Exclusive: To celebrate jubilee, BCI splits top moot into 3 at Nirma, NLU J and NLU D

The Bar Council of India (BCI) Trust announced that it would conduct three BCI moots this season in collaboration with [[Institute of Law, Nirma University]], [[NLU Jodhpur]] and [[NLU Delhi]] respectively.

The mega BCI mooting festival is intended to commemorate the golden jubilee of India’s central lawyer representative body, which was set up under the Advocates Act 1961. The three BCI moots are scheduled to take place from mid February of next year.

MPL 3 Quicklinks:

MPL 3: Cleverer, shinier, more polished
MPL 3: Cleverer, shinier, more polished

The BCI press release dated 29th November invited each law university to register three teams consisting of two speakers and one researcher for the three moots. Law colleges affiliated to a particular university are required to participate in internal selection rounds within the university for filtering the top three teams which will take part in the BCI moots.

BCI Trust secretary-in-charge CS Kandpal told *Legally India that BCI has decided to roll out many initiatives to celebrate its fiftieth year of existence.

“The recent announcement is a part of the golden jubilee celebrations of BCI,” he explained. “We are also conducting workshops and other programmes in various parts of the country.”

Kandpal indicated that the current initiative would considerably increase student participation in the moot. “Each university is expected to send three teams and participate in all the three BCI moots. They cannot send the same team to all the three moots. This will increase student interest.”

Kandpal also confirmed that all the three proposed moots will be equivalent in terms of standing.

Last year, the BCI conducted an international moot based on arbitration law, discontinuing its 26 year old practice of having challenging moot problems on national laws. Though the moot did not see any involvement from foreign teams, 33 teams from across the country participated. Two-time, undefeated MPL champions [[Nalsar Hyderabad]] won the top-rated moot after defeating [[NLSIU Bangalore]] in the final rounds.

Kandpal said that the BCI Trust had decided to scrap the international moot this season, and that the three new moots would all be based on national laws.

It is understood that most universities have already finished their internal mooting selections and allotments and could find it difficult to allot two additional quality teams for the BCI.

The three hosting universities (Nirma, NLU J and NLU D) would not be allowed to participate in the moot each is respectively hosting, according to Kandpal.

The BCI moot was a tier 3 MPL moot. Team MPL proposes to list each of the three BCI in tier 3. Comments are invited.

[[Mooting Premier League 3 season standings]]

For more information please refer to the [[MPL 3 rulebook]].

Comments

shocking 4 Dec 2011, 10:02
+4 -0
Obviously Nirma must have got hold of a few politicians and done lobbying to get the moot shifted there. There should be an RTI application into the minutes of the meeting. It is an insult to NLU-J, NLUD and in fact to all NLUs to have this event at Nirma.
Tipsy 4 Dec 2011, 12:09
+7 -0
This is just stupid. All three moots will only suffer from dilution of quality. Expect the BCI to do something like this!
??? 4 Dec 2011, 12:31
+0 -0
Kian,

Any news as to when will they be releasing the moot problem?

Is the problem same for all the 3 competitions?
saxy 4 Dec 2011, 12:44
+4 -0
aray raita fail gaya
joshi ji 4 Dec 2011, 15:26
+5 -0
raito sa, raito.
?? 4 Dec 2011, 14:23
+3 -0
Is this law school related to Nirma washing powder? Is it a private university opened by the detergent company? Never heard of it.
Nirma Nirma Sabki Pasand Nirma 4 Dec 2011, 22:54
+2 -0
Nirma, Nirma...
Doodh si safedi,
Nirma sae aayi,
Rangeen kapda bhi,
Khil Khil Jaye
Sabki Pasand Nirma!
A 5 Dec 2011, 05:30
+6 -0
@ 2 - There is nothing to fear. If you have the quality you will win irrespective of the venue.

@ 5 - Nirma washing powder was named after the baby girl Nirma who passed away at that time. She was the daughter of the owner of Nirma detergent. The same group has now ventured into the education sector. Interestingly, Stanford was also named after Lenon Stanford Jr. who passed away at the age of 16 while studying at Harvard. At that time, many questioned the credibility of Stanford. But, today we all know how Stanford is.
Rohan, GLC Mumbai 5 Dec 2011, 06:14
+0 -0
LI don't you think BCIT should instead be elevated to Tier 2 bcuz as BCI've went back to its earlier trend; there will be four moot problems; which means that quality of utmost level.

