NUJS makes last 4 at ELSA WTO moot Geneva as NLS packs bags for Lachs Asia again

MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting
MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting
NUJS Kolkata just behind third-ranked Jodhpur in the Mooting Premier League (MPL) 4.

MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting
MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting

NUJS Kolkata snatched back its third rank is only 3 points away from NLU Jodhpur’s third place in the Mooting Premier League (MPL) 4 after breaking into the semi-finals of the Tier 4 ELSA World rounds in Geneva, as NLSIU Bangalore yesterday bested NLU Jodhpur in the finals of the Manfred Lachs funding rounds.

Correction: The original story had erroneously reported that ELSA was a Tier 2 moot, wrongly putting NUJS into third place in the rankings. We regret the error.

NUJS had qualified for the ELSA worlds in March alongside Amity Delhi.

But while the latter didn’t make it out of the prelims in Geneva, NUJS’ Satchit Bhogle, Anviti Chaturvedi, Aanchal Dalal and Shruthi Anand were only knocked out in the semi finals and Chaturvedi bagged a best speaker in the prelims citation for the team.

Because the ELSA Tier 2 World Class Tier 4 Moot does not have an overall best speaker citation, the best speaker in the preliminary rounds prize attracts 20 8 points in the Mooting Premier League (MPL) 4 sponsored by Herbert Smith Freehills.

In addition, NUJS won 15 4 points for its semi final place, but keeping Kolkata just behind ICC Trial- and Commonwealth-scorer Jodhpur in the MPL rankings after Jodhpur picked up finalist points in the Manfred Lachs Indian funding rounds.

NLS triumphs at Manfred Lachs funding rounds again, Jodhpur holds on to third place

NLSIU Bangalore yesterday won the Manfred Lachs funding rounds against NLU Jodhpur at the qualification moot jointly organised by NLSIU and International Space Research Organisation (ISRO).

NLSIU is now in the offing to repeat its 2009 and 2012 wins at the Lachs World Rounds, if they can advance past the Asia Pacific rounds that will be held in June.

At Lachs’ funding rounds yesterday NUJS’ Joachim Saldanha won the best speaker citation. RMLNLU Lucknow was the other semi finalist.

MPL 4 Quicklinks:

NLSIU Bangalore’s Aniruddha Basu, Radhika Kapoor and Ashrutha Rai’s win and citation yesterday made the law school 15 points more comfortable in their MPL 4 lead, widening the gap to persistent follower NLU Delhi to almost 50 points. Speakers Basu and Kapoor also won the best speakers in the finals citation, Basu told Legally India.

Basu said: “What happens [At NLS] is that we have a really great support structure in place, also because we have been recent champions in this moot. So there is a great deal of guidance from seniors.”

He said that focusing on the “larger parameters in international law” and the “larger framework” was a perspective that has helped the law school perform well at Lachs. After NLSIU won both Lachs and Jessup world trophies this year, its moot court society convenor told Legally India that administrative and alumni support, coupled with rigorous internal rounds had contributed to the law school’s mooting success.

The best memorial citation was not declared at the competition yesterday, because the moot’s organisers select other Indian teams for the Asia Pacific rounds of Manfred Lachs based on their written submissions. The Asia pacific rounds are scheduled to be held on 1 and 2 June 2013.

Remaining MPL moots

1 to 2 June: Lachs Asia-Pacific Rounds (Tier 4)

8 to 12 July: Maritime International Arbitration Moot (Tier 5)

International law firm Herbert Smith Freehills is sponsoring the Mooting Premier League (MPL) and will contribute a prize pool of Rs 60,000 for the top three winning colleges.

[[Mooting Premier League 4 season standings]]

