2012 CLAT preference analysis: NLS strengthens top, only 3 prefer Nalsar, NUJS, as Nuals, NLU-O gain

Nuals Kochi and NLU Orissa climbed in the traditional college preferences of Common Law Admissions Test (CLAT) at the expense of RMLNLU Lucknow and CNLU Patna, while other CLAT preferences remained unchanged in the corrected university allotment list, with NLSIU Bangalore coming top followed by Nalsar Hyderabad, NUJS Kolkata, NLIU Bhopal and NLU Jodhpur.

Legally India has conducted a fresh analysis of “Super 30” ranks in CLAT 2012, based on the revised UAL released on Friday morning. The “Super 30” score for each law college is the average rank of the top 30 students allotted to each college, in order to account for the different intake sizes of law schools.

The law schools most preferred by candidates appearing for CLAT 2012 was NLSIU Bangalore again. Only three students in the top 58 CLAT ranks did not opt for the college - rank 11 and 35 opted for Nalsar, while rank 20 chose NUJS.

Last year five students within the NLSIU cut-off did not pick India’s oldest national law school. In 2010 only two students went against the established preference.

This year Nalsar was again the second-most preferred college with a Super 30 score of 70.2.

NUJS Kolkata came a clear third in preferences with a Super 30 of 116.4, followed by NLIU Bhopal and NLU Jodhpur that were close together with average ranks of the top 30 students of 185.2 and 198.2 respectively.

GNLU Gandhinagar this year was again sixth in preferences ahead of HNLU Raipur.

NUALS Kochi, however, jumped a rank this year to replace RMLNLU Lucknow that last year had climbed to the eighth spot.

The entry of NLU Cuttack Orissa in the list of CLAT law schools usurped CNLU Patna in eleventh place. NUSRL Ranchi at thirteenth place and NLUJA Assam Guwahati in fourteenth place were the two other new participants in CLAT 2012.

Five students went against the trend of Nalsar as a second choice. Ranks 66, 89 and 91 chose NUJS Kolkata despite scoring within Nalsar’s cut-offs, while rank 78 and 101 chose NLU Jodhpur.

Changes

In the initially published list that contained errors, those five students and the 89th-ranked were allotted NLIU Bhopal instead of NUJS Kolkata and NLU Jodhpur.

There was no change in the revised list of those who bucked the trend in NLSIU preferences. Rank 427 – Osho Donnie Ashok - who told Legally India on Tuesday that he was erroneously allotted an NUSRL Ranchi seat, whereas his cut-off marks guaranteed him a seat in GNLU Gandhinagar, was allotted GNLU in the revised list.

Photo by hikingartist.com

2012 CLAT preferences by Super 30 rank (average rank of top 30 admissions to each college)

2012 Highest rank‘12 Lowest rank‘12 Cut-off‘12 Super 30 rank‘12 General list places2011 rank‘11 Highest rank‘11 Lowest rank‘11 Cut-off‘11 Super 30 rank‘11 General list placesFounded
NLSIU Bangalore15814516.655116414715.5581987
Nalsar Hyderabad1110214270.24125911714280.4441998
NUJS Kolkata20215138116.578333196137110831999
NLIU Bhopal103273136185.2334137277132221.1371997
NLU Jodhpur78312135198.2755125322131221.3802001
GNLU Ghandinagar219455132326.4786263427128336.3822003
HNLU Raipur270528131382.5607336551125418622003
Nuals Kochi190638130439.7419163638123507.9442005
RMLNLU Lucknow329595130464.2648168621123475.6742006
RGNUL Patiala208692129536.97110358710122594.6762006
NLUO Orissa323816128595.2782009
CNLU Patna3137971286945811641778120711.1632006
NUSRL Ranchi490839127775.4242010
NLUJA Assam408857127800.6302009