When this season, comments were invited; voices were raised to elevate it to Tier 2 as being the most prestigious moot in India; that time it was not so done bcuz of deteriorating quality; but now it seems BCIT is back again; I think it be elevated to Tier 2.
Karan, RGNUL 5 Dec 2011, 06:35
+2 -0
I agree with Rohan. LI it will be good if you do so. Its the most prestigious moot man!!!!! No other moot is anyway near to it and you have kept it in Tier 3 and DM Harish in tier 2. Its really ridiculous on the part of Li.
Elevate BCI 5 Dec 2011, 06:52
+1 -0
Its the biggest and oldest moot we have. Anyone who is a SOMEBODY knows about it
Soap? 5 Dec 2011, 08:58
+0 -0
why would you name your place NIRMA?
Why would you name yourself after a soap??
Soap? why not? 5 Dec 2011, 09:00
+1 -0
Its to clean the BLACK of the world to the WHITE!!!

BEST NAME FOR LAW SCHOOL!!
Pintoo 5 Dec 2011, 09:18
+0 -0
I dont know about it.
A 5 Dec 2011, 09:50
+5 -0
When I first heard of Symbiosis way back in 1999, it reminded me of Symbiotic bacteria.
Abhishek, CNLU 5 Dec 2011, 10:46
+0 -0
There are comments regarding elevating BCI to Tier 2 on the Golden Jubilee occasion. I think its a great idea, for which BCIT moot is worthy for....Legally India, it would be gr8 if you do it!!!
Ankit, RMLNLU 5 Dec 2011, 11:00
+0 -0
Ya I agree with Comment 8,9 and 15. BCI should be elevated to Tier 2 at this grand moment for them! Also it deserves it as it is back with old trend which toughest and of utmost quality.
A 5 Dec 2011, 13:11
+6 -0
What next? Lifebuoy Institute of Legal Studies?
Shreya, Nalsar 6 Dec 2011, 04:59
+2 -0
Hey! Idea to elevate BCIT Moot to Tier 2 at this grand occasion is a great one!! LegallyIndia was criticized a lot when D.M. Harish was elevated to TIer 2 and BCI was remained intact in Tier 3;considering the prestige that BCIT Moot has.
I think its the time for LI to rectify their mistake.
UJ 6 Dec 2011, 07:32
+0 -0
This is with regard to all the guys making fun of Nirma on the basis of its name.


I am from an NLU and I don't find the name too cool.
The standard of studies or the people here are also not too good. I really don't understand the issue some of you have with the name of some place.

I am sure there are more reasons to make fun of a university than its name.

And if you are from an NLU and making fun of Nirma, it shows exactly why the legal sector in India will never match professionalism of the engineering sectors.

So don't be too happy.
Because you and I and all of us suck, and are in a profession where almost all of the population would rather not be.
Its relative suckiness- not something we NLUites can be too proud of anyway.
Law graduate 6 Dec 2011, 11:27
+0 -0
A new moot with probably a new format - should remain at Tier 3 this year until the quality is judged. Also, need to see number of participating teams. Should be able to judge after this year. Might be too hasty to elevate right now.
Wohooo 6 Dec 2011, 11:49
+0 -0
Can someone please clarify whether all the three moots will be on Constitutional Law? And will there be only one moot problem common to the three moots?
BCI ELEVATE 6 Dec 2011, 12:25
+4 -0
Go to the SC once,
everyone from Gopal Subramaniyum to Kapadia, J. knows about BCI.

Anyone who is a big shot has participated/won it. Its is the only moot in india that has NATIONAL RECOGNITION from Kashmir to Kanyakumari (as cliched as it may sound)

it is one of the best organized moots.
the judging is impeccable.
and with the recent format change, the number of participants will also go through the roof
it must be elevated
X 8 Dec 2011, 05:38
+0 -0
"judging is impeccable"..... ha! all i know is previous year's judging was far from it!
Ex-Mooter 10 Dec 2011, 09:15
+0 -0
Thank you. It was time someone pointed that out. The judging is awful, except that some years, the final turns out to be good. But for the most part - horrendous.
To Law Graduate 6 Dec 2011, 13:29
+2 -0
With due respect Mr. Law Graduate sir, BCIT is not a new moot; it is the oldest moot with no new format,the format was there a year back which was followed for quite many years...which made it most prestigious moot.

