Old-school CLAT prefs wobble as NUJS gains on Nalsar; NLIU, NLU-J locked dead-heat

Pencil sharpened at the ready, set and go.
Pencil sharpened at the ready, set and go.
Exclusive analysis: NLSIU Bangalore still topped preferences among 2011 Common Law Admissions Test (CLAT) takers but NUJS Kolkata made up ground to second-most-popular Nalsar Hyderabad with eight going against convention. Plus, Legally India’s new Super 30 shows NLU Jodhpur on par with NLIU Bhopal.

NLSIU Bangalore still topped preferences among Common Law Admissions Test (CLAT) takers but NUJS Kolkata made up ground to second-most-popular Nalsar Hyderabad with eight going against convention.

NLSIU still led by far with the 32 highest CLAT scorers opting for the college, which this year had 58 places on the general list. The lowest rank to have been accepted to the NLSIU general list was at 64.

However, two people traditionally in the NLSIU ranks opted for Nalsar as their first choice and NUJS picked up three who could have also made it to NLSIU.

NLS vis-à-vis Nalsar/NUJS

The 33rd, 36th and 60th ranked chose NUJS Kolkata, which is traditionally a lower preference for CLAT takers than both NLSIU and Nalsar.

Nalsar managed to attract the 59th and 62nd ranked who could also have made the NLSIU cut-off.

Last year two toppers each chose NUJS and Nalsar respectively, despite having been able to opt for NLSIU Bangalore.

NUJS vis-à-vis Nalsar

In a big gain for NUJS eight CLAT takers gave it a first choice, despite having been able to also make it to Nalsar.

Last year only two students each had foregone guaranteed NLSIU or Nalsar seats respectively for NUJS (ranks 8, 31, 100 and 101 had selected NUJS; NLSIU’s cut-off was 59th rank and Nalsar’s was 102nd).

The Top 30 Avg Rank: NLU Jodhpur same as NLIU Bhopal

Legally India’s new Top 30 Average Rank metric, which averages the top 30 ranks at each college to come up with a weighted indication of topper-preferences without penalising larger batches, gives a clearer picture of topper preferences.

NLSIU still clearly leads and Nalsar’s top 30 scores are still 30 higher than NUJS’.

But NLIU Bhopal and NLU Jodhpur are locked head-to-head, with only a fractional difference in their respective averages scores of its 30 highest scoring entrants at 221.1 and 221.3 respectively.

NLIU with a general list batch of 37 – the smallest out of all law schools – has the stronger total average of 231, ahead of NLU Jodhpur’s 267 this year.

Nuals Kochi plummets two, HNLU, RMLNLU pull ahead

Nuals Kochi dropped behind HNLU Raipur and RMLNLU Lucknow in preference, which are now in seventh and eighth behind GNLU Gandhinagar.

The average rank for Nuals choices in 2010 was 442, which dropped to 543 this year or a Super 30 score of 507.9.

HNLU Raipur on the other hand rose slightly to 466 with an increased batch of 10 (see below), and a Super 30 score of 418.

RMLNLU Lucknow’s average rank dropped from last year to 538, with a Super 30 rank of 475.6.

RGNUL Patiala and CNLU Patna close the rankings with Super 30 ranks of 594.6 and 711.1 respectively.

By a whisker

The cut-off CLAT marks out of 200 between top-colleges are slim. Only five points each on the 200 question multiple choice CLAT divide the bottom cut-off at NLSIU (147), Nalsar (142), NUJS (137) and NLIU (132) in that order, with NLU Jodhpur’s lowest mark being only one point below NLIU’s.

GNLU and HNLU’s cut-off marks at 128 and 125 are only three and six points below NLU Jodhpur, while RMLNLU and Nuals cut-offs are both at 123 points. RGNUL and CNLU Patna’s cut-offs are at 122 and 120 respectively.

Full marks were awarded on several questions to all candidates this year, after some papers contained underlined answers, which confused test takers.

Buffered seating

The overall seat capacity at each university this year was increased by approximately 4 per cent with so-called “buffer seats” allotted to the all-India general category, decided the CLAT committee.

“This buffer is in order to provide against vacancies that may arise at the time of admissions,” explained the committee, with HNLU on request having been provided with a buffer of 10 seats. All students on the list or on buffer seats would be guaranteed a place, even if no students dropped out, did not take up their offers or did not pay their admission fees, according to a member of the CLAT committee.

The member explained: “We’ve generated the first list today. We ask folks to pay 25,000 immediately to confirm their seats. If they don’t pay within the window, their names will not be on second list. The second list will consist of the revised list consisting of first list folks who paid 25,000 and those who’ve moved up to fill the vacancies created by those who did not pay 25,000.”

