Quadruple global glory: NUJS wins ELSA moot in Geneva v Jodhpur | Nalsar wins Man Lachs Asia v NLU Delhi

Two Indian teams scored huge points internationall and in the Mooting Premier League (MPL) 6 sponsored by Herbert Smith Freehills recently at the ELSA and Manfred Lachs Space Moot Asia Pacific round.

Manfred Lachs Space Moot

The team from Nalsar Hyderabad comprising of Chinmayi Sharma, Ravishankar Krishnan and Debarpan Ghosh bested NLU Delhi to win the Asia pacific rounds of the Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court Competition, 2015 held at Padjajaran University, Bandung, Indonesia.

Chinmayi Sharma of the winning team, who also won the best speaker of finals award, commented: “We thought the moot was extremely well organized. Hats off to Padjajaran University for ensuring that every round was on schedule and for really taking the effort to make us feel at home!”

She added: “A great variety of top notch arguments were presented this year, which meant that one couldn’t have a standard approach to every round. Our most challenging rounds were probably against Murdoch and NLU-Delhi, both excellent teams. Judges throughout posed relevant and probing questions and it was an honour being judged by some of the authorities we had cited. We started working consistently somewhere around January, covering both aspects of public international law as well as space law. I think our use of scientific resources and documents particularly helped us. We would like to thank our university and the administration for their constant support.”

The team has qualified for the World Rounds to be held in Jerusalem.

NLU Delhi also won the best memorial award. NLSIU was the other Indian team which proceeded to the semi finals of the competition and was adjudged as the 2nd runners up ahead of Murdoch University.

At a glance: Moot wise

MootLaw School
WinnersNALSAR Hyderabad
Runners Up + Best MemorialNLU Delhi
Semi-finalistNLSIU Bangalore

ELSA WTO Moot

The team from NUJS Kolkata has bested NLU Jodhpur to win the world rounds of ELSA Moot Court Competition 2015 in Geneva over the weekend.

NLSIU emerged as a semi finalist at the Tier 4 moot court competition. While NUJS bested NLSIU in the semi finals, NLU-J defeated Harvard Law School to reach the finals.

There was a best speaker citation for every round and no overall best speaker award. Vatsal Vasudev from NLU, Jodhpur won it for the preliminary round and the quarter final. Ira Chaddha from NUJS won it for the Semi-Final. The one for the Final was shared by both of them. [The points for the best speaker will, however, be given to NLU – J as the preliminary round had the maximum participation.]

Rhea Jha, who was part of the runners up team of NLU-J, commented: “It was an amazing experience. The competition level was excellent. All the teams we faced, right from the preliminary round were really good. We had the pleasure of defeating Harvard in the Semi-Final after already having faced them in one of the preliminary rounds. The best part was seeing the names we read on spines of books and bylines of articles, up there on the panel judging us. The judges we were fortunate enough to have were great. The level of questioning was quite technical and in-depth. This also meant stress levels were high but I enjoyed every minute”.

She added: “After doing it, I am starting to feel ELSA is quite underrated. I knew trade law could get really technical but I don’t think I expected it to get that tough, especially from the quarters onwards. The most star-studded panel was of the course the 9-member one for the Final with Werner Zdouc (head of the Appellate Body Secretariat), A V Ganesan, Ambassador Jonathan Fried and Gabrielle Marceau among others. Both the finalist teams received some really overwhelming feedback, and coming from such eminent scholars, made all the hard work and effort worth i

At a glance: Moot wise

MootLaw School
WinnersWBNUJS Kolkata
Runners Up + Best SpeakerNLU Jodhpur
Semi-finalistNLSIU Bangalore

NLU Jodhpur and NLSIU still maintain their top ranks at MPL table while the third spot has been taken away from NUJS by NLU Delhi after the latter’s splendid performance at Manfred Lachs. NALSAR and NLIU maintain their 5th and 6th rank respectively.