Comments

Amrith 3 Jun 2012, 08:05
+1 -0
How many people are expected to leave NALSAR and join NUJS? Any hectic changes expected in the subsequent lists?
2.8 3 Jun 2012, 12:26
+5 -0
[quote name="Amrith"]How many people are expected to leave NALSAR and join NUJS? Any hectic changes expected in the subsequent lists?[/quote]

I don't think thats how it works!
ssup 3 Jun 2012, 08:56
+2 -1
NLIU over NLU-J...dats not pssbl....NLU-J is any time better be it infrastructure, faculty, placements, alumni...
hmmmm 3 Jun 2012, 11:12
+9 -0
actually it hasn't. the mode adopted LI is flawed in dat sense. tell me how can the average of ranks of first 30 students selected in a particular college can tell d trend. suppose ( simply suppose) i get 1 rank in clat but bcoz of sum random reason of mine or bcoz of misconceived notions place GNLU my 1st preference. that doesn't makes GNLU the best college however wat it will do is bring down d "SUPER 30" score tremendously.....
i think we shud se the rank of 30th selected student of each college dat will given a clearer picture...... for instance ..
NLIU 30th student rank 261

NLUJ 30th student rank 247
also nuals is still behind rmnlu its just dat sum students, most of dem frm Kerela, who were ranked pretty high maybe bcoz dey only wanted NUALS nd no other college have choosen NUALS( north -South divide cant help it) but if we look at the cut off rank the picture seems to be clearer

NUALS 30th student rank 561
RMLNLU 30th student rank 531 (exact gap of 30)

if anyone needs still more clarification dey should look onto the concepts of mean, mode, median and range dat will make it clearer why Mean is not the correct method to calculate the preference...
and LI if u are also convinced by wat ive written do bring d necessary changes in ur article bcoz its an undeniable fact dat ppl especially students take ur such articles pretty seriously
a
Hmm 3 Jun 2012, 15:14
+2 -0
Even with the method you suggested, NLIU still bests NLU-J. And it has been doing so since ever. People have misconceived notions about NLU-J. It is not as good as it seems. The placements over there might seem real great but often the quality is very bad. A large number of students work with LPO's.
... 4 Jun 2012, 08:59
+0 -0
Check the placement reports. Only 4-5 would have joined LPOs, if at all.
Bob 3 Jun 2012, 09:48
+7 -0
Enough with the CLAT stories! It's really boring and monotonous now!
NALSUR 3 Jun 2012, 09:51
+1 -0
Let the trolling begin!
Raj 3 Jun 2012, 10:44
+0 -0
yeah enough with clat thingy
Amaltas 3 Jun 2012, 11:10
+7 -0
So once again, a generation of boys and girls join NALSAR abd NUJS with the biting knowledge that they were NLS rejects!

And a generation of boys and girls join NLIU Bhopal and Jodhpur knowing they were NALSAR and NUJS rejects.

And then these boys and girls will make their mark on history by writing on Legally India that my college is better than NLSIU. Losers!
Satlama 3 Jun 2012, 11:20
+9 -0
Except for the reputation of NLSIU (which such media articles build even further), what makes NLS the best?

Better quality students.

And why do the best students join NLS? Because of this 'false' sense of reputation.

NALSAR is way ahead of NLS in terms of infrastructure and matches it in recruitments and quality of the faculty.

NUJS is way ahead of NLS in terms of the quality of faculty and matches it in recruitments and infrastructure.

The fact is, NLS offers nothing over and above what NUJS and NALSAR have to offer.

Its self perpetuating, false myth; and will surely be demolished in the next few years.

NLS has done nothing of significance in the past few years. NLS rejects will soon become 'rejected NLS'.
Amaltas 3 Jun 2012, 11:31
+1 -0
[quote name="Satlama"]

NLS has done nothing of significance in the past few years. NLS rejects will soon become 'rejected NLS'.[/quote]

Dude, at the end of the day, a brand is a brand. IIMs infrastructure may be no better than XYZ college. But its a brand. Thats why the best studs go there and thats what makes them the best. Ditto NLS.

