Paramjit Jaswal ends 9-yr term at RGNUL, joins SRM as VC • Search is on but interim VC controversial

Notification of Jaswal departure and interim replacement
Notification of Jaswal departure and interim replacement

RGNUL Patiala vice-chancellor (VC) Prof Paramjit Jaswal has ended his tenure of more than nine years today as a search process is ongoing for his permanent replacement.

Jaswal has confirmed to us that he has joined SRM University in Sonepat as vice-chancellor (VC) of the entire university, which offers engineering, management, medicine, law and other science and humanities degrees, including PhDs.

It launched in Sonepat, Haryana in 2013, and in Sikkim in 2014, with its precursor SRM Institute of Science and Technology, Chennai, having been deemed a university in 2002.

His tenure at RGNUL was to end on 6 February 2021.

The interim replacement not without controversy

At RGNUL, he has been replaced in the interim by the most senior professor currently at the national law school, Prof Anand Pawar.

Pawar, however, also already holds a number of senior positions: he is RGNUL’s dean of student welfare and controller of exams, which one student told us was not ideal, in terms of separation of administrative powers.

There is also potential controversy over a sexual harassment complaint having been filed against Pawar in 2018 by an RGNUL faculty member, which we have confirmed from two sources in the know.

The faculty member had approached the Punjab & Haryana high court in January 2019 to ensure constitution of the RGNUL internal complaints committee (ICC) in accordance with University Grants Commission (UGC) norms.

It is understood that the RGNUL ICC complaint is still pending and remains to be fully heard.

We have reached out to Pawar for comment.

We understand choices for the post may have been limited, since the VC position has to be occupied by a professor and apart from Jaswal, there was only the interim registrar Prof Naresh Kumar Vats.

And since the registrar and VC position can’t be occupied by the same person either, Pawar may have been the only available choice, other than potentially drafting in a judge or administrative officer as acting VC from outside.

The search for a permanent VC is on

As first reported by The Tribune last month, a search committee has been seeking a new permanent VC.

Nalsar Hyderabad vice-chancellor (VC) Prof Faizan Mustafa has been nominated by the RGNUL executive council to head up the search committee, with two other nominations of members to be made by the chairman of the UGC and the RGNUL chancellor.

9 years at RGNUL

Jaswal had taken over as VC at RGNUL after joining from HNLU Raipur in 2011.

While at RGNUL, students had repeatedly butted heads with Jaswal.

This included student protests, the removal of a controversial administrative officer (and the apparent stonewalling of attempts by students to obtain a related formal inquiry report) and more recently also questions about RGNUL’s finances, which the state government has also pursued.

In particular, we understand that the state government has been aggrieved that it has been funding RGNUL - which according to a student therefore enjoys good infrastructure and facilities - but that RGNUL also had Rs 48 crore sitting unutilised in a fixed deposit account.

However, Punjab state’s accountant general audit of RGNUL’s finances has settled all substantial paragraphs regarding the use of state funds at RGNUL from 2006 until 2018 (see audit reports below).

RGNUL under Jaswal has also begun posting minutes of its governing bodies on its website from mid-2019 (though it has still not published its full financial documents online).

2020 audit report
2020 audit report

2019 audit report
2019 audit report

Comments

rgnulinsider 1 Dec 2020, 13:34
+17 -1
Good luck, SRM. Hope you don't have to face the dark days like RGNUL had to for almost ten years. End of Jungle Raj in RGNUL. Hoping for a capable permanent VC soon.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 13:46
+12 -3
9 years of zero accountability.

Meanwhile Amita dhanda was set to retire I think two days back has been given extension by Faizan Mustafa. Last moment decision. Faizan has been quickly doling out promotions at nalsar.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:48
+4 -0
She's been appointed a professor emeritus several months back. After that, retirement age doesn't apply I think.
Nullsaaar 2 Dec 2020, 06:08
+3 -1
She has but the notification made it clear that she would continue on as dean until February because of Covid. Says something about how stable the institution is when one person retiring could topple it all.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 06:42
+3 -3
That's not very fair. The pandemic has brought unprecedented situations along with it. It's a natural administrative reaction to rely on experience in such times. Especially when such experience comes with proven competence.
Nullsaaar 3 Dec 2020, 09:34
+3 -3
That might’ve made sense if this transition hadn’t been in the works for a long time. And if the people poised to take over for her hadn’t already proved themselves over the years. And not everyone agrees that all her decisions have been good.
Guest 2 2 Dec 2020, 13:46
+1 -0
There is no post of Dean, it's is convenor academeic committee.
Nullsaaar 3 Dec 2020, 09:32
+2 -2
Kuch bhi?