At A Glance: Law School Wise

Law SchoolAwardScore
NALSAR HyderabadMan Lachs Asia Pacific (Winner) T230
NLU DelhiMan Lachs Asia Pacific (Runners Up + Best Memo) T225+20=45
NLSIU BangaloreMan Lachs Asia Pacific (Semi-finalists ) T215
WBNUJS KolkataELSA WTO World Rounds (Winner) T415
NLU JodhpurELSA WTO World Rounds (Runner up + Best Speaker) T48+8=16
NLSIU BangaloreELSA WTO World Rounds (Semi finalist) T44

MPL Standing

RankLaw SchoolPointsAwards
1NLU Jodhpur280Henry Dunant (Best team) = 20; Surana IT (Semi Finalist) T4= 4; Stetson (Semi Finalists + Best Speaker) T3 =10+5 : Price Media(Winner + Best Memorial) T3 =20+10; Jessup (Semi finalist + Best Memo) T3=10+5; GIMC (Semi Finalist)=4; ELSA Asia Qualifiers (Winner) T5=10; Anti Trust (Org) T5; Vis East ( 2 HM Best Oralist + HM Best Claimant Memorial) T1=30; Price Media (Semi-finalists + HM Best Memorial) T2=20; Vis Vienna (Best Respondent Memo) T1=30; Jessup (Octofinalists + 2 HM Best Oralist + HM Best Memorial) T1=45; Stetson (Best Oralist + HM Best Oralist) T2=25; ICC (Semi-finalists ) T2=15; ELSA WTO World Rounds (Runner up + Best Speaker) T4=16
2NLSIU Bangalore195Raj Anand (runners up) T4 = 8; BR Sawhney (Runners Up + Best Speaker) T4 + CLEA (Runners Up) T5 = 8 +8 + 5= 21 : Price Media (Best Speaker + Semi Finalists) T3 = 10+ 5: SLCU (Winners) T5=10; KK Luhtra (Best Speaker) T4=8; Jessup (Semi finalist) T3=5; GIMC (Best Memorial)T4=8: Amity (Winner + Best Memorial) T4=15+8; HSF (Runner’s up + Best Memorial ) T4=16; Oxford IP (Winners) T5=10; Vis East (HM Best Claimant Memorial) T1=10; Vis Vienna (Semi-finalist) T1=25; Vis Vienna (HM Best Oralist) T1=10; ELA WTO (Runners up)T5=5; NLS Arb (Organizer) T4=2; Man Lachs Asia Pacific (Semi-finalists ) T2=15; ELSA WTO World Rounds (Semi finalist) T4=4
3NLU Delhi173Manfred Lachs World (Winner + Best Speaker)+ CLEA (Best Memorial) T5 = 40 + 30 + 5 : Price Media (Semi Finalists) T3 = 5; KK Luhtra (Semi Finalist) T4=4; GIMC (Winners)=15; KLA (Winners + Best Speaker)=23; Oxford IP (Semi finalist) T5=3; Franfurt Arbitration (Semi Finalist) T5=3; Man Lachs Asia Pacific (Runners Up + Best Memo) T2=45
4NUJS Kolkata155CLEA (Semi finalists) T5; BCI (Semi Finalists) T3; Stetson (Winner) T3 = 3 + 5 + 20; KK Luthra (Winners) T4=15; DMH (Runners up)=25; HSF (Organiser) T4=2; Anti Trust (Best Memorial) T5=5; Vis East (Semi-finalists + HM Best Oralist) T1=35; ELSA WTO (Best Orator) T5=5; Vis Vienna (HM Best Complainant Memo) T1=10; Leiden Sarin (Runners Up) T5=5; Stetson (2 HM Best Oralist) T2=10; ELSA WTO World Rounds (Winner) T4=15
5NALSAR Hyderabad150BR Sawhney (Org)T4 = 2; Amity (Winners) T5= 10; BCI (Runners Up) T3 =10: Stetson (Semi Finalists) T3 = 5 : Price Media (Runners Up) T3 = 10; Rizwi (semi finalists+ best speaker) T5=3+5; Jessup (Runner up + Best Speaker) T3=10+10; HNMCC (Best Memorial)=5; Jessup (Quarterfinalist + 2 HM Best Oralist + HM Best Memorial) T1=50; Man Lachs Asia Pacific (Winner) T2=30
6NLIU Bhopal115Raj Anand (Best team + Best memorial + Best speaker) + NLIU Juris Corp (organiser) + Amity (Best Memorial) T5 + CLEA (Winners + Best Speaker) T5 + BCI (Semi Finalists) T3= 15 + 8 + 8 + 2 + 5 +15 + 5; KK Luhtra (Semi Finalist) T4=4: Amity (Runners Up) T4=8; ULC (Best researcher) T5=5; HSF (Best Team) T4=15; Anti Trust (Winner) T5=10; Commonwealth (Semi-finalists ) T2=15
7NLUO Cuttack98Henry Dunant (Best researcher + semi finalist) = 10 + 5 = 15; Amity (Runners Up) T5= 5; Surana IT (Runners Up+ Best Memorial) T4 = 8+ 8; KK Luhtra (Best Memorial) T4= 8; KLA (Best Memorial)=8: Amity (Semi Finalists) T4=4; ULC (Runner up + Best speaker ) T5=10; HSF (Semi-finalist + Best Speaker) T4=12; Anti Trust (Best Researcher) T5=5; G H Raisoni (Best Speaker) T5=5; Vis East (HM Best Claimant Memorial) T1=10