I hear the grapes and mangos are sour this time of year. Hahahaha
Satlama 3 Jun 2012, 12:03
+13 -1
NALSAR and NUJS are brand names in themselves. The studs from NALSAR and NUJS are thrashing the NLS kids everywhere; be it mooting, placements or research.

Talking about fruits, actually, they don't get sweeter than this.
Ad Nauseum 4 Jun 2012, 08:17
+1 -0
Vis Vienna. 'nuff said.
Nairobi 31 May 2013, 11:50
+0 -0
One year later, NLS is at the pinnacle at every major mooting event.

Tha ha!
rainaitbp 11 Jun 2012, 04:54
+0 -0
Dear satlama jee, competition is good and healthy one is even better but minus bitterness.
Jambaaz 3 Jun 2012, 11:14
+0 -0
he was erroneously allotted an NUSRL Ranchi seat, whereas his cut-off marks guaranteed him a seat___________


Fill in the blanks quiz by Legally India. Winner gets a special seat in Kian Ganz's International Law School in Mumbai.
Raj 3 Jun 2012, 11:49
+1 -0
I hear the grapes and mangos are sour this time of year. Hahahaa

brilliant!
haha 3 Jun 2012, 13:53
+1 -0
Nalsar and Nujs students thrashing NLS kids really? mooting, research, placements? i think u need to recheck ur facts.
also, NALSAR or NUJS might have better infrastructure or faculty than NLS but does it make them better than NLS? no. this because NLS is the best because of its academic standards and its academic rigour.
talking about NALSAR's infra, i don't get what great about NALSAR's infra, its located in a fucking village, what will you do of that infra. plus, last i went to the NLS library i remember seeing some NALSARites who came to our library because NALSAR's library in their own words is way too creepy.
and NLS has done nothing significant in recent years? you really think so ? haha...i don't think there is even a point in this.
Hypocritical haha 3 Jun 2012, 14:30
+6 -0
Fact number 1: MOOTING: NALSAR has been doing better than NLSIU in Mooting Premier League. Please check.

Fact number 2: PLACEMENTS: NLS-NUJS-NALSAR all have equally good placements; be it the top tier law firms or foreign law firms.

Fact number 3: ACADEMIC RIGOUR? NUJS' pedagogy was rated the best in India followed by Jindal by Lawyer's Update magazine.

NLS has done nothing significant over and above NALSAR/NUJS.
X-NLS 3 Jun 2012, 15:12
+1 -0
Nalsar better at mooting?
i think you need to see this mate-
http://www.legallyindia.com/wiki/MPL_3_season_standings

Also, tell me how many rhodes scholars nalsar/nujs produced this year? NIL.
have a look in here though-
http://www.legallyindia.com/Graduates-Bar-Exam/nlsius-vrinda-bhandari-only-indian-lawyer-to-win-oxford-rhodes-scholarship-will-return-to-india-for-research

Also, placements at NLS are way better than NUJS and NALSAR in terms of quality. NLS is the preferred choice for all foreign firms which is reflected in the consistently higher foreign offers received by NLS students.
http://www.legallyindia.com/201106022128/Law-schools/easy-money-for-nls-bangalore-100-jobs-strong-domestic-intl-firm-interest
also see-
http://www.legallyindia.com/201205152817/Law-schools/nls-day-zero
NLS is also the big daddy as far as debates are concerned.
see- http://worlddebating.blogspot.in/2010/09/9th-nls-debate.html
http://barandbench.com/brief/9/2251/nlsiu-wins-nalsars-2nd-inter-varsity-debate-university-of-cambridge-declared-runners-up
http://www.thehindu.com/news/states/karnataka/article3248230.ece

