of journalism on this site has deteriorated. You should at least now do a proper report and seek comment from EC members, faculty members who quit, students who saw the documents etc. Buying a chair for Rs 11,000 and a bulb for Rs 48,000? The CBI must be brought in at once.
Prachishrivastava 6 Feb 2014, 04:02
+0 -1
Hi A

Thank you for your comment.

Notice the words "ostensibly" and "apparently" in Kian's comment? Those words take away from the credibility of information published in that blog.

Had the parties we reached out to cooperated then instead of declining to comment altogether (as is mentioned in the story)there would have been a shot at credible information on financials coming out instead of a dubious anonymous blog.

Wouldn't imagine how the anonymous blog route is more preferred than speaking to journalists who are anyway going to find out what happened and run the story with or without your comment, but at NUJS this has painfully and unreasonably been the case for far too long, as is reflected not only in the negligible comment from the VC and the "no comment" from the student body in this one but even in our other stories.

Best wishes,
Prachi
John Grisham 6 Feb 2014, 08:47
+3 -1
It is my blog post.

We refrained from approaching the press because it was an internal matter and I don't see why we should have "commented".

Our primary interest is education in a premier institution and we are under no moral obligation to comment on every issue which originates in the institution

However, since the registrar decided to take it up with the Press and term it a conspiracy, much like Tarun Tejpal, I had to write out to clear the turn of events.

Cheers!
John Grisham
Hats off 4 Feb 2014, 15:38
+6 -0
Hats off to the guts and initiative shown by NUJS students. This shows that the institution is still strong, still active, ready for change and as vibrant as it ever has been!
Guest 6 Feb 2014, 08:01
+1 -0
This is a perfect example of biased reporting. Frankly, there's a good reason that student reps may not have spoken out, that is to contain the bad press and ensure fairness of the inquiry process. If Legally India could not get get a comment from the students, the least they could have done was presented a neutral view. This article comes off as a mouthpiece for the Registrar of NUJS. Great job, you guys.
legal scholar 6 Feb 2014, 10:31
+1 -3
Friends I would like to tell you that there is absolutely no problem at NUJS. Esteemed Members of EC will give full support to Respected VC Sir and Respected Registrar Sir.

This is plot to damage image of Respected VC Sir and Respected Registrar Sir by vested interest persons who thinks that having 1 year LLM foreign degree and talking good English means you become great and better than persons having 2 year LLM degree from India from top-ranked college where many Honble Judges have studied. There is no need for CBI enquiry because all account have been done in total transparent manner. May be we need CBI enquiry against students.
Guest 6 Feb 2014, 15:57
+0 -0
[quote name="legal scholar"]Friends I would like to tell you that there is absolutely no problem at NUJS. Esteemed Members of EC will give full support to Respected VC Sir and Respected Registrar Sir.

This is plot to damage image of Respected VC Sir and Respected Registrar Sir by vested interest persons who thinks that having 1 year LLM foreign degree and talking good English means you become great and better than persons having 2 year LLM degree from India from top-ranked college where many Honble Judges have studied. There is no need for CBI enquiry because all account have been done in total transparent manner. May be we need CBI enquiry against students.[/quote]

You write : "There is no need for CBI enquiry because all account have been done in total transparent manner." Is it Really ??????
You need to wait for some time when the people will be grilled
NUJS Alum 9 Feb 2014, 14:35
+0 -0
The alumni petition has been submitted to the EC and they're deliberating on it. Decision expected by next EC meeting.