CLAT 2011 facts, figures, cut-offs

Highest rank (’11)Lowest rank (’11)Cut-off mark (of 200, ‘11)Super 30 (top 30 avg rank ‘11)Avg. rank (’11)General list places (’11)Highest rank (’10)Lowest rank (’10)Avg. rank (’10)General list places (’10)Founded
NLSIU Bangalore16414715.5315815930551987
Nalsar Hyderabad5911714280.489441410278411998
NUJS Kolkata33196137110.0147838205146781999
NLIU Bhopal137277132221.12313770244197351997
NLU Jodhpur125322131221.326780109321263742001
GNLU Ghandinagar263427128336.337582112480389792003
HNLU Raipur33655112541846662219527449522003
RMLNLU Lucknow168621123475.653874151592492802006
Nuals Kochi163638123507.954344110581442332005
RGNUL Patiala358710122594.664776207637586482006
CNLU Patna641778120711.173663410668631382006

Source: CLAT.ac.in; Additional research: Jay Sayta

Download:

Read more:

Photo by arquera

Comments

annonymous 16 Jun 2011, 09:12
+3 -0
those opting 4 rgnul plz try sme other College..n who is the fool with 358 rnk joining RGNUL...Dude plz change ur opinion..another option 4 u is 2 contact the students of RGNUL..thy wil tel u the real student..PLZ tke a wise decision..
D 16 Jun 2011, 09:39
+0 -0
NUJS was started in 2000 and not 1999!
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 10:13
+1 -0
Thanks, you're right, fixed - NUJS was established in 1999 and started taking students in 2000 only.
Sidhanth 16 Jun 2011, 09:42
+1 -0
nice job mr kian.
your hard work has made legally india the no 1 choice for law students to find info about law schools.
on a side note, nlsiu shows once again, why its the best :)
myth 16 Jun 2011, 09:50
+0 -0
self perpetuating myth. don't rely on baseless magazine rankings, or the choice made my students who'd be too scared to break loose from a herd mentality. look at performance and at facts. nalsar is the best, followed by nujs and then nls.
hahahaha 16 Jun 2011, 10:07
+0 -0
NALSAR will soon be the third best; as the stats show...NUJS is gaining ground by leaps and bounds.

Better placements, a much better faculty and a huge advantage on location! Why will anyone choose NALSAR now?

This time the recruitment stats were out late; or NUJS would have been the clear 2nd!
whatever 16 Jun 2011, 12:07
+3 -0
[quote name="hahahaha"]NALSAR will soon be the third best; as the stats show...NUJS is gaining ground by leaps and bounds.

Better placements, a much better faculty and a huge advantage on location! Why will anyone choose NALSAR now?

This time the recruitment stats were out late; or NUJS would have been the clear 2nd![/quote]
lots of students like me don't really give a hoot about who is first..or second...or third..all are terrific. i had the option of choosing between nalsar and nujs but i chose nalsar because i have a my brother and sister there. oh and a side note...notice how many students there were in each batch..how many students sat for placements and how many opted for higher studies in all three institutions..compare and then come to a conclusion before starting an "ego"logical flame war
Aditya Kandy 18 Jun 2011, 09:04
+0 -0
your pattern of ranking law colleges seems to be considering only one parameter and that is MOOTING....ryt???? so, for you, law college means mooting.. Fair enough, but ket me tell you, there are a lot of other important factors that make a college, a college. Go n ask your seniors what they have done to bring NALSAR to this height. Its good that at keast you are concentrating on one factor and constantly working hard to improve on it.
blah again 16 Jun 2011, 09:44
+5 -0
NLIU over NLUJ??

you guys wont get jobs ever.
blah again 16 Jun 2011, 09:48
+1 -0
NLUJ students ('12) have got

5 ppos from Luthra AND 2 from AMSS already.

NLIU students dont even get an opportunity to intern in such firms.
CLAT aspirants WTH 16 Jun 2011, 09:57
+3 -0
Why will any sane person opt for NLIU over NLUJ?

BTW Kian, your last year's anaysis was better. Please update us on avg. scores of the candidates...this will show how close these students are on capabilities.
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 10:14
+2 -0
Thanks - this one's a work in progress. We have now added a column for mark cut-offs too and will keep adding more to the table as we extract the data out of the spreadsheets.
NUJS will soon overtake NALSAR 16 Jun 2011, 09:59
+0 -0
NUJS will soon overtake NALSAR. This is a given. NUJS faculty is continually getting better and is in one word 'classy'. The top notch placements and a dream location will propel it to greater heights!
Dunkirk! 17 Jun 2011, 08:18
+0 -0
Dude! You are a NUJS student! I want to set up an entrepreneurship thing with you man. That's what you guys keep doing all time.
Anon 19 Jun 2011, 14:08
+1 -0
My startup needs a peon, interested?
Aditya Kandy 18 Jun 2011, 09:09
+2 -0
hahaha.....u nujies are still kids.....many of the faculty members in ur college that u hype about are from NALSAR and NLSIU....
Kaaaaaaaaaandy 19 Jun 2011, 14:34
+0 -0
Ha Ha! Those faculties were about to join NALSAR, but didnt join because of Poor Administration Ha Ha!

