The Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) 2015 expert committee has found that the CLAT 2015 LLB question paper has no errors, the Punjab & Haryana high court was told yesterday in a writ filed by CLAT 2015 candidate Agrima Lailer on 12 June through advocate Ravinder Malik.
Lailer told Legally India that CLAT 2015 convenor RMLNLU Lucknow’s counsel yesterday submitted a sealed cover to the Punjab & Haryana high court stating that the expert committee - formed for the second-time since the CLAT 2015 results were declared – has reported that the errors referred to it were, in fact, not errors.
P&H HC Justice RK Jain, who was discussing the contents of the sealed cover, responded to the convenor’s counsel that even he could spot at least one obvious error, citing the analogy question 25 that had clearly relied on wrong definitions in the word pair ‘dulcet-raucous’, Lailer said.
Lailer’s writ, which brings before the court 16 alleged errors in the question paper, is posted to be heard on Thursday.
This is the second error-evaluation expert panel to have been formed by the CLAT office this year, on the orders of the Bombay high court, after the first panel only found two errors out of many more alleged errors referred to it by candidates and experts.
Writs in various high courts, including Lailer’s, have so far alleged nearly 40 errors in the LLB question paper.
Comments
The fault is of his parents who had all the power, and yet allowed his brazenness to reach thus far.
The cancer is in their flesh and blood.
Thou art my flesh, my blood, my daughter—
Or rather a disease that’s in my flesh,
Which I must needs call mine.
Thou art a boil, a plague-sore
or embossed carbuncle
In my corrupted blood.
King Lear (Act 2, Scene 4)
Bharat hamaari mata hai
Aagey kuchh nahin aata hai
But in the interest of justice, I would love to see a bunch of students who have nothing to lose (at the end of the day a law degree (from anywhere) is a law degree) to get together and drag this matter to its logical conclusion in the courts - contempt, corruption, expose the ineptitude, the malafides, the cover-up, the lies to the courts etc.
Such students who have nothing to lose & who take up this fight & hopefully have access to lawyers who will support them will not only do something admirable but also achieve recognition. So don't give up guys even if your admissions are now set in stone for practical reasons, fight this matter to the end, treat it as practical experience, put it on your cv ...
You have rightly presumed the sentiments of the admitted students. But there is a large number of left out students and their parents who can join hands for eliminating the suspected Vyapam in the CLAT Committee. Now let us join hands to gather more information/opinion from legal fraternity and put them in a National Forum for further investigation, not for anyone's harm but to testify/rectify the students/parents knowledge for future reference. Otherwise we will not know the correct answers to teach/refer our next budding lawyers. CLAT Authorities will never come out with the truth because they are terribly afraid right now.
With regards,
S.Kumar