PosLaw schoolT1T2T3T4T5OrgWR/uS/FB SB M/RHMPtsDetails
1[[NLSIU Bangalore]]170804128523252319Rizvi Moot (Semis); Surana Trial - South (Gold); Manfred Lachs Space Moot World Rounds (Gold, memo, speaker); Stetson South India (Gold); Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers (Silver, speaker); KK Luthra Criminal (semis); Jessup South Rounds (Gold, memo, speaker); GIMC (silver); Kerala Law Academy (semis) NUJS Herbert Smith (Best Memo) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Runners Up) (Best Researcher) (Best Memo); Vis, Vienna (Honorable Mention- Speaker) Jessup World Rounds (Winners) (Honorable Mentions- 2nd Best Oralist, Best Speaker in Finals); NLS Arbitration (Org); NLSIU: Lachs funding (gold)
2[[NLU Delhi]]30909039221625316272HMMCC (Semis); Henry Dunant (gold); NLU Delhi Corp Moot (organiser); NLIU Juris Corp (Semis); Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers (Gold, memo); Commonwealth Moot Nat’l (semis); Stetson North Rounds (silver, speaker), Jessup North (Gold); Kerala Law Academy (silver) NUJS Herbert Smith (Semis) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Semifinalist); Red Cross Moot (Winners)(Best Speaker) ; Oxford IPR Moot (Runners Up); Leiden Sarin Air Law Moot (Best Speaker)(Honourable Mention for Best Applicant Team) Jessup World Rounds (Honorable Mentions - 19th Best Team, 21st Best Speaker, 3rd best Memo); Oxford Media Moot (Win, 2nd & 3rd oralist for HM); NLS Arbitration (Gold & best speaker)
3[[NLU Jodhpur]]20353055301248313171(Henry Dunant) (silver); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (semis); (B.R Sawhney Moot) (semis) ; (NLIU Juris Corp) (Semis); (Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers) (Semis);(Commonwealth Moot National Rounds) (Gold) (speaker), Jessup North (semis, speaker);(KK Luthra) (Gold); ULC Bangalore (silver); NUJS Herbert Smith (Runners Up) (Best Speaker) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Organizers); Vis East, Hong Kong (Honorable Mention - Respondent Memorandum, Honourable Mention, 2nd Best Oralist); NLS Arbitration (best memo; semis); ICC Trial (semis, 2nd best speaker); Commonwealth (semis); Lachs funding (silver)
4[[NUJS Kolkata]]25454848223373168HMMCC (Best team)(speaker) (Nani Palkhivala (silver); (BR Sawhney (speaker);(SLCU Moot (Gold, speaker); Surana Trial North East: (silver); (KK Luthra) (speaker); DM Harish (semis & speaker); NUJS Herbert Smith (org); ELSA WTO Asian Rounds (Best Speaker) (Semis); Vis (East), Hong Kong, (Honorable Mention- Best Pan-Asian Team); Vis, Vienna (Honorable Mention- Respondent Memo and Octa Finalists); NLS Arbitration (semi finals); Lachs funding (semis, best speaker); ELSA WTO (semis, best prelims speaker)
5[[Symbiosis, Pune]]4035151112290(NLIU Juris Corp) Best Researcher; Kerala Law Academy (gold); Surana Corporate Moot (Semis) Amity Moot (Runners Up); GH Raisoni Moot (Winners) (Best Researcher); Vis (East) Hong Kong (Quarter Finalists) ( 2 Honorable Mentions for Speakers)
6[[ILS Pune]]10155273321312190(HMMCC) (Best researcher); (SLCU Moot) (silver); (NLIU Juris Corp) (gold); (Stetson South India)(Semis); DM Harish (semis) Surana Corporate Moot (Best Oralist) (Semis); ULC Bangalore (orator); GH Raisoni (Semis) ; NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Winners); Vis, Vienna (Honorable Mention- Respndent Memorandum)
7[[Nalsar Hyderabad]]3020582511112489(HMMCC (silver); (Rizvi Moot) (Best team); (B.R Sawhney Moot) (organisers); (NLIU Juris Corp) (speaker);(FDI Moot (memo);(Commonwealth Moot National Rounds) (memo); Jessup South (Semifinalists); Vis (East), Hong Kong (Honorable Mention- Claimant Memo); Vis, Vienna (Honorable Mentions- Speaker, Claimant Memorandum); ICC Trial (semis, hon mention)
8[[RMLNLU Lucknow]]30308201222388(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (gold, best researcher); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (memo);(Stetson North Rounds) (Gold), Jessup North (silver);GNLU International Moot (semifinalists); Stetson World Rounds (Semi Finalists) ( Honourable Mention - 2nd Best Memorial, 5th Best Speaker, 6th Best Speaker); Lachs funding (semis)
