3-moot Sunday: Nalsar, NLSIU, GLC victories at Henry Dunant, B R Sawhney, Surana Trial South; NLU-J, NLSIU in MPL 3 lead

Reigning MPL champion [[Nalsar Hyderabad]] started this season with a Tier 3 moot win at the [[Henry Dunant Memorial Moot Court Competition]] at New Delhi after defeating rivals [[NLSIU Bangalore]] in the final round. NLSIU, which finished third in last season’s MPL, won the Hyderabad-based [[Nalsar Justice Bodh Raj Sawhney Moot Court Competition|Nalsar-Bodh Raj Sawhney Moot]], after defeating [[GNLU Gandhinagar]] but NLSIU lost to [[GLC Mumbai]] in the finals of the [[Surana & Surana National Trial Advocacy|Surana Trial Advocacy South Moot]] at Kochi.

MPL3: Stronger, faster, better, fairer
MPL3: Stronger, faster, better, fairer

NLSIU gained the most points in this MPL 3 Super Sunday which consisted of one Tier 3 moot and two Tier 5 moots. However, [[NLU Jodhpur]] continues at the top the [[MPL 3 Season Standings]] after winning the best memorandum at Henry Dunant.

The weekend saw six new colleges enter the third season of the MPL by earning points at the three moots.

Henry Dunant – Nalsar v. NLS

After four mooting weekends this season, Nalsar Hyderabad has been conspicuous by its absence in the MPL 3 standings. But now the two-time MPL champion started the new season with a bang by winning a choice Tier 3 moot, after defeating NLSIU in the final round.

[[Jindal Global Law School]], which won the [[NLSIU International Arbitration Moot Court|NLS Arbitration moot]] late last season, finished semifinalists and also won the best speaker award. NLU Jodhpur bagged the best memorandum award and [[NLU Delhi]] finished semifinalists in the moot.

The Henry Dunant moot saw large participation of sixty teams from across the country. The Nalsar team consisted of speakers Swati Singh and Arushi Garg, along with researcher Shuchita Thapar.

Singh said that the team enjoyed the overall experience in the moot, which was quite intense. “We had a lot of fun arguing in the final rounds. The NLS team was also really good. The judges for the finals were awesome. Justice Ravindra Bhat from the Delhi High Court was on the bench.” Singh said that the judging in the initial rounds was fine, but could have definitely been better. “The prelim rounds saw 60 teams participating and we had to argue for both the sides all the time. After the prelims, sixteen teams qualified to the next round based on aggregate scores.”

{source}

{/source}

The moot was organised by the International Committee of the Red Cross and the Indian Society of International Law. The problem was based on international humanitarian law and was set up before the International Criminal Court.

Surana Trial Advocacy South – GLC v. NLSIU

Continuing with its impressive start to the season, GLC Mumbai emerged victorious in the Surana Trial Advocacy south rounds, after defeating NLS Bangalore in the final rounds. GLC is currently positioned third position in the MPL standings, behind NLU Jodhpur and NLS Bangalore. GLC speaker Yuvaraj Choksy won the best speaker award. [[SOEL Chennai]] won the best memorandum award while [[ILS Pune]] and [[School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur]] finished semifinalists in the moot. 15 teams participated in this Tier 5 moot.

The GLC team consisted of speakers Yuvaraj Chosky and Madhavi Doshi, along with researchers Toyesh Tiwari, Aparna Bagree. Choksy said that the moot was a satisfying experience for the team. “It was the first moot for both the speakers in the team and we had a good experience. The quality of judging in the finals was really good as we had a sessions court judge on the bench. We never lost a round and remained unbeaten.” Chosky appreciated the competition in the moot and said that their margin of victory was narrow in most of the rounds. “We never expected to get past even the preliminary rounds. We were a bit inspired by the trials shown in some old English movies, but some of our team mates also visited the Bombay sessions court to see how a trial works. At the end, it worked for us and we enjoyed the good experience. The moot was also organised very well.”