8ILS Pune88NLIU Juris Corp (Best team + Best speaker) = 15 + 8 = 23; BR Sawhney (Semi Finalist) T4 = 4; Surana Corp (Winner)=15: Amity (Semi Finalists) T4=4; HSF (Semi-finalist) T4=4; ILS Pune=10; Vis Vienna (Quarter-finalist) T1=20; Palkhiwala Tax (Runners up) T4=8
9JGLS81Jessup (Winner) T3; Anti Trust (Best Speaker + Semi Finalists) T5=8; Franfurt Arbitration (Winners) T5=10; Jessup (2 HM Best Oralist + HM Best Memorial) T1=30; NLS Arb (Winners + Best Respondent Memorial) T4=23
10RMLNLU Lucknow77Henry Dunant (runners up + Best Memorial) + Raj Anand (semi finalist) = 10 + 10 + 4 = 24; Surana IT (Semi Finalist + Best Speaker) T4= 4+8; Rizwi (semi finalists+ best researcher) T5=3+5; GIMC (best researcher) T4 = 8; Anti Trust (Runner Up) T5=5; Red Cross Best Memorial=20
11Symbiosis Pune56Raj Anand (semi finalist) + Juris Corp (Best researcher) = 4 + 8 = 12; Surana IT (Organizer) T4= 2; G H Raisoni (Best Researcher) T5=5; Vis East (Semi-finalists) T1=25; Palkhiwala Tax (Semi Finalist + Best Researcher) T4=12
12GNLU Gandhinagar51Stetson (Best Memorial) T3; GIMC (org)=2; G H Raisoni (Runner Up + Best Memorial) T5=10; Vis East (HM Best Claimant Memorial) T1=10; NLS Arb (Semi Finalists ) T4=4; ICC (Semi-finalists ) T2=15
13HNLU Raipur44NLIU Juris Corp (Runners up) = 8; BR Sawhney (Winners) T4 = 15; HNMCC (org)=1; Surana Corp (Best Speaker + Best Memorial)=4+8; Palkhiwala Tax (Best Speaker) T4=8
14RGNUL Patiala41BR Sawhney (Best Memorial) T4; Stetson (Runners Up) T3 = 8 + 10; Palkhiwala Tax (Winners + Best memo) T4=23
15ILNU Ahmedabad38BR Sawhney (Semi Finalist) T4 = 4 ; BCI (Winner + Best Speaker) T3 =20+10= 30; Surana Corp (Semi finalist)=4
16NUSRL Ranchi29NLIU Juris Corp (Best memorial) = 8 SLCU (Semi Finalist + Best Memorial + Best Speaker) T5=3+5+5; KLA (Runners Up) =8
17School of Law, Sashtra University27Surana IT (Winners) T4 = 15; HNMCC (Winners)=10; Palkhiwala Tax (Org) T4=2
18CNLU Patna26Amity (Best Researcher) T5 + CLEA (Organizer) = 5+1: DMH (Best Memorial)=20
19Symbiosis Law School, Noida24HNMCC (Runner up)=5; KLA (Semi Finalist)=4; Surana Corp (Semi finalist)=4: Amity (Best Researcher) T4=8; ULC (Semi finalist) T5
20CLC Delhi Univ20KK Luthra (Runners up): Amity (Best Speaker) T4=8; Palkhiwala Tax (Semi Finalist) T4=4
21NUALS Kochi18Amity (Semi Finalist + Best Speaker) T5 = 3+5 = 8; Rizwi (winners) T5=10
22GLC Mumbai18Amity (Semi Finalist) T5 = 3; DMH (Semi Finalists )=15
23KLA17Henry Dunant (Best speaker + semi finalist) = 10 + 5 = 15; KLA (organizer)=2
24Christ Univ, Bangalore17SLCU (Organizer) T5; KLA (Semi Finalist)=4; NLS Arb (Semi Finalists + Best Claimant Memorial) T=12
25CMR Law School15SLCU (Runners Up) T5=5; ULC (Winner) T5=10
26M S Ramaiah College, Bangalore12Surana Corp (Runner up + Best Speaker)=8+4
27UPES Dehradun8HNMCC (Best Speaker + Semi Finalist)
28Amity Delhi8Amity (Org) T4; Anti Trust (Semi finalist) T5=3; G H Raisoni (Semi finalist) T5=3
29School of Law, Galgotia University5Rizwi (runners Up) T5
30JSS law College, Mysore5Surana Corp (Organizer); ULC (Semi finalist) T5=3
31Faculty of Law, Allahabad Univ5ULC (Best memorial ) T5
32ULC Bangalore4HNMCC (Semi Finalist); ULC (Org) T5=1
33BILS Bangalore3CLEA (Semi finalists) T5
34AIL Mohali3SLCU (Semi Finalist) T5=3
35Pravin Gandhi, Mumbai3G H Raisoni (Semi finalist) T5
36Lloyd Law College2BCI (Organizer) T3 = 2
37Amity Noida1Amity (Org) T5 = 1
38Rizwi Law College1Rizwi (Org) T5
39G H Raisoni1G H Raisoni (Organizer) T5

