Jindal settles with Harvard, gets to semis in ELSA WTO, creeps to 10th in MPL with final moot this weekend

MPL 3 Logo
MPL 3 Logo
[[Jindal Global Law School]] finished semifinalists and won other honours in the [[ELSA Moot Court Competition on WTO Law]] held in France last month, which is the penultimate moot of the third season of the Mooting Premier League (MPL).

Jindal also won the Gabrielle Marceau Award for the best complainant written submissions at this MPL Tier 4 international moot. Earning a total of 13 points from the WTO finals, Jindal moved from the 13th to 10th place in the [[MPL 3 Season Standings]] ahead of [[Campus Law Centre Delhi]], [[GNLU Gandhinagar]] and [[RGNUL Patiala]].

The Jindal team consisted of speakers Akkara Chummar and Aakriti Mittal along with their professor coach James J Nedumpara. Chummar said that the team had a great experience at the moot. “The quality of judging was unmatched. Most of the judges worked at the WTO Secretariat and some of them had even argued the cases that we were quoting. Hence, there was very little leeway for any mistakes in our arguments.”

MPL 3 Quicklinks:

MPL 3: Cleverer, shinier, more polished
MPL 3: Cleverer, shinier, more polished

Chummar said that the overall approach of the team was to understand their arguments and to stretch it to see if it withstands both logical and legal scrutiny. “This approach is different from most Indian moots where judges generally test your general knowledge of the law and ask about random concepts. Here, you have a chance to direct the judges to your arguments and hence you should ensure that your arguments are strong to withstand scrutiny.” The Jindal team lost to the University of Ottawa, Canada in the semifinals. “All the teams from all the regions were placed on an equal footing. We were up against some European teams in the preliminary rounds. After being placed fourth in the prelims, we qualified to the quarters, but lost to Ottawa in the semis.” During the minor final rounds (between the losing semifinalists for the 3rd place), Jindal negotiated a settlement with Harvard University, USA. “We did not argue the minor final rounds as we mutually settled the dispute with Harvard. Under the WTO procedure, if parties wish to settle the dispute, they have to submit mutually acceptable terms of settlement to the judges. We sat overnight and prepared the settlement terms with Harvard and the judges loved it. This was the first time that any team had done this and judges appreciated the out of the box thinking and recommended WTO internships for us.”

Chummar also appreciated the efforts of the team coach, Prof James Nedumpara. “He has been of great help for the team.” He also mentioned that his law school had been very supportive throughout. “This was the first time we participated in ELSA and this was also the first time we qualified for the international rounds of a moot. We were completely sponsored by our law school and the Centre for International Trade and Economic Laws, headed by our coach Prof Nedumpara.”

Jindal was the only Indian team to qualify for the final rounds of the moot this season, after they defeated National Taiwan University in the WTO Asian rounds in March.

This season of the Mooting Premier League will end with the Manfred Lachs Asia Pacific rounds to be held at [[Nalsar Hyderabad]] this weekend. NLSIU Bangalore leads the MPL with an unassailable lead of 88 points over NLU Jodhpur, while the last two years’ winner Nalsar Hyderabad languishes in third place this year.

[[Mooting Premier League 3 season standings]]