B. R. Sawhney Moot – NLSIU v. GNLU

NLSIU Bangalore got the better of [[GNLU Gandhinagar]] in the final rounds of the moot, after NLS defeated [[NUJS Kolkata]] and GNLU emerged victorious against [[ILS Pune]] in the semis. Chitra George from ILS Pune won the best speaker award and [[RGNUL Patiala]] won the best memorandum award.

The NLSIU team consisted of Shwetank Ginodia, Subhang Nair and Pushan Dwivedi. Ginodia told Legally India: “The moot was very well organised and the Nalsar organising team did a great job. The judges during the prelim rounds up till the semis were excellent and in the final rounds we had judges from the Andhra Pradesh High Court on the bench. In the earlier rounds, we had a mix of Nalsar alumni and some experts. Mohsin Alam, L. Ravichander and Arvind Narrain are a few names that I can remember. They questioned us extremely well on our knowledge of the intricacies in the law.” Ginodia also acknowledged the intense competition in the moot and the well-drafted moot problem. “Both the semis against NUJS and the finals against GNLU were tough rounds and we are glad we won it. The moot problem was based on constitutional law and dealt with whether a student organisation in a college can discriminate based on religion and homosexuality. It was a very nice experience”.

Chand Chopra from Nalsar Hyderabad confirmed the results and said that 21 teams participated in the moot. The moot was organised by the Justice B. R. Sawhney Memorial Trust in collaboration with Nalsar. Since Nalsar did not participate in the moot, it earned the newly introduced MPL organiser points.

Check and like for winning photos and more mooting goodness.

[[Mooting Premier League 3 season standings]]

PosLaw schoolPtsDetails
1NLU Jodhpur40[Dunant] (best memo); Trial Adv North (silver, best speaker, best memo); IICLAM (gold);
2NLSIU Bangalore40[Dunant] (silver); [B.R. Sawhney] (gold); [Trial Adv South] (silver); Raj Anand Moot (semis); Maritime Arbitration (silver, best memo, hon men for best resp memo);
3GLC Mumbai31[Trial Adv South] (gold, best speaker); IICLAM (Best Memo); Raj Anand Moot (silver);
4Campus Law Centre Delhi23Raj Anand Moot (gold, best speaker);
5NLIU Bhopal22SLCU Moot (gold); Raj Anand Moot (semis, best memo);
6Nalsar Hyderabad21[Dunant] (gold); B.R. Sawhney organiser;
7NUJS Kolkata21[B.R. Sawhney] (semis);SLCU Moot (silver, best speaker, best memo); Trial Adv North (semis);
8School of Law, Christ University, Bangalore17IICLAM (silver, best speaker); SLCU organiser;
9Jindal Global Law School15[Dunant] (best speaker, semis);
10GNLU Gandhinagar15[B.R. Sawhney] (silver); Trial Adv North (gold);
11ILS Pune11[B.R. Sawhney] (best speaker, semis); [Trial Adv South] (semis);
12NLU Delhi7[Dunant] (semis); IICLAM organiser;
13[[RGNUL Patiala]]5B.R. Sawhney (best memo);
13[[SOEL Chennai]]5[Trial Adv South] (best memo);
15KLE Bangalore4IICLAM (semis);
15Symbiosis Law School, Pune4IICLAM (semis);
17HNLU Raipur3SLCU Moot (semis);
17RMLNLU Lucknow3Trial Adv North (semis);
17ULC Bangalore3SLCU Moot (semis);
17School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur3[Trial Adv South] (semis);

For more information please refer to the [[MPL 3 rulebook]].