They didnt join NLS becuase NUJS environment was flexible. Ha! ha.

You Nalsirurts and NLSiiiiitss are just small cute kids :P
Noojie 20 Jun 2011, 03:40
+0 -0
hasnt that already happened? look at the placement data this year
The trinity of NLS-NUJS-NALSAR 16 Jun 2011, 10:04
+0 -0
This shows the HUGE gap which exists between the trinity of NLS-NUJS-NALSAR and other law schools.

Just have a look at the average ranks.

NLSIU- 15
NALSAR- 80
NUJS- 110

And then a HUGE gap.

NLIU- 221
NLUJ- 221
Silly 25 Jun 2011, 22:03
+0 -0
Silly fellow, the huge difference in the average rank is because of the huge number of seats available at NUJS. Instead, see the cutoffs and their difference. 131-147- a difference of merely 16 marks amongst the top 5 colleges. That too a difference of 6 marks between the 3rd, 4th and 5th colleges (NUJS, NLLIU, NLUJ)
remain or wobble 16 Jun 2011, 10:06
+1 -0
Why have you turned on the title on its head?

Is it "CLAT preferences REMAIN"? or "CLAT preferences WOBBLE"?
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 10:15
+1 -0
Good spot. The story was initially published without final data on some of the lower-preference colleges. We have now updated this and reverted the title to 'wobble' since some rankings have changed.
glaring mistake 16 Jun 2011, 10:10
+0 -0
Why have you put NUALS high up on the table when it should be placed much lower?
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 10:16
+2 -0
The order is last year's order - we are compiling cut-offs and averages as we go and will update the table and the order once all the figures are in. Please bear with us in the meantime.
the myth called NLSIU 16 Jun 2011, 10:17
+1 -0
3 students preferred NUJS over NLSIU.

2 students preferred NALSAR over NLSIU.

Sign of things to come! Go NUJS! Go NALSAR!

Demolish the cartel, the myth, the egotist, the supercilious called NLSIU!

I can already see people at NLS getting insecure!
Sidhanth 16 Jun 2011, 10:22
+3 -0
as far as i can see, only u are feeling insecure .
the top 29 ranks unanimously chose nls.
choron ko sab chor nazar aatey hain. :D
the sheep 16 Jun 2011, 10:26
+1 -0
They are the sheep buddy! People who know the scene will embrace the change.

NALSAR gives you better infra.
NUJS gives you better location and faculty.

What is better at NLSIU vis-a-vis NUJS/NALSAR?

The mythical reputation? That is it?
Sidhanth 16 Jun 2011, 10:58
+1 -0
nlsiu has double the no. of foreign placements when compared to nalsar and nujs.
nlsiu is going to recruit new world class faculty.
nlsiu has good faculty, although nujs has better.
nlsiu has the best alumni network.
nlsiu is the biggest brand name in legal education in india.
the only thing going for nalsar is mpl, a perch from which you will be knocked off next year by nlsiu.
nalsar and nujs will always follow nlsiu. the king of kings.
hahahaha 16 Jun 2011, 11:44
+2 -0
true about foreign placements; but see the stas for top domestic law firms. these are the ones who know the ground realities of law schools and thus are making their movies in favour of colleges like NUJS and NLUJ.

new faculty- dream on

best alumni network- doesn't matter. that is ascertainable to age; not excellence.

biggest brand name? thats being toppled. NLSIU is doing nothing to keep upto its brand name. for NLSIU, it has been a downhill journey since the last three years.

NLSIU has the myth factor. The myth is slowly being destroyed.
Sidhanth 16 Jun 2011, 13:07
+1 -0
so you claim that foreign firms dont have the ability to see the quality of students?
regarding domestic firms, amss recruited 12 students each from nls,nalsar, and nujs.
this shows that the difference b/w the three is very less.
the difference manifests itself in the no. of foreign placements.
and if nlsiu was doing nothing to promote its brand, why are all the toppers chosing it?
a myth. yeah well, maybe..the difference is very less in terms of quality, and thats where the better brand wins.
Biggest Brand Name huh? 22 Jun 2011, 13:54
+0 -0
Sidhant,

What brand name? Might have had some, but today? think again !
Did you not see your college website where they have put your SBA Vice President's accomplishment? With a photo and everything? Just for getting his article published in NLIU Law Review?
Sidhanth 16 Jun 2011, 11:01
+1 -0
in short, nlsiu has the X factor. :P
Anonymous 16 Jun 2011, 16:04
+2 -0
They were misguided people. May be the tall claims made by Noojies and Nalsarites on forums like LI had some contribution?