Comments

Funny 9 Jun 2015, 15:05
+2 -0
And NALSAR swoops into the lead for MPL 7 with 30 points of the bat for Man Lachs world round!
Crappy scoring system FTW!
Guest 9 Jun 2015, 16:25
+1 -0
[quote name="Funny"]And NALSAR swoops into the lead for MPL 7 with 30 points of the bat for Man Lachs world round!
Crappy scoring system FTW![/quote]

75 of NLU-D's 173 points in MPL-6 are for the win at Man Lachs finals, a moot that commenced under MPL-5. So does the scoring system get crappy when it benefits NALSAR, or is it generally crappy?

On the contrary, NALSAR will more than happily collect its Man Lachs world rounds points in the present year (MPL-6) assuring itself third rank, with an outside chance at second.

...

Speaker scores need to be added.
Umm Actually 10 Jun 2015, 08:18
+0 -0
I made the same comment at the beginning of this year as well. I'm only for the rule when it benefits NLS :-) (which has never happened, because every time NLS has made it to the world rounds, they've won the whole thing, which ought to count for points)

Solution is to not give semi finalist points for Man Lachs world rounds, as the moot starts at Semis...
Honourable Mention 9 Jun 2015, 15:28
+0 -0
Beat speaker in the finals is not considered an HM? Are you sure?
In the know 9 Jun 2015, 15:40
+0 -0
NALSAR also has the best speaker at Man Lachs. No points for that?
Amused Bystander 9 Jun 2015, 17:08
+3 -2
Why this bias against NALSAR? No points for Best Speaker? I see LI versus NALSAR continues :'D
Honourable Mention 9 Jun 2015, 17:24
+2 -0
Also points for ISRO funding rounds need to be added. 4 points for SF of the funding rounds + 5 points for the HM will see NALSAR leapfrogging NUJS to 4th place.
Fairplay 9 Jun 2015, 23:38
+2 -1
Please provide NALSAR with the points it earned for being declared as the Best Overall Applicants. The same has been voiced for the longest period of time, but LI hasn't updated the table. Now kindly do that before the season ends.
What?! 10 Jun 2015, 07:58
+1 -2
What the hell is happening to NLSIU, it is losing in Mooting! Heartening to see it fall. Placements are also going down, as NALSAR takes over.
Guest 10 Jun 2015, 08:17
+0 -0
Missing points of NALSAR, in short

Man Lachs Funding round = semi finals (4 points)
Man Lachs AP = Best speaker in final/HM (5 points)
Jessup World Best Applicant = HM (whatever the rule says)

Kindly do the needful Kian.
Lover 10 Jun 2015, 08:33
+1 -0
She was the best speaker ONLY in the finals and not the whole competition.

Everyone relax.
Guest 10 Jun 2015, 12:36
+1 -0
That's an honourable mention in case you haven't realized. GNLU was awarded 5 points for it last time.

I'm sure people understand that and when they say best speaker they mean in the finals since they can all read.
kianganz 10 Jun 2015, 12:37
+1 -0
Thanks for feedback, we're looking into all of these and will update if required.
Dude 18 Jun 2015, 09:53
+0 -0
Kian? Is there an update coming?
Guest 10 Sept 2015, 17:33
+0 -0
Jodhpur also won a Dillard award at Jessup this year. Time for an update?