And last of all, our massive and incredible alumni base. With people like Umakanth, Dayan Krishnan, V Niranjan, Vikram Raghavan and many more out there, there is not much to say, is there?
ABC 3 Jun 2012, 15:30
+4 -0
A new institution can match or even topple an older one with the right administration (e.g. ISB toppled IIM, NLSIU toppled Delhi Univ). As an NUJS alum, I would have liked to see NUJS do well, as it was founded by Madhav Menon and many good things happened in the early years. Unfortunately, the VCs that succeeded Menon ruined the college.I also blame a certain person in the faculty who used NUJS for his personal publicity and promotion in recent years but did nothing for the college [...].
DEF 3 Jun 2012, 17:39
+4 -0
[quote name="ABC"]A new institution can match or even topple an older one with the right administration (e.g. ISB toppled IIM, NLSIU toppled Delhi Univ). As an NUJS alum, I would have liked to see NUJS do well, as it was founded by Madhav Menon and many good things happened in the early years. Unfortunately, the VCs that succeeded Menon ruined the college.I also blame a certain person in the faculty who used NUJS for his personal publicity and promotion in recent years but did nothing for the college and was a faculty in name only.[/quote]


and that certain person (faculty) [...] I agree to that point entirely. But I do not agree on the point of VC. Prof. M.P. Singh did not ruin anything, rather he has done many things for NUJS a lot.
XYZ 4 Jun 2012, 13:06
+0 -0
MP Singh is a good person who was handicapped by various problems outside his control. [...]
Anon 4 Jun 2012, 04:35
+0 -0
(e.g. ISB toppled IIM): Get your facts right - IIM Ahmedabad ranks way higher than ISB, Hyderabad. {Check: http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/global-mba-rankings-2012}
ISB aspirant 4 Jun 2012, 05:29
+0 -0
[quote name="Anon"](e.g. ISB toppled IIM): Get your facts right - IIM Ahmedabad ranks way higher than ISB, Hyderabad. {Check: http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/global-mba-rankings-2012}[/quote]

FT ranks ISB higher overall than all the IIMs. Only one IIM has a higher ranking in one prgrammme.
GMAT 4 Jun 2012, 05:50
+0 -0
The FT rankings of business schools are suspect at best. No one with a serious interest in attending these schools would rely on them to make decisions.
Better way-cut off marks 3 Jun 2012, 15:37
+0 -0
A better way to rank colleges will be on the basis of cut-off marks
Wrong Analysis 3 Jun 2012, 16:24
+1 -0
Since NLIU-Bhopal has to fill up only 30 seats, their mean is obviously lesser than NLU-Jodhpur. Nlu-Jodhpur has 75 seats to fill. NLU-Jodhpur does not have domicile reservation making it way better than NLIU-Bhopal. The Placements of Jodhpur and its MPL ranking further strengthen its credentials to be a first tier law school!!!
Hmm 3 Jun 2012, 17:07
+1 -0
The method implied by LI only takes the top 30 seats of NLU-J into account. That means NLIU has received a lot more top rankers as compared to NLU-J.
River 3 Jun 2012, 17:57
+2 -0
NLIU is older than Nalsar and NUJS but still has not been able to establish itself as a top tier law school. It is placed in tier 2 along with NLU-J with NLU-J being regarded better. The reason for that is the "MP" quota. With state based quotas it is very difficult for any university to tap talent from all across the country and are forced to admit students who are less deserving and may not be ready to compete at a national level. Nalsar too I believe has a quota but that is for the fairer sex (although going by the recent trends in the top 3 law schools its us guys who will soon be needing it) but that does not affect the talent pool much.

