ILS Pune thumps NLS Bangalore at NLU-J Antitrust moot

MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting
MPL 4: The home of Indian mooting
”)

ILS Pune beat NLSIU Bangalore in the finals of the fourth NLU Jodhpur Antitrust Law Moot Court Competition held last weekend between 8 and 10 March.

However, NLSIU Bangalore swiped the MPL points for best memo and Nayantara Ravichandran of NLSIU snatched the points for best researcher. Mohanakrishna C of Jindal Global Law School (JGLS) Sonipat was recognized as best student advocate.

GNLU Gandhinagar and NLU Delhi were knocked out in the semifinals of the moot.

The winning team of ILS Pune was composed of speakers Ravi Raghunath, Shagun Arora and researcher Sai Prashanth, while NLSIU fielded Sapan Parekh, Tuhina Joshi and Nayantara Ravichandran.

MPL 4 Quicklinks:

Raghunath said: “This success is indeed a team effort. My co-speaker Shagun Arora and researcher Sai Prashanth are pursuing CS [company secretary]. Their inputs were invaluable and helped the team perform very well and answer the questions from judges.”

He commended that judges did not throw out “random questions” but instead grilled participants on points pertinent to the moot proposition. “I would say it was an excellent judgment that we got at this moot. The quarter final round with Jindal was the toughest round we confronted in the moot.”

Raghunath added: “I’ve participated in moots like [KK] Luthra, Stetson, Willem C Vis. Still, on the point of organising I would rate this moot as number one. Because the organisers were ready at any time to make it happen, whatever we needed. For example, as soon as we requested for a room to practice, it was ready. The travel, accommodation, everything was perfect and much better than the international levels.”

ILS Pune with its win solidified its sixth place lead in the Mooting Premier League (MPL) 4 sponsored by Herbert Smith Freehills to 23 points ahead of RGNUL Patiala. Despite losing in the finals of the moot, NLSIU extended its MPL lead, now sitting at 232 points compared to NLU Delhi with 116 points in second place.

NLU Jodhpur received MPL organiser points because it did not take part in its own moot.

Note: Team MPL is getting final confirmation of the ELSA South Asian qualifiers – we’ll be updating shortly. We’re also confirming Amity Delhi’s organiser points for its moot last week.

International law firm Herbert Smith Freehills is sponsoring the Mooting Premier League (MPL) and will contribute a prize pool of Rs 60,000 for the top three winning colleges.

[[Mooting Premier League 4 season standings]]