9[[HNLU Raipur]]10324112221684Nani Palkhivala (Best Researcher); (Pro Bono) (Runner’s Up, speaker, Best researcher, memo) (Rizvi Moot) (silver) (Justice Hidayatullah Moot) (organizer) (Stetson North Rounds) (memo); Surana Trial North East (winner, speaker) (KK Luthra) (memo); Kerala Law Academy (semis) Amity Moot (Best Memo) NUJS Herbert Smith (Semis)
10[[GNLU Gandhinagar]]530212131158(Nani Palkhivala) (best team); (NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (Best team);(FDI Moot) (Honourable Mention);Jessup North (semis); GNLU International Moot (organizers) Surana Corporate Moot (Gold); GH Raisoni Moot (Runners Up)(Best Mooter) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Semifinalist); Frankfurt Investment Arbitration Moot (Semifinalists)
11[[RGNUL Patiala]]2032521357(HMMCC (silver); (Rizvi Moot) (Best team); (B.R Sawhney Moot) (organisers); (NLIU Juris Corp) (speaker);(FDI Moot (memo);(Commonwealth Moot National Rounds) (memo); Jessup South (Semifinalists); Vis (East), Hong Kong (Honorable Mention- Claimant Memo); Vis,Vienna (Honorable Mentions- Speaker.
12[[Jindal Global Law School]]20815121243(Nani Palkhivala) (memo)(Henry Dunant) (best researcher, semis); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (gold); (Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers)(Semis); NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Best Speaker)
13[[NUALS Kochi]]1023511238(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (silver); (Stetson South) (memo); Kerala Law Academy (memo) Amity Moot (Winners)
14[[NLUO Cuttack]]16132229B.R Sawhney Moot (memo); NLIU Juris Corp (memo); GH Raisoni Moot (Best Memo) (Semis);Amity Moot (Semifinalists); NLS Arbitration (semis)
15[[Faculty of Law, Jamia Milia Islamia University]]1081011128Nani Palkhivala (speaker); Henry Dunant (memo); Surana Trial adv-North (Silver, speaker)
16[[GLC Mumbai]]10881126(Surana Trial Advocacy South) (silver) (NLU Delhi Corp Law Moot) (Semifinalist); Jessup South Rounds (silver); GNLU International Moot (memo)
17[[Amity Law School,Delhi (IP University)]]541321224Commonwealth Moot (semis); Stetson North Rounds (semis); GIMC (semis) Amity Moot (Organizers) ; ELSA WTO Asian Rounds (winners)
18[[Institute of Law, Nirma University, Ahmedabad|Nirma University]]1083321Henry Dunant (semis); (Pro Bono) Semis; Stetson North Rounds (semis)
19[[SVKM’s Pravin Gandhi College of Law]]51621121SLCU Moot (memo, semis); Jessup South (semis); ULC Bangalore (semis, memo)
20[[CNLU Patna]]201120(Stetson South) (Silver); Jessup North (memo)
21Campus Law Centre, New Delhi1541119KK Luthra (Semifinalists); NUJS Herbert Smith Moot (Winners)
22[[ULC Bangalore]]1611117(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (memo);(Pro-bono Enviro Moot (Gold); ULC moot (org)
23[[NLIU Bhopal]]4822114HMMCC (Semis, memo); Nani Palkhivala (semis); NLIU JurisCorp (org);
24[[Amity Law School Noida]]1311113Rizvi Moot (semis, speaker, memo);
25[[KLA, Trivandrum]]10110Stetson South (speaker)
26[[Department of Law, North-Eastern Hill University]]10110Henry Dunant (speaker);
27[[KIIT School of Law]]10110B.R Sawhney Moot (Gold) ;
28Faculty of Law, Allahbad University10110ULC Bangalore (Gold)
29Faculty of Law, Benaras Hindu University88Surana Corporate Moot (memo)
30[[CUSAT Kochi|School of Legal Studies, CUSAT Kochi]]8118Surana Trial South (memo, semis);
31[[UILS Punjab]]818Kerala Law Academy (speaker)
32[[School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur]]0626Surana Trial - South (semis); Pro Bono (Semis)
33[[V.M. Salgaoncar, Goa]]515Stetson South (Semis)
34[[A K K New Law Academy, Pune]]515Commonwealth Moot National Rounds (Runners Up)
35[[New Law College, Bharti Vidayapeeth University, Pune]]515Surana Trial Adv - South (speaker);
36Lucknow University Faculty of Law515Surana Trial Adv - North East (memo)
36GLC Ernakulam515ULC Bangalore (memo)
37Symbiosis, Noida414Amity Moot (Semifinalists)
38Law Centre-I, Delhi University313ULC Bangalore (Semifinalists)
39JSS Law College, Mysore22Surana Corporate Moot (Organizer)