[quote name="the myth called NLSIU"]3 students preferred NUJS over NLSIU.

2 students preferred NALSAR over NLSIU.
[/quote]
tall claims? OR FACTS? 17 Jun 2011, 06:07
+1 -0
Those weren't tall claims bud. Facts. Simple facts.

NLSIU can't match NALSAR's infra.
NLSIU can't match NUJS' faculty and location.
Placements are neck to neck in all three.

NLS offers nothing vis-a-vis NALSAR and NUJS.
Le 16 Jun 2011, 20:52
+2 -0
8.5% people preferring NUJS/NALSAR over NLS does not in any way threaten the hegemony of NLS.
it does make a dent 17 Jun 2011, 06:08
+1 -0
It does make a dent though.
Earlier top top 54 would go to NALSAR.

That now 5-6 students will be going to NUJS/NALSAR is a good trend. People will take note. The rise and rise of NUJS and NALSAR has already made a dent into NLSIU's hegemony!
NLIU Bhopal over NLUJ! 16 Jun 2011, 10:20
+2 -0
The people who have chose NLIU Bhopal over NLU Jodhpur have committed a BLUNDER!

NLIU Bhopal had shit recruitments this time! NLUJ was much much better!

What were you thinking CLAT aspirants? Did you leave all your brains on the CLAT desk?
J 16 Jun 2011, 10:42
+2 -0
The recruitment figures show that NLU-J is slightly ahead, but still it is the students who make up the name of the institute; and the students have voted NLIU to be fourth-so be it!
Anonymous 16 Jun 2011, 16:06
+2 -0
They havent voted it to be fourth. They have just blindly followed the CLAT seniority list. NLUJ has not only fared better in placements but also done much better in other things like Moots.

[quote name="J"]The recruitment figures show that NLU-J is slightly ahead, but still it is the students who make up the name of the institute; and the students have voted NLIU to be fourth-so be it![/quote]
anonymous@nujs 16 Jun 2011, 10:21
+2 -0
So here they are - the satistics! Revealing that NALSARites are just the self-proclaimed #1!

Good going NUJS! Congratulations! :)
KGB 16 Jun 2011, 10:39
+1 -0
The Clat students have ranked the colleges the same way as predicted.
Congrats NUJS 16 Jun 2011, 10:41
+1 -0
CLAT 2009 NUJS General Merit Closed at 357 Rank.

CLAT 2010 - It closed at 205 Rank(1st List) with 78 candidates.
2nd list - 242
CLAT 2011 - It closed at 196 Rank with 83 General candidates.(2nd list unlikely to go much higher)

Share rate of NUJS has increased drastically over last few years.
2009 stats wrong 16 Jun 2011, 11:00
+1 -0
Your 2009 stats are wrong!
Congrats NUJS 16 Jun 2011, 15:31
+1 -0
Yes, it closed at somewhere at 844 rank. Vacant seats. I remember. Else, by the 3rd list 357 rank was confirmed.
NLU J 16 Jun 2011, 13:04
+2 -0
we are gunning for the so-called Top 3 law schools.. I think NUJS gets all the hype but we have done really well in every field. In fact, last year we beat most other law schools at mooting. Also, social life at NLU J is the best. NUJS doesnt hold candle to us in that respect.

Concerned young lawyer
Aspiring Young Lawyer 16 Jun 2011, 13:24
+4 -0
in that case you should feel bad about this acceptance of inferiority. people fight for top slot not for the third spot at the podium. i really hope you guys have a good social life, given the fact that u r located somewhere off the mark near the sleepy town of Jodhpur (i know u 'll HIT BACK with all that hogwash about how Jodhpur is the "it" city), atleast a good group-therapy session will ward-off ever looming mass depression. A word of wisdom to you Mr. Concerned Young Lawyer, gun for the best.
cheers.
Not a very young lawyer 16 Jun 2011, 20:04
+1 -0
I think concerned young lawyer has put in an adequate disclaimer using the word "so-called" before the term "top 3". And are you trying to suggest that NUJS is at the third spot?
AYL 17 Jun 2011, 05:01
+1 -0
Not at all. personally i really don't care about the rankings of the institutions. Well if do need to know about my suggestion then i think NLSIU, NALSAR and NUJS are the only law schools to labeled Tier 1 (going by their track record). as far as the "so called" part, i think concerned lawyer's comment leaves him in a worse off position cause now i know that he wants to fight for the spot which apparently doesn't even exist...
NLUJ 17 Jun 2011, 05:53
+3 -0
Do you think someone would prefer burning in Jodhpur, a small town than be in salt lake city, Kolkata? haha.

