Articles tagged with: collegium

Madras bar & bench reach out to governor against Chief, alleges favouritism and casteism

Madras High Court Advocates Association (MHAA) president Paul Kanagaraj, with an MHAA “delegation”, met Tamil Nadu governor K Rosaiah seeking his intervention in recalling a list of 12 names recommended for judgeship at the HC, and taking exception to the fact that the recommended advocates were “sh...

Need to know: Madras HC collegium circus | Delhi judiciary needs | New Kerala judges | MMB Legal new partner | more...

Madras HC 12-judge-names appeal : The Madras HC through its registrar general will move the SC against its own division bench decision that had stayed the appointment of the 12 recommended Madras HC advocates as judges whose recommendations has courted controversy at the HC [ TOI ] Madras HC advocat...

Parliamentary Standing Committee report on JAC condensed

The Parliamentary standing committee on the Judicial Appointments Bill 2013 asked for constitutional status to the JAC, speedy creation of the All India Judicial Services, a change in the composition of JAC as suggested currently in the bill, and tightening the noose around higher judiciary vacancie...

Wired: Elusive SC appointment | BCI fails 28 | NLSIU senior | Caravan collegium

Elusive SC appointment: Calcutta high court chief justice Arun Mishra has missed a Supreme Court seat for the second time since June last year despite hailing from Madhya Pradesh, which has been left unrepresented at the SC since Justice Deepak Verma’s retirement [ Telegraph India ] BCI fails 28: 28...

Wired: Bars in unrest | Press test | Kohli rejects Nike nurture | Karnataka benched perm | Groklaw post-snoop shut | Guj Pendency | No sleep banker dies

Bar unrest: Madras high court bar experiences heartburn and resentment at the selection of two out of eight newly appointed judges from neighbouring state Kerala, while western UP lawyers are gearing up to Gherao the Taj Mahal to mark their discontent over government inaction for a permanent western...

Collegium clears 8 Madras HC judges out of controversial 15

The Madras high court will get eight new judges as the SC collegium cleared eight out of 15 names recommended to it by the high court, reported The Hindu . Six advocates including two women (R Mahadevan, K Kalyanasundaram, PS Jayakumar, S Vaidyanathan, VM Velumani and Pushpa Sathyanarayanan) and two...

BCI press release: Kapil Sibal meeting was ‘fruitless’ ‘waste of time’, nothing resolved & welfare not discussed

The Bar Council of India (BCI) was displeased with its completely “fruitless” and “meaningless” meeting with union law minister Kapil Sibal on 10 August. Sibal allegedly did not discuss any of the items on the meeting’s agenda and instead focused on the National Judicial Appointments Commission in w...

BCI lobbies for appointing judges

The Bar Council of India (BCI), which is currently pushing for representation in Supreme Court and high court judges’ appointments , on Saturday staged a demonstration at Rajghat, Delhi demanding immediate withdrawal of the National Judicial Appointment Commission Bill terming it as an “affront on i...

Madras advocates: Leaked IB reports critical of 3 HC nominees, as list of 15 made outside collegium under ‘vulnerable’ acting CJ

Letter: 'Disturbing'
Letter: 'Disturbing'
The Madras High Court Advocates Association (MHAA) claimed that the Intelligence Bureau (IB) gave a negative report on three judicial candidates.

Open letter pleads CJI to scrap ‘damaging’, ‘undeserving’, incompetent nominees to Madras HC bench

A group of 46 lawyers and civil society activists have asked Chennai’s and the country’s most senior judges to withdraw a list of names recommended for elevation to the Madras high court (HC), because it would lead to “undeserving persons of questionable competence, experience and integrity get appo...

Ex-CJI Altamas Kabir issues press release to defend v ‘maligning’ TOI, IE printing ‘canards’

The former Chief Justice of India (CJI) Altamas Kabir, who retired last week, has lashed out at the Times of India and the Indian Express for their critical reports of Kabir, purporting to explain in a six-page press release what actually went on behind the scenes.

Wired: Altamas Kabir blasts collegium ‘gang’ | SC snakes & ladders | IT raids HNLU | Costly frivolous PILs | Food and/or nutrition

Altamas Kabir blasts collegium ‘gang’: Justice Altamas Kabir, who retired as the chief justice of India (CJI) yesterday, on 2 July requisitioned a meeting of the SC collegium – himself and justices P Sathasivam, GS Singhvi, RM Lodha and HL Dattu – to propose that they recommend the elevation of an u...

Guj CJ Bhattacharya accuses CJI Kabir of collegium bias

Gujarat high court chief justice (CJ) Bhaskar Bhattacharya, whose elevation to the Supreme Court was rejected unanimously by the SC collegium , has accused chief justice of India (CJI) Altamas Kabir of bias spurred by Bhattacharya’s opposition of the CJI’s sister’s elevation to the bench, reported t...

Wired: IB nixes terrific collegium | Lest CBI be judged | CJI for judicial reservations | Demonstrating for good judges

IB nixes terrific collegium: A collegium of judges in a state affected by militancy had six months ago recommended an advocate, who was linked to a terrorist outfit, for elevation to the high court. The Prime Minister’s Office ordered an Intelligence Bureau (IB) scrutiny of all the persons recommend...

Wired: MHAA dislikes judge choices | HC Nagpur bench boost | US SC for gay marriage | Ramlu young training

MHAA recalls judge choices: Madras HC Advocates Association (MHAA) petitions the CJI to reject the list of 15 proposed judges sent by the Madras HC collegiums to him, on the ground of it being below “constitutional standards”. “It appears that the names have been proposed on extraneous criteria such...

Wired: Obscene justice? | Judicially endorsed? | Political prosecutors | Enlightened humans on judges

Obscene justice? A 61-year old doctor threatened a Supreme Court bench today that she would commit suicide if her case of malicious prosecution was sent back to the Delhi HC. She alleged that a Delhi HC judge had been sending her obscene messages and had colluded with BSES Rajdhani to falsely implic...

BCI wants say over judicial appointments

The Bar Council of India’s (BCI) chairman Manan Kumar Mishra and vice chairman Zafar A Khan will prepare a report on the manner in which the BCI and the state bar councils could participate in the appointment process of Supreme Court judges and the chief justices of all high courts. The report is pl...

Wired: Writ extorts 500 Rupee JEE key | Sex and the Judiciary | SC cuts NE(E)T of suffering | Sibal on the collegium | Chicken came first or parrot? | Dutt jail-holiday ends | Not your business, TRAI

Writ extorts 500 Rupee JEE key: The CBSE has today notified that it will provide the JEE-mains answer key to interested candidates for Rs 500. Legally India had yesterday reported the listing of a writ in the Delhi HC against the CBSE, by a JEE candidate, to force the CBSE to disclose the answer key...

District judges Sunita Gupta, Deepa Sharma, registrar VP Vaish to become Delhi HC judges alongside seniors Nath, Rao, Bakhru, Sachdeva [UPDATE]

The Delhi High Court is slated to welcome Delhi Tis Hazari district judge Sunita Gupta and Delhi HC registrar general VP Vaish as additional judges after at least four senior advocates and one advocate are due to take seat at the bench.

MP Chief Justice Bobde heads to SC: CJI in 2019; LK Advani moots SC appointed by ministers

Madhya Pradesh High Court chief justice SA Bobde to be elevated to the Supreme Court. He will become the Chief Justice of India in 2019, after justice Ranjan Gogoi, and will preside for 18 months [ Hindu ] After the recent decision to elevate Justice AK Sikri, this would take the total bench strengt...