Here is nalsars website describing her as dean of academic affairs https://www.nalsar.ac.in/faculty/AmitaDhanda-profile.html

We’re truly post fact here huh.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 11:00
+1 -3
neha Pathak ji is supposed to be new Dean academics
Guest 2 4 Dec 2020, 06:15
+1 -0
@2.1.1.2 You have given a misleading link. You are doing an Amit Malviya type of thing.
The link below is the correct one and will take you to the university website.
https://www.nalsar.ac.in/amita-dhanda
I do not have any issue with anyone becoming Dean or the vice chancellor. This is just to supply correct information.
Nullsaaar 4 Dec 2020, 07:42
+0 -0
You’re just wrong dude. The plaque outside her office reads dean of academic affairs. The intros on the website are intended to be informal which is why it doesn’t mention her title. Just wrong !
Guest 4 Dec 2020, 09:29
+2 -0
Website is supposed to be informal, but plaques are supposed to be formal? To see lawyers or law students making such claims is just sad.
studentreaderq 1 Dec 2020, 13:54
+7 -0
Jaswal is not welcome in SRM.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:13
+2 -0
Lizzie going to TNNLU holds the clue. Next VC will probably be Nandimath.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:25
+1 -0
Please elaborate.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:15
+3 -6
Jaswal wins here. His salary will be higher. Also better to be VC of a full university.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:18
+9 -0
PJ suffers no consequences and gets a plum position just like his friend PIB. Also ensures that acolytes hold interim VC and Registrar positions thus ensuring no embarrassing skeletons tumble out. Likely that the new VC will be "forward looking" and so the charade will continue.

Didn't Registrar Vats brief the Chancellor and his retinue that AP is facing SH charges?

Maybe PJ knows something that we don't. Such as, the Chancellor will be leaving for Delhi soon.
Suss. 2 Dec 2020, 04:27
+1 -0
Pawar was hardly an acolyte, their friction is well known on campus. Registrar on the other hand..
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:21
+3 -2
[img]https://img-9gag-fun.9cache.com/photo/a9nROEo_700b.jpg[/img]
Pupil 1 Dec 2020, 14:33
+6 -39
Prof Jaswal was an excellent VC who built RGNUL single handedly. Under Sir's leadership RGNUL topped Swachhata Ranking and achieved top 10 NIRF rank ahead of NLIU Bhopal. This year RGNUL did well in CLAT preference. Because of Sir's reference letter many student made it to top foreign colleges for LLM admission. Most importantly Sir made every effort to improve faculties despite challenges. In student initiatives Sir gave every support to recruitments and tZelus and Ritvaan fests. Sir will be badly missed. However, RGNUL will continue to improve in NIRF because of momentum Sir has built and Sir's blessings will remain with everyone.
Rgnulstudent 1 Dec 2020, 16:04
+13 -6
Please stop bootlicking. Apply your mind and speak true facts.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:39
+2 -0
Bar & Bench has kindly credited Legally India in their report. In future please credit Bar & Bench for any report copied from them.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 14:42
+2 -10
An NLU grad should be VC. Maybe Srividhya Raghavan, Mrinal Satish and Nigam Nuggehalli. Punjab is the richest and cleanest state in India, so it is a good opportunity. Patiala is also not the far from Delhi.
Nls 1 Dec 2020, 16:35
+2 -0
I don’t think Mrinal sir will leave nls. Aparna Ma’am and sir seem settled there.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 16:46
+10 -2
So far, NLU grads have a horrendous reputation as NLU VC, courtesy the Messiah of Nagarbhavi. Nigam seems a much more sorted person than Messiah though. Has got a good rep at Munjal as a wise, empathetic and intelligent head.
Guesttt 1 Dec 2020, 17:23
+2 -2
We don't want a Sudhir here, just because he's from the NLU
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 17:19
+2 -2
Possible candidates for next VC:

- Nandimath @ NLSIU
- Gurpur @ Symbi
- Afzal Wani @ GGSIP
- Vijender @ NLU Nagpur
- Nigam @ Munjal
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 18:10
+3 -0
Don't sell yourself short. I'm sure you would make an excellent candidate too. All-knowing about affairs even when you are in no way involved in them.
Insider 2 Dec 2020, 03:29
+1 -1
Include Balraj Chauhan, R Venkata Rao, Nishtha Jaswal too in your list.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 06:44
+0 -0
RVR is 70 plus. He can't join an NLU anymore as VC.
Guest 1 Dec 2020, 17:22
+6 -1
Congress party and CM Amarinder Singh's coterie will decide the next VC. Expect a Congress party chamcha.
Good 2 Dec 2020, 04:29
+3 -0
At this point the leadership can't fall any lower, so anything is an improvement.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 03:07
+1 -0
The search committee is good, in the sense that there are no political people or third-rate people. I expect a good candidate will be chosen.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 03:11
+0 -3
I agree with the Nandimath theory. One member of the anti-Sudhir camp has already fled. This opportunity is perfect for the other to run away. Then, the two of them will gang up against Sudhir at the CLAT Committee.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 06:45
+9 -0
Nobody has to gang up against Sudhir. He manages to alienate everyone whom he works with sooner or later.
Yeet 2 Dec 2020, 13:11
+6 -1
Haha no need for anyone to gang up, Sudhir does a pretty good job of kicking himself out of the CLAT committee and literally any other situation he's present in, if you count the faculty meetings he storms out of routinely
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 14:41
+2 -1
He still storms out of faculty meetings? Looks like he hasn't grown up at all back from his days at another NLU. A pity, since with a good administrator at the helm of affairs, there's no height that NLSIU cannot reach.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 16:22
+1 -0
Do you mean he zooms out of those meetings? Because given the current virtual nature of the meetings, it might be a tad difficult to storm out of any.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 17:46
+0 -0
PSJ left HNLU for RGNUL, so VCV can leave too. Same for VCs of other lower NLUs, like Gauhati, Patna, Vizag etc.
Guest 2 Dec 2020, 17:48
+0 -0
99% sure the next VC will be OVN.
LaughingBuda 2 Dec 2020, 19:48
+4 -5
Frankly a poorly written piece regarding the audit comments. If CAG irregularities were accepted on face value practically every department and ministry as well as public sector entity should have their head arrested and imprisoned. The army (maximum audit issues) should be disbanded. Fact: Financial irregularities and lapses such as these are common to all public entities and no way a reflection on the VC. I'm not Jaswals lover but to damn him based on these audit remarks shows the immaturity of the author.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 05:32
+3 -5
One wonders about your sense of logic. Everyone knows the level of corruption that prevails in the government departments. Irregularities are indicators of that. Investigations are conducted on their basis. In NLUs, the VC has sufficient power to stop/delay any investigation. Therefore, if no investigation has been conducted till date after the irregularities came to light, then that is certainly the VC's responsibility. Given the nature of NLUs, no big financial irregularity can take place without the VC being aware of it.
LaughingBuda 4 Dec 2020, 12:48
+0 -2
Thanks for agreeing with me that "everyone knows the level of corruption in government departments".

That is what was my point. If everyone is corrupt why single out this poor guy at RGNUL. I bet an audit of any other law school would throw up similar issues. And if incompetency is added even saints like Sudhir K should be jailed.

You can't bring about change on generic grounds like this simply because nobody in government will support such causes which may bite them in the back.

Till such time as there is a demand-supply mismatch in legal education gullible law students will continue preferring these government law schools where they will have no choice but to put up with the likes of Pamamjeet.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 03:12
+2 -0
RGNUL students are drafting a petition to the selection committee like the NLSIU and NLUD students had done. It will be shared with Legally India and Bar & Bench. Certain things will be tailored to RGNUL, but the core will be the same as the NLSIU and NLUD petitions , i.e:

- The person must have a track record of integrity: No prior charges of corruption, sexual harassment etc.

- The person must promise to comply with the RTI Act and not delay and cut corners.

- The person must have a strategic plan to improve faculty and involve more guest faculty.

- The person must have a strategic plan to make RGNUL a top 5 NIRF university and present it to the students.

- The person must have prior experience with the NLU system: either as a teacher, admin or alum. A person with pure TLC exposure and absolutely zero NLU exposure is undesirable

- The person must have a strong track record of research and publications.

- The person should preferably have international exposure, either through studies or teaching or research fellowships.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 05:35
+4 -0
Most of the NLU VCs who have been proven to be successful had no prior 'NLU experience' when they had joined the NLU. That's what history and statistics say. People with 'prior NLU experience' learn almost nothing about administration, given how tiny the places are, which is why they fumble the ball when they get some power. The other conditions seem okay enough.
Haha 4 Dec 2020, 05:00
+0 -2
We all saw how that worked out for NLSIU. Their VC squarely ticks almost all these categories and is currently running the institution into the ground. If the students spent all this brainpower in collectively coming up with a plan where they, as stakeholders of their own future, chart out a plan to root out the problems in the student body, maybe it would be of some use. You can't stick an NLU alum in a chair, call him VC and wave your problems away.
Guest 4 Dec 2020, 05:48
+1 -0
Running NLSIU into the ground is a bit of an exaggeration, but your point is well-taken.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 08:58
+2 -11
Sorry to say this, but no good person will ever come to RGNUL because the college has a bad reputation. Certain students protested against Prof Jaswal because of personal vendettas and gave the college a very bad name. A lot of bad things came out in the media, such as smoking/alcohol/drug use by students, ragging juniors, coming back late nights after parties, poor academic performance etc. Better not to say more, because even more serious offences are there by students which outside world does not know.
Ex-student 3 Dec 2020, 11:30
+5 -0
I protested against Paramjit. I was one of the leaders and I couldn't be more proud of getting him thrown out. [...]