Plus Nalsar's infrastructure is better than all other colleges (though it is located in the middle of nowhere). NUJS despite starting off with the worst infra possible (did not have a campus for one and a half years) was able to make quick ground all thanks to Prof Madhava Menon and the hard work put in by the initial batches (eg Vienna champs and Jessup semis). Bhopal is lagging far behind despite having a head start and has been unsuccessful in attracting talent, both in terms of students and faculty from all across the country. Its sad but true that the bulk of the 33 students from the general category are primarily rejects of of the top 4 NLUs and the remaining have nowhere else to go.
Amaltas 3 Jun 2012, 20:52
+1 -0
[quote name="River"]NLIU is older than Nalsar and NUJS but still has not been able to establish itself as a top tier law school. It is placed in tier 2 along with NLU-J with NLU-J being regarded better. The reason for that is the "MP" quota. With state based quotas it is very difficult for any university to tap talent from all across the country and are forced to admit students who are less deserving and may not be ready to compete at a national level. Nalsar too I believe has a quota but that is for the fairer sex (although going by the recent trends in the top 3 law schools its us guys who will soon be needing it) but that does not affect the talent pool much.

Plus Nalsar's infrastructure is better than all other colleges (though it is located in the middle of nowhere). NUJS despite starting off with the worst infra possible (did not have a campus for one and a half years) was able to make quick ground all thanks to Prof Madhava Menon and the hard work put in by the initial batches (eg Vienna champs and Jessup semis). Bhopal is lagging far behind despite having a head start and has been unsuccessful in attracting talent, both in terms of students and faculty from all across the country. Its sad but true that the bulk of the 33 students from the general category are primarily rejects of of the top 4 NLUs and the remaining have nowhere else to go.[/quote]

Well written! To add to this, I would say that the lead NLS enjoys today is relatively low if you take into account the fact that it is about 10 years senior to NALSAR and NUJS. That will only get worse next year when the Karnataka quota kicks in.

similarly, NALSAR's lead over NUJS is slight given the vast differences in terms of money and infrastructure the former had. NUJS has really had to put in a lot more effort to reach where it is today, given the complete lack of any facilities it started off with. That goes to show just what a man Professor Madhava Menon was!

NLIU Bhopal is like the North Korean missile that never took off. The poor location and the state quota ensure it is a cesspool of rejects, however harsh that sounds.

NLU Jodhpur is IMO not really any better than Bhopal but the location (N India), lack of state quota and the anti-Bhopal factor mean that the student pool is better. The course and administration though is bollocks.
NLIU over NUJS 3 Jun 2012, 18:05
+0 -1
Saying that most law school aspirants preferred NLIU over NUJS was a big goof up.

I am surprised that NUJS students did not take offence to that as that was relegating them from tier 1 to tier 3
Alum 3 Jun 2012, 18:42
+11 -0
Such sweet, sweet trolling from many above.

And aren't we all touchy and running out this weekend to defend our alma maters?

Here's the deal. And we all need to be honest about this. As the no. of people taking the CLAT goes higher and higher every year, the difference in 'quality' of the top 200 odd rankers will be lesser and lesser. No, really. It already is. And smart people, be it employers, or foreign universities, will sooner or later wisen up to it. So much then, for the 'my wabooo strongest' rant routinely ushered in by losers across the spectrum.

Another thing is,for better or for worse, there's a noticeable increase in the no. of snobs getting through to law schools in recent years, and for the sake of all that is green and itchy, I hope every law school(and any fresher who might be reading this), does something about it. The one thing all law schools could do with, is bucketfuls of humility. Maybe we could start here.

For those who made it --- Yes, you made it. Congratulations. Sincere ones.

Now, could all of us please retain head on shoulders and not contribute any further to the (often deserved) tag of 'elitist-arrogant-irresponsible lawschoolite'?

Sincerely,
alum

ps. Braccae tuae aperiuntur
NLUJ over NLIU?!!! 3 Jun 2012, 20:16
+6 -0
All of you who has picked NLIU over NLUJ.. you have made the BIGGEST mistake of your life.
CLAT 2011 4 Jun 2012, 00:58
+0 -0
Another example of erroneous reporting. In CLAT 2010, at least 4 students did not pick NLSIU, and not only 2. 2 each in NALSAR and NUJS [Ranks 14, 52, 8 and 31]
New Start 4 Jun 2012, 05:48
+0 -0
All those who have managed the big 5 (NLS, Nalsar, NUJS, NLU-J and NLIU) all the best. Which college yu have graduated from will not matter if you work hard and do well. Make you sure all of you have a great time and be prepared for a little bit of positive interaction with your seniors.