NLUJ isn't in the league baby!
ZM 16 Jun 2011, 14:01
+1 -0
Both NLIU and NLUJ had 80-85 % recruitment (clerkships included).. What is shocking is NLIU's State List closer above Jodhpur's National List ( 2010 figures)..
Reply 16 Jun 2011, 16:08
+4 -0
Check LI kid. NLIU had 75% and NLUJ had more than 95% placements (clerkships included).
Ram Jaspal 16 Jun 2011, 14:12
+1 -0
With 37 General List Places NLIU places almost 45-50 people with each batch.. thats a big achievement LOL :P !! I think that deserves recognition..

NALSAR with 44 general seats places more than that.
Ram Jaspal 16 Jun 2011, 14:14
+1 -0
Be ready guys..

all law colleges are soon gonna have the 50 per cent quota..

:D
Law Grad 16 Jun 2011, 14:38
+1 -0
NUJS certainly has been rising the ranks, consistently. Placements, faculty, mootcourt achievements, research output by faculty, NUJS Law Review, start-ups by the enterprising students and a certainly very proactive VC in Professor M.P. Singh, all ensure that NUJS has the recipe for success ready. The results are there for all to see. Even the Legal Aid Society that is otherwise considered to be less glamorous in Indian law schools, is extremely dynamic and active. Coming to the location, NUJS is albeit the best. In Salt Lake City and in close proximity to most of the best facilities that Kolkata has to offer and all that a Law School student will need, NUJS certainly is in a different league of its own. Nalsar may have the best infrastructure, but isnt it natural that they create all the infrastrucutre from zero because of their location outside Hyderabad? Besides, does infrastructure like a sprawling campus, glass and steel buildings, amongst a host of others that are usually talked about, matter to the a Law School? As long as a University ensures that the basic infrastructure is in place and consistently endeavours to improve it, it should serve its students well. NUJS in its a little over a decade march has risen to create its own legacy and niche.
Yawn 16 Jun 2011, 15:05
+2 -0
[quote name="Law Grad"]NUJS certainly has been rising the ranks, consistently. Placements, faculty, mootcourt achievements, research output by faculty, NUJS Law Review, start-ups by the enterprising students and a certainly very proactive VC in Professor M.P. Singh, all ensure that NUJS has the recipe for success ready. The results are there for all to see. Even the Legal Aid Society that is otherwise considered to be less glamorous in Indian law schools, is extremely dynamic and active. Coming to the location, NUJS is albeit the best. In Salt Lake City and in close proximity to most of the best facilities that Kolkata has to offer and all that a Law School student will need, NUJS certainly is in a different league of its own. Nalsar may have the best infrastructure, but isnt it natural that they create all the infrastrucutre from zero because of their location outside Hyderabad? Besides, does infrastructure like a sprawling campus, glass and steel buildings, amongst a host of others that are usually talked about, matter to the a Law School? As long as a University ensures that the basic infrastructure is in place and consistently endeavours to improve it, it should serve its students well. NUJS in its a little over a decade march has risen to create its own legacy and niche.[/quote]

*yawn* I am sick of this self-boasting.
NLUite 16 Jun 2011, 21:09
+3 -0
lol i agree. All that NUJS do is self boast about themselves... yaaaawwwnn again...
Babaji 17 Jun 2011, 14:45
+1 -0
The library, dude, the library.
Dunkirk! 17 Jun 2011, 17:12
+1 -0
Babaji! Aap yahaan! Dhanya hai!
Aditya Kandy 18 Jun 2011, 09:22
+3 -0
arey baba baboo......what are u talking about?????NUJS has a good lib,is that so?????a good section on SPACE LAW where the college has been deteriorating its performance to demostrate the same....MANFRERD LACHS: what a route for NUJS against GNLU n NLUD....