PosLaw schoolT1T2T3T4T5OrgWR/uS/FB SB M/RHMPtsDetails
1[[NLSIU Bangalore]]10080242832325232Rizvi Moot (Semis); Surana Trial - South (Gold); Manfred Lachs Space Moot World Rounds (Gold, memo, speaker); Stetson South India (Gold); Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers (Silver, speaker); KK Luthra Criminal (semis); Jessup South Rounds (Gold, memo, speaker); GIMC (silver); Kerala Law Academy (semis) NUJS Herbert Smith (Best Memo) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Runners Up) (Best Researcher) (Best Memo)
2[[NLU Delhi]]9016913151116HMMCC (Semis); Henry Dunant (gold); NLU Delhi Corp Moot (organiser); NLIU Juris Corp (Semis); Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers (Gold, memo); Commonwealth Moot Nat’l (semis); Stetson North Rounds (silver, speaker), Jessup North (Gold); Kerala Law Academy (silver) NUJS Herbert Smith (Semis) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Semifinalist)
3[[NLU Jodhpur]]3035301235396(Henry Dunant) (silver); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (semis); (B.R Sawhney Moot) (semis) ; (NLIU Juris Corp) (Semis); (Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers) (Semis);(Commonwealth Moot National Rounds) (Gold) (speaker), Jessup North (semis, speaker);(KK Luthra) (Gold); ULC Bangalore (silver); NUJS Herbert Smith (Runners Up) (Best Speaker) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Organizers)
4[[NUJS Kolkata]]3516402221593(HMMCC (Best team)(speaker) (Nani Palkhivala (silver); (BR Sawhney (speaker);(SLCU Moot (Gold, speaker); Surana Trial North East: (silver); (KK Luthra) (speaker); DM Harish (semis & speaker); NUJS Herbert Smith (org)
5[[HNLU Raipur]]10324112221684Nani Palkhivala (Best Researcher); (Pro Bono) (Runner’s Up, speaker, Best researcher, memo) (Rizvi Moot) (silver) (Justice Hidayatullah Moot) (organizer) (Stetson North Rounds) (memo); Surana Trial North East (winner, speaker) (KK Luthra) (memo); Kerala Law Academy (semis) Amity Moot (Best Memo) NUJS Herbert Smith (Semis)
6[[ILS Pune]]15527332131280(HMMCC) (Best researcher); (SLCU Moot) (silver); (NLIU Juris Corp) (gold); (Stetson South India)(Semis); DM Harish (semis) Surana Corporate Moot (Best Oralist) (Semis); ULC Bangalore (orator); GH Raisoni (Semis) ; NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Winners)
7[[RGNUL Patiala]]2032521357(Nani Palkhivala) (Semis); (NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (semis); B. R Sawhney Moot (silver); (NLIU Juris Corp) (silver); Amity Moot (Best Researcher) (Best Memorial)
8[[GNLU Gandhinagar]]530212121158(Nani Palkhivala) (best team); (NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (Best team);(FDI Moot) (Honourable Mention);Jessup North (semis); GNLU International Moot (organizers) Surana Corporate Moot (Gold); GH Raisoni Moot (Runners Up)(Best Mooter) NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Semifinalist)
9[[RMLNLU Lucknow]]3042012254(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (gold, best researcher); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (memo);(Stetson North Rounds) (Gold), Jessup North (silver);GNLU International Moot (semifinalists)
10[[Symbiosis, Pune]]3515111250(NLIU Juris Corp) Best Researcher; Kerala Law Academy (gold); Surana Corporate Moot (Semis) Amity Moot (Runners Up); GH Raisoni Moot (Winners) (Best Researcher)
11[[Nalsar Hyderabad]]5825111239(HMMCC (silver); (Rizvi Moot) (Best team); (B.R Sawhney Moot) (organisers); (NLIU Juris Corp) (speaker);(FDI Moot (memo);(Commonwealth Moot National Rounds) (memo); Jessup South (Semifinalists)
12[[Jindal Global Law School]]20815121243(Nani Palkhivala) (memo)(Henry Dunant) (best researcher, semis); (Surana Trial Adv - North) (gold); (Oxford Media Law National Qualifiers)(Semis); NLU-J Antitrust Moot (Best Speaker)
13[[NUALS Kochi]]1023511238(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (silver); (Stetson South) (memo); Kerala Law Academy (memo) Amity Moot (Winners)
14[[GLC Mumbai]]20161136(Henry Dunant) (speaker);(Surana Trial Advocacy South) (silver) (NLU Delhi Corp Law Moot) (Semifinalist); Jessup South Rounds (silver); GNLU International Moot (memo)
15[[Faculty of Law, Jamia Milia Islamia University]]1081011128Nani Palkhivala (speaker); Henry Dunant (memo); Surana Trial adv-North (Silver, speaker)
16[[NLUO Cuttack]]12131225B.R Sawhney Moot (memo); NLIU Juris Corp (memo); GH Raisoni Moot (Best Memo) (Semis);Amity Moot (Semifinalists) ;
17[[Institute of Law, Nirma University, Ahmedabad|Nirma University]]1083321Henry Dunant (semis); (Pro Bono) Semis; Stetson North Rounds (semis)
18[[SVKM’s Pravin Gandhi College of Law]]51621121SLCU Moot (memo, semis); Jessup South (semis); ULC Bangalore (semis, memo)
19[[CNLU Patna]]201120(Stetson South) (Silver); Jessup North (memo)
20Campus Law Centre, New Delhi1541119KK Luthra (Semifinalists); NUJS Herbert Smith Moot (Winners)
21[[ULC Bangalore]]1611117(NLU Delhi Corp Moot) (memo);(Pro-bono Enviro Moot (Gold); ULC moot (org)
22[[NLIU Bhopal]]4822114HMMCC (Semis, memo); Nani Palkhivala (semis); NLIU JurisCorp (org);
23[[Amity Law School Noida]]1311113Rizvi Moot (semis, speaker, memo);
24[[Amity Law School, Delhi (IP University)]]543212Commonwealth Moot (semis); Stetson North Rounds (semis); GIMC (semis)
25[[KLA, Trivandrum]]10110Stetson South (speaker)
26[[Department of Law, North-Eastern Hill University]]10110Henry Dunant (speaker);
27[[KIIT School of Law]]10110B.R Sawhney Moot (Gold) ;
28Faculty of Law, Allahbad University10110ULC Bangalore (Gold)
29Faculty of Law, Benaras Hindu University88Surana Corporate Moot (memo)
30[[CUSAT Kochi|School of Legal Studies, CUSAT Kochi]]8118Surana Trial South (memo, semis);
31[[UILS Punjab]]818Kerala Law Academy (speaker)
32[[School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur]]0626Surana Trial - South (semis); Pro Bono (Semis)
33[[V.M. Salgaoncar, Goa]]515Stetson South (Semis)
34[[A K K New Law Academy, Pune]]515Commonwealth Moot National Rounds (Runners Up)
35[[New Law College, Bharti Vidayapeeth University, Pune]]515Surana Trial Adv - South (speaker);
36Lucknow University Faculty of Law515Surana Trial Adv - North East (memo)
36GLC Ernakulam515ULC Bangalore (memo)
37Symbiosis, Noida414Amity Moot (Semifinalists)
38Law Centre-I, Delhi University313ULC Bangalore (Semifinalists)
39JSS Law College, Mysore22Surana Corporate Moot (Organizer)