Also, speaking about no. of team participation, kindly check BCI policy, a team from University not from a college. Moreover, 33 teams participated in the moot last year which was more than DM Harish participation.
Any student dies to be a part of this moot and this is the best time to elevate the moot!
LI Team go for it!!!!
I
Rachit, NLU Delhi 6 Dec 2011, 13:33
+2 -0
What all I know bout mooting system in India, all I know is BCI is the best and most prestigious moot.

This is Golden Jubilee year for BCI Trust. Legally India, considering the prestige the moot carries should elevate it.
BCI 6 Dec 2011, 16:46
+0 -0
the point is since they are having 3 seperate moots which the participation be big in all three? will the judging be good in all three?? what will be the problem like. none of this is known had it been said that it is going back to its original format and BCI was having just one moot then it should have been elevated but not at this point where nothing is known about the moot. and since most of the teams would have been alotteed moots (one team would have surely taken BCI) but for thr other two BCI moots the teams might not be as good as the first one
Kapil, NLIU 7 Dec 2011, 08:11
+0 -0
It will be great if Legally India elevates BCI to Tier 2 at Golden Jubilee occasion.
mooting fever 7 Dec 2011, 18:34
+0 -0
I think the moot is one of the most sought after moot in india and is very prestigious!
the other two venues should also be included in tier 3! all colleges would certainly send three best teams availabe to such a moot.
therefore i m in favour of keeping all the three in tier 3.,...
(howeve the decision to hold a moot like BCi in an unknown college like NIRMA lowers the repute of the moot)
Ex-Mooter 8 Dec 2011, 02:23
+0 -0
With due respect to the above commentators, the D.M. Harish Moot is better organised, better judged, and has better (including international) teams. In fact, D.M. Harish is one of the few national moots where the quality of judging is less controversial than usual (along with, say, the Palkhivala moot). Added to that, the fact that the BCI format (barring last year) is entirely random - you can win both your prelim rounds and fail to break if your speaker scores aren't high enough (and speaker scores are entirely a function of the room in which you're arguing) - clearly indicates that D.M. Harish deserves to be a tier above BCI.
To Ex Mooter 8 Dec 2011, 04:25
+2 -0
Mr. Ex mooter, your argument is purely baseless with no standings as prestige of BCI stands miles above than that of D.M.Harish. Also, mere few international teams participating does not add the prestige to a moot. There are other international moot courts too like GIMC which are in Tier 4.
Responding to your argument of judges, I'd rather say BCI is probably the few moots in India which calls reputed persons as judges right from the prelims rounds.
BCI is only moot which is known to all lawyers and legal personalities.
D.M.Harish can never match the status of BCI and LegallyIndia has committed a blunder by putting DM Harish above BCI which they must rectify.
Ex-Mooter 8 Dec 2011, 07:09
+0 -0
Are you BCI's PR manager?

More importantly than that, have you been to either BCI or DM Harish?
Ex Mooter 8 Dec 2011, 10:58
+0 -0
Though I have not gone in any of the two. But I keep a close watch on the moot court competitions and an independent invigilator.

By the way are you PR MAnanger of DM Harish?
Raman, NUALS 8 Dec 2011, 10:59
+2 -0
I think BCI should be elevated because of the prestige this competition has.
Kapil, NLIU 8 Dec 2011, 15:03
+0 -0
LegallyIndia, Go for it!!! Elevate BCI to tier 2.
kianganz 10 Dec 2011, 12:06
+0 -0
It appears a lot of the voices in favour of upgrading the BCI moot come from similar IP addresses...

If you are in favour of upgrading the BCI moots, please visit our MPL FB page and make your voice heard there:
http://www.facebook.com/mooting.in

For the time being we have not yet heard a good argument that would justify an upgrade, particularly since the moots will be split into 3 which logically is more likely to dilute the quality than improve all 3.

We welcome your views.

Best wishes
Kian
Ex-Mooter 12 Dec 2011, 08:17
+0 -0
"It appears a lot of the voices in favour of upgrading the BCI moot come from similar IP addresses..."

Haha. Unsurprising. Anyone with an ounce of sense would know that BCI's terrible judging does not render it fit to come anywhere close to Tier 2.
X 4 Jan 2012, 20:08
+0 -0
Ofcourse, Supreme Court judges are the worst judges to be caught hold for judging an event on national laws. How stupid can they get?! (Just in case u dint get it, note the sarcasm).