Shamnad Basheer - extraordinary visionary, lawyer, human being - passes away

Rest in peace, Shamnad Basheer
Rest in peace, Shamnad Basheer

Prof Shamnad Basheer, who despite his young age of 43 had become one of the most well-known, influential and impactful lawyers and academics in India, passed away earlier today in an accident.

Basheer, an NLSIU Bangalore graduate, was a pathbreaking academic, having founded the hugely influential SpicyIP blog before blawging was even a thing in India.

In 2010, he was also the founder of the Increasing Diversity by Increasing Access (IDIA) initiative, which has allowed dozens if not by now hundreds of underprivileged students to study at India’s top national law universities, providing funding and support throughout their studies.

Some of these students have already gone on to join the judicial services exams and to work in the legal profession.

Basheer has probably single-handledly done more to change the dialogue around privilege in the legal profession than any other lawyer in recent times.

After leaving NUJS Kolkata in 2014, where he had held the MHRD ministry’s IP chair professorship, he had spent his time tirelessly growing IDIA, working on institutionalising it, and teaching at several universities.

Basheer had been suffering from ill health for a number of years now.

His is truly a big loss for the legal community, but fortunately for the profession, his legacy is bound to endure, as evidenced by the outpouring of grief and accolades.

Update 20:27: IDIA executive vice president Aditi Kamath has made the following statement, with a detailed official statement to follow separately:

It deeply saddens us to inform you that our founder and managing trustee, Prof. Shamnad Basheer has passed away. Each of us not only grieves at the passing of such a tremendous individual but also for the loss the IDIA family suffers.

IDIA will continue to carry forward his legacy and work towards equitable access to legal education. At this difficult moment, we continue to count on the kind support that you have shown towards IDIA over the years.

NLU Delhi intellectual property (IP) professor Yogesh Pai:

The news of Prof. Shamnad Basheer’s untimely and tragic demise comes with unimaginable sadness and utter shock. He was not just a brilliant academician but a dear friend, and a benevolent mentor to many. A scholar par excellence, a deep thinking academic, who shaped the course of IP law and policy in India with several legal interventions, Public Interest Litigations, high-impact scholarship, and path-breaking legal activism.

Above all, a wonderful human being, a great humanist, who made a difference in the lives of many an underprivileged student through his enduring efforts in the founding and functioning of IDIA. The void he has left can never be filled, but the profound impact he made as a scholar, mentor, and friend will always live on in fond memories. He will be truly and dearly missed. His legacy carries on in the heart of every person whose life he touched.

The disability sector in India is richer for Shamnad Basheer’s contributions - his support to the work around the Copyright Law Amendment for accessibility of published works, and the inclusion of young lawyers with disability in the IDIA programme. Rest in power, Shamnad. -Amba (@MumbaiCentral)

Shocked and pained to hear abt the untimely death of Prof @shamnad Basheer in an accident. His contribution to the legal field is unmatched particularly through @IDIALaw & @SpicyIP. I hope someone takes the baton of @IDIALaw forward to help underprivileged venture into law. -Abhishek Dubey (@abhishekcdubey)

Founder of @IDIALaw and SpicyIP & one of the most humble person I ever met, Prof. @shamnad Basheer is no more. He fulfilled dreams of more than half a century underprivileged students, including me, study in top law schools. I literally owe my life to him. #RIPShamnadBashee - Manash Mandal (@ManashManav)

I am shocked beyond words to hear that Prof. Shamnad Basheer has passed away in a tragic accident. His fight for the rights of underprivileged students & their access to legal education cannot be forgotten. It’s an irreparable loss to the entire legal fraternity. -Jay Sayta (@jnsayta)

Shocked to hear this. What a tragic untimely death of an idealist and scholar, devoted to his students, worked tirelessly for equal opportunities. Terrible loss. -Sagarika Ghose (\@sagarikaghos)

Such a sad day. The brilliant, humane Prof Shamnad Basheer is no more. He gave so selflessly, worked tirelessly to get disadvantaged people access to quality legal education. Why are good people going early?? So many people will remember him fondly and with gratitude - Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha)