For more information please refer to the [[MPL 4 rulebook]].

Comments

What the Fish ? 8 May 2013, 07:16
+2 -2
ELSA WTO is Tier 4 Moot acc. to MPL 4 rulebook. How are you RETROSPECTIVELY changing it to Tier- II after NUJS did well at it. Also there is an addition mistake in NUJS tally. They were given 45 points for Dm Harish . They should be given only 35. ( 20+15 an NOT 20 +25).

It also seems to be big conspiracy to put NUJS at 3rd position because these errors keep inadverently happening. It has been proved beyond a speck of doubt that LI has huge biased towards NUJS.
kianganz 8 May 2013, 07:25
+4 -2
And here silly us thought we would get away with this massive conspiracy of NUJS love...

But seriously, thank you very much for your comment - we unintentionally got it very wrong and took the moot to be in Tier 2 (as it was in 2010 - http://www.legallyindia.com/20100601906/Mooting/mpl ).

But yes, you're right, it is a Tier 4 moot according to the MPL rulebook (and see this discussion for some more thinking behind it - http://www.legallyindia.com/index.php?Itemid=622&option=com_kunena&catid=13&id=1961&lang=en&view=topic ).

Correcting the article now - sorry for the confusion, that shouldn't have happened...

Best wishes,
Kian
What the Fish ? 8 May 2013, 07:22
+3 -2
ELSA WTO is Tier 4 Moot acc. to MPL 4 rulebook. How are you RETROSPECTIVELY changing it to Tier- II after NUJS did well at it. So instead of getting 8 points from ELSA WTO, NUJS get 20 points,( 12 extra points.)

Also there is an addition mistake in NUJS tally. They were given 45 points for Dm Harish . They should be given only 35. ( 20+15 an NOT 20 +25).

SO the NUJS tally is at 169 as against 191. AND THIS IS SOMETHING WHICH is VERIFIABLE. Kindly do so and rectify it.

Otherwise it would be apparent that it is a big conspiracy to put NUJS at 3rd position.
kianganz 8 May 2013, 07:44
+2 -3
Just looking into DM Harish - you're right that NUJS won 35 points from DMH but we had re-tallied and double-checked the overall figures before and it was fine. Will go through this now and see whether an addition error crept in somewhere.
kianganz 8 May 2013, 08:01
+2 -2
Have added up all the tallies again and there was indeed a mistake that 45 points were marked against NUJS in Tier 2, rather than 35 points.

However, NUJS' tier 1 tally was 10 points too low at 25 points, where it should have been 35 points (Vis East HK Honourable Mention (10 points); and Vis Vienna HM (10) and Octa finalists (15)).

Going through the rest of the scores with a fine toothcomb, but vis-a-vis DMH, the total therefore stands unchanged as of now.
Ankit 9 May 2013, 07:27
+1 -0
Whoa! Some people take themselves (and their colleges) too darn seriously!
NLS 8 May 2013, 17:11
+0 -0
Add points for Geeta's speaker rank. The divide between NLUD and us is bigger.
Guest 8 May 2013, 17:23
+0 -0
NLIU ?
NUJS 10 May 2013, 04:20
+0 -0
NUJS reached finals in NLS Arbitration (not semi-finals). It also won an hon men for team orals at Vienna. Please add these points!
kianganz 10 May 2013, 07:48
+0 -0
Thanks - we're just doing a full audit of the table, and in particular NUJS scores - some errors may have crept in. Will keep you posted...
Looking forward to MPL 5 10 May 2013, 10:41
+0 -0
Dear Kian,
Please reconsider the entire tier system of moots. I guess, we can rope in the Moot Court Society of every MPL 4 rank listed college this year and tell them to send their ranking/tier of moots.
Further, moots like NLS-Tax, Gurucharan Das Criminal Moot (nalsar), RGNUL Moot, PN Bhagwati Moot, UPES Paras Diwan Moot can be addded tier 5 or create another tier of moot, TIER 6.
Guest 28 Jun 2013, 08:47
+0 -0
I strongly support a tier system bases on the averaging the ranks and corresponding scores for each win as sent by the MCCs of each law university.
Looking forward to MPL5 18 Jul 2013, 06:35
+0 -0
Also I urge Team Kian to include Amity International moot into Tier 5 because of the rave reviews on its 1st and 2nd edition.

Team MPL please be back, there has been no news on MPL for past so many days!