BABAJI bane baboo.....
Dunkirk! 19 Jun 2011, 08:03
+1 -0
Learn sarcasm, Kandy shop
Babaji 19 Jun 2011, 13:25
+2 -0
Manfred*

They call it a "reading room". Libraries have books and space, this college has a small hall with a few donated books. (And lots of Leftist literature)
Disgusted with LI 16 Jun 2011, 15:53
+8 -0
I don't know if this comment will get posted, but if it does, this is to express my extreme and utter disgust at LI. Kian - you have turned this website from one which everyone thought was being modeled off the Lawyer and bringing news and information about law firms to a forum where 1st and 2nd year law students come to berate other law schools and have petty and idiotic fights. (FYI - If this comment is not posted, I would still urge you, Kian to read it... I do not want to necessarily make this a public comment, but would like you to note my thoughts here)

LI sure enjoys it and maybe that is what is keeping the site going - the sensationalized headings are just fodder for people to pounce on and argue... I was really hoping that this website would be made appealing to mature readers and actual lawyers - Kian: if you and your team care to know, there are amazing and interesting deals happening out there, and NO - that is not a lead to make a forum for 1st and 2nd year associates of Indian law firms to start fighting about whose *&%$ is bigger.... Please bring in interesting and exciting news - that 1st and 2nd year students and lawyers alike can enjoy and benefit from, and also make this a forum where people stay abreast of legal news... not just placements and college admissions.

No doubt, your attempt is to present a complete picture and I appreciate your efforts in compiling college placements data, but please make this a little sane by disallowing comments... it frankly makes me, as I am sure it does a lot of slightly more mature people, who have passed out from law schools a fair number of years back, quite disgusted to see the silly bickering.... I know some guys are going to come and say "well... why don't I just stop reading this site"... and my response is, I read it because I like to know the news, but news should be presented in a manner that does not sensationalize and instigate petty squabbling.

My two cents for what its worth... Cheers!
Reply 16 Jun 2011, 16:33
+5 -0
Why do you want to rob people the entertainment of commenting and recommenting? I think LI gives people fair notice when it says- "View comments at your own risk"

You should realise more than 50% of the content on LI is not inter law school comparison related. Its a different thing that these meaningful articles attract much less comments in comparison to the mudslinging prone ones.
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 19:41
+3 -0
Thanks for your feedback. I understand where you are coming from and it is a constant conflict we face.

We get so much feedback from students who love reading the comments as a bit of harmless fun. And because it is mostly their voice that gets heard in the comments, perhaps we often assume that the comments are a niche for them and those who don't enjoy comments never read them.

On the other hand, I can understand that they are a waste of time and somewhat frustrating for more serious readers. But can more insightful and as lively discussions be had on these subjects if we moderate more heavily to block anything insulting, or would it just turn into a bunch of dry platitudes?

In response to your point we have introduced the hiding of comments by default, for example, to keep such discussions confined to only those who really wish to read them. But short of disallowing comments completely, which would upset a large number of law school readers who are a large audience of our law school articles, I do not see an easy solution.

I do harbour the hope that all this transparency - much of which is still very new - will contribute to all law schools one day seeing things more rationally and some of this fighting toning down.

And perhaps the last two weeks have been particularly vitriolic because of the 'high stakes' of the CLAT selections around the corner and the lobbying by college students trying to show that they are not as bad as others say or to entice the best students.

Now that the selections are over and the dust will settle, maybe discourse will be more civilised?

After all, there are only so many ways that people can say 'my college is better than yours' before it gets boring, no?

Perhaps I am wrong or my approach is not correct. I would be grateful for suggestions and more feedback as ever.

Best regards
Kian
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 19:45
+1 -0
Ps: That said, having read the free debate in the comments has also taught me personally a lot about Indian law schools and legal education, both good and bad. Perhaps that is the case for some other readers too? I feel that if you take everything you read in comments with a large pinch of salt, there can be some value extracted, even in the mudslinging?
kianganz 16 Jun 2011, 19:51
+3 -0
Pps: I didn't talk about our headlines.

I do not like to think that we over-sensationalise news but all newspapers and publications do need to sensationalise news to some extent to make it interesting to readers (or at least what hacks thing readers are interested in).

Otherwise our headline here should have read: "The CLAT preferences have been announced today". I would not want to read that story, nor would it be very informative.

We therefore try to pick angles that will make readers ask questions, provoke some thought or surprise and make readers want to learn more. All journalists will be guilty of that to some degree but it is unfortunately part of the profession.

Take The Economist, for example, a publication far superior to Legally India, where a headline about Italy's PM Berlusconi yesterday read: "The man who screwed an entire country." It may be sensationalising but I wanted to read more when I saw it.
Law School-ite 16 Jun 2011, 16:25
+4 -0
NUJS people are going gaga over this. Great going! your long propaganda paid off. wonderful stuff! keep it. [...] deserve a special mention. Any awards for 'Special Services to the L-School' being instituted at NUJS for these two?
NUJS knows it all:
NLS is a myth.
They haven't been to Nalsar but they know of their faculty.
HNLU is a failed institute.
NLIU is not going places.