For more information please refer to the [[MPL 4 rulebook]].

Comments

sad 11 Mar 2013, 06:54
+14 -3
"thumps" LI? Please dont forget these are young students who you thoroughly insult and demoralise by using phrases like "thumps". Why cant you say "ILS pune wins" or "ILS Pune beats NLS". This need to sensationalise is disgusting. Is a moot like a cricket match where a margin of 200 runs or an innings defeat can be characterised as "Thumps". Did you see the difference in the marks awarded by judges to use a word like "thumps".
Agree 11 Mar 2013, 09:19
+3 -1
"Thumps" doesn't sound right.
Osho 11 Mar 2013, 12:38
+7 -5
[quote name="Agree"]"Thumps" doesn't sound right.[/quote]
how about "humps"? B /
Disagree 12 Mar 2013, 04:11
+2 -3
[quote name="sad"]"thumps" LI? Please dont forget these are young students who you thoroughly insult and demoralise by using phrases like "thumps". Why cant you say "ILS pune wins" or "ILS Pune beats NLS". This need to sensationalise is disgusting. Is a moot like a cricket match where a margin of 200 runs or an innings defeat can be characterised as "Thumps". Did you see the difference in the marks awarded by judges to use a word like "thumps".[/quote]
you are a loser if you get demoralise for something as trivial as this!
There is an error 11 Mar 2013, 07:54
+0 -1
GLC Mumbai didn't win best Speaker at Henry Dunant this year. I think it was the North Eastern Hill University. Please clarify Kian
Not insecure NLS grad 11 Mar 2013, 07:56
+7 -1
It's okay guys. Let ILS have its day. I guess Kian is trying to placate ILS's hurt feelings after he carried the story of their placements. Congrats ILS.
NLUJ Alumnus 11 Mar 2013, 09:22
+4 -1
Proud to see juniors carrying on the tradition of excellence and doing better than us -

QUOTE
“I’ve participated in moots like [KK] Luthra, Stetson, Willem C Vis. Still, on the point of organising I would rate this moot as number one. Because the organisers we ready at any time to make it happen, whatever we needed. For example, as soon as we requested for a room to practice, it was ready. The travel, accommodation, everything was perfect and much better than the international levels.”
UNQUOTE

Congrats ILS.
Yup 11 Mar 2013, 11:31
+0 -1
fantastic job, MCC. who is the current convenor BTW? everyone go for a committee lunch now! :P
abc 11 Mar 2013, 09:58
+1 -2
Check who wrote their memos. LI itself posted an article showing how nobody is recruiting from ILS.
Guest 11 Mar 2013, 11:49
+0 -1
I am not good with maths but 58 according to me is more than 57...so GNLU should be above Patiala then.. plz check
green lantern 13 Mar 2013, 14:45
+0 -0
now we know how mommies of losing cricket team members feel like.