Comments

Rooshka 26 Sept 2011, 09:45
+0 -0
Well done Yuvraj! Great going!
nludelhite 26 Sept 2011, 12:45
+0 -0
by the way this was the opening moot for NLU Delhi this season.
dabang 28 Sept 2011, 15:09
+0 -0
beta nlu d took part in ramaia moot in blore also where they lost in prelims
Sattwik 26 Sept 2011, 14:44
+0 -0
RGNUL won the Best Memorial Award at B.R. Sawhney Moot. The MPL-3 points table mention it. Kindly look into the same.
NLU, Delhi 26 Sept 2011, 15:43
+1 -0
@Kian

NLU, Delhi won the best researcher award. Won't they be awarded any points for it?

Please look into it.
kianganz 26 Sept 2011, 20:21
+1 -0
It didn't seem like any of the 3 moots had researcher awards - for which one did NLU Delhi win the researcher?

Rules for the three moots:
Dunant: http://www.isil-aca.org/download/2011/moot_court_rules_22-25-09-11.pdf
BR Sawhney: http://www.nalsar.ac.in/Bodhraj_Moot/BR%20Sawhney%202011,%20Final%20Rules%202011.pdf
Trial Advocacy South: http://mootsite.com/pdf/National%20Trial%20Advocacy%20Moot%202010%20-%20Rules.pdf
MOOTS 27 Sept 2011, 09:09
+0 -0
dont be so hungry for points.....do well,you will get....dont claim on something which is not there
Point Checker 26 Sept 2011, 16:01
+0 -0
RGNUL should have 5 points for best memo. Kindly correct it.
kianganz 26 Sept 2011, 20:19
+0 -0
Thanks - has now been fixed, sorry about that...
arthur 26 Sept 2011, 18:36
+0 -0
a perfect start for the country's best law school:nls-b
abc 27 Sept 2011, 17:23
+0 -0
its funny to see that you need to specify that now :P
MS 27 Sept 2011, 07:17
+1 -0
Bullcrap !!! JGLS winning the best orator...he wasn't all that great...I wonder how could this happen...their coach sat as judge in one of the round and was later with the team...huh....against natural justice as well... Kudos to NLS & NALSAR...their teams were outstanding ....
Crybaby 28 Sept 2011, 20:38
+1 -0
Sour Grapes
Al 29 Sept 2011, 09:45
+0 -0
At least he won the best orator, while your just the retard who hasn't won a thing.

You also seem to be the kind of retard who does not go to a national law school but loves to kiss and perhaps even wipe and shine their ass
Jatin Garg 27 Sept 2011, 08:52
+0 -0
RGNUL PATIALA HAS BEEN ALLOTED TO DIFFERENT POSITIONS 13TH AND 17TH RESPECTIVELY, one for best memo in BR SAWHNEY and one for Semis in the same....please correct the same.....
kianganz 27 Sept 2011, 09:00
+0 -0
Sorry - RGNUL should only be in 13th - the position in 17th was there in error. Best, Kian
Point Checker 28 Sept 2011, 02:01
+0 -0
Learn how to or how not to use the damn CAPS LOCK. Oh and while you're at it, learn grammar.
misleading 27 Sept 2011, 08:56
+1 -0
Article says
- "However, NLU Jodhpur continues at the top the MPL 3 Season Standings after winning the best memorandum at Henry Dunant"

But, both NLSIU and NLU Jodhpur have 40 points each. The line seems to be misleading.
nls bangalore 27 Sept 2011, 09:12
+3 -0
leave it...it does not matter.Nowadays, no one goes by headlines...people will find it out and yes, NLU J is doing well, it deserves to be publicized for sometime...
Duh 1 Oct 2011, 14:18
+2 -0
Is it so hard to understand plain english? NLU J was at the top last week, and it continues to be at the top. It might have been joined by nls at the top.. but it still continues to be at the top..!!!