Prof Shamnad Basheer’s death is a truly devastating loss to the Indian legal community. He led the fight to make the CLAT more accountable over the years, and was the leader in the fight for access to legal education. - Vensy (@vensykrishna)

It’s hard to accept that the years hold no more wonderful, inspiring conversations with Shamnad. He taught me what hope and heart count for. It was a privilege to see him build IDIA, and to stand up for the vulnerable even when his energy was fading. Rest in power, my friend. - Chinmayi Arun (@chinmayiarun)

@inabluehouse Impossible to believe that Shamnad is gone. The most generous and kind soul and a visionary. @IDIALaw and the legal academy will be poorer without him. It’s deeply saddening to know that he is no more. Irreparable loss to legal education! -Jhuma Sen (@inabluehouse)

Heart broken to hear the news of Shamnad Basheer @shamnad passing away. The world desperately needs more people like him. He was one of the finest legal scholars of his generation, but what set him apart was a desperate urge to make the world a better place! Alas, it has 1 less. His work and memory can never be diminished. We all owe it to him and the legal profession to keep his work going - and there is no better cause than supporting his brain child - @IDIALaw. RIP Shamnad -Mohit Abraham (@abraham_mohit)

Comments

Well wisher 8 Aug 2019, 13:54
+30 -7
How tragic .....so few work tirelessly and selflessly for others. RIP Shamnad
Facepalm 9 Aug 2019, 06:46
+21 -6
I want to know who are these people who objected to this comment and why they did so.
Taint 9 Aug 2019, 12:56
+11 -3
Some crazy, paranoid, deranged person who most probably who had an axe to grind with him.
Garden walker 9 Aug 2019, 17:24
+9 -4
Yeah.. everyone knows who that person is. Thanks to incessant trolling and spamming.
NUJS 2013 8 Aug 2019, 14:08
+24 -7
The good pass away early they say....

... You will be missed Sir! Thank you for your yeoman service to the legal fraternity at large and being a guide to us in our formative years. May your soul attain moksha!
Mentee 8 Aug 2019, 14:15
+15 -7
We still needed you sir. The world won't be same without you.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 14:20
+12 -0
RIP. A big loss also for the #NationaliseNLUs movement seeking accountability from VCs and end corruption. His petition had made the SC set up the CLAT Consortium (although one VC takes credit for it) and ask the govt why National status cannot be given. Now there is no one to follow up on the petition and it will lapse.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 14:23
+64 -0
NUJS should start a Shamnad Basheer IDIA Memorial Lecture (for speakers below 45 doing pathbreaking work) + a medal for best IP student.
Needs to be done 9 Aug 2019, 11:46
+15 -1
1. Madhava Menon Medal for Best Student in Administrative Law + Annual Memorial Lecture in Administrative Law
2. Shamnad Basheer Medal for Best Student in IP Law + Biannual IDIA Lecture Series (for young speakers)
3. Jyoti Basu Policy Fellowship + Annual Law and Socialism Lecture Series
4. Dipankar Gupta Litigation Fellowship + Annual Lecture in Professional Ethics
5. Somnath Chatterjee Policy Fellowship + Annual Lecture in Political Science

The new NUJS VC should institute all these to honour these deceased people who helped the college.
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 18:50
+2 -6
Who pays for the fellowships and the lectures?
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 14:28
+11 -11
He died in an ACCIDENT not disease. Very insensitive.

https://barandbench.com/idia-founder-professor-shamnad-basheer-is-no-more/
kianganz 8 Aug 2019, 15:09
+36 -7
Our article states that he died in an accident in the first paragraph. But sadly, separately from that, he was also quite ill for much of the last few years, though it didn't seem to slow him down much or diminish his enthusiasm or passion.