[...]
Fac 3 Dec 2020, 11:41
+4 -0
Serious offences are there by the ex-Vice Chancellor and others as well which outside world only now knows. :)
Ragnoolite 4 Dec 2020, 01:08
+7 -1
"Sorry to say this, but no good person will ever come to RGNUL because the college has a bad reputation."

Having spent 5 years there, I can guarantee that it will be tough. No person can be as rigid, megalomaniac and / or egoistical as Prof Dr. Col PS Jaswal. Why does RGNUL have a bad reputation? That is a first. None of the NLUs which came around the same time (except NLU D) are better than RGNUL in any relevant metric (graduate employability, academics, infrastructure).

"Certain students protested against Prof Jaswal because of personal vendettas and gave the college a very bad name."

Wow! Do you even know what the protests were for? High handedness of the administration backed by VC. A student was suspended without following due procedure. Do read LI reports or newspaper. :-)

A lot of bad things came out in the media, such as smoking/alcohol/drug use by students, ragging juniors, coming back late nights after parties, poor academic performance etc.

It is unfortunate that students smoke and drink. If you start throwing students and colleges for this reason to the gallows, you probably will not have any college or many students left. They are 17-22 year olds who are experimenting. Cut them slack. Most of the top universities have alcohol being sold inside their campus. There is hardly a top university in the world where students and faculty don't party. How can that even be relevant? What is poor academic performance? Please do tabulate the number of students who clear judiciary, other competitive exams, get admitted to and finish their LLMs from top universities abroad.

"Better not to say more, because even more serious offences are there by students which outside world does not know."

Yes, and you sir know about it? Why don't you come out and list them out? By protecting criminals, you are becoming an accomplice. The way you've preached, I don't think that you'd want to be morally corrupt like the delinquent RGNUL students are.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 13:02
+0 -0
https://www.barandbench.com/news/karnataka-government-moves-supreme-court-nlsiu-domicile-reservation

Seriously, Kian?
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 16:09
+3 -0
Kian, with all your NLSIU contacts, how is it that you missed this story? It directly shows the declining relationship between NLSIU and the state government, and also questions the carefully built narrative that the central government through VB tacitly supports NLSIU's claim for exclusivity. Otherwise karnataka having the same party in power, it would hardly have moved to SC in this matter.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 17:27
+3 -0
I agree with 20.1. Vikramjit Banerjee is the ASG of the country. He must speak up and clarify why he argued that only NLSIU is special. I can understand Bar and Bench hushing it up, but LI must boldly highlight this.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 18:44
+0 -0
He wasn't arguing as the ASG. Didn't have any government mandate.
Ripper by Law 3 Dec 2020, 13:17
+7 -0
PSJ turned RGNUL into a fiefdom - a tiny heaven for him, his family and those who obeyed him. Every single department and level at the university was plagued by mediocrity and complacency because of this man. It took students nearly 10 years to bring only a part of the situation to the public eye. However, PSJ and his retinue is still untouched, and the road for students (in both RGNUL and SRM) is long and arduous.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 13:34
+0 -0
[quote]NLSIU Bangalore registrar Prof OV Nandimath has resigned from his position but will remain as part of faculty, according to a number of press reports (see below).

Students had publicly blamed him for delaying the appointment of new vice-chancellor (VC) Prof Sudhir Krishnaswamy last week.[/quote]

https://www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/nls-registrar-ov-nandimath-resigns-post-sudhir-appointment-20190929-10883

So it makes perfect sense for him to go to RGNUL.
Guest 3 Dec 2020, 16:10
+1 -2
I bet students are now ruing their reaction after all the antics pulled by Sudhir in the last 13 months.
Guest 7 Dec 2020, 13:41
+0 -0
OV Nandimath and Afzal Wani are both likely to apply. Faizan Mustafa and Wani are old friends. As for Nandimath, he will bank on the NLSIU tag.
Nalsarite 31 Jan 2021, 19:53
+0 -0
I visited rgnul for a competition. I had a poor impression of the vice chancellor after listening to him speak and looking at the university policies in place. Differential curfew timings for men and women reflect a backward mindset. Was of the opinion that the leadership ought to be chased out. Glad to see he has left. All the best to RGNUL.
Outsider 10 Apr 2021, 15:01
+0 -2
Prof. Nishtha Jaswal is most likely to join as VC @ RGNUL, Patna.