NUJS. GOD HATH SPOKEN. Wait for the bubbl burst guys. Startups are well just upstarts.
Nalsarite 17 Jun 2011, 06:44
+2 -0
hahahaha! awesome! :D
Dunkirk! 17 Jun 2011, 08:20
+2 -0
Gimme a smoke, man
Law School-ite 17 Jun 2011, 14:19
+4 -0
trippesh dudddee!

Closest anyone comes to pulling off an argument in favor of NLS (the usual retort being "NLS is great well.. uhh.. because it iss NLS.. that's what we heard when we came here.. oh crap, aren't we the best?").. and what do you have to say? Wait for OUR bubble to burst?

Great argument my friend =D! That's a great argument indeed!

PS
For faculty comparison, use the internet. It's been around a while. Use it. And Noojies aren't very interested in whatever you had to say about NLIU / HNLU. We're eyeing that top spot that you'd been holding before we came around.
Le 16 Jun 2011, 18:22
+2 -0
good statistical analysis, but add SD to show the swing within the group
Chulbul Pandey 17 Jun 2011, 00:39
+6 -0
I'm really impressed..

NUJS has a special course in their 1st year - The History of National Law Schools.

After the course they're asked to start 10 blogs per batch and prepare their own rankings based on that where they modify certain parts as if they'd been to the past as Doctor Who.
NALSAR- the badnaam munni 17 Jun 2011, 05:57
+6 -0
In a similar course NALSAR kids are asked to 10 CLAT coaching institutions, ask all those who made it to the top to prefer NALASR over NLSIU and NUJS.

NALSAR kids are also taught the art of discreet persuassion by secret phone calls.
Jealous? 17 Jun 2011, 06:09
+1 -0
Ooooh! Red with jealously?
Neutral 17 Jun 2011, 09:02
+9 -0
I am first a neutral observer and then a graduate from NLSIU. My brother appeared for CLAT 2011 and is joining NLSIU. Having read the articles and comments on this forum for the past six months I have the following assertions to make on the first five NLU's established in India:

i) NLSIU is numero uno because of its rich history (since 1987) and the students that join this institution.

ii) Among the next established i.e. NLIU (1997) and NALSAR (1998) I consider NALSAR to be slightly ahead because of its location (hyderabad) and the efforts made by Prof. Ranbir Sing (its first director). However, in terms of academic, I consider NLIU Bhopal to be better because of the trimester system (similar to NLSIU) which keeps the students on their toes, if not for 5 years than at least for 4 and half years. In terms of placement NALSAR is better, however, one must not forget that out NLIU has a 50% state quota and inspite of that it is able to place 80% of its students on a consistent basis. Overall, though, NALSAR is ahead despite of being established a year later.

iii) I have never noticed students from NLIU joining issues with the fellow students from WBNUJS and NLUJ on the acerbic comments made by them. Anyone who is a regular to LI would have noticed the repeated attempts made by a few students from WBNUJS and NLUJ to belittle everything about NLIU. According to me, by not choosing to reply or take umbrage of their comments, students from NLIU come out smarter and sanely.

iv) Next established was NUJS in 2000. Has without doubt the best location advantage and faculty. Calcutta or Kolkata has to be the intellectual and cultural capital of India. They are a potential threat to NLSIU's number one position. However, the students can do without self publicity though.

v) Then came NLUJ in 2001. The students are good and the infrastructure is even better. The students can do without self publicity though.
Le 17 Jun 2011, 10:27
+7 -0
Now I know where from India Today used to get the neutral rank list creators.
Another neutral person 18 Jun 2011, 06:01
+6 -0
Assuming you are actually a graduate from NLSIU, what makes you think that the anonymous comments on LI against NLIU are actually from students of NUJS or NLUJ or GNLU? They could just be frustrated NLIU students using this as a platform to vent their frustration. Moreover, how do you know that the people pretending to be NUJS/NLUJ/GNLU students are actually from those colleges? For all you know they could be people from other colleges posting just to have some fun and start fights.

You say:
I have never noticed students from NLIU joining issues with the fellow students from WBNUJS and NLUJ on the acerbic comments made by them.

How can u be so sure that the acerbic comments against NUJS and NLUJ in the various LI discussion threads are not from NLIU students?

Bottomline: Anonymous comments on LI are not the best way to judge the students of any institution. We'd all expect a lawyer with experience such as yours to not be so presumptous.

[quote name="Neutral"]
iii) I have never noticed students from NLIU joining issues with the fellow students from WBNUJS and NLUJ on the acerbic comments made by them. Anyone who is a regular to LI would have noticed the repeated attempts made by a few students from WBNUJS and NLUJ to belittle everything about NLIU. According to me, by not choosing to reply or take umbrage of their comments, students from NLIU come out smarter and sanely.
[/quote]
True 17 Jun 2011, 10:06
+3 -0
True: NLSIU is just about history.