He was and will forever remain a truly inspiring human being.
Not for publication 11 Aug 2019, 06:39
+2 -0
Hi Kian,

I'm trying the dark mode in LI. While it's generally great, but a couple of suggestions: (a) in this comment of yours, the colour of the text of your comment is too dark to work on the dark mode; and (b) if possible, the place where folks type comments should also be dark - right now it's the morning, but during night time, the white background is hard on the eyes.
Sad Day 8 Aug 2019, 14:36
+8 -4
This is truly a loss for the entire legal fraternity.
Rest in Peace, Sir.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 15:50
+12 -0
His last unfulfilled dream was to see #NationaliseNLUs and #MakeVCsAccountable come to fruition.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 15:56
+8 -3
What about his PIL on legal academicians practising??? What happens to that???
Anon241 9 Aug 2019, 08:42
+5 -0
Professor Basheer had instituted something called Public Interest Fellows. These young lawyers are actively building a case to get the BCI rule scrapped
rip 8 Aug 2019, 16:03
+7 -3
rip basheer. you made the world a better place.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 16:10
+10 -2
Spent last few years at law school thinking abt this man and that maybe would get to meet him. Rest in peace sir.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 16:33
+9 -2
Shamnad Basheer - extraordinary human being, and everything else follows that!
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 17:26
+2 -0
Three important people associated with NUJS passed away this year: Prof Menon (founder), Dipankar Gupta (backer in early days) and now Shamnad (started IDIA from there). I hope the new NUJS VC will do something permanent in their memory. A visiting chair or lecture series may be good, as it will ensure some good academicians and lawyers interact with the students. The families of all the 3 people should be contacted.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 17:38
+3 -0
[i]Shamnad Basheer is suspected to have asphyxiated in his car, police believe that he may have slept off in the car with the heater on.
[/i]

If this is the case I request media and social media posters not to speculate and say he was in bad health (when he never mentioned any specific disease and nobody knows).

https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/idia-founder-and-ip-rights-expert-shamnad-basheer-dies-43-106888
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 17:47
+3 -0
[quote]His colleagues fear that he may have asphyxiated two days ago. A colleague told TNM that there were roadblocks due to landslides and Shamnad may have sat in the car waiting for help. The body could not be retrieved for many hours, and was taken out only after 7.45 pm on Thursday.

Superintendent of Police of Chikkamagaluru Harish Pandey told TNM that they don't suspect any foul play as of now. "He may have slept off in the car, and left the heater on. There was a key in the ignition. He had been incommunicado for five days. We mounted a search last night but could not find the car. Today we made a detailed search. There is dense fog and one can't see anything," he said.[/quote]

So it looks like he was stranded in a remote area in bad weather with no mobile signal and stuck in a car for days without food and water.

https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/idia-founder-and-ip-rights-expert-shamnad-basheer-dies-43-106888
Terrible news 8 Aug 2019, 18:09
+5 -0
This is what he died of it seems. As the article says, rare but deadly.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/carbon-monoxide-poison-drayton-valley-conklin-exhaust-1.4484037
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 18:32
+5 -1
Heartbreaking news. Shamnad was truly one of a kind. He will be missed sorely.
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 19:39
+5 -1
Shamnad Basheer is a real hero!
Guest 8 Aug 2019, 20:22
+1 -9
We should be concerned about IDIA now. Maybe one of the good NLU alumni profs can take over the baton.
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 07:00
+24 -3
We don't need Alumni of any NLU, thanks for your concern we have good team and Prof. Basheer is with us not physically but in our heart. IDIA will continue as same as the time of Sir.
Pearlpet 10 Aug 2019, 18:06
+7 -1
RIP Shamnad sir. I was not your student but am thankful to IDIA for so much it has given to so many people in this country.

I feel IDIA should be run by an NUJS professor to continue the NUJS connection of Shamnad. There are many brilliant NLU almni professors in the faculty, especially Tilottama madam who has spent many late nights and so much hard work in raising the calibre of NUJS students. Another choice is Shammek sir who recently was nominated on the IJCTRS an also received the FDM Award for 2019.
Guest2019 9 Aug 2019, 02:41
+5 -1
Shamnad was a wonderful person - someone who genuinely cared about breaking through the barriers to higher education that the lack of privilege raises.