PosLaw schoolPtsDetails
1NLSIU Bangalore288Jessup Intl rounds (hon men for team orals, hon men for 3rd best memo); ISRO Man Lachs (gold); NLS Arb (organisers); Oxford Media Intl rounds (best memo); DMH (best speaker); Surana Corp (silver, best memo); GIMC (gold); KLA (best memo); Rizvi (gold); Jessup South (gold, best memo); Oxford Media India rounds (silver, best memo); Stetson South (gold, best memo); NLIU-Juris Corp (gold, best speaker, best memo); Palkhivala (gold); Dunant (silver); B.R. Sawhney (gold); Trial Adv South (silver); Raj Anand Moot (semis); Maritime Arbitration (semis, best memo, hon men for best resp memo);
2NLU Jodhpur200NLS Arb (best memo); Stetson Intl rounds (gold, 5th best oralist, 9th best oralist); Vis (East) (hon men for respondent memo); Raisoni (gold, best speaker); NLU Antitrust (organiser); Amity moot (silver, best speaker, best researcher); Surana Tech (semis); GIMC (silver); Jessup North (best speaker); Stetson North (gold); Hidayatullah (gold, best speaker, best memo); Dunant (best memo); Trial Adv North (silver, best speaker, best memo); IICLAM (gold);
3Nalsar Hyderabad186Vis Vienna (gold, hon men for oralist); ISRO Man Lachs (silver); NLS Arb (silver); Oxford Media Intl rounds (gold); Leiden - Sarin (best speaker); BCI - NLU Delhi (semis); NLU Antitrust (silver, best memo); BCI-Nirma (gold, best female speaker); DMH (semis); Jessup South (semis); Oxford Media India rounds (semis);Dunant (gold); B.R. Sawhney (organiser);
4NLU Delhi156Jessup Intl rounds (hon men for team orals, hon men for 38th best oralist and 11th best memo); Oxford Media Intl rounds (semis); BCI - NLU Delhi (organisers); ULC moot (best male speaker, best female speaker); BCI-Nirma (semis); Surana Tech (semis); DMH (semis); KLA (semis); Jessup North (gold); KK Luthra (gold); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (best researcher, semis); Oxford Media India rounds (gold, best speaker); (Law Asia (semis); Dunant (semis); IICLAM (organiser);
5NUJS Kolkata119Vis Vienna (hon men for team orals, hon men for best resp memo); Vis (East) (hon men for claimant memo, hon men for respondent memo); NLU Antitrust (gold, best researcher); NUJS-HS (organiser); KLA (silver); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (gold, best memo); Oxford Media India rounds (semis); NLIU-Juris Corp (semis); Hidayatullah (silver, best researcher); B.R. Sawhney (semis); SLCU Moot (silver, best speaker, best memo); Trial Adv North (semis);
6GLC Mumbai106Amity moot (gold); DMH (best memo); NUJS-HS (gold, best speaker, best memo); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (best speaker); NLIU-Juris Corp (semis); Trial Adv South (gold, best speaker); IICLAM (Best Memo); Raj Anand Moot (silver);
7ILS Pune97Vis Vienna (hon men for oralist, hon men for team orals, hon men for oralist); Pro Bono Enviro (best speaker); BCI - NLU Delhi (best female speaker); Surana Tech (silver); GIMC (best memo, best speaker, semis); KK Luthra (silver); Stetson South (best speaker); B.R. Sawhney (best speaker, semis); Trial Adv South (semis);
8RMLNLU Lucknow85ISRO Man Lachs (best speaker, semis); Stetson Intl rounds (8th best oralist); Leiden - Sarin (gold, best applicant memo); DMH (best reseracher); Surana Corp (semis);KK Luthra (best memo); Stetson North (silver); Palkhivala (silver); Trial Adv North (semis);
9NLIU Bhopal77NLS Arb (best speaker); Pro Bono Enviro (silver, best memo); NLU Antitrust (best speaker, semis); BCI-Nirma (semis); NUJS-HS (silver); GIMC (semis); Rizvi (silver, best speaker); NLIU-Juris Corp (organiser); SLCU Moot (gold); Raj Anand Moot (semis, best memo);
10Jindal Global Law School69[WTO Final rounds] (best complainant memo, semis); NLS Arb (semis); ELSA Asian rounds (gold, best memo); [Pro Bono Enviro] (best researcher); ULC moot (gold); NUJS-HS (semis); KK Luthra (semis); Dunant (best speaker, semis);
11Campus Law Centre Delhi60BCI - NLU Delhi (silver, best male speaker); Amity moot (semis); ULC moot (semis); KLA (gold); Raj Anand Moot (gold, best speaker);
12GNLU Gandhinagar60Raisoni (silver); Frankfurt (hon men for best team in the Asian regional group); ELSA Asian rounds (best speaker); NLU Antitrust (semis); GIMC (organiser); Jessup North (best memo, semis); Palkhivala (best researcher, semis); B.R. Sawhney (silver); Trial Adv North (gold);
13RGNUL Patiala57Raisoni (semis); Pro Bono Enviro (semis); Amity moot (best memo, semis); ULC moot (silver); Surana Tech (best memo); Jessup North (semis); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (semis); Stetson North (best speaker); Hidayatullah (semis); B.R. Sawhney (best memo);
14School of Law, Christ University, Bangalore52Pro Bono Enviro (semis); Surana Corp (gold, best speaker); KLA (best speaker); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (organiser); IICLAM (silver, best speaker); SLCU Moot (organiser);
15SOEL Chennai46Pro Bono Enviro (organisers); BCI-Nirma (silver, best male speaker); Jessup South (silver, best speaker); Stetson South (semis);Trial Adv South (best memo);
16Symbiosis Law School, Pune40NLS Arb (semis); BCI - NLU Delhi (semis); ULC moot (best memo); Surana Tech (organisers); NUJS-HS (semis); Rizvi (best memo, semis); Palkhivala (best memo); IICLAM (semis);
17HNLU Raipur39Jessup North (silver);Stetson North (semis); NLIU-Juris Corp (best researcher); Palkhivala (best speaker, semis); [Hidayatullah (organiser); SLCU Moot (semis);
18CNLU Patna25BCI - NLU Delhi (gold); Stetson North (semis);
19School of Legal Studies, CUSAT Kochi23Surana Tech (gold, best speaker);
20Symbiosis Law School, Noida14Pro Bono Enviro (gold); Surana Corp (semis);
21M. S. Ramaiah College of Law, Bangalore10Vis Vienna (hon men for oralist);
22V M Salgaocar Law College, Goa10Stetson South (silver);
23Army Institute of Law, Mohali10Stetson North (best memo);
24Amity Law School IP University Delhi10Amity (oraganisers); NLIU-Juris Corp (silver);
25NUALS Kochi10Raisoni (best memo); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (silver);
26KLE Bangalore9ULC moot (best researcher); IICLAM (semis);
27New Law College, Bharti Vidayapeeth University, Pune8Raisoni (semis); Stetson South (semis);
28School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur6ULC moot (semis); Trial Adv South (semis);
29Dr. Ambedkar Law College, Chennai5Jessup South (semis);
30MATS Law School, Raipur5Raisoni (best researcher);
31Seedling School of Law and Governance, Jaipur4ISRO Man Lachs (semis);
31AKK New Law Academy, Pune4KLA (semis);
33ULC Bangalore4ULC moot (organisers); SLCU Moot (semis);
34SVKM’s Pravin Gandhi College of Law3Hidayatullah (semis);
34Guru Gobind University3Rizvi (semis);
36J S S Law College, Mysore2Surana Corp (organiser);
36Nirma University2BCI-Nirma (organisers);