At present, its doing nothing to improve itself; whether in terms of faculty, research or any other thing.

The future trend of its growth will be downwards.
RAMDEV 17 Jun 2011, 13:15
+3 -0
stay watever man. NUJS rocks. People dont study. They drink and smoke and have awesome parties. and then they kick ass. nlsiu gets everything because it works for it. nujs just keeps getting lucky
Marx 17 Jun 2011, 16:39
+2 -0
[quote name="RAMDEV"]stay watever man. NUJS rocks. People dont study. They drink and smoke and have awesome parties. and then they kick ass. nlsiu gets everything because it works for it. nujs just keeps getting lucky[/quote]
stop trolling u J.A, no one is interested in you or ur NUJS.
Not Complete 17 Jun 2011, 15:29
+0 -0
I guess the whole picture can be figured out when NLU Delhi is being included. There are certainly some students who could have joined NLS, NALSAR, but will be joining NLU Delhi. So, the preference among CLAT schools will be affected by NLU Delhi. Right?
Rohit Bali 17 Jun 2011, 15:54
+5 -0
We all understand NLU Delhi is coming up well...

but kid whats with you guys.. do you really need to hype it up.. is your Director not enough ??

NLU Delhi.. NLU Delhi.. We're coming up, We're coming up..

Why do you need OUR approval ?? That is SOME insecurity you guys have..!! :D
not sane 18 Jun 2011, 11:23
+3 -0
No sane guy will leave the top 5-6 CLAT law schools (NLSIU, NUJS, NALSAR, NLIU, NLUJ and even GNLU) for NLUD.

Rome was not built in a day. Heard of it? NLUD is promising...but still it has a long way to go.
1 18 Jun 2011, 08:37
+0 -0
nujs has not even been ranked by outlook. LOL.
Rank 2 FYI 18 Jun 2011, 10:16
+0 -0
FYI it was ranked 2 by Outlook magazine.
Unbelievable! 18 Jun 2011, 18:30
+1 -0
[quote name="1"]nujs has not even been ranked by outlook. LOL.[/quote]
[quote name="1"]nujs has not even been ranked by outlook. LOL.[/quote]

Dude do you go by the Outlook rankings? I mean, really? :o Are you really that dumb?
Akshay Sharma, 2014 19 Jun 2011, 05:19
+0 -0
[quote name="Unbelievable!"][quote name="1"]nujs has not even been ranked by outlook. LOL.[/quote]
[quote name="1"]nujs has not even been ranked by outlook. LOL.[/quote]

Dude do you go by the Outlook rankings? I mean, really? :o Are you really that dumb?[/quote]

seriously if you think rank 6 is worth being quoted here then you're really really dumb. if i were you, i'd want to bury my head in the sand and say that outlook DID NOT rank us this year. dont let people know that you were ranked so low
Seriously 19 Jun 2011, 11:36
+2 -0
Nice way to show your frustration here. If you are not from NLS or NALSAR, then I think you are quite frustrated with your entrance test that you could not get a good college.

Better try next time :)
H. Bhogle da puttar 19 Jun 2011, 05:11
+0 -0
http://www.legallyindia.com/201006221004/Law-schools/india-todayoutlook-law-school-rankings-2010-nliu-gains-nujs-drops-most

NUJS HAS GAINED YES YES
FROM RANK 8 TO RANK 6
HAHAHA

a little dyslexic maybe.. 6 seems like 1 to them. but they are right. they have gained. I'm regretting having picked this place after these rankings came out.LOOK AT WHAT PEOPLE SAY ABOUT YOU:

Outlook ranked ILS Pune in third place but NLIU Bhopal was by far the fastest climber, jumping from tenth to fourth this year.

NUJS saw the biggest drop in Outlook's rankings to fifth place this year.
bologandy, A. 19 Jun 2011, 05:14
+1 -0
nujs should not mislead the clat aspirant. you are playing with their future. this is not done. atleast tell them th truth that you were ranked low, and also say that you have lots of entrepreneurial stuff so its fun n all and yo're in the city so if the clat fresher is tired of seniors throwing him in the cess pool, he can get hammered and drown his misery in alcohol... AND THEN LET THE FRESHER DECIDE. but please please give them all the facts first.
it may be fun for you to get better ranks in clat and clearly you are jumping with joy but dont do it at the cost of a student's career by portraying wrong info.
Info 19 Jun 2011, 11:34
+0 -0
Things speak for themselves.

Anyways, Nice attempt to make your college reputation better. Where are you from ? RGNUL? No, NO, I think NLIU. No, No may be CNLU
KD 24 Jun 2011, 09:28
+0 -0
What rank can i expect NUALS 2nd allotment list to go upto? Anyone? 800 maybe?