I will always recall with fondness his passion for IDIA and his desire to implement the change that others only spoke of. You will be sorely missed, Shamnad.
Mentee 12 Aug 2019, 01:20
+2 -0
Next level trolling. I read this website only for the comments, really.
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 04:47
+5 -1
Will miss Shamnad, who was a fount of knowledge on IP matters and such a lovely person, too. His insights on several issues was a great help in writing my regular column (Patently Absurd) on IP matters. Shamnad's commendations were the ultimate accolade
tribute 9 Aug 2019, 07:07
+4 -2
Someone should read the tribute that one of his classmates sent out this morning. Personal and heartfelt. Dont have it to post it here.
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 13:43
+3 -0
It is by Gopal S and posted on LiveLaw.

https://www.livelaw.in/columns/the-art-of-kindness-147051
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 11:49
+2 -0
[quote]Bengaluru: Mystery shrouds IPR expert’s death

However, suspicions are abound about the manner in which Shamnad Basheer died. According to a theory, he might have slept off in his car with the heater on and might have died of asphyxiation.[/quote]

https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/090819/bengaluru-mystery-shrouds-ipr-experts-death.html
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 12:00
+6 -2
Just like all great and good men are persecute by small and evil men, he too was persecuted by a small and evil man at NUJS. Even though the small and evil man will outlive him, history will remember the great and good man, not the small and evil man.
Bhumesh Verma 9 Aug 2019, 12:02
+6 -0
Will miss Shamnad, a good friend, visionary and mentor - gone too early, had a lot to offer to the fraternity. He and his legacy will live forever in hearts of people whose lives he enlivened and changed forever. I used to tease - an IDIA can change lives.
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 13:46
+3 -1
Can anyone from NUJS say whether there is a plan to do anything in Shamnad's memory (or for that matter others who were associated with NUJS, like Menon, Althmas Kabir, Dipankar Gupta etc )?
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 17:25
+5 -0
Prabhash Rajan has revealed some important information on Facebook today. He said that MP Singh, Shamnad and he tried to bring a lot of academic reforms to NUJS, but was resisted by older faculty members. Also, Prabhash has disclosed that after he left NUJS in Bhat's tenure and joint NLUJ, Shamnad supported him and passed on information to Legally India about Bhat's treatment of Prabhash. In other words, Shamnad was a whistleblower source for Legally India's stories on Bhat's misrule. I hope Kian will not censor this post. As a journalist you do not have to disclose your sources and you can refuse comment, but it needs to be shared after Shamnad's demise that he was a whistleblower source for exposing corruption and misrule.

https://www.facebook.com/prabhash.ranjan.58/posts/10156200116052676
Guest 9 Aug 2019, 19:46
+1 -0
[quote]“He had parked and locked his car from inside and the cause of death is either suffocation or carbon monoxide poisoning because he must have switched on his heater, because after some time it led to short-circuit,” Chikkamagaluru Superintendent of Police Harish Pandey told PTI.
[/quote]

https://scroll.in/latest/933369/legal-scholar-shamnad-basheer-may-have-died-inside-car-due-to-suffocation-say-karnataka-police

[quote]Legal scholar Shamnad Basheer, 43, who was found dead in his car in the Bababudanagiri hills in Karnataka’s Chikkamagaluru district on Thursday evening, died due to suffocation from a lack of oxygen in the car, a post-mortem conducted on Friday has indicated.
[/quote]

[quote]A short circuit is suspected to have resulted in fumes engulfing the interior of the car, where Basheer is suspected to have been seated alone. [/quote]

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/idia-founder-basheer-may-have-suffocated-due-to-lack-of-oxygen-says-post-mortem-report-5893189/
Guest 10 Aug 2019, 03:37
+2 -1
Inspiring!
August Company 10 Aug 2019, 10:08
+6 -0
Good by my Friend! You leave a legacy, which is second to none. You worked for the betterment of society and now it’s time for you to take a break and guide us as we embark on that wonderful journey you started.
RIP 11 Aug 2019, 11:56
+4 -0
If you want to truly remember Shamnad, then please continue his legacy by fighting for NLU Nationalisation, transparency in administration, end to moral policing by VCs and Registrars, and scholarships for financially weak students (if admin says there is no money, then it is their job to raise money!!!).

Shamnad himself would have preferred that people remember him by deeds and not words. There is plenty of unfinished business.
Qrius Jorge 14 May 2022, 15:56
+1 -0
Just bumping this up in loving memory of Prof. Basheer, and the deep impact he's had on countless folks in the legal fraternity.
LegallyIndia 16 May 2022, 13:18
+0 -0
+1