Legend: gold (winners); silver (runner-up); semis (semi-finalist); best memo (best memorandum); best researcher; best speaker; hon men (honourable mention); resp (respondent); organiser (organiser points)

For more information please refer to the [[MPL 3 rulebook]].

Comments

Lawyer 23 Jun 2012, 04:35
+0 -0
Great show Chummar & Aakriti! JGLS was among top 3 teams in the world alongwith the team of Harvard Law School in ELSA Moot. This might be one of the best International Moot performance of an Indian Law School team this year and really happy to see JGLS among top 10 mooting teams at Mooting Premier League.
whatever 24 Jun 2012, 07:51
+3 -0
[quote name="Lawyer"]Great show Chummar & Aakriti! JGLS was among top 3 teams in the world alongwith the team of Harvard Law School in ELSA Moot. This might be one of the best International Moot performance of an Indian Law School team this year and really happy to see JGLS among top 10 mooting teams at Mooting Premier League.[/quote]

Yes, in a year when NALSAR won Oxford Media and Vis Vienna and NLU Jodhpur won Stetson, this really might be one of the 'best international moot performance of an indian law school this year'
Whatever 24 Jun 2012, 09:43
+0 -0
HAHAHHAHA.

Ignorance.
Chill 24 Jun 2012, 14:41
+1 -0
How do you know that's not just his opinion? Maybe for him or her, Trade Law is THE thing? Everyone is entitled to their own opinion man
Lawyer 25 Jun 2012, 04:15
+1 -0
That's why I said it is one of the best performances :) NALSAR and NLU Jodhpur makes the legal fraternity proud too with their performances!
JindalStudent 23 Jun 2012, 17:41
+0 -0
Great show Bobby and Aakriti. Best of luck for your future endeavours. You will be missed
Updates 25 Jun 2012, 14:52
+0 -0
Any updates on Manfred Lachs? I heard that NLS won.
kianganz 25 Jun 2012, 14:57
+0 -0
Yep, it's true - please become a fan of the MPL Facebook page to be kept in the loop:

http://www.facebook.com/mooting.in

Full update to follow...