All those who will join NLUD, its kind of uncharted waters but I have a feeling it will soon be giving NUJS and Nalsar a run for its money (to know why ask some of the senior Nalsar students)
Law Schools 4 Jun 2012, 06:02
+2 -0
Which law school you graduate from makes a good amount of difference. The reason why NLS, Nalsar and NUJS are in the top bracket is because of the opportunity these colleges provide their students.

1. Foreign placements- NLS by far has the best foreign placements. Their foreign placements are always in double digits which means more than 1/8th of the batch every year). Nalsar has around 7 and NUJS around 5.

2. Domestic Placements- NLS again leads the race in terms of domestic placements. Nalsar enjoys the second spot amongst law firms with NUJS a fraction behind them. Amongst corporates its NUJS that has the best domestic placements.

3.Higher studies abroad- NLS again rules the roost. Nalsar, thanks to Ms Danda has been able to inculcate a good culture in academics and sees a good number of students going for higher studies. NUJS lags behind in this category. The 2013 batch luckily has been able to break the fascination with corp jobs and has a lot of students who wish have opted out of placements and are looking to go for higher studies, but I think that is all because of people such as Prof MP Singh, Shamnad Basheer (NLS), Prabhash Ranjan, Pritam Baruah and Saurabh (last two are students of Ms Danda- so I guess Nalsar and NLS deserves some credit for the change at NUJS:p).

Now if you compare the other colleges, NLU-J and NLIU they do not enjoy a standing in the legal franternity (especially abroad) which is at par with the top 3 resulting in the lesser opportunities being available to their students.
Rohit 4 Jun 2012, 06:17
+0 -0
Dear Kian,
The cutoff list is not entirely correct. I know people who got 870 in General and are in RGNUL.. please make some corrections...
Thank you.
Delhi Lawyer 4 Jun 2012, 07:07
+4 -0
No law school will teach you the art of getting clients :) Business of law is much different than practice of law. Instead of slogging under the Shroffs and Modis, aspire to do something in your own life.
PR 4 Jun 2012, 09:07
+0 -0
As per the table, In 2011 SOMEBODY with Rank 168 chose RMLNLU Lucknow over NUJS Kolkata...whaaaaatttttt?? SOMEBODY's gonna get hurt real bad then..
Anon 4 Jun 2012, 09:26
+3 -0
@21 : Couldnt agree more. The "business of law" is very different from the "study of law". Chalk and cheese. U can be the most technically proficient lawyer in the world but without the ability to harness a client base, u wud be no better than the average lawyer. Law is a business more than a profession and this is all the more true for law firms. Fact. Nothing to be ashamed of.
FACT 5 Jun 2012, 06:26
+0 -0
NLUJAA was established in 2011 and not in 2009.
Lawstudent 7 Jun 2012, 10:23
+0 -0
Good to see 'Harvard of the east' rising.
pavi06 8 Jun 2012, 19:41
+0 -0
I'd been alloted for NLU-Assam and everyone adviced me to join some local clge and take up CLAT again in 2013..!@ I badly wanted to join there..:(:(any say on this lyk;;whether i've missed an opportunity..;wasted one year..;you wud have gone..;you have done the right thing..;Do have some say..opinion matters..'m still regretting:(:(
pavi06 8 Jun 2012, 19:41
+0 -0
I'd been alloted for NLU-Assam and everyone adviced me to join some local clge and take up CLAT again in 2013..!@ I badly wanted to join there..:(:(any say on this lyk;;whether i've missed an opportunity..;wasted one year..;you wud have gone..;you have done the right thing..;Do have some say..opinion matters..'m still regretting:(:(