[quote name="misleading"]Article says
- "However, NLU Jodhpur continues at the top the MPL 3 Season Standings after winning the best memorandum at Henry Dunant"

But, both NLSIU and NLU Jodhpur have 40 points each. The line seems to be misleading.[/quote]
@Kian 27 Sept 2011, 09:27
+0 -0
NLU Delhi won best researcher at Henry Dunant. Please confirm with organisers
@Kian 27 Sept 2011, 11:11
+0 -0
It's true. NLUD won the Best Researcher award at Henry Dunant. Another 10 points to NLUD.
abc 27 Sept 2011, 11:37
+2 -0
Another 5 points to NLU D for ccribbing so much?
calulator 27 Sept 2011, 11:52
+0 -0
I guess RGNUL got total 8 point from BR Sawheny moot ...best memo and semi final....please add remaining three points also.
kianganz 27 Sept 2011, 11:53
+2 -0
RGNUL was not in the semi finals of BR Sawhney, I think... We are investigating NLU Delhi in Dunant...
Yuvraj 27 Sept 2011, 13:23
+0 -0
Thanks a lot @rooshka!
menon fan 27 Sept 2011, 14:09
+6 -0
NUJS will be back with a bang soon. Currently the convener is busy with certain more important pursuits. :)

Go menon
Al 29 Sept 2011, 09:56
+0 -0
God its like u have a PHD in Ass Kissing
menon fan 29 Sept 2011, 11:05
+2 -0
If only you knew what the 'more important pursuits' were... an inside joke. and whats the point of anon. ass kissing?
menon fan 29 Sept 2011, 11:05
+3 -0
but noojies do have a phd in ass kiCKing. wait and watch
a 27 Sept 2011, 15:26
+0 -0
can anyone tel who all from nujs participated in b r sawhny moot court competition
Dunnant Participant 27 Sept 2011, 16:30
+0 -0
NLU Delhi did win best researcher at Dunnant. However there was no researcher test for the same nor was it given to the team which won the best memo. There was no criteria for the judgement of the same...it just seemed they wanted to acomodate the semi finalist teams, the way they gave the best speaker to jindal...who was not worth it.
MPL Live 27 Sept 2011, 17:52
+0 -0
Hi,

Thanks for your comment.

As mentioned earlier, Rule 6 of the Dunant moot rules (available here: http://www.isil-aca.org/download/2011/moot_court_rules_22-25-09-11.pdf) do not envisage an award for the best researcher.

We could not contact organiser Prof. Vinai Kumar Singh today. We'll follow up with him and find out if the alleged best researcher award given to NLU Delhi was official or not.

Thanks!

Cheers,
Prashanth
Dubby 30 Sept 2011, 11:38
+0 -0
Perhaps if you learnt to spell Dunant correctly you might have a better chance next time. You sound like you'll develop into the kind of lawyer who casts aspersions on the Judge's integrity everytime he loses a case in court.
Dubby 28 Sept 2011, 11:33
+0 -0
Considering the angst of some of the commenters (#7 and 16) about unfair awards could you give the names of all those who have undeservedly won best speaker, best meo and best researchers.

All this whining seems to suggest that some people (who choose not to identify their schools) are poor losers. No one likes losing and since all judgements in competitions like these are subjective there is bound to be dissent. However, complaints of malpractice are beyond the pale. in the past I have seen commenters claiming that Jindal participants' memos are drafted by their faculty. Besides the defaatory aspect of the charge, the sheer arrogance is astounding. It implies that these wonderful students have a better grasp of the law than the Jindal faculty. I suggest you guys grow up instead of complaining "we was robbed".
Akshay 28 Sept 2011, 17:53
+0 -0
Good to see GLC doing well..The institution (or rather its students) deserve more credit than they are sometimes given..
glc 29 Sept 2011, 11:07
+0 -0
hey, is it true that the GLC prici has filed a sexual harassment case against some of the prof.s? clarify pls
Moots 15 Oct 2011, 15:21
+1 -0
Why is MPL going so slow in covering things....?Kindly update us with the results at Nani Palkiwala and other moots which happened this week...